ŷ

Marc's Reviews > Solaris

Solaris by Stanisław Lem
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
2876105
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: science-fiction

“And what does all this mean? Yes indeed, what does it mean …�
I don't understand why this novel has escaped my attention until now. This must be pretty much the quintessential book of classic science fiction. And I don't mean it is the precursor, because then you can go back to the Roman Greek Lucian, the inevitable Jules Verne or the British Olav Stapledon. No, as far as I can estimate, Stanislaw Lew is the first who managed to make the oppression of space travel tangible, you know, that image that constantly appears in science fiction films ever since: clinical spaces, bathing in absolute silence and colored by an unspecified threat. It's beautiful how Lem portrays this.

At its root, in this story, is the highly dynamic plasma ocean surrounding the planet Solaris, with its constantly changing erratic shapes and its ability to apparently influence the thoughts, memories and images of visiting space travelers. Lem perhaps occasionally loses himself a little too much in describing these strange phenomena (they are much better reflected in a movie). But on the other hand, he provides an important philosophical underlayer: how do we deal with a reality that we do not understand? The author focuses on how scientists try to get a grip on the bizarre phenomena in a succession of theories, speculations, movements, etc. spread over decades. I think it is phenomenal how Lem has managed to highlight the winding roads, the limitations and the power of the scientific approach.

A second important layer is at least as essential, namely how we as humans deal with things we don't understand, and especially with our most repressed feelings and memories, because apparently it are mainly those that are evoked and physically shaped by Solaris. The tragic love story between Kris Kelvin and his wife Harey, and especially the self-doubt of the 'cloned' Harey, are certainly gripping, although I find it slightly less successful than the philosophical-scientific underlayer.

Lem ultimately puts his finger on one of the most essential dilemmas of our existence, both individually and collectively: can we accept that reality outside us (is it really outside us?) may have no pattern, logic, or rationality at all? Really well done.
92 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Solaris.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 18, 2023 – Shelved
August 27, 2023 – Started Reading
August 30, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-18 of 18 (18 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Philippe (new)

Philippe Hé, die heb ik ook klaarliggen, naar aanleiding van de lectuur van Christopher Brackens 'Magical Criticism' waarin een mooie postlude, gewijd aan Solaris, is opgenomen.


Marc Philippe wrote: "Hé, die heb ik ook klaarliggen, naar aanleiding van de lectuur van Christopher Brackens 'Magical Criticism' waarin een mooie postlude, gewijd aan Solaris, is opgenomen."
Net uit, absoluut de moeite. Qua science fiction doet het erg vertrouwd aan omdat natuurlijk tal van scifi-schrijvers en filmscenaristen na hem (het boek is van 1960) zich op hem baseren. Wat me vooral boeide, was de heel fijne schets van hoe wetenschappers (soms klungelig) omgaan met onverklaarbare fenomenen.


message 3: by Philippe (new)

Philippe Bracken: "Scientists have learned nothing from Solaris except their own incapacity to describe things and state facts. Solaristics is a failure of constative language. The ocean-brain, in contrast, prefers immediation to communication. It makes hypotheses into phenomena instead of pointing out correspondences between them. Solaris is a triumph of performative language."


Yves S Thank you Marc for this excellent review. I have never read this book and only saw Andrei Tarkovski's movie adaptation which I found to be a masterpiece (although aware opinions and appreciations on this movies are generally divided).
So thank you for the reminder and I shall add Lem's book to my TBR list.


message 5: by Hanneke (new) - added it

Hanneke Wonderful to read your review of Solaris, Marc! You are rating it 4* and that means something as you seldom give such a high rating! Like you did and no doubt many other readers, I have ‘Solaris� on a pile already for many years. I will now look for my copy and will read it shortly. Thanks!


message 6: by Miltiadis (new)

Miltiadis Michalopoulos a very thorough review. Thank you


message 7: by Jan-Maat (new) - added it

Jan-Maat Wow, I am surprised Marc that you liked this, I would never have guessed that from your other reviews!

It strikes me now reading your review to wonder how much his book was a response to living under communism in Poland which was further more in a (semi-)colonial relationship to the Soviet Union, as you say: can we accept that reality outside us (is it really outside us?) may have no pattern, logic, or rationality at all?


Marc Yves wrote: "Thank you Marc for this excellent review. I have never read this book and only saw Andrei Tarkovski's movie adaptation which I found to be a masterpiece (although aware opinions and appreciations o..."

You're welcome, Yves. Always a pleasure to see readers can get inspired by my review. Enjoy your read!


Marc Hanneke wrote: "Wonderful to read your review of Solaris, Marc! You are rating it 4* and that means something as you seldom give such a high rating! Like you did and no doubt many other readers, I have ‘Solaris� o..."
Beware, Hanneke (as you already know I always have a 'beware'): some parts of the book are rather tedious, especially when Lem describes the extraordinary phenomena on the surface of Solaris, and when he gives an overview of scientific theories about them. But that's just part of the game, I guess. An extraordinary book, for sure! Hope to see your review soon.


message 10: by Marc (new) - rated it 4 stars

Marc Hanneke wrote: "Wonderful to read your review of Solaris, Marc! You are rating it 4* and that means something as you seldom give such a high rating! Like you did and no doubt many other readers, I have ‘Solaris� o..."
Beware, Hanneke (as you already know I always have a 'beware'): some parts of the book are rather tedious, especially when Lem describes the extraordinary phenomena on the surface of Solaris, and when he gives an overview of scientific theories about them. But that's just part of the game, I guess. An extraordinary book, for sure! Hope to see your review soon.


message 11: by Marc (new) - rated it 4 stars

Marc Miltiadis wrote: "a very thorough review. Thank you"
You're very welcome, Miltiades. Thanks for dropping by!


message 12: by Marc (new) - rated it 4 stars

Marc Jan-Maat wrote: "Wow, I am surprised Marc that you liked this, I would never have guessed that from your other reviews!

It strikes me now reading your review to wonder how much his book was a response to living un..."

Have to read a biography on Lem to answer that, Jann. You never know, it could be that Lem's subconsciousness played tricks on him! And... did I just catch you at trying to explain the inexplicable? Auch!


message 13: by Gijs (new) - rated it 3 stars

Gijs Grob There are two very fine films based on the book, which both fail to visualise the wonderful wonderful landscapes of the book, but which both capture the book's mysterious atmosphere very well


Violeta A superb review, Marc! "How do we deal with a reality that we do not understand?" You perfectly capture the philophical essence of the book with this question.


message 15: by Michael (new)

Michael Rieman There is a fine movie by Tarkovsky based on this book


message 16: by John (new) - rated it 5 stars

John Gossman While Solaris is Lem's masterpiece, I also recommend reading The Cyberiad, a series of comic fairy tales for robots. Lem could write comedy or drama equally well. He is also a master of parody, much of this driven by his experiences living in Poland during the cold war. It is now easy to miss that books like "His Master's Voice" and "Fiasco" are about the nuclear arms race, partly because they can simply be read as interesting stories with no agenda. His late novel "Peace on Earth" combines all three Lem traits: the light humor, the political parody, and the serious thinking about AI and alien ways of thinking. And, yes, I'm a little obsessed with him.


message 17: by P.E. (new) - rated it 4 stars

P.E. Thanks for your enthusiastic review, Marc! Your remarks reminded me of 'Fiasco', another novel by S. Lem dealing with pretty much the same questions!


message 18: by Marc (new) - rated it 4 stars

Marc John wrote: "While Solaris is Lem's masterpiece, I also recommend reading The Cyberiad, a series of comic fairy tales for robots. Lem could write comedy or drama equally well. He is also a master of parody, muc..."
Thanks, John, you just made my To Be Read list a bit longer!


back to top