ŷ

Charles's Reviews > Wellness

Wellness by Nathan  Hill
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
13904332
's review

it was amazing

What I love most about Wellness is the vignette format.

It’s been a long time since I first noticed how swift changes in scenes serve couple stories particularly well—think The Maples Stories�, and Wellness is no exception to the concept. In depicting Jack and Elizabeth’s couple over a few decades, Nathan Hill successfully layers countless episodes that sometimes focus on both partners, and sometimes single one out. The result is as dynamic as it is deep, and amounts to fantastic characterization. This is nimble storytelling at its best for a novel that leans so steadily on psychology.

What I love almost as much is the tone.

Or maybe I love it just as much as the format, in fact. After The Nix, it was anyone’s guess what a second offering might read like, all these years later. Relief first washed over this reader, then mounting joy. Hill’s eloquent irreverence? That sharp eye trained on personal and collective shortcomings in today’s world? That heart, that balancing act between cynicism and good-natured humor? All the boxes are checked. In both The Nix and now Wellness, the author's voice feels like home to me.

And then there's everything else.

There is a myth-buster vibe to the novel, which tackles a vast array of beliefs. Wellness explores the pressure people put on themselves in an effort at self-improvement; less to do with the divine, more with the mundane. As we follow Jack and Elizabeth from their initial meeting in the nineties to their approach to middle age as Gen Xers (and parents), what we are made to reflect on is their quest for meaning while meaning markers evolve over time.

Themes like real estate, peer pressure, consumerism, and parenting ambitions are very present: again, a substantial part of this novel is about people looking for life hacks. But equally important are Jack and Elizabeth’s respective childhood, as significant chunks of this story explore how these two people became who they are today. Elizabeth grew up to be a perfectionist; Jack, an artist; neither is entirely satisfied. So Wellness is also about growing out of your own childhood, which can be the work of a lifetime. Interspersed among current-day interludes, these rearview-mirror chapters felt relatable, heartbreaking, and entertaining at once. A poetic wind blew over them.

On becoming who Jack was meant to be with the help of his visiting elder sister, despite growing up in a house devoid of art or books, with TV shows being of no assistance in providing models:

“Which was another lack that Evelyn sought to remedy. At the conclusion of that first week, she borrowed the Ford to go into town—ostensibly to fetch ingredients for a cake, as it was their mother’s birthday, but she came back also lugging a bag that she secreted to Jack’s room. It was filled with used books: Great Expectations. The Call of the Wild. The Great Gatsby. On the Road. A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man. Books, she said, about people who leave home and go forth into the world and reinvent their very selves.�

Of special interest to me in Wellness was the private language that couples develop, and sometimes families: these favourite idioms that become distinctively ours, despite having been up for grabs by just about anyone all along. Hill has a definite knack for them. That’s all I will say.

While I found the ending saw an elaborate construction fold on itself in the equivalent of a blink, the road to get there leaves me marveling, and giving this book fewer than five stars just wouldn’t feel right.

Must I really wait north of five years for a third novel to come out, now?
76 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Wellness.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 2, 2023 – Shelved as: to-read
August 2, 2023 – Shelved
January 12, 2024 – Started Reading
January 15, 2024 –
page 41
6.74%
January 17, 2024 –
page 95
15.63%
January 19, 2024 –
page 151
24.84%
January 23, 2024 –
page 201
33.06%
January 26, 2024 –
page 262
43.09%
January 28, 2024 –
page 321
52.8%
February 1, 2024 –
page 410
67.43%
February 2, 2024 –
page 529
87.01%
February 3, 2024 –
page 624
100%
February 3, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-44 of 44 (44 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Lisa Ah, you and Jennifer together again!


message 2: by Charles (last edited Feb 07, 2024 05:09AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Charles Lisa wrote: "Ah, you and Jennifer together again!"

We're thinking of becoming Mexican wrestlers. I heard she's designing masks for us.


Stacey B Too funny!


NicoleWReads Your review made me smile


Charles Stacey B wrote: "Too funny!"

Part-time luchador, full-time clown. :P


Charles NicoleWReads wrote: "Your review made me smile"

I'm delighted, Nicole! Thanks for popping in. :)


Antoinette Wonderful review, Charles. You have made this book very enticing!


Charles Antoinette wrote: "Wonderful review, Charles. You have made this book very enticing!"

Thanks, Antoinette! I'm slowly reintroducing longer books on my docket, and this one felt precisely like what I was hoping to stumble upon. I'd recommend it to any discerning reader who values pacing and depth in equal measure, which certainly isn't a given.


message 9: by Diane (new) - added it

Diane Barnes You make me want to read this Charles, despite the fact that's its very contemporary. I've been in the mood for classical and older books lately, but this sounds very good.


message 10: by Chad (new) - rated it 5 stars

Chad Such a lovely and astute review! I loved reading about all the things you picked up on--this book was my favorite from 2023, there's so much to dive into and pick apart.


Charles Diane wrote: "You make me want to read this Charles, despite the fact that's its very contemporary. I've been in the mood for classical and older books lately, but this sounds very good."

Glad this piqued your curiosity. As a deviation from your recent trajectory, you really could do worse than give this compelling story a chance! :) Fingers crossed that it pulls you in like it did me, Diane.


Charles Chad wrote: "Such a lovely and astute review! I loved reading about all the things you picked up on--this book was my favorite from 2023, there's so much to dive into and pick apart."

Thanks, Chad! This title sets the bar pretty high for whatever follows it this year, I agree, and I can totally see how it would have nabbed that top spot for you. Such richness. Such memorable reflections!


Antoinette Question for you, Charles. Have you read The Nix by him? My older son said it was one of his top books last year- I was thinking I should read that first. Thoughts?


Charles Antoinette wrote: "Question for you, Charles. Have you read The Nix by him? My older son said it was one of his top books last year- I was thinking I should read that first. Thoughts?"

I did read The Nix when it came out, and at the time I had also given Hill's debut novel five stars. I certainly get how your son might've enjoyed it! They're two different novels, completely unrelated, and they require no particular order in reading them, no worries there. You get to pick between an intriguing family mystery and an exploration of couplehood going stale, but both are clever, beautifully written works. Lucky you!


Candi I've been interested in reading The Nix for some time now, but this book keeps appearing and tempting me. I especially like when you say this: "So Wellness is also about growing out of your own childhood, which can be the work of a lifetime." Your splendid review has convinced me I might want to read this before I grab The Nix, Charles :)


message 16: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Charles wrote: "Lisa wrote: "Ah, you and Jennifer together again!"

We're thinking of becoming Mexican wrestlers. I heard she's designing masks for us."


I'll be first in line to see that show! 😁


message 17: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Outstanding review! I have been hesitant about this one, and I'm not sure why. You've convinced me, so on the list it goes.


message 18: by Charles (last edited Feb 09, 2024 02:19AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Charles Candi wrote: "I've been interested in reading The Nix for some time now, but this book keeps appearing and tempting me. I especially like when you say this: "So Wellness is also about growing out of your own chi..."

Thanks for this, and there's no doubt in my mind you and Nathan Hill will hit it off instantly. In fact, I believe you'd be a perfect reader for this title, and like I was mentioning to Antoinette, getting to The Nix only later on will matter zero. Let yourself be tempted: my review doesn't even begin to reflect the riches hidden in there. This book keeps popping up in your feed for a reason!


message 19: by Charles (last edited Feb 08, 2024 02:52AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Charles Lisa wrote: "Outstanding review! I have been hesitant about this one, and I'm not sure why. You've convinced me, so on the list it goes."

Oh, I'd blame the cover, myself. Blech. :P But honestly, narratives this fabulous are the reason why I grew into a reader. Don't miss out on this one, Lisa: it's well worth your consideration. (And thanks!)


message 20: by Julie (new)

Julie G Well, if you go around referencing The Maples Stories, I'm bound to show up, aren't I? I'm going to ignore your enthusiasm for this for now, but I doubt it will be long before I succumb to curiosity!
xoxo


message 21: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala You write so well about this book, Charles, that I'm now very curious about how Nathan Hill writes in turn. Plus I'm glad to hear of a contemporary author who may be worth investigating.


Charles Julie wrote: "Well, if you go around referencing The Maples Stories, I'm bound to show up, aren't I? I'm going to ignore your enthusiasm for this for now, but I doubt it will be long before I succumb to curiosit..."

You're my Updike genie. I'll have to find you a lamp. Maybe something mid-century modern?


Charles Fionnuala wrote: "You write so well about this book, Charles, that I'm now very curious about how Nathan Hill writes in turn. Plus I'm glad to hear of a contemporary author who may be worth investigating."

Fionnuala, you are too kind. If you do decide to stray in this direction, I'll be first in line to cheer you on. :) He's really something, in my view.


message 24: by Julie (new)

Julie G Ha! Exactly.


message 25: by Jennifer (new) - added it

Jennifer Welsh Interesting comparison to The Maples Stories, Charles, in terms of a structure that works for couples! And I love "eloquent irreverence" as a Nathan Hill descriptor, too. It's rare that a work is both wide and deep, and you conveyed that so well here, along with its dynamism. I bet your review alone will have friends grabbing this. As always, it was so much fun to read this with you—I'm glad we had that convo some time ago about our mutual love for The Nix. I'll let you know when I finally post a review...


message 26: by Jennifer (new) - added it

Jennifer Welsh Charles wrote: "Lisa wrote: "Outstanding review! I have been hesitant about this one, and I'm not sure why. You've convinced me, so on the list it goes."

Oh, I'd blame the cover, myself. Blech. :P But honestly, n..."


I do have to say, Charles, that I could never misplace this book with those cover colors ;)


message 27: by Jennifer (new) - added it

Jennifer Welsh Charles wrote: "Lisa wrote: "Ah, you and Jennifer together again!"

We're thinking of becoming Mexican wrestlers. I heard she's designing masks for us."


Charles, I'm laughing so hard! Lucha Libre, here we come!


message 28: by Jennifer (new) - added it

Jennifer Welsh Lisa wrote: "Outstanding review! I have been hesitant about this one, and I'm not sure why. You've convinced me, so on the list it goes."

Lisa, I think you'll have fun with this :D


Derek Driggs This is such a great review of an excellent novel; you really highlighted a lot that makes Hill unique!


Charles Jennifer wrote: "Interesting comparison to The Maples Stories, Charles, in terms of a structure that works for couples! And I love "eloquent irreverence" as a Nathan Hill descriptor, too. It's rare that a work is b..."

Jen, I loved our buddy read—as usual. Thanks so much for pushing the reflection further all along. I'm looking forward to your own insightful review, whenever the moment feels right, as I know you'll have much to bring to the table. This book, and our time together reading it, definitely brought sunshine to my winter. :)


Charles Derek wrote: "This is such a great review of an excellent novel; you really highlighted a lot that makes Hill unique!"

Many thanks, Derek, including for popping in like this. Wonderful to get acquainted on GR through such a quality author as this one. Curious where our literary paths will cross next!


Violeta I don't know how I missed this review, but I'm glad I caught up with the thread of admiring comments for your lucid, eloquent writing, Charles. You seriously tempt me with your descriptions of this book's themes, especially this: we are made to reflect on is their quest for meaning while meaning markers evolve over time.

Funny, a few minutes ago, I read a review of Fionnuala, where she too mentions the idea of a "private language."


Charles Violeta wrote: "I don't know how I missed this review, but I'm glad I caught up with the thread of admiring comments for your lucid, eloquent writing, Charles. You seriously tempt me with your descriptions of this..."

Many thanks, friend. This novel turned out to be the highlight of my (literary) winter. I'm delighted to pique your curiosity with this review, and I hope you'll let yourself be tempted. A review from you would be a definite treat!


message 34: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Charles, I'm circling back now that I've read this one. Your review perfectly captures everything I loved about this novel. There is so much here that's ripe for thought and discussion. Thanks for nudging me to read this one.

I also appreciate how Hill threads the idea of placebo throughout this work--both the Latin "to please," as poor Jack and Elizabeth have strived to do from childhood on twisting themselves into so many shapes, and the idea of fakery, the faces they both put on to present to the world.


Charles Lisa wrote: "Charles, I'm circling back now that I've read this one. Your review perfectly captures everything I loved about this novel. There is so much here that's ripe for thought and discussion. Thanks for ..."

Lisa, I'm glad you found something to love in there, which isn't to say I'm surprised. This is one smart novel. I'm heading over!


Violeta Charles, I come back to this review that originally put this book on the map for me, and I realize that 'tone' and 'format' are two of my favorite reasons for loving a book. Given that your judgment and taste are indisputable, I'm adding and ordering it asap.
I've had an overdose of Welness today, what with all the reviews of esteemed friends popping up on my feed, but I think it will pay off.


Candi There's so much to say about this novel, that it's hard to capture it all in a review. Having now read it for myself, I can say you perfectly relay the feel of this one, Charles!


message 38: by Charles (last edited Apr 24, 2024 05:46PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Charles Violeta wrote: "Charles, I come back to this review that originally put this book on the map for me, and I realize that 'tone' and 'format' are two of my favorite reasons for loving a book. Given that your judgmen..."

I'm confident it will pay off. Tone and format are up there for me, as well, perhaps tone in particular nowadays, and I find this is not always so easy to infer from a cover blurb, so it amounts to a true celebration when something like Wellness crosses my path. It feels like finding my tribe. This is a review of yours I'm sure to take pleasure savouring, when the time comes, whatever the results. But again, I'm confident, Violeta. :) I'm excited you'll be reading this!


Charles Candi wrote: "There's so much to say about this novel, that it's hard to capture it all in a review. Having now read it for myself, I can say you perfectly relay the feel of this one, Charles!"

Thank you so much! I'm heading over to your own review, but a third of the way into 2024, Wellness remains my number one read, this year, and verges on feeling like a gift to humanity or something; maybe a mirror, more accurately, with so much to love about the delivery. You're right about the scope, and I can't imagine how consuming it must be for a writer to take on something like this, so broad yet so intimate, and manage to drive it home. Both The Nix and Wellness have secured a place on my physical shelves, in this place where I keep so few of the books that transit here—as you know. I'm in total awe before this guy's talent and observations.


Candi "...verges on feeling like a gift to humanity or something"

Such a lovely sentiment, Charles! I love it when a book is so deeply affecting :)


Charles Candi wrote: "Such a lovely sentiment, Charles! I love it when a book is so deeply affecting :)"

So what's your #1 this year so far?


message 42: by Candi (last edited Apr 24, 2024 02:58PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Candi Charles wrote: "Candi wrote: "Such a lovely sentiment, Charles! I love it when a book is so deeply affecting :)"

So what's your #1 this year so far?"


Oh, that's tough! Well, if I had to go with just one, I'd have to say Kent Haruf's Benediction. I have a feeling that Strout's Olive, Again will be a good contender once I finish that one though!


Charles Candi wrote: "Oh, that's tough! Well, if I had to go with just one, I'd have to say Kent Haruf's Benediction. I have a feeling that Strout's Olive, Again will be a good contender once I finish that one though!"

Haruf's a great one to bring up, and I needed the reminder. I'm glad I asked. :) Thanks!


Candi Might as well finish that trilogy, Charles! It's well worth it :)


back to top