Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Jonathan K (Max Outlier)'s Reviews > True Story: Murder, Memoir, Mea Culpa

True Story by Michael Finkel
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
32433113
's review

really liked it

As stated during the reading updates, I'd seen the James Franco, Noah Hill film and found the story intriguing since it bore a vague similarity to the adaptation of In Cold Blood due to the murders of innocent people. When I learned the film has been adapted, I make an effort to track the book down.

Told in a sort of diary format, Michael Finkel shares his own battle with the truth along with that of Christian Longo, husband to Mary Jane and father to three young children. Longo came from a Jehovah Witness family and was 7 years younger than MJ when they met. Due to the conservative 'rules' Witness' abide by, it took several years for them to become husband and wife. During that time Chris struggled with finding a stable vocational path, but when the first child was born, things changed.

Finkel was a young, successful New York Times magazine journalist whose stories stood apart from most. When he learned of cocoa plant 'slavery' in Africa, he was compelled to explore the details, and when it came to writing the story, he 'fudged' major parts of the research in an effort to 'dramatize' what he'd learned. Soon after it was published, the truth surfaced and with it, the loss of his career.

Longo jumped from one job to another and found stability working as a construction laborer. When the other two children were born, making ends meet became challenging. Taking notice of the difficulty contractors had getting companies to clean up the sites, he managed to finance a start up that delivered clean up services. Over the course of a year, the company grew from 3 employees to over 100 and with it, a $15K/week payroll. But with the growth came challenges since contractors tend to delay payments straining the financial stability of Longo's company. Having succeeded with deceit of lesser nature in his youth, he resorted to criminal behavior in an effort to keep both his family and company floating. As the saying goes, "No good deed goes unpunished', he went deeper into debt causing him to forge checks, deceive creditors while keeping his family in the dark.

Suffice it to say that Chris Longo had difficulty with the truth and like any sociopath, lived in a world of lies. Soon he resorted to desperate measures and in this case, he fabricated stories in order to convince his family that it was 'time to leave'. On the run from creditors and the law, they eventually ended up in Newport, OR where Chris created a new identity. Over time the truth surfaced causing their domestic life difficulties. In one instance a battle with his wife triggered a horrific murder of his family. In need to escape arrest, he ran to Cancun, MX and when his money was nearly gone, took on the identity of Michael Finkel, a journalist he revered.

What's important to understand is Finkel learned the 'true story' via countless letters sent by Longo from prison which were enhanced by regular visits during the year Chris awaited trial. The relevance of this 'match made in heaven', is both of them have issues with the truth making the story unlike most. Longo pleads guilty to murdering his wife and one child and during the trial, his testimony is pure fantasy.

Having watched the film twice, its extremely disappointing to see how the script leaves out the details that led to Longo's murders. Dramatizing is one thing, but naming a film "True Story" seems erroneous in all ways imaginable. When compared to the Oscar winner, "Capote" which captures nearly every detail of In Cold Blood, this is a travesty of epic proportions.

For those who may have read In Cold Blood, or find unique murder mysteries to their liking, you'll find this book of particular interest since its based on fact rather than fiction.
21 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read True Story.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 26, 2023 – Shelved
August 26, 2023 – Shelved as: to-read
September 4, 2023 – Started Reading
September 4, 2023 –
page 39
12.5% "Outstanding and as expected, is filled with details left out in the film. This is true crime at its best and Finkel does a masterful job."
September 4, 2023 –
page 64
20.51% "For those that may not have seen the James Franco, Noah Hill movie the script does a good job with the facts, but the book illuminates it further. While the mystery and crime genre are popular, there's no getting around a factual accounting of a man who murders his family."
September 4, 2023 –
page 80
25.64% "As with most adaptations the studio takes the liberty of adding a love interest played by Felicity Jones, when the book lacks the character completely. And the appearance of the murderer Chris Longo is nothing like James Franco, lol"
September 4, 2023 –
page 80
25.64% "For those who enjoy crime mystery, True Story, the movie can be seen on Prime video. It's remarkable in all respects and like the title is fact"
September 4, 2023 –
page 80
25.64% "Oops.. The movie is on Max not Prime, lol"
September 5, 2023 –
page 112
35.9% "Fascinating how a guy murders his family then takes off for Mexico only to assume the identity of a favorite journalist who he writes to from prison hoping he'll believe his story"
September 6, 2023 –
page 112
35.9% "It's uncanny that a husband escapes to Mexico keeping the murders of his family secret and chooses to become a journalist whose recent story is fiction rather than fact. What could they possibly have in common you ask? They're both liars!"
September 7, 2023 –
page 158
50.64% "Remarkable how much deeper the book is than the film. And most of the emotion comes through from excerpts of the letters Longo sends to Finkel.. But Longo is a sociopath of epic proportions and one who murdered his family"
September 9, 2023 –
page 206
66.03% "As with most adaptations, the absence of details that were the driving factors of the murders is debilitating to say the least. So glad I decided to read the book!"
September 11, 2023 –
page 255
81.73%
September 12, 2023 –
page 255
81.73% "What's fascinating is that Longo is analyzed by numerous therapists who without knowing one another, come to the conclusion that he's self centered, intelligent and a sociopath. And Finkel comes clean about his own issues with the truth which makes them a perfect match. Little if any of these elements make their way to the film which is why reading the book is important"
September 12, 2023 –
page 209
66.99% "Oops.. Made an error with page numbers. Regardless, it's easy to see how the murderer took Finkel as his name when in MX as well as why he enrolled him to write his story. A true life cat and mouse story with murders as the undercurrent"
September 13, 2023 –
page 209
66.99% "Wow..decided to watch the James Franco, Noah Hill film again and its startling how much different it is from the book, though this isn't unusual with screen adaptations"
September 13, 2023 –
page 230
73.72% "Remarkable that the movie completely left out countless legal problems Longo had due to fraud, a failed company and more. As we all know these things take a toll on a family relationship so it's clear what drove him to murder"
September 13, 2023 –
page 238
76.28% "Talk about crazy, Longo pleas guiltily to killing his wife and oldest child and not guilty to the murder of the two youngest!"
September 13, 2023 –
page 251
80.45% "Horrifying reading about the prosecution testimonies especially the ME who describes Longos wife being stuffed in a suitcase much as he had the three children"
September 15, 2023 –
page 300
96.15% "As a film buff, screen writer and book enthusiast, when I come across a film that's been adapted from a book, I will make the effort to find it. And while most scripts take liberties, the adaptation of this one barely resembles the events. And given it's title of True Story, the only way to know the real details is to read the book. This is one of the most unique stories about murder you'll read"
September 16, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-9 of 9 (9 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Margaret M - (having a challenging time and on GR as much as I can) Thanks for the heads up on this one. I don't normally read true crime but you definitely have me on this one. Wonderful review Jonathan


Jonathan K (Max Outlier) Margaret M - wrote: "Thanks for the heads up on this one. I don't normally read true crime but you definitely have me on this one. Wonderful review Jonathan" Thanks Margaret..I'm a fan of both actors in the movie and enjoyed it UNTIL I read the book. Frankel does a good job with both this one and the Art Thief though here he comes clean about his struggles with the truth, much as Longo did


message 3: by Rachel (new) - added it

Rachel Hanes Fantastic review, Jonathan! I’m definitely intrigued! I had never heard of Longo or Finkel (or the film adaptation), until reading your review. I enjoy true stories, especially true crime, and I’m adding this to my list!


Jonathan K (Max Outlier) Rachel wrote: "Fantastic review, Jonathan! I’m definitely intrigued! I had never heard of Longo or Finkel (or the film adaptation), until reading your review. I enjoy true stories, especially true crime, and I’m ..." Thanks Rachel..its rare to see a book where the people involved share difficulty with honesty though Longo is a true sociopath and murderer. But unlike most murderers he's not violent, dark or malevolent. I think you'll find the story unique, though I recommend you don't watch the film until you've read it


Jonathan K (Max Outlier) Rachel wrote: "Fantastic review, Jonathan! I’m definitely intrigued! I had never heard of Longo or Finkel (or the film adaptation), until reading your review. I enjoy true stories, especially true crime, and I’m ..." I'd also recommend you read "The Art Thief" since Sebastian and Anne-Catherine are two of the most unique criminals you'll find. You don't need to be an art historian to appreciate the uniqueness of the crimes committed


message 6: by Rachel (new) - added it

Rachel Hanes Jonathan wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Fantastic review, Jonathan! I’m definitely intrigued! I had never heard of Longo or Finkel (or the film adaptation), until reading your review. I enjoy true stories, especially true ..."

Thank you so much for the recommendation, Jonathan! “The Art Thief� sounds interesting as well. Also, I don’t watch many movies or TV lately, so I will definitely read “True Story� before I watch the film. :)


Jonathan K (Max Outlier) Rachel wrote: "Jonathan wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Fantastic review, Jonathan! I’m definitely intrigued! I had never heard of Longo or Finkel (or the film adaptation), until reading your review. I enjoy true stories,..." My pleasure Rachel.. as a screen writer, I watch tons of movies and having loved the Oscar winner, "Capote", this one stuck a chord. And while its well acted and directed, it fails miserably with telling the 'true story'


message 8: by Rachel (new) - added it

Rachel Hanes Jonathan wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Jonathan wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Fantastic review, Jonathan! I’m definitely intrigued! I had never heard of Longo or Finkel (or the film adaptation), until reading your review. I enjo..."

Jonathan, I am honored (and feel important) to have a screen writer as my friend here on Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ. I will be looking forward to more of your reviews and recommendations!


Jonathan K (Max Outlier) Rachel wrote: "Jonathan wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Jonathan wrote: "Rachel wrote: "Fantastic review, Jonathan! I’m definitely intrigued! I had never heard of Longo or Finkel (or the film adaptation), until reading yo..." Thanks Rachel..am sure you're aware of the SAG-AFTRA strike of which the Writer's Guild of America, aka WGA, is part. Regardless, I just wrote a short review of another book which was mediocre at best. I'll look forward to hearing your thoughts about one or both of Finkel's.


back to top