Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Meike's Reviews > Grief Is for People

Grief Is for People by Sloane Crosley
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
59050228
's review

liked it
bookshelves: usa

Crosley's first memoir shows the author lost in grief after the suicide of her best friend and former colleague, , who hanged himself in 2019. The book's strength is also its weakness: Crosley depicts the process of coming to terms with what happened as messy, fragmentary, and mysterious. Thus, it is rendered realistically from a psychological standpoint, but the construction diminishes the essayistic force when mundane scenes that suddenly acquire meaning and random connections the mind makes under such pressure get the same (and frequently more) weight than the parts that are interesting on the factual level.

The book rests and emotional movements, and it does so intentionally, meaning that the text is just as much about Crosley as about Perreault. But I wanted to hear more about Perreault's backstory and his possible motivations. I only briefly learnt how he, as a gay man, fled to NYC to live freely, how he did tend to not supplement, but replace his life with performance art, and, most interestingly, how he received regular complaints for his behavior at work because he was stuck in the old world where harsh, inappropriate words from older men were just accepted. I was wondering: How did Crosley feel about it, did they talk about it? Of course there can't be one definite answer as to why a person ends their life, but the neuralgic points remained too murky for me. I also loved the little bits and pieces about the publishing world, like the scandal around A Million Little Pieces, and I wanted more.

Still, Crosley remains a great writer, and it's intriguing to witness her trying to capture the unspeakable. The title hints at the fact that with a person, a whole world disappears, also a world of things, routines, events. There are many smart little throwaways in there, relating to the power of anger, for instance, or the existential loneliness that becomes graspable when you realize you can't fully know a person. I wished the text made more of it potential though.
60 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Grief Is for People.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

September 18, 2023 – Started Reading
September 18, 2023 – Shelved
September 18, 2023 – Shelved as: usa
September 27, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-8 of 8 (8 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Katy (new) - added it

Katy I think the fact she weaves seemingly unrelated and mundane things are often a large part of grappling with grief. Those left behind are left grappling for a connection and assigning meaning to things just to feel their lived one again.


message 2: by olivia farrell (new)

olivia farrell The way too many typos in this review make it quite painful to read and distract from the thoughtful commentary.


message 3: by Kristen (new)

Kristen The "mundane scenes that suddenly acquire meaning and random connections of the mind makes under such pressure" is what grief is. I believe that's the whole point. The parts that are "interesting on the factual level" are the parts the author wishes to forget. As for your wanting to hear more about a subject that is external to the author of a, ahem, memoir, I don't believe that's the author's fault.


Meike Katy wrote: "I think the fact she weaves seemingly unrelated and mundane things are often a large part of grappling with grief. Those left behind are left grappling for a connection and assigning meaning to thi..."

As I write in my review: It's realistic, but it doesn't help on a narrative level.


Meike olivia farrell wrote: "The way too many typos in this review make it quite painful to read and distract from the thoughtful commentary."

I'm sure you're way more eloquent in your third language than I am English, which is my third language, Olivia.


message 6: by Meike (last edited Mar 03, 2024 12:01AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Meike Kristen wrote: "The "mundane scenes that suddenly acquire meaning and random connections of the mind makes under such pressure" is what grief is. I believe that's the whole point. The parts that are "interesting o..."

Writing a memoir does not mean that someone who reads it is forbidden to comment on the content because they are not the author - that would mean that discussing the quality of a memoir is not allowed per se, which goes against the very purpose of storytelling. Also, writing a memoir does not mean that the book is strictly and only about the memoirist. On top of that, t's VERY daring to just go ahead and try to lecture strangers on the nature of grief and the personal feelings that come with it, if you are unaware what they went through.


Shannon I think maybe what you are asking for isn’t the purpose of this particular book. The book is about her grief, rather than his suicide. And I think perhaps that’s where people struggle with this book. They want more of the spectacle of suicide and not what happens to the people left behind. It was refreshing for me to read a book about the side I know, those of us left to put the pieces together after we lose someone to suicide. Those of us who aren’t family or the partner, but who lose someone who is a significant part of our life. Rarely do we get books like this.


Meike Shannon wrote: "I think maybe what you are asking for isn’t the purpose of this particular book. The book is about her grief, rather than his suicide. And I think perhaps that’s where people struggle with this boo..."

I think that the vast majority of people have already lost someone close to them, and quite some people (including me) have lost someone in gruesome circumstances. To believe otherwise is rather self-centered, and to suppose that others long for the "spectacle of suicide", thus assuming they're a bunch of sick creeps, is also an interesting worldview..


back to top