Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Kathleen's Reviews > Just an Ordinary Day: The Uncollected Stories

Just an Ordinary Day by Shirley Jackson
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
48502194
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: favorite-authors, short-stories, women-writers

This is a strange and unusual collection. Jackson’s children found a box of their mother’s unpublished stories decades after her death. Thirty of them are included here, along with 22 additional stories that were only published once. I believe they span almost the whole of her writing career, the last story coming out after her death. This is not a great intro to her work--some of the stories are, well, the kind you’d put away in a box. But to a Jackson fan like me, taken as a whole, this is revelatory and inspiring.

The fun part was immersing myself in her style. Just like with The Lottery (though not as good, obviously), I noticed she disarms you with her regularness, and then lays something crazy on you. I’m just like you, but look what I see! I love the title for that reason. It’s just an ordinary day, but Shirley sees something different in it. That’s not to say these are supernatural or spooky stories. Only one or two come close to that. But they do explore humanities odd, quirky side. Many are kind of like her Life Among the Savages, only as if she wrote them not caring who would read them, which made them scandalously fun.

The first story was one of my favorites, The Smoking Room , where you learn you can trick the devil with words.

The best spooky one was Summer Afternoon , about two pre-school aged girls and a ghost.

The Very Hot Sun in Bermuda - man, this one sounded like an exposé of her husband’s flings with his students. Ouch!

And I loved how Shirley, the 1950’s housewife, wrote a number of stories with mysteriously magical helpers that came into the home and took care of meals and children and kept everything together.

Several stories made me think Shirley was more like Eleanor in The Haunting of Hill House than I may have imagined. She grew up very much an outsider in an affluent suburb of San Francisco that I know well, and I suspect the small towns she included in these stories were inspired by that snobbish enclave.

One of my favorites was a silly one--she is good at silly stuff. In Maybe it was the Car , she is being taken for granted at home, so takes off on an adventure of her own. “I am a writer, I said to myself in the corner of the kitchen. I am a writer and here I sit broiling hamburgers.� �'Listen,� I said, ‘am I a writer or am I a middle-aged housewife?’�

Another favorite was What a Thought . You know how sometimes you let your imagination go and picture some disaster, like a train wreck or hitting someone over the head with a shovel? Yeah, well, Shirley knew about this and wrote a great story around it.

I didn’t like the section of once-published stories as much. Publication dates span from 1943 to 1968, in magazines from Good Housekeeping to Playboy. Here, in contrast to the unpublished ones, I felt she was holding back. Some interesting explorations, but no standouts for me.

Recommended for fans, and for a deep dive into Shirley Jackson’s writing style. A fun journey.
16 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Just an Ordinary Day.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

October 17, 2023 – Started Reading
October 17, 2023 – Shelved
December 14, 2023 – Shelved as: favorite-authors
December 14, 2023 – Shelved as: short-stories
December 14, 2023 – Shelved as: women-writers
December 14, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-11 of 11 (11 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Margaret M - (having a challenging time and on GR as much as I can) Wonderful review Kathleen 💖


Teresa Some of these stories would work well for a writing class, I thought -- they'd show how different versions of similar stories evolve.

I agree about Shirley's connection to Eleanor. I think The Road Through the Wall also reveals Jackson's outsider status within her old snobby SF neighborhood.

Great review, Kathleen.


Kathleen Margaret M - Away until Feb - wrote: "Wonderful review Kathleen 💖"

Thank you, Margaret. :-)


Kathleen Teresa wrote: "Some of these stories would work well for a writing class, I thought -- they'd show how different versions of similar stories evolve.

I agree about Shirley's connection to Eleanor. I think [book:T..."


Thanks so much, Teresa. Great point about showing the transformation, and I totally agree about The Road through the Wall. I think you and I are examples of the perfect readers of this collection! Off to read your review.


message 5: by Sara (new) - added it

Sara I would love to visit these stories someday. Jackson was a one-of-a-kind writer. Reading her is mostly fun, with a little edge of sorrow, I think.


message 6: by Violeta (new)

Violeta It must be quite liberating writing for your own pleasure without having imaginary readers and their expectations in mind. But is that possible? From your review I gather it is, or at least it was for Shirley Jackson. Writing must have been lifesaving for her.
Marvelous review, Kathleen. Thanks for sharing!


Kathleen Violeta wrote: "It must be quite liberating writing for your own pleasure without having imaginary readers and their expectations in mind. But is that possible? From your review I gather it is, or at least it was ..."

Thanks, Violeta!

We can't know whether Shirley wrote these not expecting to publish them, or wrote them and then decided not to or couldn't get them published. My thought was she just hadn't edited them for publishing yet. Regardless, I think you're right it was a lifesaver--probably is for most writers. :-)


Kathleen Sara wrote: "I would love to visit these stories someday. Jackson was a one-of-a-kind writer. Reading her is mostly fun, with a little edge of sorrow, I think."

Oh, I agree about the sorry, Sara. I love her attempts to mask it though. :-)


message 9: by Candi (new)

Candi "... they do explore humanities odd, quirky side."

Yes - that's what I love best about the SJ short stories I've read thus far! I'll save this collection for when I get close to the end of her list! Fabulous review, Kathleen :)


Kathleen Candi wrote: ""... they do explore humanities odd, quirky side."

Yes - that's what I love best about the SJ short stories I've read thus far! I'll save this collection for when I get close to the end of her lis..."


Enjoy it when you do, Candi. Thanks!


Teresa Kathleen wrote: "I think you and I are examples of the perfect readers of this collection!"

Love that!


back to top