欧宝娱乐

Paul Bryant's Reviews > Nine Stories

Nine Stories by J.D. Salinger
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
416390
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: short-stories

If kidnappers had snatched up J D Salinger some time in the early 1970s, driven like madmen through the night and the next day too and imprisoned him in a small but pleasant room somewhere near Boise, furnished him with with all mod cons, and told him he wasn't going anyplace soon until he'd finished at the very least another nine stories, and at best three or four complete novels; and if the kidnappers - due to an endearing cocktail of naivete and compassion (because you know they were just literature fans like you and me, not blank-eyed killers, and they weren't entirely convinced about this whole caper to begin with let it be said) let JD go for long walks (to get inspiration, but really to beat on a nearby farmhouse door and call the cops); and if they were then rounded up (not too hard, said the cops) and put on trial - not a jury in the land would have convicted them.
When the prosecution rested and the defence opened, their lawyer would simply have issued a copy of Nine Stories to all 12 jurors and said "Ladies and gentlemen, I rest my case."

This is not to say that each of the Nine is such a great golden glowing nugget of controlled power, insight and wisdom (some are) but that the whole is such eloquent proof of the perspicacity, intelligence and all-round humanbeingness of JDS that reading this collection is very bittersweet - how lovely it all is, and how very little of it there is, when duller, pudgier-fingered writers type on, and on, and publish, and publish.
Anyone who has encountered comments by myself on Ye Olde Catcher in Ye Rye will now accuse me of inconsistency, or at least, be expecting me to accuse JDS of the same. How can I hate the novel for its unbearable whine and Johnny-one-note somebody-shut-him-up-please tiresomeness and yet enjoy all the rest of JDS as I do? They're cut from the same cloth, it's not like Picasso's blue period and Picasso the cubist which could have been different guys, or the Velvet Underground's first and third albums which could have been a different band. But I've come across this in different areas of the universe - can't stand Tom Waits until Swordfishtrombones, think he's a genius for three albums, then can't stand him again. Shakespeare's tragedies - oui! Shakespeare's comedies - er, non! So maybe not that unusual.

JDS famously published all his stuff between 1951 and 1963 and then STOPPED. (Which is why the kidnappers pounced, they gave him a good ten year rest and that was ENOUGH to their way of thinking.) And he stopped just as things were getting really interesting. He writes of the murderous conformities of American educated middle-class life and of the outcasts and especially young kids who either subvert this button-down world or bail out swiftly. Just as he stopped publishing things began to change. the 60s began swinging, and the youthquake (as it has been termed) was upon us. Just the very stuff that you might have thought would have fascinated JD. What do the kids do when they try to make their own rules up? I feel the absence of JDS throughout the 60s and 70s, as i feel the absence of another American writer who STOPPED in 1963, Sylvia Plath. I want to know what these two clever clogs would have made of the tumultuous ten years which followed the self-stilling of their voices.

But back to the Nine Stories - and to steal a fellow reviewer's catch-phrase:

Is it a classic?

Answer : Yes. Goddamn!


PS : I realise I also speculated upon the advisability of kidnapping Thomas Bernhard elsewhere but that was to save the world from any further novels like Extinction, whereas the JD Salinger kidnap is for the opposite reason. But I would like to publicly state that I do not condone the imprisonment of any writers for any reasons, so please don't try this at home.

126 likes ·  鈭� flag

Sign into 欧宝娱乐 to see if any of your friends have read Nine Stories.
Sign In 禄

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
June 10, 2009 – Shelved
June 14, 2009 – Shelved as: short-stories

Comments Showing 1-23 of 23 (23 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Dottie (new)

Dottie So I probably shouldn't admit here that I'm not much of a Slinger reader BUT this little write up gave me a chuckle when it came to love to hate and love to love. I'm thinking that might fit me on these as well -- but I'll have to read more Salinger to find out for sure so maybe i'll try Nine Stories -- stories equal shorter, varied -- might help give me a better Salinger picture overall, no? Yes?

Anyway -- I'll watch for your final word on this one.


message 2: by [deleted user] (new)

Yes!

(But you're wrong about The Catcher in the Rye.)


message 3: by Trevor (new)

Trevor and Waits, he just works best in threes, the three after Mule Variations are also the work of genius, though, Rain Dogs is still probably his best...

Must try to track this down. Wonderful review.


message 4: by Joshua Nomen-Mutatio (last edited Jun 16, 2009 11:47PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Joshua Nomen-Mutatio Trevor wrote: "and Waits, he just works best in threes, the three after Mule Variations are also the work of genius, though, Rain Dogs is still probably his best..."

I think I'd place Bone Machine in a tied position with Rain Dogs. Disclaimer: I'm a pretty big fan but I've still not listened to everything he's done.






message 5: by Trevor (new)

Trevor And Twelfth Night is one of Shakespeare's best.


message 6: by Cookiesue9x (new)

Cookiesue9x My fave bit with Tom Waits is in "Ironweed", Jack Nicholsen, Meryl Streep AND Tom Waits!!!
Your review was just great fun to read, but, I love Catcher in the Rye, I REALLY LOVED it as a teenager, but, still liked it a lot when I read it again a few years ago.


Paul Bryant Tom Waits is also great in Short Cuts (which is based on Raymond Carver stories and directed by Robert Altman - three of my favourite American artists coming together - had to be something special, and it was)


Noran Miss Pumkin My favorite--see my review. My favorite too! sorry David Rye sucks! Just do not get Rye--really think you have to have a set of balls to get it at all! Now nine stories is a treasure for the ages. The basis for "Finding Forester" with Sean I love the Scot!


Lisa Vegan Oh, I loved Catcher in the Rye as a kid; I understood his grieving I guess. I don't know if it would hold up or not. Nine Stories is well worth reading, although I read it decades ago as well.


message 10: by Paul (new) - rated it 4 stars

Paul Bryant Hey Abigail, my review of Rye is supposed to put you OFF! Don't do it!


message 11: by Ian (new)

Ian "Marvin" Graye I still wonder what John Lennon would think if he was alive.


message 12: by Dan's (new)

Dan's Well I just show that girl U must ;ve been talking about. I was expectin to see J.D Sallinger in there some place.. guess I mistook yr thread for sth else completely. Still U came on rather hard down on that man.. He was an outsider leaving his life the way he decided to.
Are u criticing him for that.. even if he went all te way to meet her, which still U got no account for, yr notions are way off the limit


message 13: by Paul (new) - rated it 4 stars

Paul Bryant Hi Liz - I hope the guy in the photo doesn't find out!


message 14: by Lzz (new) - added it

Lzz well, to be fair, plath didn't STOP, she DIED

;)

but then again, perhaps neither salinger nor plath would have survived the 60's, let alone what followed?


message 15: by Paul (new) - rated it 4 stars

Paul Bryant Plath would have become a fierce feminist and Salinger would have written the ultimate novel of student rebellion. (He may actually have done that, and it might be one of the five books we've been promised).


message 16: by Lzz (new) - added it

Lzz I dig it. :)


message 17: by Paul (new) - rated it 4 stars

Paul Bryant I did know that, Liz!

/review/show...

These English actors are all over the place now, such as Andrew Walking Dead Lincoln.


Andrew Smith Loved the stories - and your review!


Katie Pham @Paul, every review you posted on the book I've read or am reading is a story of its own. The kind of story that one gets very excited to read. You're one of the reasons I'm very grateful for having a 欧宝娱乐 account.
Even when I sometimes don't share the same sentiment towards a piece, please don't stop reviewing books, Goddamn!


message 20: by Paul (new) - rated it 4 stars

Paul Bryant thanks Katie - I don't intend to stop, but Brothers Karamazov has slowed me down in the last week or so. It's a bit long, you see.


message 21: by Frederic (new) - added it

Frederic Van Laere Love the Catcher. And your reviews of course. Thank you. Once again 馃檪


message 22: by James (new) - added it

James I dislike Catcher so much. I had no interest in reading any more Salinger, but I will take your glowing recommendation. Thank you.


message 23: by Paul (last edited Aug 19, 2020 07:46AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Paul Bryant thanks James... as ever, money back if not completely satisfied.


back to top