ŷ

switterbug (Betsey)'s Reviews > Wellness

Wellness by Nathan  Hill
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
2843912
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: favorites

I’m gobsmacked, and have remained so from page one to the last word. An epic, sweeping, transformative, colossal (adverbs and adjectives are just not enough!) door-stopper of a book, a windswept and fiery, burning satire of a 1990s marriage between a modern couple in Chicago, Jack and Elizabeth. There’s a preoccupation with eternal love, health and well-being, the potent obsession with fitness and strength. How past years� discarded identities generate the self of today, afraid or unafraid of tomorrow.

Jack is a photographer, but his pictures arise from the chemicals and fixatives in the darkroom, not from the camera. Elizabeth is a scientist who peddles placebos to rejuvenate passion. WELLNESS spans twenty years forward, but reaches back, to their childhoods, shifting back and forth in time. Or should I say Time, since Time is essential here, it subverts the narrative and liquidates expectations. It’s about everything, sort of like Infinite Jest is about everything, and it’s a parabola, like Gravity's Rainbow is a parabola, but it’s neither the former or latter. The prose is gracefully placed on the page, despite the legion of info (critics would say info-dumping) that the text provides. Hill straddles the line between saying and pontificating, which may cause some readers to recoil.

Hill has created his own radical, non-starry-eyed romance, a 90s mosaic of Gen X ideology, as Jack and Elizabeth assemble and inhabit their identities via several and ongoing selves throughout the years, to someday evolve or diminish into what they are now. The stakes, at first, seem fairly mellow. I mean, the worst that I thought could happen is a break-up. Hooooold on, about those stakes. Hill drove them hard through my heart. It’s heavy, at times I felt my throat closing up. This isn’t a book I could read non-stop, I had to take breaks to release the tension, otherwise I would explode!

It's also about perception and paradox, connections and loneliness, greed and loss, manipulation and madness. The narrative winds through a buffet of subjects, and love is the polestar, and the threat. Love at first sight is endorsed and dismantled, but never abandoned. There’s so much breadth, from artists to investors, groupthink to prairie fires, children to ancestors, “forever homes,� the World Wide Web, health, sickness, and cures, social media, absence--and the faith in metaphysics, that our souls can travel at night.

Paradox: “…that was a pre-globalized world, a pre-9/11 world, a pre-housing bubble world…when they all sort of understood implicitly that however much they resented and resisted the mass economy, they would also have little trouble eventually finding a job and livelihood within it.�

Thematically rich in artful contradictions, as a new friend earnestly says to Elizabeth: “He practices the art of nothingness, while you practice the science of nothingness. You’re both obsessed with it: nothingness, emptiness, blankness, absence. Don’t you find that really meaningful?�

And this touched my heart, a poignant guidance from the scientist that mentored Elizabeth:

“Believe what you believe…but believe gently. Believe compassionately. Believe with curiosity. Believe with humility. And don’t trust the arrogance of certainty.�

This book is so deep, vast, mind-bending, and provocative, I just can’t do it justice. It’s written for all of us, all the Time, wherever you are, visible and manifest.
480 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Wellness.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

October 26, 2023 – Started Reading
October 26, 2023 – Shelved
November 1, 2023 – Shelved as: favorites
November 1, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 54 (54 new)


message 1: by Bruce (new) - added it

Bruce Katz Wow. I'm convinced!


BooksnFreshair (Poornima Apte) Hmm, I read so many negative reviews of this one that I figured I wouldn't pursue it. Maybe I should?


switterbug (Betsey) BooksnFreshair (Poornima Apte) wrote: "Hmm, I read so many negative reviews of this one that I figured I wouldn't pursue it. Maybe I should?"

Hi P'ma!! I think it kind of depends on whether you like a novel with this kind of vast subject matter. He does squeak into Foster Wallace territory at times. I can definitely see why this is divided in critique. Some people feel there's too much "telling" rather than showing, but I think it all depends on how you interpret this sort of third person limited, put I'm still trying to determine what "tense" it is. I do like these crazy trippy books, though. It's not stream of consciousness, per se, but it is filed with lyrical language. Gravitas, too. I had to take a few breaks. Especially on the Grand Prairie of Kansas occasionally


BooksnFreshair (Poornima Apte) Thanks, Betsey! Yeah, it might not be for me if it's stream-of-consciousness type prose. I'm still curious though so might rent it from the library...


switterbug (Betsey) It's not stream-of-consciousness, it's actually rather smooth and graceful and rational. But it's a LOT of information on all these subjects he covers. The haters might say he was info-dumping or "telling" too much, but he straddles that line well, at least for me.


switterbug (Betsey) Bruce wrote: "Wow. I'm convinced!"

Bruce--I would love to know what you think of this book--you always have a prevailing cool head when you review!


message 7: by Bruce (new) - added it

Bruce Katz "you always have a prevailing cool head when you review"
I'm trying to think of something witty or winsome to say in response. Hold please.


message 8: by K (new)

K Fabulous review! It makes me want to go to the bookstore right now and buy this book! I have The Nix by Nathan Hill on my shelf, but I haven't read it yet.


switterbug (Betsey) Bruce wrote: ""you always have a prevailing cool head when you review"
I'm trying to think of something witty or winsome to say in response. Hold please."

: > )


switterbug (Betsey) K wrote: "Fabulous review! It makes me want to go to the bookstore right now and buy this book! I have The Nix by Nathan Hill on my shelf, but I haven't read it yet."

That you, K, for your kind words. And you sound like me--collecting books by authors that still sit on the shelf. For instance, I have most of Sebastian Barry's books but didn't read any until this year, when I read Old God's Time! Now I can go back and read his oeuvre, mostly available on my shelf. !! I need to go back and read The Nix. I think I once started it and got disrupted.


Theresa (mysteries.and.mayhem) Awesome review! I have this book on my shelf just begging to be opened. I need to read it before the year's out. I can't wait after your review!


message 12: by Ann (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ann Amazing, great review, Betsey!! I loved this as well - but you said it all so perfectly!!


message 13: by switterbug (Betsey) (last edited Nov 02, 2023 11:55AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

switterbug (Betsey) Theresa (mysteries.and.mayhem) wrote: "Awesome review! I have this book on my shelf just begging to be opened. I need to read it before the year's out. I can't wait after your review!"

Thank you, Theresa! So glad you liked my review--and the book is amazing!


switterbug (Betsey) Ann wrote: "Amazing, great review, Betsey!! I loved this as well - but you said it all so perfectly!!"

Ann, thank you so much! Wellness is quite a magnum opus!


message 15: by Cathy (new) - added it

Cathy Fabulous review, Betsy! I have to tell you, I found you (quite some time ago) via my husband who also enjoys your reviews. You should write a book yourself as your way with the written word is so fluid and descriptive. Reading is everything to me, it relieves me of stress and helps me forget my worries. Whenever I’m ready for my next book I always check your reviews! Thank you.


switterbug (Betsey) Cathy wrote: "Fabulous review, Betsy! I have to tell you, I found you (quite some time ago) via my husband who also enjoys your reviews. You should write a book yourself as your way with the written word is so f..."

Cathy, you just gave my heart a big pump with your kind words. That really made my day and turned my week around! I can now say, "This week was extra special" when I look back on it. Namaste to you and your husband and your family. If my reviews give you even one millimeter of insight into a book I read, then I am so grateful to you and your husband and also happy to keep doing it. I am speechless!!! xo


message 17: by Fran (new)

Fran Excellent review, Betsey!😍


switterbug (Betsey) Fran wrote: "Excellent review, Betsey!😍"

Thank you so so much, Fran!!


message 19: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa I am confused and intrigued by your review. I think clarity may come after reading the book. I want to get to it eventually when I am in the right frame of mind.


switterbug (Betsey) Lisa wrote: "I am confused and intrigued by your review. I think clarity may come after reading the book. I want to get to it eventually when I am in the right frame of mind."

I hope I didn't add to your confusion, Lisa! I hope you can enjoy this book for yourself.


message 21: by Lori (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lori Cote Scott Brilliant review Betsey! I LOVED it too!


switterbug (Betsey) Thanks so much, Lori! I must see your review, also!


message 23: by Alec (new) - rated it 5 stars

Alec Cartwright @switterbug (Betsey) I appreciate your considerate review, and it is a book that exceeded my fairly high expectations.

I completely respect the validity of your perspective to put Hill’s masterpiece within the pantheon of Infinite Jest & Gravity’s Rainbow (full disclosure, Infinite Jest I’ve in a not bragging way read 6 times and is my favorite novel alongside Musil’s “Man Without Qualities�, Pynchon’s GR I’m on my second run).

I think Hill is indebted to David Foster Wallace, and he is I think also influenced heavily by Dave Eggers & Jonathan Franzen (27th City, earlier, better Franzen).

I loved Wellness, only Charlie Kaufman’s 2020 “Antkind� would for me rank higher as best novel in the past 15 years.

I wish Hill had doubled the length, made it the 1,000 page Gaddis-like epic.

I felt he ironically was only lacking in one area:

He needed to overwrite, give us more character depth and shift POV’s even more. Basically do more of what he did already.

I think if he writes another novel, it will be that William Gaddis-esque epic.

This is such a promising milestone, and it changes the reader, for the better.

It’s powerful.

“Don’t forget to subscribe�, Madagascar, Benjamin Quince’s scene-stealing hilarity, “hunger�, he is hilarious in his incision of a particular cluster of American pathologies in a way David Foster Wallace or say John Kennedy O� Toole (“Confederacy of Dunces�) would applaud!

I am glad you wrote this amazing review Betsey, honestly it was the clincher when I found a copy for 30% off at Target (your review!)


switterbug (Betsey) Alec—you totally made my day with your compliment and comments, Thank you!

Yes, I agree he is indebted to DFW, Eggers, and I haven’t read 27th city but sounds like I should. I do see tendrils of Franzen. I own some Gaddis, i believe, and need to peek in.

In all ways, thank you so so so much, Alec!


message 25: by Jill (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jill YES, this is a brilliant book, and I'm so glad I waited 'til T-Day weekend when I could it without too much interruption. It pierced me to the core. Your review does great justice to the book (you DO do it justice) and you captured the very core of it.


BooksnFreshair (Poornima Apte) Betsey, I finished this book yesterday and loved it! So glad you reviewed it because otherwise I might not have picked it up. There are so many sharp vignettes in here. The most profound stuff for me was the abuse young Jack and Elizabeth faced growing up. Different "kinds" but piercing nevertheless. Just a great book overall. Definitely worth the five stars.


switterbug (Betsey) Jill wrote: "YES, this is a brilliant book, and I'm so glad I waited 'til T-Day weekend when I could it without too much interruption. It pierced me to the core. Your review does great justice to the book (you ..."
Thx, Jillz! This book had a lasting effect on me, it was brilliant!


switterbug (Betsey) BooksnFreshair (Poornima Apte) wrote: "Betsey, I finished this book yesterday and loved it! So glad you reviewed it because otherwise I might not have picked it up. There are so many sharp vignettes in here. The most profound stuff for ..."

Oh, I'm so glad that you did! I almost didn't go for it, either. I thought it might be to "cute." Boy oh boy, it blew me away! Yes, the abuse really gutted me, too. It made me think about the many many many different kids of abuse, but that all add up to the worst kinds of PTSD.


Farnoosh Brock Exactly. I'm feeling the same. Incredible! And the narration, omg the narration. It is such a superb performance.


message 30: by Deirdre (new)

Deirdre Bronchick Love this review! I so enjoyed The Nix and this sounds like a great ride of a read, adding this one to the list immediately.


David McDonald Beautiful review. It's difficult to know where to begin discussing a book like this that is borderline ineffable.


switterbug (Betsey) David--I so agree!


message 33: by Ceri (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ceri Yes!!!!!


switterbug (Betsey) Ceri wrote: "Yes!!!!!"
Yes, for sure! It's a topper!


Catherine I adored this book! Your review is much more thorough than mine, but I can see it hit all the same buttons for us.


Angela Brightwell The book is a masterpiece. Plain and simple.


message 37: by Anya (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anya This is a great review, I agree! The paradox of everything and the beauty of it all.


switterbug (Betsey) Farnoosh wrote: "Exactly. I'm feeling the same. Incredible! And the narration, omg the narration. It is such a superb performance."

Yes, Farnoosh. It swept me away!


switterbug (Betsey) Angela wrote: "The book is a masterpiece. Plain and simple."

Yessssssssssss!!!!!


switterbug (Betsey) Anya wrote: "This is a great review, I agree! The paradox of everything and the beauty of it all."

Thank you, Anya! Now I need to go back and read The Nix.


switterbug (Betsey) Catherine wrote: "I adored this book! Your review is much more thorough than mine, but I can see it hit all the same buttons for us."

Catherine, I love how your review includes the way you relate to it personally--I wonder what I would do if Jack's mother were my mother!


message 42: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Betsey, I am circling back now that I've read Wellness. I loved this one, though not quite as unabashedly as you. Hill definitely has the most important bases covered: prose, characterization, plot, and structure. Definitely one to recommend!


switterbug (Betsey) Lisa wrote: "Betsey, I am circling back now that I've read Wellness. I loved this one, though not quite as unabashedly as you. Hill definitely has the most important bases covered: prose, characterization, plot..."

Yes, I think I fell in love with this book while reading this. And I really liked his sister, too. I just read your review, Lisa, and you nailed it!


message 44: by Jaidee (new) - added it

Jaidee I am so hesitant about this one but your admiration gives me hope Betsey !


switterbug (Betsey) Jaidee wrote: "I am so hesitant about this one but your admiration gives me hope Betsey !"

It's hard to know who will and won't like it. Even for friends I've had for years. But I'll say this---one of my friends didn't think this would really be a book for her, and then ended up loving it.


message 46: by Glo (new) - rated it 5 stars

Glo Well done review. I listened to the audiobook and replayed parts to write down. The pain and pathos throughout this book are bookended with magic reminders of renewal and hope. Ari’s narration was part of the magic. His voice propels one forward without being precious. Love what you pointed out re prose and author’s ability to cover so many subjects.


switterbug (Betsey) Thank you, Glo! I love what you said about the pain and pathos being bookended with magic reminders of renewal and hope.

A lesser author WOULD have been too precious. Nathan Hill really rocks!


Natalie Snedden wow! That's an amazingly, on point review!


Patti Schreiber The quote about nothingness was the big aha moment.


message 50: by Tina (new) - rated it 5 stars

Tina I love your review. It was big for me too and definitely tense. There were a few times I almost put it down and I hardly ever do that.. For different reasons I saw some of myself in Elizabeth (I had both math and psychology degrees) and recognizing that, I made a dramatic positive change in myself. I also made an oil painting of a prairie burn. No spoilers, but that whole idea fascinated me.


« previous 1
back to top