Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Kathleen's Reviews > Shards of Honor

Shards of Honor by Lois McMaster Bujold
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
13954899
's review

liked it
bookshelves: space-opera, series-opener, fiction, audio, vorkosigan

I listened to the Blackstone Audio app. The narration is decent, but not outstanding. A pleasant male voice, probably a baritone. Given the 3rd-person POV was mainly the heroine's, a female voice would have served better, IMO.

3.5 stars for this space opera / romance, written under the guise of sci-fi, even though there is very little scientific innovation beyond the odd species in the opening chapters -- big bloodsucking balloon-like creatures, and some novel carnivores and herbivores. Of course, the series includes space ships, jumping through wormholes, and fierce battleship weapons.

At its core, this is a "clean" romance (despite a filthy sexual offender) amidst a backdrop of interplanetary war. The heroine is taken captive and -- under dangerous circumstances -- falls in love with her noble captor. The feeling is fully reciprocated. The two must face various problems (some quite intense and creepy) and are separated several times across the book. For fairly long stretches, they are apart.

I was impatient during these separations, especially since the interplanetary espionage and warfare was not interesting to me. Also, Bujold did not provide any sufficiently developed and sympathetic secondary characters to follow when the leads were apart. (There are sympathetic secondary characters -- especially that one poor bastard -- but they mainly serve as props, used to help characterize the two protagonists as compassionate, loyal, and strong.)

I liked the heroine, Captain Cordelia Naismith. Not a whiner, she makes tough decisions, never taking the easy route if it will cause an innocent to suffer. Commander Vorkosigan falls for her quickly, as we eventually learn:
Later, lying warm in the darkness in Vorkosigan's room in the Count's townhouse, Cordelia remembered a curiosity. "What did you tell the emperor about me?"

He stirred beside her, tenderly pulling the sheet over her bare shoulder... "Hmm? Oh. He wanted to know what I saw in you. I told him," he paused a bit and continued almost shyly, "that you poured out honor all around you, like a fountain." (Hence the title.)
Cordelia is admirable, but I did not like the fact that she only returned to Vorkosigan when life on her planet became untenable. I felt she kept him hanging too long. He deserved better. (However, she makes up for it.)

I really liked the hero, Lord Aral Vorkosigan, starship commander and sometimes Admiral of noble birth. Unfairly dubbed "The Butcher of Kommar," he is honorable yet flawed, both needy and protective. He also keeps a few secrets. Expect to be surprised.

This is the first of a long and popular series. According to reviews, the author improves her craft with subsequent books. I will read another. (I did. The series does improve. See update below.)

=====================

About the series: The Vorkosigan Saga is space opera with some romantic bits here and there. As science fiction it's not outstanding, but interesting enough. In terms of innovations, the series mainly hinges on advanced biomedical technology, including cloning and other types of genetic engineering (no longer fiction).

Bujold does a nice job with characterization and plot development. Her pacing is good, too. I grew to love young Miles Vorkosigan (Cordelia and Aral's son), who first appears as a young man in The Warrior's Apprentice, and as a young boy at the end of Barrayar.

The series contrasts the militaristic, intolerant, feudal planet of Barrayar against the enlightened and generally progressive planet of Beta Colony. This cultural dichotomy is fairly suspect, but interesting. It serves a purpose.

Reading tip and a little history: Many last names sound the same. On planet Barrayar, noble sir-names begin with Vor, as with Vorkosigan, Vorbarra, Vorpatril, etc. "Vor-" is a prefix that means "warrior-lord" or something similar. This naming system began about 600 years ago, after Barrayar's wormhole to Mother Earth collapsed and the Period of Isolation began, transforming (and regressing) advanced Barrayar into a feudal system of government. Barrayarans are descendants of Russian, English, French, and Greek colonists.

Some photos that describe the entire series:

=======

My reviews of this series (*favorites):

Shards of Honor review
*Barrayar review
*The Warrior's Apprentice review
The Vor Game review
Cetaganda review
The Mountains of Mourning review
Labyrinth review
*Borders of Infinity review
Brothers in Arms review
Mirror Dance review
*Memory review
*Miles in Love: Komarr, A Civil Campaign, Winterfair Gifts review
*Komarr review
Diplomatic Immunity review
Captain Vorpatril's Alliance review
Cryoburn review
9 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Shards of Honor.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 20, 2013 – Started Reading
April 20, 2013 – Shelved
April 21, 2013 –
0.0% "Space opera. A popular series begins here"
April 24, 2013 –
32.0% "Chapter 5. Cordelia and V are now on board his spaceship. Hmm. He put her in fancy digs -- the admiral's vacant cabin."
April 25, 2013 –
34.0% "Chapter five.

"It first occurred to me when I saw you in the ravine."

"What? Throwing up in the mud?"

He grinned at that. "With great composure. By the time we finished burying your officer, I knew.""
April 26, 2013 –
85.0% "A clever operation a lá fish tank. Put those feminine wiles to good use, Cordelia."
April 26, 2013 –
85.0% "Surprised and full of surprises, this Lord Commander Varkosigan."
April 26, 2013 –
92.0% "I can see why this series is so popular."
April 26, 2013 –
95.0% "Later, lying warm in the darkness in Varkosigan's room in the Count's townhouse, Cordelia remembered a curiosity. "What did you tell the emperor about me?" He stirred beside her, tenderly pulling the sheet over her bare shoulder... "Hmm? Oh. He wanted to know what I saw in you. I told him," he paused a bit and continued almost shyly, "that you poured out honor all around you, like a fountain.""
April 26, 2013 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-24 of 24 (24 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Suzanne (Under the Covers Book blog) Is this a romance book, or a sci fi adventurey one?


Kathleen I will let you know more when I finish it, but definitely there is a developing relationship between Cordelia and her captor, and it's starting to look like a romance, set in space, with warring planets. I'm not expecting sex, but who knows?!


Kathleen So, probably both a romance and an action-sdventure space opera. It's the first of a series. Very popular, too.


Kathleen Thanks, my dear Ji-chan! You were interested? It does have some great scenes. I may read book two. (Maybe) If the writing improves as much as people say, I'll let you know. =)


Kathleen Yup! So many books, so little time! I totally understand the need to prioritize. It's fairly low on my list, but perhaps some day I'll be in the mood again. :)


message 6: by Ingie (new)

Ingie Nicely written Kathleen. Love your odd book selections! =)


message 7: by S (new)

S Great review, Kathleen!


Kathleen Ingela wrote: "Nicely written Kathleen. Love your odd book selections! =)"

Hah! Thanks, Ingela dear!


Kathleen Susanne wrote: "Great review, Kathleen!"

Thanks, Susanne! :)


Blacky *Romance Addict* Woman you are not comping up on my feed at all, and none of your reviews are in my daily review e-mail :((((( that is so weird :((( I had to go and check what you've been reading lately :((((
Hope all is ok?


Kathleen Huh? That is really wierd. I am gonna go see if my settings got screwed up. I have not been on GR as much this last week. Traveling. Thanks for letting me know!! :)


Blacky *Romance Addict* Kathleen wrote: "Huh? That is really wierd. I am gonna go see if my settings got screwed up. I have not been on GR as much this last week. Traveling. Thanks for letting me know!! :)"

No problem! I have noticed several other friends that NEVER get into my review mail :(((
I haven't seen the last several reviews you wrote, and not a single status until today when I saw someone else like it. Totally weird, damn GR :((((


Kathleen Blacky *Must have HEA* wrote: "Kathleen wrote: "Huh? That is really wierd. I am gonna go see if my settings got screwed up. I have not been on GR as much this last week. Traveling. Thanks for letting me know!! :)"

No problem! I..."


Damn! Thanks for telling me, Blacky! I think I fixed it. I re-clicked all the Friend buttons. See if you get something in your Feed about my latest book, By These Ten Bones.


Kathleen Jill wrote: "...Instead, I'm going through my friends' book reviews manually each day. Time consuming as all get out, but effective. I'm sick of the problem with missing friends' reviews."

Wow, Jill. You have so many friends; that sure-fire method must take a lot of time. You and Blacky both!


Blacky *Romance Addict* you're missing people too Jill??? Omg will they ever fix it?????
What I do now, i go daily through my feed, separate the reviews from everything else and go through them, then later on check the mail. And yeah, I've seen lots of reviews that never get into the mail :(
but going through friends manually??? Omg i bow to you! That must take huge amounts of time :( but I understand, it's the safest way to go.
I'm gonna continue doing it this way, both the feed and the mail, I just might go trough my friends once a week to see what I've missed.

Kathleen, I'm on my mobile now, I'll check if I see your latest review as soon as I get to my laptop


Suzanne (Under the Covers Book blog) Great review Kathleen! I am definitely going to give this book a try, I love sci-fi heavy on the romance!


Kathleen Jill and Blacky, you amaze me. You both deserve the Very Finest Friend Award. Hands down!


Kathleen Suzanne the Mighty ~Satin Seductress~ wrote: "Great review Kathleen! I am definitely going to give this book a try, I love sci-fi heavy on the romance!"

Yay, Suzanne! it's a very popular series, with at least 12 installments. Word has it that each book is better than the last one.


Suzanne (Under the Covers Book blog) That's good news! Hopefully when I (eventually) get around to reading it I will like it, that way I have 12 books to look forward to!


Kathleen Yup! I am told book 12 is really great, A Civil Campaign


Suzanne (Under the Covers Book blog) Lol it might be a while before I get that far!


Kathleen So true, Suzanne! *chuckles*


message 23: by Floqueta (new)

Floqueta You do write magnific reviews, Kathleen. I laughed when I saw your comment, some days ago, that you had left the Earth, as I had done the same with Reckless Rescue


Kathleen Floqueta wrote: "You do write magnific reviews, Kathleen. I laughed when I saw your comment, some days ago, that you had left the Earth, as I had done the same with Reckless Rescue"

It is funny that we both read a space story at the same time. I am planning to read that off-world romance novel, Reckless Rescue. It sounds good, and then we can chat about it.

Magnificent. That's quite a compliment. The $$$ is in the mail, Floqueta!


back to top