Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Swankivy's Reviews > Night Mare

Night Mare by Piers Anthony
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
84660
's review

liked it

Imbrium is the main character of this story. She's the author's first female protagonist in this series, and though she is a horse (a night mare to be exact), she's still handled with the same sort of disrespect that Anthony frequently frames his female characters. At one point she is made powerless because a man tricks her into being dominated by him (he gets on her back and fits her with a bit, and she can't escape), and later the same man turns out to be a shapeshifter who dominates her by shifting into his horse form while she's "in season." Convenient, no, that the female's one weakness is her complete inability to resist the sexy man? Her urges overcome her and she's done in by her own attraction! This is the kind of thing that makes a lot of these books sound like a disturbing boy fantasy. That stuff can really be dangerous. But I'll look at the story too.

It's pretty inventive, though transparent in places. I still like the "gourd" world--the dream underground of sorts where nightmares come from. It was very clear that the man wearing a gold band was the same person as the horse wearing it, so I don't know what Anthony was trying to pull with that revelation. I also thought the succession of kings was interesting . . . the existing king was in an apparently hypnotic state and couldn't rule any more, so the successor got on the throne, and one by one their consciousnesses were captured by the Horseman. The rule was that Xanth could only be ruled by a Magician-class talented person. And when they start running out of possible kings, oh dearie me, it strikes them to wonder . . . hey, maybe we could get chicks to do it! Girl kings! No one ever thought of that before, even though the definitive factor for eligibility was supposed to be their magical strength. The very fact that anyone had to consider this a revelation is pretty telling. But for some reason, especially when I was a kid, I found it engaging to find out who'd be the next king to lead Xanth through an influx of attacks from Mundania while fearing being the next to be captured.
2 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Night Mare.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
February 22, 1995 – Finished Reading
April 22, 2013 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-5 of 5 (5 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Tony Agreed. Very inventive yet misogynistic. Still love Xanth, seems like it'd be better if Piers were from a different time. Meh


Wesy2k The part about Imbri sound like Fifty Shades of Grey and that didn't bother too many females ;-D


Swankivy If you think "not many females" were bothered by Fifty Shades, you haven't actually bothered to look up any of the criticism. It's pretty common for people to assume its popularity among women means that the Female Hivemind Approves of such things, but if you look at the HUGE discussions of consent violation and abuse surrounding that book, you will see that "lol but women like them some 50 shades tho don't they wink wink" is not an appropriate defense here. Not to mention that Fifty Shades was (imperfectly) portraying a consensual BDSM relationship. The female character in this situation did not consent at all. This is very important and is not something to create false equivalences about so you can rub someone's face in it.


Wesy2k Sorry, didn't mean to offend you. "Her urges overcome her..." didn't sound like any inconsensual thing and "dominates her by shifting into his horse form while she's "in season."" neither at the moment I read it. More like other written garbage with Fabio on the cover.
But no, I will not look up the internet for any discussion. Because they always look like "Da Vinci Code and Religion" or "Female Ghostbusters" and only the loudest group will be heard.
And no, I haven't bothered to read the whole 50 Shades because the contract was as fun as an IKEA manual. Actually less.
But looking at who actually went into the movie on valentines day, only the smallest portion actually brought a male companion to the cinema and they didn't seem bothered. Not the whole Female Hivemind but a small visible portion people saw sitting in the cinema.
And no, I won't defend any non-consensual relationship in RL.


Swankivy See but that's what I mean man. You're saying "ladies went to this movie, so clearly they weren't bothered." Yes, plenty of women loved Fifty Shades! And plenty of people in general used it as a bad inspiration to pursue what they thought was actual BDSM in their relationships. But you specifically said "not many females" were bothered by this book and I will guarantee you explicitly and enthusiastically that THERE WERE TONS AND TONS AND TONS AND TONS OF WOMEN WHO WERE EXTREMELY FRUSTRATED AND OFFENDED BY THIS BOOK. You have also specifically declared that you do not want to go look for them, so I imagine if that's the case, you'll trust me. As a person who did not read Fifty Shades at all, I can't comment on the content or compare it to a book I did read. But I can absolutely say that winky comments about how the ladies didn't mind when it was Fifty Shades are inappropriate because yeah, they did mind. You just didn't hear them because you don't look in the places they're saying them.


back to top