Julie's Reviews > A Constellation of Vital Phenomena
A Constellation of Vital Phenomena
by
by

Julie's review
bookshelves: contemporary-fiction, war-conflict, east-central-europe, best-of-2013, read-2013
Apr 23, 2013
bookshelves: contemporary-fiction, war-conflict, east-central-europe, best-of-2013, read-2013
Updating this review 10/28/15. Wishing I could read this again for the first time.
In a hospital in Volchansk, Chechnya, on a boarded-up gash where a window once sat, a crude mural depicts the city as it had been before it was reduced to rubble. Looking at the mural the viewer is spared, for as long as she can pretend, the reality that the open space would offer: a void of destruction and death.
In his astonishing debut, A Constellation of Vital Phenomena, Anthony Marra paints a mural of war so vivid in its awfulness that we tremble as we gaze, but we enter the tableau and become so caught up in the power of Marra’s narrative that we tread heedlessly on the landmines of heartbreak.
The war in Chechnya occurred not once but twice in our recent past. Its roots are so deep and tangled in the history of the North Caucasus region—which one character tries to tell in a six-volume, 3,300-page history—that most of us are helpless to identify who is fighting whom and where. Forget even trying to tackle the why. But if you can grasp that Chechnya tried to break away from Russia after the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1989, you’ll have a glimpse of the First Chechen War. If you understand the first war obliterated the infrastructure of the country and left it vulnerable and run by corrupt warlords, then you’ll have an inkling why Russia invaded a second time. But don’t worry that you still don’t know where this place is or why it’s fought over like a scrap of meat between starving dogs. You’ll get there. Be patient. Take a few minutes to Google a map of Chechnya or Wikipedia, but trust Anthony Marra help sort it out, through the graceful and tragic voices of his characters.
Marra unveils a time so awful it’s hard to get the head around, but with a sense of whimsy and just a touch of the surreal that the reader smiles, feeling awash with affection and hope, before being plunged again into the viscera of war. Akhmed’s exchanges with Sonja are delicious. Akhmed, who is so inadequate as a physician that he does less harm by drawing portraits of the dead and missing than treating the wounded, offers his skills to Sonja, who can sew up a man’s chest with dental floss. Yet she finds use for him in the hospital she runs with the assistance of an ancient nurse who speaks in the third person. Akhmed represents humanity—a flawed man, but one imbued with tremendous compassion. The child he saves, Havaa—the daughter of his best friend—is the shining star in this constellation of survivors. Sonja’s sister, Natalia, is a comet that sears past so quick and bright it takes the breath away. If you’re lucky, the comet will return again in your lifetime, as Natalia does between the two wars, but know that it will burn fast and disappear while your heart is still pounding. And Sonja is the sun—a strong and shining beacon of intelligence and ferocity—that keeps the stars in alignment. As much as a vulnerable, tired, angry and frightened human can.
It takes some time to settle into Marra’s style and the jarring construction of the narrative, but let go of logic, let go of linear structure and let the characters show you what they need to tell their story. The surface story takes place over a few days in 2004, when Havaa’s father is “disappeared� and Akhmed takes her from their village to the nearby city of Volchansk, to shelter her in the crumbling hospital. But expect shifts of time between the first and second Chechen wars—that is to say, between 1994 and 2004—with a few jumps to World War II, as the nesting dolls of history are dumped out and scattered on the table. There is a steady stream of characters, each with his or her own tattered tale to represent the ancient and modern history of Chechnya, each illustrating the madness of war.
War is absurd. The very idea that modern societies continue to resolve conflict with wanton destruction is beyond explanation. Regardless of our obsession with history, our pop culture fascination with wars distant and current, we seem destined to do the same thing over and over again, expecting but never achieving a different result. Einstein’s definition of insanity. In this arena of the absurd are ordinary people forced to live extraordinary lives.
Marra’s novel reminds us why art is vital to the continuation of the human race: art keeps us human, despite our avid attempts to obliterate humanity. Art exposes history that we tune out while it’s happening, because we’re just trying to get through our daily lives. Ah, the irony: experiencing at our leisure—with an act most of us find pleasurable (reading) —a past that we couldn’t make sense of when it was happening. The absurdity continues. But so does humanity.
In a hospital in Volchansk, Chechnya, on a boarded-up gash where a window once sat, a crude mural depicts the city as it had been before it was reduced to rubble. Looking at the mural the viewer is spared, for as long as she can pretend, the reality that the open space would offer: a void of destruction and death.
In his astonishing debut, A Constellation of Vital Phenomena, Anthony Marra paints a mural of war so vivid in its awfulness that we tremble as we gaze, but we enter the tableau and become so caught up in the power of Marra’s narrative that we tread heedlessly on the landmines of heartbreak.
The war in Chechnya occurred not once but twice in our recent past. Its roots are so deep and tangled in the history of the North Caucasus region—which one character tries to tell in a six-volume, 3,300-page history—that most of us are helpless to identify who is fighting whom and where. Forget even trying to tackle the why. But if you can grasp that Chechnya tried to break away from Russia after the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1989, you’ll have a glimpse of the First Chechen War. If you understand the first war obliterated the infrastructure of the country and left it vulnerable and run by corrupt warlords, then you’ll have an inkling why Russia invaded a second time. But don’t worry that you still don’t know where this place is or why it’s fought over like a scrap of meat between starving dogs. You’ll get there. Be patient. Take a few minutes to Google a map of Chechnya or Wikipedia, but trust Anthony Marra help sort it out, through the graceful and tragic voices of his characters.
Marra unveils a time so awful it’s hard to get the head around, but with a sense of whimsy and just a touch of the surreal that the reader smiles, feeling awash with affection and hope, before being plunged again into the viscera of war. Akhmed’s exchanges with Sonja are delicious. Akhmed, who is so inadequate as a physician that he does less harm by drawing portraits of the dead and missing than treating the wounded, offers his skills to Sonja, who can sew up a man’s chest with dental floss. Yet she finds use for him in the hospital she runs with the assistance of an ancient nurse who speaks in the third person. Akhmed represents humanity—a flawed man, but one imbued with tremendous compassion. The child he saves, Havaa—the daughter of his best friend—is the shining star in this constellation of survivors. Sonja’s sister, Natalia, is a comet that sears past so quick and bright it takes the breath away. If you’re lucky, the comet will return again in your lifetime, as Natalia does between the two wars, but know that it will burn fast and disappear while your heart is still pounding. And Sonja is the sun—a strong and shining beacon of intelligence and ferocity—that keeps the stars in alignment. As much as a vulnerable, tired, angry and frightened human can.
It takes some time to settle into Marra’s style and the jarring construction of the narrative, but let go of logic, let go of linear structure and let the characters show you what they need to tell their story. The surface story takes place over a few days in 2004, when Havaa’s father is “disappeared� and Akhmed takes her from their village to the nearby city of Volchansk, to shelter her in the crumbling hospital. But expect shifts of time between the first and second Chechen wars—that is to say, between 1994 and 2004—with a few jumps to World War II, as the nesting dolls of history are dumped out and scattered on the table. There is a steady stream of characters, each with his or her own tattered tale to represent the ancient and modern history of Chechnya, each illustrating the madness of war.
War is absurd. The very idea that modern societies continue to resolve conflict with wanton destruction is beyond explanation. Regardless of our obsession with history, our pop culture fascination with wars distant and current, we seem destined to do the same thing over and over again, expecting but never achieving a different result. Einstein’s definition of insanity. In this arena of the absurd are ordinary people forced to live extraordinary lives.
Marra’s novel reminds us why art is vital to the continuation of the human race: art keeps us human, despite our avid attempts to obliterate humanity. Art exposes history that we tune out while it’s happening, because we’re just trying to get through our daily lives. Ah, the irony: experiencing at our leisure—with an act most of us find pleasurable (reading) —a past that we couldn’t make sense of when it was happening. The absurdity continues. But so does humanity.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
A Constellation of Vital Phenomena.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
April 23, 2013
– Shelved
December 6, 2013
–
Started Reading
December 6, 2013
– Shelved as:
war-conflict
December 6, 2013
– Shelved as:
east-central-europe
December 6, 2013
– Shelved as:
contemporary-fiction
December 8, 2013
–
35.16%
"This is such an emotion- and information- loaded book I can manage only small bits at at time."
page
135
December 8, 2013
–
48.18%
"Everyone knew Sonja was destined for great things, but no one knew what to do with her until then. P 170"
page
185
December 9, 2013
–
57.81%
"I struggled with this at first, but now the pages are flying past."
page
222
December 9, 2013
– Shelved as:
read-2013
December 9, 2013
– Shelved as:
best-of-2013
December 9, 2013
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-24 of 24 (24 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Julie
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Dec 09, 2013 08:42PM

reply
|
flag

Connie- thank you. I generally avoid post-modern fiction that smacks of MFA cleverness and erudition. But Marra is brilliant. He manages to create a complex, multi-layered, multi-themed story with a unique and complicated structure about a place and time that lives in the abstract for most of us that is 100 percent accessible, humane, loving and respectful of the reader. Wow.


Michael, thank you! Add that made me laugh! SUCH a great scene from one of my favorite films. This may be the best reading year I've had since joining Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ. I'm getting ever more picky about what I'll read, so my To Read list doesn't expand much but my high ratings are becoming more frequent.
I've also decided to stop reviewing anything that I rate less than three stars-which is still a high rating, as far as I'm concerned. I just don't have the time (though it's rare that I get through something I don't enjoy!) and I don't want to expend the energy on negativity.
I learned so much from this book and the research it compelled me to do during and after reading. Next on the "If I can muster the courage " list is Tolstoy's Hadji Murat.

Perhaps it wasn't just the reminder of why I loved this book (but couldn't summon the words or ..."
Barbara, what a beautiful comment. Thank you. I'm so glad this book touched you as it did me. And thank you for the reminder to watch Joyeux Noel.
Peace to you during this season of darkness and light.



Margitte- you are so wonderful- thank you. I just saw this comment- my apologies for the delayed reaction!

Hee! Your gushing is delightful-thank you! This is one of my top "shove in everyone's hands and exclaim 'You must read this!"' reads of last year. Nothing beats the joy of discovering a book that sweeps you away, even one as painful to read as this is, at times.

Thank you, Carol. So young and so skilled. I'm just in awe of writers like Marra!


This must be amazing via audio. What a great gift to yourself, Angela. Happy listening :)

Happy New Year, my beautiful friend!
