ŷ

Nika's Reviews > Fatherland

Fatherland by Robert   Harris
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
76203549
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: fiction, thriller

The novel is set in 1964. We are transported to an alternate world in which Nazi Germany won the war, or at least it did not lose. Aging Hitler continues to hold onto power. He and his henchmen seem to tightly control Germany and the Germans. The territories under their rule stretch over much of Europe to Siberia in the east. Switzerland maintains neutrality.

What if Hitler had won? The story gives an idea of what life in Germany could have been like had the Nazi regime survived the war.

A corpse is found in the Havel River in Berlin. The dead man turns out to be a retired high-ranking Nazi official named Josef Buhler.
What caused his death? An accident? Suicide? Was he murdered? Xavier March, a criminal detective, has to investigate the case.
It is not long before he finds out that the death of Buhler may be part of something bigger. Some other former high-ranking Nazi officials died in the space of several years under somewhat dubious circumstances. Most of them knew Buhler and worked with him in the 1940s during the war.
Moreover, they seem to have attended the Wannsee Conference in 1942.

March's investigation leads him not only to solving the case of the alleged murders but also forces him to open his eyes to the history of his fatherland, to the history freed from myths and propaganda. March spent the war years in the Navy and knew close to nothing about what was happening on the ground. While his lack of knowledge can be explained, it seems that the whole nation succumbed to what could be called collective amnesia. Germans prefer to turn a blind eye to the fate of all those people who disappeared overnight, many of them their neighbors.
It is easier not to think of those whose lives were destroyed. The war almost inevitably produced certain excesses. Some things that were done had to be done. Maybe those things were horrible, but now it is over, and we, Germans, live in a peaceful Reich. Well, one careless word might raise suspicion. Soldiers are still dying. But they fight 'terrorists' in Siberia, those who do not want to become slaves, and they defend the German national interests, do they not? We should not dig into the past, should we?
But as one of the characters says:
“You can't build on a mass grave. Human beings are better than that - they have to be better than that - I do believe it - don't you?�

At some point March realizes that he can no longer ignore the past. The truth has the habit of revealing itself sooner or later. The power of truth usually cannot be hidden or silenced completely.

The novel is more than just a detective story. It can make us think of the famous or rather infamous adage "History is written by the victors." Is it always so? Does this mean that historical narratives are always somewhat biased? I believe, yes, to a certain extent they are.

The book is not perfect. I would have liked to see more details describing life in an alternate Reich. But I found it a very good read overall.
126 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Fatherland.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 28, 2023 – Shelved
November 28, 2023 – Shelved as: to-read
Started Reading
January 4, 2024 – Shelved as: fiction
January 4, 2024 – Shelved as: thriller
January 4, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-40 of 40 (40 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Berengaria (new)

Berengaria Read this years ago and it's one of the few Harris novels I've actually liked (Pompeii was the other). Glad you were able to enjoy it, too.


message 2: by Nika (last edited Jan 04, 2024 12:18PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nika Berengaria wrote: "Read this years ago and it's one of the few Harris novels I've actually liked (Pompeii was the other). Glad you were able to enjoy it, too."

Glad you, too, managed to like this novel, Berengaria. Besides this book, I read only An Officer and a Spy by Harris. I found it quite well-done and engaging. Maybe I should try Pompeii. Thanks for your comment. :)


message 3: by Connie (new)

Connie Sounds like a thought-provoking read! Glad you enjoyed this one, Nika! Great review!


message 4: by Nika (last edited Jan 04, 2024 01:24PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nika Coco wrote: "Sounds like a thought-provoking read! Glad you enjoyed this one, Nika! Great review!"

Thanks very much for your comment, Coco!


Mica Santos ⇢ What a nightmare! Great review, Nika! 💫💜


Nika Mica Santos � wrote: "What a nightmare! Great review, Nika! 💫💜"

Thanks so much for reading, Mica! 🧡


message 7: by Ian (new) - rated it 3 stars

Ian Great review Nika! This was the first book by Harris I read and still think it's one of the better ones. I'm kind of hit and miss with author; some books I like, others leave me cold.


message 8: by Laysee (new)

Laysee You made me curious to contemplate a world in which Hitler was victor. An interesting book for sure. Good review, Nika.


Mirnes Alispahić This novel deserves another movie adaptation, although HBO one is not that bad. I liked the novel, it's terrifying.


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) Scary alternate history, that! :)


message 11: by Chantel (new)

Chantel ^ I agree with Rosh, scary indeed.
Based on your star rating, I'll take it that this book was well-written so I will keep an eye out for it myself!


message 12: by Nika (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nika Ian wrote: "Great review Nika! This was the first book by Harris I read and still think it's one of the better ones. I'm kind of hit and miss with author; some books I like, others leave me cold."

Thanks so much, Ian! I see what you mean. I liked this novel but I can imagine how it doesn't resonate with the reader.


message 13: by Nika (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nika Laysee wrote: "You made me curious to contemplate a world in which Hitler was victor. An interesting book for sure. Good review, Nika."

This was an interesting read for me. Thanks so much for dropping a comment, Laysee.


message 14: by Ray (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ray Glad you liked this. I think it is one of his best books. If you want more alt history from Harris I would recommend Archangel


Chrissie I loved this book! I agree with Ray that it is one of his best


message 16: by Nika (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nika Mirnes wrote: "This novel deserves another movie adaptation, although HBO one is not that bad. I liked the novel, it's terrifying."

I've been thinking of watching a movie adaptation. At least it's not that bad. The novel is terrifying in many aspects, including the way in which it portrays a pervasively suffocating atmosphere of the Third Reich.


Stacey B Great book! Great review.


message 18: by AiK (new)

AiK Если бы войну выиграл Гитлер, или, по крайней мере, не проиграл - звучит устрашающе. Такое и в страшном сне не приснится. Надеюсь, в книге нет иллюзий о том, что Германия бы от этого выиграла.
"I may add some thoughts later." Хотелось бы узнать больше. С интересом ознакомлюсь с Вашими мыслями об этой книге.


message 19: by Nika (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nika Rosh (is busy; will catch up soon!) wrote: "Scary alternate history, that! :)"

Quite scary! :)


message 20: by Nika (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nika Chantel wrote: "^ I agree with Rosh, scary indeed.
Based on your star rating, I'll take it that this book was well-written so I will keep an eye out for it myself!"


Hope you find this book worthwhile if you get around to reading it, Chantel. In addition to being a what-if and mystery/crime story, it also comments on totalitarianism as a concept.


Persephone's Pomegranate What if Hitler had won? Thank goodness he didn't! Nicely summarized, my friend.


message 22: by Nika (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nika Ray wrote: "Glad you liked this. I think it is one of his best books. If you want more alt history from Harris I would recommend Archangel"

Thanks so much for the reference, Ray! I haven't heard of Archangel before.


message 23: by Nika (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nika Chrissie wrote: "I loved this book! I agree with Ray that it is one of his best"

So pleased to hear that you, too, loved this novel, Chrissie!


message 24: by Nika (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nika Stacey B wrote: "Great book! Great review."

Thanks so much, Stacey!


message 25: by Ron (new)

Ron Good review Nika! The kind of story that could give us a lot to think about. PS. Philip K. Dick also wrote stories in a similar vein.


message 26: by Nika (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nika AiK wrote: "Если бы войну выиграл Гитлер, или, по крайней мере, не проиграл - звучит устрашающе. Такое и в страшном сне не приснится. Надеюсь, в книге нет иллюзий о том, что Германия бы от этого выиграла.
"I ..."


Нет, в книге нет никаких иллюзий по этому поводу. Наоборот, в каком-то смысле сложно назвать победой ту жизнь немцев, которую рисует автор. Рисует иногда не прямо, не в лоб, а штрихами.
Спасибо, AiK. Может быть, напишу ещё об этом романе.


message 27: by Nika (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nika Persephone's Pomegranate wrote: "What if Hitler had won? Thank goodness he didn't! Nicely summarized, my friend."

It would have been a nightmare if he had. Thank you for the feedback, my friend!


message 28: by Nika (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nika Ron wrote: "Good review Nika! The kind of story that could give us a lot to think about. PS. Philip K. Dick also wrote stories in a similar vein."

Yes, a thought-provoking story that has some layers under the surface.
I know Philip K. Dick wrote stories about alternate history, but haven't read them yet. Thank you for reminding me of this, Ron.


message 29: by Joe (new) - rated it 2 stars

Joe I remember reading this, and I remember being underwhelmed, but for the life of me I can't remember why. The Philip K. Dick novel of a similar theme is The Man in the High Castle.


message 30: by Karen (new) - added it

Karen What an amazing review Nika! 😊 I hadn't heard of this and as scary as it sounds like I'm intrigued by your thoughts and rating enough to add to my tbr list. Thank you as always you 💓 manage to aid in my discovery of 📚 books to stimulate me. 🌹
xx


Hanneke Very good review, Nika. I thought too that the book surely makes you think of what might have happened. For sure, an interesting novel, I thought.


message 32: by A (new)

A Mac This one sounds like it could be quite fascinating and thought-provoking. I'm glad you enjoyed this one overall, Nika!


message 33: by Nika (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nika Joe wrote: "I remember reading this, and I remember being underwhelmed, but for the life of me I can't remember why. The Philip K. Dick novel of a similar theme is The Man in the High Castle."

Seems that this novel isn’t everybody’s cup of tea. And I think I can understand why.
Exactly! The Man in the High Castle.

Thank you for your feedback, Joe.


message 34: by Nika (last edited Jan 12, 2024 12:40PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nika Karen wrote: "What an amazing review Nika! 😊 I hadn't heard of this and as scary as it sounds like I'm intrigued by your thoughts and rating enough to add to my tbr list. Thank you as always you 💓 manage to aid ..."

Thanks so much for your kind comment, Karen! 🧡 This was a stimulating read for me. I was thinking of this novel days after finishing it. Do hope you too like it and get the most out of it! Anyway, I’d be very interested in learning your thoughts on it. 📘😊


message 35: by Nika (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nika Hanneke wrote: "Very good review, Nika. I thought too that the book surely makes you think of what might have happened. For sure, an interesting novel, I thought."

Thank you for stopping by, Hanneke! Looks like we’re on the same page regarding this novel.


message 36: by Nika (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nika A wrote: "This one sounds like it could be quite fascinating and thought-provoking. I'm glad you enjoyed this one overall, Nika!"

Thanks so much for stopping by, A! 🧡


message 37: by Linda (new)

Linda Interesting. This reminds me of the Man in the High Castle.


message 38: by Nika (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nika Linda wrote: "Interesting. This reminds me of the Man in the High Castle."

I’ve yet to read the Man in the High Castle. Thank you, Linda.


message 39: by Joe (new) - added it

Joe Krakovsky That was a good review, Nika. Alternate histories can be scary.


message 40: by Nika (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nika Joe wrote: "That was a good review, Nika. Alternate histories can be scary."

Thank you for your feedback, Joe!


back to top