ŷ

Jeffrey Keeten's Reviews > The Girl Who Played With Fire

The Girl Who Played With Fire by Stieg Larsson
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3427339
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: nordic-noir

He had come.
He smelled of aftershave.
She hated the smell of him.
He...observed her for a long time.
She hated his silence.
Then he spoke to her. He had a dark, clear voice that stressed, pedantically, each word.
She hated his voice.
He laid the back of a moist hand on her forehead and ran his fingers along her hairline in a gesture that was probably intended to be friendly.
She hated his touch.

Lisbeth Salander is simply unforgettable.


I read the first book in this trilogy the year it was published in English and I remember the book so vividly that even five years later I transitioned into this book as if I’d just finished reading Dragon last week. Salander is 4�11�, but she walks across the literary landscape with such giant strides it is impossible to ignore her. People who have never read the books or seen the movies have a vague idea of who she is. People who have watched the movies or read the books may eventually forget her name decades from now, but they will not forget her persona; her verve; her courage.

Now before we start feeling all warm and fuzzy about Salander there are few problems with knowing her. If you cross her she might throw a Molotov cocktail through your window. She is unreliable, unrelenting, and if you own a computer she will know everything about you. She is a hacker extraordinaire and even though she is extremely private, almost maniacal about her own personal information, she has no problem hacking into your personal affairs after all YOU should have been more careful with it. Despite her bristly exterior and her tendency to answer questions with a stare or a monosyllabic response you might find yourself attracted to her. She has a lesbian friend Mimmi who tries to explain Salander’s relationship with sex.

”Apart from the fact that you’re not a dyke. You’re probably bisexual. But most of all you’re sexual--you like sex and you don’t care about what gender, You’re an entropic chaos factor.�

ENTROPIC CHAOS FACTOR, sounds mathematical and math does play a role in this novel, but my version of what Mimmi meant by that statement is that Salander is a person who will parachute in out of the blue, shag you until your nucleus becomes a comet, and then leave before you’ve had time to light your first coitus joint.



”A root of an equation is a number which substituted
into the equation instead of an unknown converts
the equation into an identity. The root is said to satisfy
the equation. Solving an equation implies finding
all of its roots. An equation that is always satisfied,
no matter the choice of values for its unknowns,
is called an identity.�


Salander solves complex math equations for relaxation purposes. Throughout the novel she is pursuing the answer to Fermat’s last theorem. Now in the 1990s Andrew Wiles solved the problem using the world’s most advanced computer programme which sounds like cheating to me. When she does figure out Fermat’s intention it is the only time I can remember Stieg Larsson recording his literary heroine...giggling.

Stieg Larsson is an interesting story. He delivered three novels to his publisher and shortly thereafter died from a heart attack, attributed to walking up seven flights of stairs. This unexpected demise helped launch the books onto the bestseller lists. We are morbid aren’t we. He was an investigative reporter by trade and there was an inquiry into whether foul play was involved. It seems he was just a 50 year old man that fate placed a situation in front of him, an out of service elevator, that provided the proper strain to his heart to kill him. What endears these novels to me, even more, is that he wrote them in the evenings as an escape from regular life. Now, there are issues with these books, the use of name brands over and over. You will tire of hearing Powerbook, IKEA and Billy’s Pan Pizza. If Larsson ate as many Billy’s Pan Pizza as Salander does in the book that might be the doughy rope that squeezed his heart.


Billy's Pan Pizza is YUMMY!!!

Click the link to check out the Billy's Pan Pizza television commercial. It is a hoot.


Despite any issues I had with the writing, and sometimes it was clunky, the raw power of the writing and a compelling plot made those issues irrelevant.

Salander gets along just fine with the majority of the population, but she hates men who hate women. She ran into several of those in the first book and one in particular is seared into my memory, Nils Bjurman. He is the lawyer that has been assigned to her competency case. She was declared incompetent by the courts and assigned Bjurman to take care of her affairs. Salander is a confident person sometimes too confident and in book one she underestimates her ability to control a situation with Bjurman. He turns the tables on her and brutally raped her. With a presence of mind that is beyond most of the rest of us she recorded the rape and even as he is doing the most sadistic things to her she is going over and over in her head where she made the mistake and what she was going to do to him if he allowed her to live. Interesting enough she lets him live, but holds the video over his head like the sword of Damocles.

Besides the video she does administer her own form of brutal vengeance, but there is a practicality to her decision not to kill him. The courts would simply assign her another mentor that she doesn’t have control of and of course she would have to weather an investigation into his murder. In this book she makes a similar mistake in her pursuit for the man responsible for inspiring the rage and the violence that swirls around her.



Mikael Blomkvist is back and when his team of writers unearth a white slavery ring he finds himself battling a controversial issue that may impact the highest levels of society. Underage girls are being brought from Russia and forced into prostitution. It would be an easy assumption to make that every member of society would want to eliminate a situation that allows young girls to be exploited against their will. One of the problems is that men in government, in positions of power, enjoy the availability of such young, beautiful girls for their own sexual perversions. Despite the fact that Salander is not talking to Blomkvist, he is baffled as to why, she is drawn into the investigation because of the use of the name of one man... Zalachenko. As she becomes the main focus of the investigation she is forced to go underground, a skill she is particularly adept at, and as the rocket fueled plot comes to a conclusion this reader couldn’t have put this book down even if the building was burning down around my ears because Salander... always... puts out a fire with gasoline.

See these tears so blue
An ageless heart
that can never mend
These tears can never dry
A judgement made
can never bend
See these eyes so green
I can stare for a thousand years
Just be still with me
You wouldn't believe what I've been thru

You've been so long
Well, it's been so long
And I've been putting out fire
with gasoline
putting out fire with gasoline
David Bowie
138 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Girl Who Played With Fire.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 27, 2013 – Started Reading
April 27, 2013 – Shelved
May 1, 2013 – Finished Reading
February 9, 2015 – Shelved as: nordic-noir

Comments Showing 1-50 of 57 (57 new)


Jeffrey awesome read. One of the few trilogies I've read where each book gets better than the previous


Dolors hoping for a daring review on this one!


Jeffrey Keeten Me TOO! I hope to get time to work on it tomorrow.


Gary  the Bookworm I think this was the weakest of the three (all that shopping at IKEA) but I'm sure your review will entertain.


Dolors yep Gary, but the ending was surely a shot of adrenaline, at least it was for me!


Gary  the Bookworm WOW!!!


Jeffrey Keeten Gary wrote: "WOW!!!"

Thank you Gary! Three !!! points put a smile on my face.


Arah-Lynda I loved this trilogy as well Jeffrey. Great review!


Jeffrey Keeten Arah-Lynda wrote: "I loved this trilogy as well Jeffrey. Great review!"

Thanks Arah-Lynda! Really compelling trilogy, almost impossible to put down.


Dolors Daring review indeed Jeffrey (almost got a heart attack with the Billy's Pan Pizza guy).
Even I have a soft spot for Salander, and I think I'm not bisexual, at least for the moment! ;P


Jeffrey Keeten Dolors wrote: "Daring review indeed Jeffrey (almost got a heart attack with the Billy's Pan Pizza guy).
Even I have a soft spot for Salander, and I think I'm not bisexual, at least for the moment! ;P"


If you get a chance to watch the TV commercial (46 seconds) it is fun. I included the link in the review.

As far as bisexuality there is always a time and a place where anything is possible. :-)haha I'm glad you found the review daring enough.


Dolors Jeffrey wrote: "Dolors wrote: "Daring review indeed Jeffrey (almost got a heart attack with the Billy's Pan Pizza guy).
Even I have a soft spot for Salander, and I think I'm not bisexual, at least for the moment!..."


Ha!I'd love to have a toaster like that, plus I love the music, not strange that he couldn't stop dancing! :))


message 13: by Lawyer (new) - added it

Lawyer You da'man. Hittin' all the hot licks right down to the perfect Bowie lyrics.


Jeffrey Keeten Mike wrote: "You da'man. Hittin' all the hot licks right down to the perfect Bowie lyrics."

Thank you Lawyer Stevens. I'm so glad you were not assigned Lizbeth Salander to your case load. She would have kept you so busy you wouldn't have time for anything else.


message 15: by Harry (new)

Harry Great book, great movie, great review, Jeffrey. Larsson's the one that got me going on my latest Nordic thriller binge...:-)


Gary  the Bookworm Harry wrote: "Great book, great movie, great review, Jeffrey. Larsson's the one that got me going on my latest Nordic thriller binge...:-)"

Nordic thriller binge sounds intriguing. More information, please?


message 17: by Jonathan (new)

Jonathan Peto Read the first one and was drawn in but didn't continue, mainly because there's so much else out there and the writing was a bit clunky, the organization too sometimes. I'm glad to hear this has some power though and just may have to give it a shot sometime. Thanks.


Michael Fun and thoughtful review. I delayed on reading the second one too. Disappointed how Michael and Salander never really intersected in this one. Sort of like a fugue with different instruments, apart but making music together. And I wished the Fermat Theorem was integrated into the plot more. Still for a fan of thrillers, this was still a good ride. So we should do the Hornet's Nest sometime in the next 5 years (but sadly, no more).


midnightfaerie Loved these books too. Loved Lisbeth. Great review!


message 20: by Harry (new)

Harry Gary wrote: "Harry wrote: "Great book, great movie, great review, Jeffrey. Larsson's the one that got me going on my latest Nordic thriller binge...:-)"

Nordic thriller binge sounds intriguing. More informati..."


Gary, this counts for both books and Netflix. First and foremost, I began to read Jo Nesbo's Harry Hole series which I think is probably at the top of my list for this genre. It is the most devastating examination by an author and written tale of a flawed character and his redemption as a policeman that I've ever read (read in order). Then there's the Mankell "Wallanderr" series (TV and books). Then we have the Annika Bengtzon series (TV and books). I'm working on finding some lesser known Nordic writers as we speak. Hope that helps.


Jeffrey Keeten Jonathan wrote: "Read the first one and was drawn in but didn't continue, mainly because there's so much else out there and the writing was a bit clunky, the organization too sometimes. I'm glad to hear this has so..."

Oh I understand Jonathan. I didn't expect to take this long to read the second one. I have too many interests in too many genres and authors to stay in one pasture very long. Yes, as I alluded to in my review the writing is clunky and I kept thinking I should be more upset about this, but Salander and the plot were just so compelling it overrides the technical difficulties. I did think as I was reading this, what a perfect airplane book.


Jeffrey Keeten Harry wrote: "Gary wrote: "Harry wrote: "Great book, great movie, great review, Jeffrey. Larsson's the one that got me going on my latest Nordic thriller binge...:-)"

Nordic thriller binge sounds intriguing. M..."


Jo Nesbo is fantastic. I just had him sign all my books this year. I like the Wallander books as well though some people find them too slow. I enjoy the pace though. Sjöwall and Wahlöö are fun as well, only ten of those. I also like the Icelandic writer Arnaldur Indriðason, but he can be uneven. I also enjoyed Peter Høeg's Smilla's Sense of Snow.


Jeffrey Keeten Michael wrote: "Fun and thoughtful review. I delayed on reading the second one too. Disappointed how Michael and Salander never really intersected in this one. Sort of like a fugue with different instruments, a..."

Thanks Michael I was trying to have fun with this one and yet focus more on the character of Salander than on the plot of the novel. When Salander gets mad at a person she stays mad. It is like trying to thaw an iceberg with a microwave.

He really had a great concept with using Fermat's Theorem, but didn't take full advantage of the concept. I have no idea how the editing worked on this books since he died before they got that far.

I hear this is the weakest of the three so I'm hopeful he will finish strong with Hornet.


Jeffrey Keeten midnightfaerie wrote: "Loved these books too. Loved Lisbeth. Great review!"

Thank you Midnightfaerie! I might have had too much fun with this review. I'm not sure how many more times I can look at the guy eating pizza. haha


Jeffrey Keeten Bennet wrote: "I've seen both versions of the film and loved the story. Your review brings it even more to life and makes me want to read it soon, and not just this one but the series. As always, well done!"

I have really enjoyed the Swedish films. I think they capture the essence of Salander perfectly. The Dragon Tattoo might make for a nice break between weightier reads. Thanks Bennet!


Gary  the Bookworm Thank you Harry and Jeffrey for the recommendations.


message 27: by Lynne (new)

Lynne King An extraordinary review Jeffrey. You never cease to amaze me. I especially liked the sword of Damocles image.


Jeffrey Keeten Lynne wrote: "An extraordinary review Jeffrey. You never cease to amaze me. I especially liked the sword of Damocles image."

Thank you Lynne. I had all the balls in the air on this one. If you have time click the link for the Billy's Pan Pizza commercial. It is rather humorous (46 seconds).


message 29: by Lynne (new)

Lynne King Love it!


message 30: by Will (new) - rated it 4 stars

Will Byrnes Combustible!


Jeffrey Keeten Will wrote: "Combustible!"

Will Byrnes the Stephen King of GR blurbs. I'm using this blurb--COMBUSTIBLE!-- on the front cover of my first novel.


message 32: by Lynne (new)

Lynne King Combustible Will. My..now that gives me thoughts of fire...Of all the senses...


Jeffrey Keeten Michael wrote: "Fun and thoughtful review. I delayed on reading the second one too. Disappointed how Michael and Salander never really intersected in this one. Sort of like a fugue with different instruments, a..."

Michael I forgot to mention to you that Larsson did have 3/4 of the fourth book in the series written. He had intended 10 all together following in the footsteps of the Sjöwall and Wahlöö duo. Unfortunately his estate is under siege with relatives and a girlfriend vying for their share of the royalties, but I assume at some point in time someone will be commissioned to finish the fourth novel. Wouldn't it be cool if it were Jo Nesbo?


message 34: by Cathy (new)

Cathy DuPont ...that Salander is a person who will parachute in out of the blue, shag you until your nucleus becomes a comet, and then leave before you’ve had time to light your first coitus joint.

Jeff, only you could come up with the description of that sweet young thing. Bet you chuckled (rather LOL) when you were writing that one. We're among friends, tell me.


message 35: by Lynne (new)

Lynne King I agree with your comment Cathy!


Michael Cathy wrote: "...that Salander is a person who will parachute in out of the blue, shag you until your nucleus becomes a comet, and then leave before you’ve had time to light your first coitus joint..."

I agree with Lynne and Cathy how outrageously good that is. But does it not reflect more on you? How one interlude in the books captured your imagination and had you hoeplessly waiting for more through more than 1,000 pages?

Am laughing to myself over a reminder of the scene in "What's New Pussycat" where Ursula Andress parachutes into Peter O'Tool's convertible sports car. (But in that case she starts to unzip, and he zips her back up, and say's "Put that away", trying to stay faithful despite being hopelessly magnetic).


Michael Jeffrey wrote: "...Michael I forgot to mention to you that Larsson did have 3/4 of the fourth book in the series written...Wouldn't it be cool if it were Jo Nesbo?
Aye! Likely to work better than with literary giants. (As a contrast, Hemingway's "Garden of Eden" had 48 chapters when he died, and it was chopped to 30 for the posthumous book).


message 38: by Cathy (last edited May 04, 2013 04:58AM) (new)

Cathy DuPont Michael wrote: "Cathy wrote: "...that Salander is a person who will parachute in out of the blue, shag you until your nucleus becomes a comet, and then leave before you’ve had time to light your first coitus joint..."

Michael:

You guys (other posts from other reviews) amaze me of your recollection of specific scenes in movies. I saw that movie and damned if I can recall that scene or any other for that matter. I do vaguely recall the overall theme of the movie though, thank goodness.


message 39: by Cathy (new)

Cathy DuPont Lynne wrote: "I agree with your comment Cathy!"

Hi Lynne:

It seems we get a kick out of some of Jeff's more racy comments, don't we? Does that say anything about us? Maybe that we're human and like humor? :D


Jeffrey Keeten Cathy wrote: "...that Salander is a person who will parachute in out of the blue, shag you until your nucleus becomes a comet, and then leave before you’ve had time to light your first coitus joint.

Jeff, only..."


Well Cathy you know how I go about writing these reviews and ever so often lightening strikes and the right words get in the right order and I go to myself WHOA! that's not bad. I was for sure chuckling over that line.


Jeffrey Keeten Michael wrote: "Cathy wrote: "...that Salander is a person who will parachute in out of the blue, shag you until your nucleus becomes a comet, and then leave before you’ve had time to light your first coitus joint..."

Thanks Michael! I remember that scene. I need to rewatch that movie. It has been twenty plus years since I've seen it. Cathy probably doesn't remember that scene because she was neckin' with some guy in the movie theater. ;-)


message 42: by [deleted user] (new)

So well done. Salander seems like a marvelously interesting character. Kind of turns traditional femme fatale on its head.


Gary  the Bookworm Steve aka Sckenda wrote: "So well done. Salander seems like a marvelously interesting character. Kind of turns traditional femme fatale on its head."

She's been compared to Pippi Longstocking.


message 44: by Cathy (new)

Cathy DuPont Jeffrey wrote: "Michael wrote: "Cathy wrote: "...that Salander is a person who will parachute in out of the blue, shag you until your nucleus becomes a comet, and then leave before you’ve had time to light your fi..."

Ha, ha, Jeff. I was going to say "well, maybe" but then thought "well, probably." And he was probably thinking I was Ursula Andress. Whatever it takes.

Guess I need to see it again myself, by myself, huh? :-)


Michael The loneliness of Kansas breeds imagination. It did for Dorothy too.


Michael And Truman Capote. But Jeffrey shows no sign of homicidal madness, just looped a bit from all the Updike he read recently. We should be grateful he is a "make love, not war" kind of guy, but dwelling on Salander to have both in one package.


message 47: by Cathy (new)

Cathy DuPont Michael:

Nice comment re: Jeff. I agree and had forgotten about Updike. Yes, looped is a very nice way to put it.

Enjoy your comments, by the way. And I see you gave it three stars. Apparently you weren't as intrigued with Salander as Jeff.


Jeffrey Keeten Steve aka Sckenda wrote: "So well done. Salander seems like a marvelously interesting character. Kind of turns traditional femme fatale on its head."

Lots of intriguing issues in these novels and the way Larsson handles morality is very interesting. Thanks Steve aka Sckenda


Jeffrey Keeten Michael wrote: "And Truman Capote. But Jeffrey shows no sign of homicidal madness, just looped a bit from all the Updike he read recently. We should be grateful he is a "make love, not war" kind of guy, but dwel..."

And more Updike to be read this year. He is such a bad, bad boy and such a wonderful influence on me. haha


Jeffrey Keeten Cathy wrote: "Jeffrey wrote: "Michael wrote: "Cathy wrote: "...that Salander is a person who will parachute in out of the blue, shag you until your nucleus becomes a comet, and then leave before you’ve had time ..."

I didn't ask you if you behaved yourself watching Lincoln or did your "friend" prove to be a distraction. haha


« previous 1
back to top