Sara's Reviews > The Covenant of Water
The Covenant of Water
by
by

Sara's review
bookshelves: borrowed-from-library, culture, family, india, individuality, literary-fiction, multi-generational
Dec 09, 2023
bookshelves: borrowed-from-library, culture, family, india, individuality, literary-fiction, multi-generational
I was warned by more than one person that this book was not equal to Cutting for Stone and might disappoint me. That was not the case. I found it had the same depth, the same magical quality, and the same ability to put me in a particular location and in the skins of the characters. IMHO, Verghese has done it again.
The Covenant of Water follows three generations of an Indian family who have a “condition� that makes them unable to tolerate water and susceptible to drowning. Once more, Verghese brings his medical expertise to bear on a very human story. He immerses his reader in the culture of India, without ignoring the pitfalls of a caste system and the influence of the British.
One thing Verghese does that might be jarring to some readers is switch between stories as he follows different characters through their lives. He begins with a young girl, unnamed, which I think is very intentional, who at 12 years of age is about to be married to a much, much older man. I became very invested in her story and suddenly found myself in what could be another book entirely as Verghese takes up the story of Digby, a young doctor from Glasgow, on his way to India to get the surgical experience he is being denied in Scotland.
Again, I was completely drawn into Digby’s story when I was transported back to the original set of characters. It was necessary to trust Verghese to run these two parallel lines together at some point, and he was entirely worthy of this trust. I personally found both stories so compelling that the switches from one to another were only momentarily startling.
This book is replete with profound themes, including the nature and purpose of suffering, the role of religion in coping with life, the ties of family, the question of fate vs. free choice, the danger of secrets, and the importance of love.
“Forgive me, Lord.� She thought her prayers were unanswered. But God’s time isn’t the same as hers. God’s calendar isn’t the one hanging in her kitchen. To everything there is a season, and a time to every purpose under heaven.
What’s fur ye won’t go by ye, Digby thinks. It was a phrase his mother would use: whatever is in his destiny will come to him, regardless.
I found much of the book to be about this balance: trusting and waiting for God to intercede and finding the destiny you cannot avoid, the one that gives you purpose, the one that makes your life meaningful. Sometimes the destiny we want is not the one that is meant for us; but the one that is meant for us can be richer than we imagine.
There is also the sense of loneliness and isolation that comes from being different. Yet, it is the difference that makes each of these characters so extraordinary. It is the sorrows and tragedies that inform their talents and what they give back to the world in which they live. They do not leave the world as they found it.
Yes, old man, yes, eyes open to this precious land and its people, to the covenant of water, water that washes away the sins of the world, water that will gather in streams, ponds, and rivers, rivers that float the seas, water that I will never enter.
This is a very weak review for a very marvelous book. I cannot match the inspiration or convey the exceptional depths of thought this book stirred in me. I believe Abraham Verghese is one of the great writers of his time.
The Covenant of Water follows three generations of an Indian family who have a “condition� that makes them unable to tolerate water and susceptible to drowning. Once more, Verghese brings his medical expertise to bear on a very human story. He immerses his reader in the culture of India, without ignoring the pitfalls of a caste system and the influence of the British.
One thing Verghese does that might be jarring to some readers is switch between stories as he follows different characters through their lives. He begins with a young girl, unnamed, which I think is very intentional, who at 12 years of age is about to be married to a much, much older man. I became very invested in her story and suddenly found myself in what could be another book entirely as Verghese takes up the story of Digby, a young doctor from Glasgow, on his way to India to get the surgical experience he is being denied in Scotland.
Again, I was completely drawn into Digby’s story when I was transported back to the original set of characters. It was necessary to trust Verghese to run these two parallel lines together at some point, and he was entirely worthy of this trust. I personally found both stories so compelling that the switches from one to another were only momentarily startling.
This book is replete with profound themes, including the nature and purpose of suffering, the role of religion in coping with life, the ties of family, the question of fate vs. free choice, the danger of secrets, and the importance of love.
“Forgive me, Lord.� She thought her prayers were unanswered. But God’s time isn’t the same as hers. God’s calendar isn’t the one hanging in her kitchen. To everything there is a season, and a time to every purpose under heaven.
What’s fur ye won’t go by ye, Digby thinks. It was a phrase his mother would use: whatever is in his destiny will come to him, regardless.
I found much of the book to be about this balance: trusting and waiting for God to intercede and finding the destiny you cannot avoid, the one that gives you purpose, the one that makes your life meaningful. Sometimes the destiny we want is not the one that is meant for us; but the one that is meant for us can be richer than we imagine.
There is also the sense of loneliness and isolation that comes from being different. Yet, it is the difference that makes each of these characters so extraordinary. It is the sorrows and tragedies that inform their talents and what they give back to the world in which they live. They do not leave the world as they found it.
Yes, old man, yes, eyes open to this precious land and its people, to the covenant of water, water that washes away the sins of the world, water that will gather in streams, ponds, and rivers, rivers that float the seas, water that I will never enter.
This is a very weak review for a very marvelous book. I cannot match the inspiration or convey the exceptional depths of thought this book stirred in me. I believe Abraham Verghese is one of the great writers of his time.
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
The Covenant of Water.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
December 1, 2023
–
Started Reading
December 1, 2023
– Shelved
December 2, 2023
–
9.93%
"Off to a great start. I feel caught up in this girl's tale. Has the feel of Amy Tan's early novels for me."
page
71
December 2, 2023
–
15.1%
"The first part completed, the book segues into a completely different story. The transition is startling, but the story is good right from the first page and it takes no time at all to be involved in the new set of characters. I am anxious to see how these people will intersect, as I'm sure they will."
page
108
December 4, 2023
–
26.71%
"OMG, NO! And now we go back to the original story, when I only want to stay with this one. LOL. This is just too marvelous. Nothing could make me stop reading."
page
191
December 5, 2023
–
37.2%
"End of Part III. Back to Big Ammachi and introduced to Rune and the leper colony.
Wondering about Digby."
page
266
Wondering about Digby."
December 7, 2023
–
78.32%
"There is a beautiful symmetry to Ammachi's life. What a marvelous and memorable character. I also love Baby Mol--the recognition that every life has meaning."
page
560
December 9, 2023
– Shelved as:
borrowed-from-library
December 9, 2023
– Shelved as:
culture
December 9, 2023
– Shelved as:
family
December 9, 2023
– Shelved as:
india
December 9, 2023
– Shelved as:
individuality
December 9, 2023
– Shelved as:
literary-fiction
December 9, 2023
– Shelved as:
multi-generational
December 9, 2023
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-41 of 41 (41 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Cathrine ☯️
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Dec 09, 2023 07:05AM

reply
|
flag

No, Sara. The book may have been marvelous, but so was your review. I wouldn't have expected anything less.
I've owned "Cutting for Stone" for a good while and now I want to read it and "The Covenant of Water."


Thank you, Ann. I felt inadequate to review it. It is one I will not forget.

No, Sara. The book may have been marvelous, but so was your review. I wouldn't have expected anything less.
I've owned "Cutting for Stone" fo..."
I would be so delighted to know what you think of both, Howard. I loved Cutting for Stone, but I think this one might even edge it a little for me.

I know you are going to love this, Megan, because I know how you reacted to Paul Scott's Raj Quartet. This book and A Fine Balance are both musts for you!

It is a beautiful novel, Cynthia. I am so impressed with this man's ability to draw into a world that is so foreign to me and make me feel one with it. Cutting for Stone did that and so does this one.

I'm not sure what people who were not happy with this could have wanted from Verghese. Read Cutting for Stone, Diane...you will like it, and just go ahead and add this one, because you will want to read Verghese more than once!



I think he is going to be an important author when people are looking back 50 years. I won't be here to give him my vote, so I am voting now.

Thanks, Laysee. I feel frustrated when I want to convey that a book is special and all the superlatives feel trite and over-used. He is putting together a puzzle but you cannot tell what the picture is until he reaches the end.



Thank you, Terry. You are all so kind! I tend to put newer books off (so many older ones I haven't gotten to), but I was anxious to read this one. Your heartfelt review is a testament to how this book can affect someone!

I think you will, Antoinette! I will be waiting and watching to see your reaction. I could have closed the book, flipped it and started over again.



