ŷ

Rosemary Atwell's Reviews > Stone Yard Devotional

Stone Yard Devotional by Charlotte  Wood
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
15847499
's review

did not like it

Another navel-gazer, another endless musing best suited to a private journal or writing retreat. I long for crackling, sharp-edged writing that captivates and entertains instead of endless show-don’t-tell tactics and techniques.
105 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Stone Yard Devotional.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 7, 2023 – Started Reading
December 9, 2023 – Shelved
December 9, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-17 of 17 (17 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Jeanette Navel-gazing is a good description of this book. I have just finished it and wondered what on earth?


Rosemary Atwell I’m only reading classics of all genres and eras next year, Jeanette. Going to try and tick off that ‘should give it a go list!� Looking forward to your reviews.


message 3: by Sportyrod (new)

Sportyrod Sounds like you’re in for a good year.


Rosemary Atwell 😀


Karen Stephenson I didn’t enjoy this book, forced myself to finish hoping that the end would shed light on!


Rosemary Atwell 😞


Kate I'm sad for you that you didn't allow the naval gazing to process, I found this book healing and therapeutic.


Margaret I couldn’t agree more


Rosemary Atwell So this is long listed for the Booker!


Sammy Navel gazing is a pejorative for reflection and I found the moments of observation cracked open the hard baked judgements.


message 11: by Ernie (new) - added it

Ernie Rijs I agree that “navel gazing� sells this novel short. However, I think Wood’s use of an episodic and pastiche structure did the story no favours. However, there were some highlights for me: the “last days of [her] mother’s life�; the Vietnamese words “Kelly and I forgot�; and the constant gardener (a nod to Le Carré), Richard Gittens. I suspect this piece needs to be given time to soak into the soil of our souls. But I found it difficult to like.


Ingrid I love reflective books, but this one left me not cold� but rather, tepid? I cannot see how someone would be ‘deeply moved� by this book.


Marion Brownlee This book should not have been published


Lawrie Nah it’s incredible


message 15: by Trish (new)

Trish Mannix Why read a � navel gazer� or reflective autobiography if you don’t enjoy them?
I can learn from other peoples life experience and wisdom.


message 16: by Pat (new) - rated it 5 stars

Pat I hated when I ended this remarkable book. Some passages I read over and over. Oh how I loved the writing. I found myself reflecting on my own life through her memories. Wood wrote a definite award winner in this book.


Nancy Lauer I loved it. Couldn’t disagree more on this review.


back to top