Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Alwynne's Reviews > Creation Lake

Creation Lake by Rachel Kushner
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
119953219
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: contemporary-fiction, netgalley-arc

An intelligent, carefully-crafted play on an existential thriller partly inspired by Rachel Kushner’s fascination with leftwing, French crime writer Jean-Patrick Manchette. Set in 2013, Kushner’s narrative centres on an agent provocateur known, for now, as Sadie Smith. Ignominiously fired from her job as a covert operative for internal American intelligence, Sadie’s currently selling her services to the highest bidder. All we really know about Sadie is she’s 34, fluent in several European languages, and once embarked on a doctorate in rhetoric. The perfect background for her current assignment working for a shadowy grouping of powerful, monied figures. Sadie’s journey begins in Paris where she presents as the stereotypical, wide-eyed American abroad, rather like Sally in The Dud Avocado; but it’s a ruse that provides access to her targets through a complex process of seduction and infiltration.

Sadie’s expertise lies in environmental activism, what her employers would label eco-terrorism. She’s been charged to gain access to a communal farm overseen by faded politico Pascal Balmy who’s suspected of orchestrating a series of attacks on French infrastructure: forms of industrial sabotage intended to disrupt the forward march of agribusiness. During background surveillance, Sadie manages to hack Pascal’s email accounts, monitoring his contact with Bruno Lacombe a philosopher/anthropologist who’s retreated from the world, installing himself in a cave on his property close to Pascal’s group in southern France. Pascal and Bruno are both broadly anti-capitalist, direct descendants of the radicalism of May �68. But while Pascal remains convinced that capitalism can be fought from within, building on the situationist ideals of Guy Debord, Bruno’s drawn to a kind of anarcho-primitivist, anti-civilisation stance. He’s become obsessed with the paths not taken: prehistory and the culture of the Neanderthals, a “world before the fall, before class and domination.� For Bruno disrupting capitalism is no longer the answer, what’s needed is a shift in consciousness, to think beyond and outside it.

Although it’s effective read purely as a slightly-satirical variation on a conventional spy story, Kushner’s novel works well as a loose companion piece to her earlier The Flamethrowers: where that examined Italian leftist politics in the seventies, this could be viewed as an exploration of what came next. Kushner’s piece is impressively researched. She expertly interweaves fact and fiction indirectly referencing: Deleuze’s nomadism; key political texts like The Coming Insurrection, infamous journal Tiqqun; and elements of French social and political history from the climate change activism that led to the formation of Les Soulèvements de la Terre (Earth Uprising) to the fight for Larzac and the Tarnac Nine; violent police tactics and growing clashes over megabasin projects in rural France. Many of her fictional characters have real-life counterparts: Bruno parallels aspects of philosopher Bruno Latour; hapless politician Platon is a version of the controversial Manuel Valls; a prominent French novelist Michel Thomas conjures provocative author Michel Houellebecq. Thomas’s cameo also establishes a link to Houellebecq’s Serotonin which Kushner’s story sometimes overlaps.

Sadie’s an intriguing creation, world weary and cynical, she views the world as chaotic and ultimately lawless � she sometimes reminded me of Musil’s man without qualities. Like Reno in The Flamethrowers she often appears less engaged in action than in representing and interpreting everything around her. And like Reno years before, she soon realises women in far-left circles are routinely relegated to the periphery, the women of Pascal’s commune are mostly assigned to childcare and serving coffee. A situation that suits Sadie’s agenda, making her far less likely to be fingered as a potential saboteur. Although Sadie’s experiences will take her in a wholly unexpected direction, one which elegantly solves the mystery of Kushner’s ongoing juxtaposition of Bruno’s musings and Sadie’s activities. Although this may prove a little too dry for some readers, and I don't entirely agree with Kushner's underlying arguments, I found it surprisingly absorbing, ambitious and inventive.

Thanks to Netgalley and publisher Jonathan Cape for an ARC
67 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Creation Lake.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 1, 2024 – Shelved
August 29, 2024 – Started Reading
August 30, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-14 of 14 (14 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

endrju You've seriously whetted my appetite.


Alwynne I've no idea what you'd think of it, I can see that viewed from certain angles it might be considered slightly too slick and superficial. It was just refreshing to see someone engaging with theoretical perspectives that didn't involve wheeling out yet another tired commentary on Barthes! I also enjoyed puzzling out what texts/histories she was drawing on, in a trainspottery kind of way.


message 3: by Jan-Maat (new)

Jan-Maat sounds fun!


endrju Yeah, the theoretical corpus you mention is certainly more exciting than Barthes, with all due respect.


Alwynne endrju wrote: "Yeah, the theoretical corpus you mention is certainly more exciting than Barthes, with all due respect."

Although I'm not particularly drawn to anarcho-primitivism, and I'm not totally convinced about the direction that angle takes in relation to Sadie's journey. I also think in sending up Pascal's group there's possibly a danger of downplaying the significance and political importance of actual French climate change activists protesting recent rural corporate developments. But then again it's a twist on a thriller so presumably not meant to be read as a political treatise.


Alwynne Jan-Maat wrote: "sounds fun!"

It often was!


Lady Clementina ffinch-ffarowmore Sounds very good, especially all the ideological explorations.


Alwynne Lady Clementina wrote: "Sounds very good, especially all the ideological explorations."

I just liked how cleverly she subverted expectations and reworked the genre conventions, it was like reading an old school spy thriller but with the political/theoretical aspects brought to the fore.


message 9: by Claire (new)

Claire This sounds incredibly accomplished, as is your review! I'm intrigued, though I'm not familiar with the texts you mention, that subtle embedding of references seems to be popular at the moment, some authors pointing them out, others using more cryptic measures.


Alwynne Claire wrote: "This sounds incredibly accomplished, as is your review! I'm intrigued, though I'm not familiar with the texts you mention, that subtle embedding of references seems to be popular at the moment, som..."

Thanks! Yes it's very intricate and impressively constructed. It's not necessary to be familiar with her sources just things I've read at Uni etc...


Meike Excellent review, Alwynne!


Alwynne Thanks!


Sonja I too found it very absorbing. Loved your dense and satisfying review. I had a lot of feelings too reading this book. Like Sadie who was going through stuff and had to have a bunch of beers and other things to keep going.


Stephen Great review Alwynne. I haven't heard of most of the texts you reference.


back to top