Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

emma's Reviews > Land of Milk and Honey

Land of Milk and Honey by C Pam Zhang
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
32879029
's review

did not like it
bookshelves: non-ya, literary-fiction, authors-of-color, diverse, unpopular-opinion, nope, dystopian, sci-fi, lgbt-plus, reviewed, 1-star

i'll never be able to see the words milk and honey without thinking of instagram poetry. thanks rupi kaur.

but i liked this about the same as i would if it were in that genre, so. fair enough.

this is just not my type of book (no more pandemicish dystopian, please, i'm too fragile) nor of writing style.

more frankly, this is overwritten, with words used for how they sound rather than what they mean. "hulkings," as a synonym for hills. "humping" instead of rising. "eloquent" for an image of a graffitied d*ck. i didn't like it when cormac mccarthy did it, and he did it a lot better.

beyond that, between piles of adjectives, this landed heavily on cliches: "it wasn't until i hung up that i realized he'd never asked my name." no way! really?

add to these its gimmicks: "my employer" unwieldily used as many as four times a paragraph, as what was a fun style choice in early pages loses its sheen by the halfway point. if only there were a short, one or two syllable thing that we could call a specific person in order to reference them.

there are haystacks of em dashes every time another language is used, in an italy surrounded by expats as our monolingual protagonist.

there's italicized dialogue instead of the proletariat quotation mark.

in other words...a lot of unearned style here.

and ultimately my interest in the idea of an illicit, hyper-gifted chef cooking in secret in a dystopian world without food died when met with an untalented line cook. that, and a nonsense plot hinging on the justification-less idea that she'd be portraying a woman of another nationality at least decades her senior. 

not to mention that goofy ending.

anyway. this book doesn't know what it wants: for us to condemn its cast of wealthy, even as they do more than the politicians it can't bring itself to frame as the good guys; to extol the virtues of our protagonist, deliberately ignorant to the selfishness and ego and greed that rival anyone's; to approve of fine cuisine or skewer it, same with capitalism and global travel and age- and power-gap relationships and money and philanthropy and and and.

it's mealy mouthed in every way you can imagine, and it leaves a sour taste.

bottom line: not yummy.

---------------------
tbr review

i just like reading about food
266 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Land of Milk and Honey.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 14, 2024 – Shelved
April 19, 2024 – Started Reading
April 23, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-16 of 16 (16 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Sydney (new)

Sydney Have you looked at Piglet by Lottie Hazell yet


message 2: by s.penkevich (new)

s.penkevich For real though!


message 3: by Emma (new) - added it

Emma I DNFed this and I’ve never felt more affirmed in my life


Mel (Epic Reading) Thanks for even this brief note to start Emma. Moved from ‘want to read� to ‘maybe to read�. I suspect it might get downgraded again� I’m also not a poetry fan so I suspect the details of your review will resonate. Looking forward to reading it!


message 5: by Nahyan (new)

Nahyan Ameen I definitely thought it had something to do with Rupi Kaur from the title as well!


message 6: by emma (new) - rated it 1 star

emma Nahyan wrote: "I definitely thought it had something to do with Rupi Kaur from the title as well!"

craziness!


message 7: by emma (new) - rated it 1 star

emma Mel (Epic Reading) wrote: "Thanks for even this brief note to start Emma. Moved from ‘want to read� to ‘maybe to read�. I suspect it might get downgraded again� I’m also not a poetry fan so I suspect the details of your revi..."

it isn't poetry-y but it is overwritten!


message 8: by emma (new) - rated it 1 star

emma Emma wrote: "I DNFed this and I’ve never felt more affirmed in my life"

this validation is everything to me


message 9: by emma (new) - rated it 1 star

emma s.penkevich wrote: "For real though!"

!!!


message 10: by emma (new) - rated it 1 star

emma Sydney wrote: "Have you looked at Piglet by Lottie Hazell yet"

yes i read it and did not like it


message 11: by molly (new) - added it

molly DAMN I wanted this to be good


David Coyer Wow, this sounds like a truly captivating and sensory novel! The premise of a young chef discovering pleasure and her own power in a world struggling with food scarcity is already intriguing. Add to that the lush setting, enigmatic characters, and themes of desire, deception, and transformation, and I'm hooked! The use of language sounds stunning, and I appreciate the blend of sensuality, joy, and sharpness. The exploration of ethics, privilege, and survival is timely and thought provoking. And, of course, who can resist a love letter to food and wild delight? I'm excited to dive into this rapturous and revelatory novel, and I appreciate your recommendation! Lol


Michael M Your review was spot on. Rarely has a book given me such a visceral reaction.


message 14: by glen (new)

glen r Thankfully I’m a bit older so I still think of Exodus & the Promised Land when I hear Milk & Honey (& I certainly don’t think poetry when I Rupi Kaur)


message 15: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Hanson Interesting. I loved this book. I see your points, but for me it was like a decadent and guilty pleasure, but also rich with meaning. The premise and the narrative arc worked for me and delivered surprises. I will be following this author for sure.


message 16: by hannah (new)

hannah Saved me a book purchase


back to top