ŷ

Lynne King's Reviews > The Ginger Man

The Ginger Man by J.P. Donleavy
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
15736557
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: fiction, j-p-donleavy

Review � The Ginger Man � 28 May 2013

“When you get back Kenneth, I’ll walk naked wearing a green bowler to greet you at the boat. With a donkey cart flying green streamers and green shamrocks imported from Czechoslovakia and a band of girl pipers blowing like mad. Did you know that they imported the English sparrow into America to eat horseshit off the streets?�

Who else, but an Irish writer, and a zany one at that, could possibly have written that?

It’s interesting to know, however, that when “The Ginger Man� was published in Paris in 1955, it was simultaneously banned in Ireland. It was considered obscene at the time and it typically took the all-embracing French to appreciate it for its sensual and literary worth.

Yes, I did find it slightly risqué when I first read it but then that was twenty or so years ago and so returning to “The Ginger Man� after this gap, has been a shock, to put it mildly, to my system. I recall that previously I sailed through it, appreciating it for the Irish dry sense of humor, the nonchalant air of the poverty-stricken protagonist, Sebastian Dangerfield, and the atmosphere of Dublin in the late forties. I was so impressed by it in fact that I immediately purchased another five of his books:

“The Onion Eaters�
“A Singular Man�
“Meet My Maker the Mad Molecule�
“The Saddest Summer of Samuel S�
“The Beastly Beatitudes of Balthazar B�

They were all pretty comical and wacky, especially “The Onion Eaters� but basically the best one was “The Ginger Man�. Why is it, I ask myself, that so many authors write a magnificent first novel and then the following ones never seem to live up to the initial expectations?

But now, reading this book, I’m viewing it completely differently; if anything it’s more the style as opposed to the plot which really cannot be called too exciting and which regrettably doesn’t enthrall me to turn the page, and read and read, without putting it down until the end. It has a writing style, however, that is quite unique, and I would imagine very difficult to do, that of swinging from the first to the third person and back via the main character, Sebastian Dangerfield. That is either very clever or extremely foolish but it suits the style of this book.

An example is:

“O’Keefe sauntered sadly off and disappeared down this gray dark street called Seville Place. Dangerfield walked back across Butt Bridge, a finely divided rain falling. My body has blue joints. Ireland is heaven bound with this low weather...And clusters of men hunched in black overcoats sucking cigarettes, spitting and mean. With tongues of shoes hanging out like dogs� hungry mouths. I’d give anything for a drink now.�

Who but J. P. Donleavy could have started his book with the first three mini paragraphs:

“Today a rare sun of spring. And horse carts clanging to the quays down Tara Street and the shoeless white faced kids screaming.
O’Keefe comes in and climbs up on a stool. Wags his knapsack around on his back and looks at Sebastian Dangerfield.
Those tubs are huge over there. First bath for two months (note from me: let me stay a mile from him � I imagine that he would be “well cooked�). I’m getting more like the Irish every day. Like going on the subway in the States, you go through a turnstile.�

Strange turns of phrase run throughout the book but what a helter-skelter of a ride has this turned out to be. One moment I think that Sebastian is a ghastly fellow. He appears to be such an unsavory, unclean, unreliable, Irish-American, who really doesn’t seem to know which country he belongs to � Ireland or America; who is constantly on the lookout for sexual pursuits and imbibing copious amounts of alcohol. Worst of all, he’s a liar to all intents and purposes. Then a few paragraphs or chapters later on, he becomes funny, gentle, endearing, picaresque, full of the blarney and a pleasure to read. There’s a certain mockery about him too and yet also a poignant side.

I feel for his long suffering wife Marian, who tries so hard to make a go of this marriage but our dear Sebastian had no idea how to behave with her and even fantasizes and thinks of another woman, Ginny Cupper, when he’s making love to her. Ah yes, she “took me in her car out to the spread field of Indiana�.

I actually think I would have tossed him out with a flea in his ear!

To help their financial problems, Miss Lilly Frost comes to live with them. Marion finally, however, gives up on her husband’s feckless behavior and takes the child Felicity back to Scotland. Does Dangerfield appear to miss her? Not really, just the convenience of having her around, like a well-heeled shoe.

His attitude towards money counts for naught. What decent man who has been left money by his wife to pay the bills, would spend it and in addition hock their fire.

His well-spoken American friend, Kenneth O’Keefe, with delusions of grandeur, also deserves a boot up the backside. Such a clever, amusing, unclean, complex individual and also thoroughly unlikeable but then he also turns up trumps in that he’s so amusing from time to time. What a contradictory book this is turning out to be. He constantly admonishes Sebastian about his bad drinking habits:

“This, Dangerfield, is your blood for which your family will starve and which will finally send you all to the poor house. Should have played it cozy and married strictly for cash. Come in drunk, have a quick one and whoops, another mouth to feed…�

Other girls/women such as Chris, Mary and Miss Frost all love him to death, feed him, not only by giving him their food or money but also physically. He’s a taker and the remarkable thing is that he gets away with it; his stealth in his creepy, sly way of getting into Miss Frost’s bed and the guilt after the event. Her wish to confess to the priest because this sexual act was a mortal sin.

And yet the hypocrisy:

“Lilly, why did you want me to do it this way?�
“O Mr Dangerfield, it’s so much less of a sin.�
“And fun too.�

Still Sebastian always manages to extricate himself from his involved, convoluted relationships with women and yet he goes off to London with Mary and �.well that’s for you to find out.

And finally, on being viewed by other people:

“On O’Keefe’s head a brown dirty tweed cap. Women in this lounge looking at the two of them with their legs stretched all over the place. And they were cocking their white ears to hear that bearded man go on about such fantastic things with that awful accent of his and who is that man with his haughty ways and county voice, flicking his fingers exquisitely and rolling back his head to belch laughter. So sure of themselves.�

In conclusion, am I pleased that I reread this book? Well, yes and no. There’s a strange kind of brilliance to it that I didn’t feel the first time around but the criticism I do have, of myself anyway, is my ambivalent feeling here. This was definitely the best of all his books but nevertheless I think my reading style is now going in a different direction. I’m more into a good plot, sensitivity in the writing style, one that flows but with a touch of exotic spices and flavors thrown in, combined with musical elements that enthrall me; a book to entice and whet the appetite; to try and venture out and experience all; laughs and thrills too I guess. But the most important aspect is that of unexpected anticipation� That says it all. Whatever one says about this book, it certainly remains in the mind and I’m intrigued to know for how long.
45 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Ginger Man.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

May 26, 2013 – Shelved as: to-read
May 26, 2013 – Shelved
May 26, 2013 – Shelved as: fiction
May 26, 2013 – Shelved as: j-p-donleavy
May 26, 2013 –
0.0% "This book has to be read by friends here: One review states: "Feckless, unwashed, charming, penurious Sebastian Balfe Dangerfield, Trinity College Law student, Irish American with an English Accent, maroon in the ould country and dreaming of dollars and ready women...delirious search of freedom, wealth..."
I can already feel the enthusiasm building up..."
May 28, 2013 –
67.0% "This is a very odd writing style switching backwards and forwards between the first and third person. Am I enjoying this book? I'm not too sure as I like and hate it at the same time. Sebastian is too feckless for my liking and there's really not much of a plot. Shall I abandon it? See how tonight goes..."
Started Reading
May 29, 2013 –
86.0% "Well this book has surprisingly picked up or has my brain gone on holiday?"
May 29, 2013 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-28 of 28 (28 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Dolors (last edited May 29, 2013 09:18AM) (new)

Dolors Love what you have done here Lynne. Mixing your changing relationship with the book with the way you have evolved since you read it twenty years ago (wow...daring!!) and its controversial character, this Sebastian Dangerfield who seems to be equally disgusting and appealing.

Then a few paragraphs or chapters later on, he becomes funny, gentle, endearing, picaresque, full of the blarney and a pleasure to read

He seems interesting, to say the least. His quick wit and spiced remarks echoed of Wilde's...
Maybe what we were talking about earlier this week, Ireland is a magic land, its influence works in mysterious ways, specially to those foreigners who are daring enough to settle down there! ;P


message 2: by Lynne (last edited May 29, 2013 08:18AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lynne King Thanks for that Dolors! Donleavy's parents were Irish immigrants living in the Bronx I believe. I think that he studied at Trinity, Dublin for three years but didn't get his degree. He's now alive and kicking in Ireland at the grand old age of 87.


message 3: by Caroline (last edited May 29, 2013 08:11AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Caroline What a fabulous review. It has been so many years since I read this book, yet your wonderful insights and excellent quotes really opened it up to me again. Would I read it again? No, I don't think so. I was enthralled with it at the time, but for me the past is another country, and I would not expect to be enthralled again. (It was a delight to hear his voice in your review again though....) I thoroughly enjoyed this review.


message 4: by Lynne (last edited May 29, 2013 08:17AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lynne King Catoline, How lovely of you to say that. Thanks a million!


message 5: by s.penkevich (new)

s.penkevich Fantastic review, Lynne. This sounds like a good time, I quite enjoyed the quotes you have provided. I always fear rereading a book I had loved, sometimes books I've only read a year or two ago I wonder about holding up to my current scrutiny. I guess it is a good thing though, and a side-effect of goodreads. We push ourselves to read such great books that we discover here, and good literature is one of these things where it seems like you can't really come back from. Javier Marias really opened my eyes to the incredible possibilities created by that weird zone of relationship between author, narrator, character, truth and fiction of plot, etc, and now I can't help but go looking for that in books and most likely find that there was never any such consideration of it in the book. Wow, I'm really rambling, but I hope you get what I'm stretching towards. Glad this still help up for you though!

Why is it, I ask myself, that so many authors write a magnificent first novel and then the following ones never seem to live up to the initial expectations? Ha, yeah, don't you hate when that happens!? It's like chasing a drug, you can't ever reach that first high of an author. If I discover and author I suspect I'll love, I do a bit of digging to try and read what seems to be their 2nd best book first ha, that way I can savor them.

Great review!


message 6: by Lynne (last edited May 29, 2013 08:20AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lynne King Penky, thank you! Greatly appreciated.


message 7: by [deleted user] (new)

Great review Lynne. THis book is on the Modern Library list of best 100 English language novels of 20th Century, so I plan on reading soon and your review motivates me. (I sent an earlier comment which I deleted warning you that your review would not show up under the standard edition. But I checked and your review does show up there. So disregard if you saw it. It's not your fault because the GR search engine was broken for days and so you were not able to access the standard edition with a picture when you first entered this book.


message 8: by Ilhem (new)

Ilhem Great review, Lynne. Beyond your perspective on the book, I really liked your words about your reading tastes.


Lynne King Steve aka Sckenda wrote: "Great review Lynne. THis book is on the Modern Library list of best 100 English language novels of 20th Century, so I plan on reading soon and your review motivates me. (I sent an earlier comment ..."

Thank you Steve. Yes, I did have a problem at the time calling up "The Ginger Man" and I clicked mistakenly on a "Study Guide of the Ginger Man".


Lynne King Ilhem wrote: "Great review, Lynne. Beyond your perspective on the book, I really liked your words about your reading tastes."

Thank you Ilhem - that was really a nice thing to say.


message 11: by [deleted user] (new)

The Ginger Man


Here is a link to the main edition of the book which you could not access the other day. If you click choose this edition, you should get a picture instead of the brown generic cover you have.


Lynne King Thanks Steve. I've just found the edition of my own paperback and so I've changed it to that.


message 13: by Dolors (new)

Dolors Lynne wrote: "Thanks for that Dolors! Donleavy's parents were Irish immigrants living in the Bronx I believe. I think that he studied at Trinity, Dublin for three years but didn't get his degree. He's now alive..."

I'll be doing the same if I ever reach 87. In Ireland if I can. :)


message 14: by Richard (new) - added it

Richard Derus The Beastly Beatitudes of Balthazar B. was my first Donleavy. This one was my last, after The Onion Eaters. I concluded that Donleavy was, like Thomas Wolfe, someone that one needed to approach at a particular juncture in one's reading life, and I missed the connection.

Ambivalent is a darn good word for the emotion stirred in me. Very balanced review, thanks for it.


Lynne King If we have our faculties at 87 Dolors! I don't want to be "ga ga" at that age, if I'm still alive that is. As for living in Ireland, it does have its appeal. Wales is on the horizon at the moment but that's just a foolish idea. I love France.


Lynne King Richard, I cannot find my copy but in "The Onion Eaters", isn't there an incident where some woman (cannot remember her name) goes into a bedroom on roller skates? Or is my memory playing me tricks?

Thanks for liking the review too. That's a nice compliment from you.


message 17: by Richard (new) - added it

Richard Derus It sounds like a Donleavy moment, but I wouldn't swear an oath that it was in that book. And you're welcome!


message 18: by Steve (new)

Steve I can see why you're of a mixed mind with this one, Lynne. You explain yourself well!

BTW, my wife and I are taking a first-time trip to the Emeral Isle soon. Though it's unlikely in these more recent times, I'm hoping Dublin and its people are not much like you described as Donleavy's portrayal.


Lynne King You say the nicest things Steve. Thank you.

I'm sure that you and your wife will both have a marvellous time in Dublin if you go there, as I understand that it's a very vibrant city.


message 20: by Steve (new)

Steve Yup, Dublin is top of the list. Thanks, Lynne!


message 21: by Jan (new)

Jan Rice Well, Lynne, ha ha, ho ho--what a rambling, rollicking and fun review! A pleasure to read.


Lynne King Jan wrote: "Well, Lynne, ha ha, ho ho--what a rambling, rollicking and fun review! A pleasure to read."

What a thoroughly delightful thing to say to me Jan. You've made my day! But "I just want to have fun" - always did like that song.


message 23: by J. (new) - rated it 5 stars

J. McMahon Not Irish, American


Lynne King J. wrote: "Not Irish, American"

Somewhat belatedly I've seen your comment J. To me Donleavy although US did have Irish emigrant parents and so technically he's Irish (well in the genes anyway).


message 25: by J. (new) - rated it 5 stars

J. McMahon Okay then so is something like 25% of Caucasian Americans then. He's not Irish because he is American with American values, history and experiences which is why when he wrote about Ireland (where he has lived since 1946) he did so as an outsider to great effect.


Lynne King Thanks for that J.


message 27: by Nick (new) - rated it 4 stars

Nick Marmor Just finished The Ginger Man. Your review is spot on!


Lynne King Thanks for that Nick!


back to top