ŷ

PattyMacDotComma's Reviews > Project Hail Mary

Project Hail Mary by Andy Weir
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1128612
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: aa, aa-ce, favourites-adult, fiction, kindle, science-fiction, audio-while-reading

5� (audio also while reading)
“That other hatch in the lab—the one that leads farther up—that must be important. This is like being in a video game. Explore the area until you find a locked door, then look for the key. But instead of searching bookshelves and garbage cans, I have to search my mind. Because the ‘key� is my own name.�

So� what seems to be the problem then. His own name? Um, yeah. He doesn’t remember it. Not only that, he woke up in a bed in a craft in goodness-knows-where with two corpses in the other two beds. What the?

Our hero (this is a quest, after all, so I can call him a hero) has occasional instinctive flashes of memory, kind of like muscle memory. It’s also like when you can’t think of a word, but then a phrase pops into your mind, and there’s the word. If he knew he was on a spaceship named the Hail Mary, he might have gone on to say “full of grace�, and there it is! His name is Ryland Grace.

As he recalls things, Grace takes us back to his time teaching high school science and gradually works forward to the mission and the problems on earth that he seems to have been sent out to solve. It’s quite a while before he (and we) learn the actual circumstances that found him on board, and I think it’s just as well.

Grace narrates the story, which I read and simultaneously listened to on audio. The writing is good, of course, but Rob Porter’s narration is outrageously good. I mean really good. He has exactly the right tones of optimism and despair as well as the voices and manner of the other characters on earth, as well as the onboard computer (it speaks sometimes), and another distinctive chiming voice.

Grace gets into the control room and is pleased to find that he understands what he’s looking at, by which I mean he can read the many screens and understand what the readings are. What he can’t believe is what they’re telling him.

“That’s a little over two days. Over ten times faster than the rotation should be. This star I’m looking at � it’s not the sun. I’m in a different solar system.
. . .
Okay. I think it’s time I took a long gosh-darned look at these screens! How am I in another solar system?! That doesn’t even make sense! What star is that, anyway?! Oh my God, I am so going to die! I hyperventilate for a while. I remember what I tell my students: If you’re upset, take a deep breath, let it out, and count to ten. It dramatically reduced the number of tantrums in my classroom.�


He remembers that some little ‘things� are attracted by light, eating the sun, and the sun is dimming, destining earth for a dark ending. It seems as if a similar thing is happening a long, long, long way away, but that star, Tau Ceti, seems to be unaffected and scientists on Earth want to find out why, hoping to save our sun and the planet.

So Ryland Grace wakes up with only the computer and automated robot arms for company. The food is good (he likes the breakfast burritos), and the medical care is excellent, often taking place while he’s asleep. He wakes up with fresh bandages as needed.

He got a burn injury at one point and asked for painkillers. The ‘arms� hand him two pills and a cup of water. He goes back to work instead of resting, and pays the price.

“It’s been less than an hour, but the painkillers aren’t doing the job anymore.

‘Computer! Painkillers!�

‘Additional dose available in three hours and four minutes.�


I frown. ‘Computer: What is the current time?�

‘Seven-fifteen P.M., Moscow Standard Time.�

‘Computer: Set time to eleven P.M. Moscow Standard Time.�

‘Clock set complete.�

‘Computer: painkillers.�


The arms hand me a package of pills and a bag of water. I gobble them down. What a stupid system. Astronauts trusted to save the world but not to monitor their painkiller doses? Stupid.�


I particularly enjoyed that, because I’ve done the same thing myself to game a system that was going to cause something I had to expire on a certain day, so I changed the date on the computer and went offline for a while. That was a long time ago, though. Not sure it would work now.

His arm continues to hurt, but at least he still has it.

“I climb down the ladder. My arm hurts. But less than it has. I’ve been changing the bandages every day—or rather, Dr. Lamai’s medical marvel machine has been doing it. There’s definitely scarring all over the skin. I’m going to have an ugly arm and shoulder for the rest of my life. But I think the deeper layers of skin must have survived. If they hadn’t, I probably would have died of gangrene by now. Or Lamai’s machine would have amputated my arm when I wasn’t looking.�

I don’t want to give anything else away. Some other readers have shared more than I’m willing to. I was just so happily surprised by how he managed everything he encountered that I seemed to let all the science and engineering wash over me, whether or not I understood it. It was enough that I thought he understood it, more or less � sometimes less, admittedly � and that it worked, usually.

The audio really is extra-good, but I do like having the text to follow and quote from. I have yet to figure out how to review the audio without counting it as a separate book.
44 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Project Hail Mary.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 6, 2024 – Started Reading
February 21, 2024 – Finished Reading
February 23, 2024 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-26 of 26 (26 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Liz (new)

Liz Excellent review. I should really give this one a try as I keep seeing lots of five stars, esp for the audio.


message 2: by Bella (Kiki) (new)

Bella (Kiki) Another wonderful review, Patty! I loved reading it.


Peggyzbooksnmusic Patty; Great review! Love this author.


message 4: by Rosh (new) - added it

Rosh Wonderful review, Patty! I have YET to read this, but am very eager to try it out. Glad it was a 5 star for you.


Carolyn Entertaining review Patty! Glad you enjoyed it :)


PattyMacDotComma Liz wrote: "Excellent review. I should really give this one a try as I keep seeing lots of five stars, esp for the audio."

YES YES YES! (That will make more sense if you read it) and definitely add the audio or listen only to it. The writing is good, but the addition of the narrator's inflections while the character is thinking aloud (chastising himself for a dumb error), make it even better.


PattyMacDotComma Kiki (Formerly TheGirlByTheSeaOfCortez) wrote: "Another wonderful review, Patty! I loved reading it."

Peggyzbooksnmusic wrote: "Patty; Great review! Love this author."

Thanks, Kiki and Peggy. Jazz hands indeed, Peggy!


PattyMacDotComma Rosh (is busy; will catch up soon!) wrote: "Wonderful review, Patty! I have YET to read this, but am very eager to try it out. Glad it was a 5 star for you."

I'm glad I chose it for a challenge, Rosh, or I might never have started it. What a wonderful experience it was. The audio is absorbing, too.


PattyMacDotComma Carolyn wrote: "Entertaining review Patty! Glad you enjoyed it :)"

I was glad YOU gave it 5 stars - it encouraged me to give it a try.


BookishDramas Great review.
I loved the story when I read it earlier especially the end.
One person's determination and willing sacrifice to save another brings out the best thing that we as humans have.


message 11: by Mary Jo (new)

Mary Jo A PattyMacDotta Review? What a treat. You are a verrry seductive writer. Bookstores must love you.


message 12: by PattyMacDotComma (last edited Feb 28, 2024 12:21AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

PattyMacDotComma Sanjib Dash wrote: "Great review.
I loved the story when I read it earlier especially the end.
One person's determination and willing sacrifice to save another brings out the best thing that we as humans have."


I loved it for the same reasons, and I don't think the author limits that to humans!


PattyMacDotComma Mary Jo wrote: "A PattyMacDotta Review? What a treat. You are a verrry seductive writer. Bookstores must love you."

Thanks, Mary Jo. I'm just an enthusiastic reader (or can you tell 😉)


BookishDramas PattyMacDotComma wrote: "Sanjib Dash wrote: "Great review.
I loved the story when I read it earlier especially the end.
One person's determination and willing sacrifice to save another brings out the best thing that we as..."


Even here in our lives this is an attitude that we should all adopt.
More than just lip-sync, a feeling for our fellow beings (even animals unless they are primarily for food or they are our absolute enemy). :)


Phyllis Runyan I loved this book. Great review.


Dorie  - Cats&Books :) Great review, I liked this one too :)


message 17: by Suz (new)

Suz Your going off line and changing the date made me laugh, Patty. Great review!


PattyMacDotComma Sanjib Dash wrote: "PattyMacDotComma wrote: "Sanjib Dash wrote: "Great review.
I loved the story when I read it earlier especially the end.
One person's determination and willing sacrifice to save another brings out ..."


You're right, Sanjib. 😊


PattyMacDotComma Phyllis wrote: "I loved this book. Great review."

Dorie - Cats&Books :) wrote: "Great review, I liked this one too :)"

It's nice to be in such good company - and thanks.


PattyMacDotComma Suz wrote: "Your going off line and changing the date made me laugh, Patty. Great review!"

Ah, one does what one must do sometimes, It was fun to see an astronaut able to use unsophisticated tricks, too. Thanks!

If you're hunting for a good audio, Suz, I can't recommend this one highly enough, and I'm pretty sure it was a BorrowBox book, too.


message 21: by Maureen (new)

Maureen Carden Wow, just wow. Somehow I'm not surprised.


PattyMacDotComma Maureen wrote: "Wow, just wow. Somehow I'm not surprised."

Maureen - it's so good, especially with the audio. There's a reason for that, but it's a bit of a spoiler to say why.


message 23: by Chris (new)

Chris Great review!


Peggyzbooksnmusic Patty; This popped up on my feed so thought I'd let you know that IMDB shows that this is in pre-production for 2026 release with Ryan Gosling cast as Ryland!


PattyMacDotComma Chris wrote: "Great review!"

Thanks, Chris - I loved the book.


PattyMacDotComma Peggyzbooksnmusic wrote: "Patty; This popped up on my feed so thought I'd let you know that IMDB shows that this is in pre-production for 2026 release with Ryan Gosling cast as Ryland!"

Oooo great, Peggy! Thanks. He is certainly watchable and should have just the sort of appeal that I think Ryland Grace does - not helpless, but you wish you could help him.


back to top