Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

switterbug (Betsey)'s Reviews > We Burn Daylight

We Burn Daylight by Bret Anthony Johnston
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
2843912
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: favorites, prizeworthy

I watched the entire televised Waco siege of David Koresh (Lamb) and the Branch Davidians tragedy as it unfolded in March-April 1993. I was pregnant with my daughter, on temporary bedrest. Our technology was limited yet we thought it was vast. So what did I do? I read books and watched TV, and the Waco siege was the most compelling TV at the time. I was facing potential loss while loss was unfolding on our TV screens. Waco is 100 miles north of Austin, my home, a plain small city with not a whole heckuva lot going for it. Then Waco broke national and international news. That was huge then, in the 1990s, when not even Austin was on the "destination" map. Texas writer Bret Anthony Johnston says that this is not the life of David Koresh. Which, I'm going to interpret as--rather, this is the life of fictional characters, Roy and Jaye, and their friends and family. Or consider it as a re-imagining of David Koresh’s clone. I have read some of the non-fiction material on the whole damned catastrophe, and nobody has hit the right notes of truth more than this author.

It isn’t just facts that tell a story about an event. It’s emotional and psychological truth that matters, and that’s where it counts for me. The main characters are Jaye, a fourteen-year-old girl and beaux Roy, also fourteen. Roy and Jaye tell their love story in alternating narratives, certainly borne from Johnston’s imagination, but the setting/melding of the calamity in Waco is brilliant. Johnston’s muscular use of language is sizzling, simmering. He uses robust and ripe words and phrases, very physical and forceful and yet sinewy and lucid. No word is superfluous; every sentence is nimble and supple---all five senses engaged, and a memorable romance. It's a page-turner, dear readers!

A lot is said about the stars, in metaphor, personification, and just the boundless entirety of its space. This all happened before cell phones kept us connected without interruption, when we had to depend on being there in the room where the telephone rang. There was a lot more waiting, suspense, expectancy, or not knowing that went along with this era right before the explosion of iPhones. Time and space have been reclassified by mobile phones, and some of the magic and anxiety of being able to contact your most important person was wholly different then.

“…I imagined a universe where a person could rearrange the stars to relay a message to someone else, a night sky inscribed in cryptic code, an illuminated language of loss.� How much would you sacrifice for a faith or glory, the abstractness of a supreme being? What would you do to save the person you most care about---and what is the meaning of “saved� to these characters? Is it religious, spiritual, emotional, or literal? Would you save your one true love first, or would you save what a charismatic leader calls your “soul.�

David Koresh (OK, Perry Cullen in the novel), to some folks, was like Jesus, a prophet of the Seven Seals, a person who could probably quote the entire Bible. To his worshippers, he is inviolable, unassailable. He was also a pedophile, and essentially had babies with babies. But he twisted these people’s minds enough that they believed he was their savior, and everything he did was part of his God-given right.

The story progresses with a pacey rhythm and I was on edge the whole time. Does this novel have more impact if you are familiar with the Waco standoff and siege? I do think my knowledge of the event and the minutiae of its moving parts created a particularly ripe suspense for me. However, it is Johnston that held all these facts together and wrote a compelling love story that is superimposed and braided into the dark events of the time. Those of us that followed the story in 1993 will have that whole scenario playing in our heads while we read WE BURNED DAYLIGHT.

I also kept thinking of the Supertramp song, “If Everyone was Listening." At one point, I put it on to connect to the most moving lyrics. It’s from the album, Crime of the Century—“For we dreamed a lot, and we schemed a lot, and we tried to sing of love before the stage fell apart.� It was like a play, Koresh as the mad clown, the compound his stage. “You don’t know what you’ve done, the finale’s begun.�

The friendship/romance between Jaye and Roy was deeply emotional but held with subtle restraint. They must have been the two most intelligent, quick-witted people in Waco, their feelings for each other illuminated their vulnerability and their strength. Could it survive—one love on the inside, one on the outside? While Perry Cullen kept his flock close at hand—everyone on the commune had a job to do, there was no plumbing, and there were hard chores to be done—the drama of Jaye and Roy played out.

Jaye's mother hauled her to Texas from California to be with Perry Cullen and his nutty flock. Jaye endured, she loved her mother, but she also kept a cautious distance to Perry, at the very least spelling out her boundaries to him, with a cutting tone, if that’s what it took. She knew he tried to groom her, and all the young ones. She was only fourteen, an attractive age for Perry. Yeah, he's that.

Jaye did things like sneak in Cullen’s room when he was gone to use the only telephone in the compound, to call Roy, and to do a bit of sabotage, like pour out Perry’s milk and put the empty carton back in the fridge, or eat his cheese. Lots of people went hungry, there wasn’t sufficient food, but not Perry. He had everything he wanted and more.

The story is propulsive, irresistible. It engulfs me. You may break dates, disregard dinner, ignore everything else but the book. It’s so gripping, meaningful, and expressive that you’ll obliterate any obstruction between you and WE BURNED DAYLIGHT. It’s page-turning and maximum appeal, natural sounding, effortless, but you know he worked hard on it with dedication and no fakery. Johnston is a breath of fresh air, a fearsome writer and master storyteller, with tantalizing wordplay.

Thank you to Random House for sending me an ARC to read and review. It’s a hard act to follow. I’ve been a fan of Johnston since REMEMBER ME LIKE THIS, another ripped-from-the-headlines event written for specific and individual fictional characters. Johnston does that so well. Took a huge national tragedy and yet owns it for his indelible make-believe one. The song remains the same.
87 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read We Burn Daylight.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 1, 2024 – Started Reading
March 1, 2024 – Shelved
March 2, 2024 –
page 108
30.68% "Seriously, to all, I'm having the thrill of my days here, and nights. Johnston has evolved to riveting storytelling. And he has captured 1993 so organically that I've only found one semi-anachronism, and that's just someone saying, "Sweet!" the way we use it in 2024. Anyway, you'll be hanging by a splinter while reading this. THIS BOOK HAS EVERYTHING!"
March 5, 2024 – Shelved as: favorites
March 5, 2024 – Shelved as: prizeworthy
March 5, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-23 of 23 (23 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by K (new)

K Brilliant review, as all of yours I’ve read so far are. Your words always make me wish I had the book right now! My second baby was just a couple of months old during the Waco tragedy and, like you, I was glued to the TV. I’m so looking forward to reading this when it’s available.


message 2: by Bonnie G. (new) - added it

Bonnie G. Well, this is clearly a can't miss. I love what you said about muscular language. I said something similar about a book I just finished but I said it felt like the prose was repeatedly punching me in the head. I like your words a lot better.


switterbug (Betsey) K wrote: "Brilliant review, as all of yours I’ve read so far are. Your words always make me wish I had the book right now! My second baby was just a couple of months old during the Waco tragedy and, like you..."

Thank you, K! Oh, yes, those of us that were more confined were more glued to TVs. "Working from home" was unusual then, and new moms were often home alone with the baby. You are gonna love it. I think knowing about Waco makes it even more exciting. I remember it like yesterday!


switterbug (Betsey) Bonnie G. wrote: "Well, this is clearly a can't miss. I love what you said about muscular language. I said something similar about a book I just finished but I said it felt like the prose was repeatedly punching me ..."

Bonnie, I promise this isn't the punching-in-head kind. I know that kind. This is the aesthetic type pf muscular, so it's in a good way. It's a can't miss, and I miss it, I wanted to continue the story. I love the whole Podcast arrangement, too.


message 5: by Ann (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ann Outstanding review, Betsey!! I remember all this so well. It sounds like this is one not to be missed.


switterbug (Betsey) Ann wrote: "Outstanding review, Betsey!! I remember all this so well. It sounds like this is one not to be missed."

Oh, Ann--if you remember it, this will have you nodding your head!


Jill Wowza! You knocked it out of the ballpark and once again soared to the top of the community reviews! Your fourth paragraph just blew me away with its insights and truth and your last paragraph? Pitch perfect. You review better than anyone I know-- and that includes the so-called "pros."


switterbug (Betsey) Jill wrote: "Wowza! You knocked it out of the ballpark and once again soared to the top of the community reviews! Your fourth paragraph just blew me away with its insights and truth and your last paragraph? Pit..."

Jill--thank you SO much. You have to know that, coming from you, I am so humbled. The words just spilled out when I wrote the review, largely due to following the events in 1993 the way most of us followed the OJ trial. In real time, we sat there dumbfounded, having zero idea how it would turn out, until it did.

It was a controversial and tragic event that will forever be marked by failures of communication and lurid details on both sides. And, folks should read your review, which is a spot-on review coming from someone who didn't necessarily follow every second of the siege. Your review helped me parse what parts yanked me due to the meta- aspect v just reading it as a story, not really aware of the details of the original story, the ripped-from-the-headlines part.


message 9: by Keri (new) - added it

Keri Stone Wonderful review! While I was certainly aware of it while it was occurring, I was raising young kids and working and not keeping up with events closely. But we certainly connect to events that we are close to by proximity or just timing, and I have watched movies since and find it such a sad but also interesting story. It’s one thing to choose to follow someone and live that life, but as a parent, it’s so hard for me to imagine putting my children in such a situation and being blind to things happening, even as a believer. But then, people like that tend to draw people that are a little broken� not judging because we all have broken parts� Anyway, it sounds like an interesting book!


message 10: by switterbug (Betsey) (last edited Mar 07, 2024 04:25AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

switterbug (Betsey) Thank you so much, Keri! And you are right about appealing to those with broken parts. We all may have broken parts---but I think Koresh appealed to those with a specific combination of broken and missing parts. I tried to see it from their pov, but cannot ever wrap my head around giving your underage children to Koresh for Koresh's pleasure. That's some wildly broken and missing parts! It was a tragedy, all the way, from start to finish. Some answers we will never know. But, in Johnston's hands, there's a different theme or two that takes off from the Branch Davidian setting.


message 11: by Jaidee (new) - added it

Jaidee You MAKE me want to read this NOW !

Excited I have this one too Betsy


switterbug (Betsey) Enjoy, Jade! It's a compelling page-turner!


message 13: by Debbie (new)

Debbie W. Fascinating review, Betsey!


switterbug (Betsey) Thank you, Debbie!


message 15: by Maureen (new)

Maureen Terrific review Betsey.


Ricki Brodie Incredible review. I wasn’t sure whether I wanted to read this after your review definitely! I just saw a program where the FBI agents explained the situation from their perspective. I can’t wait to experience it from all sides. You write the best reviews. Glad we’re friends.


message 17: by Fran (new)

Fran Exemplary review as always, Betsey!💛


message 18: by N (new)

N Excellent review!


message 19: by Dennis (new)

Dennis I've just finished a fictional take connected to the Manson Family ("The Girls") and also read a fictional take on Patty Hearst and the Symbionese Army ("American Woman" by Susan Choi) and have noticed that many people don't have a context to place these events in (in the latter case) or overemphasize the events as the main point of the story. I wonder how many people can put this book into its proper context, as sort of paraphrasing the events for fictional purposes?


message 20: by Laura (new) - added it

Laura Rogers Such a moving review.


message 21: by Liz (new) - rated it 4 stars

Liz Excellent review. It must have been so intense to be watching it in real time. I was working then, so only seeing it on the evening news. And that was wild enough.


message 22: by Brenda (new) - added it

Brenda Fantastic review. Can’t wait to jump in.


message 23: by Lara (new) - added it

Lara What a great review!


back to top