Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Garima's Reviews > Mr Palomar

Mr Palomar by Italo Calvino
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
7915003
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: short-wonders, italo-calvino-magiciano, sui-generis, my-2-cents


The thought of a time outside our experience is intolerable.

Had I met someone like Mr. Palomar before reading this book, I’d have easily passed him off as just another middle aged man on the verge of senility with nothing better to do with his time or at the most a mad wannabe scientist who realized about his true calling when it was too late with no one interested about his observations or findings. But trust Mr. Calvino when it comes to make seemingly weak characters strong and one of the most dull situations interesting for his readers. The words flown from Calvino’s pen can render an act of staring at a ceiling fan as the most exciting adventure ever known to man, however, Mr. Palomar gives us something wider in scope which enshrouds not only his home or his local market but the whole universe including moon and stars (If Calvino won’t talk about celestial bodies then who will).

The book is divided into three parts and each part deals with a particular experience which helps Mr. Palomar in exploring various events and visuals in order to find answers about the bigger questions of life. Philosophical Enquiry is what it is called? It is but it’s something which carries the Calvinian trademark and gives us a whole new way to indulge in such philosophies without losing interest for a single moment. Mr. Palomar takes us to a beach where he observes the coming and going of the waves while waiting unsuccessfully for a repetition of a phenomenon and on the same beach he is trying his best about looking or not looking or looking in a most natural and decent (!) way at the naked bosom of a female bather. If you want to know how subtly the humor coated with right dose of irony can be used in a most successful fashion in fiction in very few words, then read this piece. In a similar way, Mr. Palomar observes love making between tortoises, tries to decipher the whistling of birds and makes an attempt in giving words to the silence. And when Mr. Palomar looks at the sky! The words thereof are like music to the ears. It makes you fall in love all over again with the stars in the night sky, the moon in the afternoon and the beauty of the world around us.
If the ancients had been able to see it as I see it now, Mr. Palomar thinks, they would have thought they had projected their gaze into the heaven of Plato's ideas, or in the immaterial space of the postulates of Euclid; but instead, thanks to some misdirection or other, this sight has been granted to me, who fear it is too beautiful to be true, too gratifying to my imaginary universe to belong to the real world. But perhaps it is this same distrust of our senses that prevents us from feeling comfortable in the universe. Perhaps the first rule I must impose on myself is this: stick to what I see.

Mr. Palomar journey further extends to a visit to his local supermarket, a zoo in Barcelona, Garden of rocks and sand of the Ryoanji of Kyoto in Japan and Ruins of Tula in Mexico. He looks, he observes, he contemplates, he draw conclusions but even on viewing the whole world as a museum where there’s hardly any entry charge, he’s not able to find a concrete relation of his existence with that of the universe. He feels the need of defining every moment, every instant of his being and also the need of finding a set pattern in the world which gives him the pleasure of knowing that he has lived his life the way it ought to be lived and the universe exist the way it ought to exist whether Mr. Palomar is a part of it or not. He is extremely unsure of himself and the gist of the matter is - he wants to be at peace with himself.

...the world around him moves in an unharmonious way, and he hopes always to find some pattern in it, a constant. Perhaps because he himself feels that his own advance is impelled by uncoordinated movements of the mind, which seem to have nothing to do with one another and are increasingly difficult to fit into any pattern of inner harmony.

Now, you see Calvino can’t do anything wrong in my eyes. With such books, I feel like he indulges me a lot and gladly accompany me in my insanity. He don’t even have to try to make me smile because his writing, which is carried out with a unique blend of intellect and easiness, does that effortlessly. It’s fascinating to see the extent of his observational skills and equally fascinating when those observations are given shape in form of words. But I’m reluctant in recommending this book to everyone. I can vouch for great writing but subject matter might not appeal to all, so read it when you want to read a little book with a big heart.
A person, for example, reads in adulthood a book that is important for him, and it makes him say, How could I have lived without having read it! and also, What a pity I did not read it in my youth! Well, these statements do not have much meaning, especially the second, because after he has read that book, his whole life becomes the life of a person who has read that book, and it is of little importance whether he read it early or late, because now his life before that reading also assumes a form shaped by that reading.


description

Italo Calvino with Jorge Luis Borges
74 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Mr Palomar.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 5, 2013 – Started Reading
June 6, 2013 – Shelved
June 6, 2013 – Shelved as: short-wonders
June 6, 2013 – Shelved as: italo-calvino-magiciano
June 6, 2013 – Finished Reading
June 8, 2013 – Shelved as: sui-generis
October 11, 2013 – Shelved as: my-2-cents

Comments Showing 1-38 of 38 (38 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Rakhi (new) - added it

Rakhi Dalal Very well done,Garima! When I read this:

He looks, he observes, he contemplates, he draw conclusions but even on viewing the whole world as a museum where there’s hardly any entry charge, he’s not able to find a concrete relation of his existence with that of the universe. He feels the need of defining every moment, every instant of his being and also the need of finding a set pattern in the world which gives him the pleasure of knowing that he has lived his life the way it ought to be lived and the universe exist the way it ought to exist whether Mr. Palomar is a part of it or not. He is extremely unsure of himself and the gist of the matter is - he wants to be at peace with himself.

I instantly felt that I need to read the book. So, thanks for such a wonderful review!!


message 2: by Madeleine (new)

Madeleine I am not surprised that Calvino continues to work his magic on you. I'm coming back to this later for a proper comment (damn you, job!) but I just wanted to let you know that your review sure did brighten a dreary morning.


Garima Rakhi wrote: "Very well done,Garima! When I read this:

He looks, he observes, he contemplates, he draw conclusions but even on viewing the whole world as a museum where there’s hardly any entry charge, he’s not..."


Thanks a lot, Rakhi. Well, like you said, you have to read it. If I'm not wrong you're yet to begin reading Calvino so I think this book or Difficult Loves would be an ideal start. You'll surely love his writing.


Garima Madeleine wrote: "I am not surprised that Calvino continues to work his magic on you. I'm coming back to this later for a proper comment (damn you, job!) but I just wanted to let you know that your review sure did b..."

Thanks Madeleine. Even this comment is perfect for me ;)


message 5: by Kalliope (new)

Kalliope ....so read it when you want to read a little book with a big heart.

Nice...!!!


Garima Thanks Kalliope :)


message 7: by Tej (new) - added it

Tej "A person, for example, reads in adulthood a book that is important for him, and it makes him say, How could I have lived without having read it! and also, What a pity I did not read it in my youth! Well, these statements do not have much meaning, especially the second, because after he has read that book, his whole life becomes the life of a person who has read that book, and it is of little importance whether he read it early or late, because now his life before that reading also assumes a form shaped by that reading."

Funny that, these days i am besotted to extreme with the very questions that you have so lucidly highlighted from this work...

The para above reminds me of a friend who was an avid reader, sort of 'look up to' entity because of the writers she introduced and books which I heard first time in my life. She mentioned her father who didn't allow her to enter his library without warning her that be-ware, after this do not complain for there is no turning back and life would cease to be a languid existence for ever.
And at that time I always was jealous of her, because after reading 'war and peace' and 'Brothers Karamazov' first time I wished I had read them at the time of her life when she was exposed by virtue of her father's library and not so late.

I have deliberated this matter time and again and somber-ed down with respect to my disappointment but could not have put it more succinctly than this last para, quoted from this work.

Thanks Garima for directing me to my first 'Calvino'.
:))


message 8: by Madeleine (new)

Madeleine (If Calvino won’t talk about celestial bodies then who will)

This makes me sad that I'm not reading Cosmicomics, like, RIGHTNOW. I'm an inveterate star gazer but Calvino gave the sky a life and a backstory I never thought possible and now can't but help recall every time I look up.

Oh, hell. I just want to read anything by Calvino. Invisible Cities is up next just by virtue of being in my house. I was going to save it for a little while longer but this review just sang of all the things I love about Calvino and reminded me of why I love him so.

Calvino can’t do anything wrong in my eyes. With such books, I feel like he indulges me a lot and doesn’t make me feel alone in my insanity. He doesn’t even have to try to make me smile because his writing, which is carried out with a unique blend of intellect and easiness, does that effortlessly.

YES! You have zeroed in on why (or part of why -- there are countless other reasons, too) I am so in love with Calvino's writing. He is one of the most perfect writers I have ever encountered and I love that one of my favorite reviewers shares one of my favorite writers.

This is just wonderful, Garima.


message 9: by Dolors (new)

Dolors You have a special gift to blend elegance with sentiment, Garima. Your reviews, peaceful havens to get lost in.


message 10: by Jonfaith (new)

Jonfaith Wonderful thoughts. I really appreciated the photo, was unaware of such.


Garima Jonfaith wrote: "Wonderful thoughts. I really appreciated the photo, was unaware of such."

Thanks Jonfaith. I knew about Borges influence on Calvino's writing and a simple google search showed me this picture which I really liked.


Garima Dolors wrote: "You have a special gift to blend elegance with sentiment, Garima. Your reviews, peaceful havens to get lost in."

Credit goes to the author, hehe. Thanks a lot Dolors! I always appreciate your encouraging words.


Garima Madeleine wrote: "(If Calvino won’t talk about celestial bodies then who will)

This makes me sad that I'm not reading Cosmicomics, like, RIGHTNOW. I'm an inveterate star gazer but Calvino gave the sky a life and a ..."


My fellow Calvino admirer, Thank you so much. I know the feeling. After this book I wanted to read the Complete Cosmicomics but I don't want to rush myself into reading everything by him. Invisible Cities is marvelous. You're in for a great treat.


Garima Tej wrote: ""A person, for example, reads in adulthood a book that is important for him, and it makes him say, How could I have lived without having read it! and also, What a pity I did not read it in my youth..."

This is just an example of how easily Calvino churns out gems of wisdom one can so easily relate to but never find words to voice ones thoughts. I have experienced something similar though not with a real life friends but most of the friends on goodreads. I think on the same lines many times but then find comfort in the fact that at last I'm reading something I should have read a long time ago so it's ok. Thanks for sharing your sentiments and do read the book. Calvino is my favorite writer if I haven't made this fact too obvious ;)


message 15: by Samadrita (new)

Samadrita Brilliant review, Garima. I loved the last picture very much as I have always found Borges' and Calvino's writings to be in a similar vein.
Really need to read more Calvino now.


Garima Samadrita wrote: "Brilliant review, Garima. I loved the last picture very much as I have always found Borges' and Calvino's writings to be in a similar vein.
Really need to read more Calvino now."


Thanks Samadrita. I'm yet to read Borges extensively. As of now I have only read Library of Babel (which interestingly Borges was not very proud of) and from there I knew how wonderfully he influenced Calvino.


message 17: by Samadrita (new)

Samadrita I have read just If on a winter's night so far. So I was wondering which one to pick as my next Calvino - I was considering either Difficult Loves or Invisible Cities. Which one would you suggest?
And I have only read Library of Babel by Borges just as you have. As has been said a million times already, too many books too little time!


Garima Samadrita wrote: "I have read just If on a winter's night so far. So I was wondering which one to pick as my next Calvino - I was considering either Difficult Loves or Invisible Cities. Which one would you suggest?
..."


You can go with Difficult Loves first since it's a different Calvino. Invisible cities carries the same level of narrative experimentation like that of If on a winter's...so it would be a nice experience for you to read that one later.


message 19: by Samadrita (new)

Samadrita Difficult Loves it is then. Thanks, Garima!


Garima Samadrita wrote: "Difficult Loves it is then. Thanks, Garima!"

Anytime :)


message 21: by Rakhi (new) - added it

Rakhi Dalal Garima wrote: "Rakhi wrote: "Very well done,Garima! When I read this:

He looks, he observes, he contemplates, he draw conclusions but even on viewing the whole world as a museum where there’s hardly any entry ch..."


Yes, I am still to start with Calvino :) And I am sure if you love the works so much, I'll enjoy him too! Definitely looking forward to read this :)


Garima Rakhi wrote: "Garima wrote: "Rakhi wrote: "Very well done,Garima! When I read this:

He looks, he observes, he contemplates, he draw conclusions but even on viewing the whole world as a museum where there’s hard..."


Ahh! I think I envy you since you're yet to read him for the first time. I shall look forward to your thoughts.


message 23: by s.penkevich (new)

s.penkevich Wow, Calvino hanging out with Borges, what an awesome picture! And what an amazing review! Such polished poetry that not only made me want to fall in love with the 'moon in the afternoon' (great line), but to fall in love with words themselves! Sounds like you really took to this book, you've unlocked Mr Palomar's heart and mind! This book sounds great. I need to get back to Difficult Loves now, I've forgotten how perfect Calvino is. Great work, Garima, absolutely stunning.


Garima s.penkevich wrote: "Wow, Calvino hanging out with Borges, what an awesome picture! And what an amazing review! Such polished poetry that not only made me want to fall in love with the 'moon in the afternoon' (great li..."

Thank you Sven! Ain't that a cool picture. I stumbled upon it by sheer chance and had to include it in the review. And Calvino gets the credit for that line. You got to read this one after you're done with Difficult Loves of course.


message 25: by s.penkevich (new)

s.penkevich I shall! I have the other version of Difficult Loves (with War Stories, Peace stories, etc instead of Smog). I read all of the Tales of Love and Loneliness ones, which were fantastic, but I've only picked through the rest. Everything is gold so far though.


Garima s.penkevich wrote: "I shall! I have the other version of Difficult Loves (with War Stories, Peace stories, etc instead of Smog). I read all of the Tales of Love and Loneliness ones, which were fantastic, but I've only..."

Great! I'm planning to get that version too. Nothing like reading a book twice and yet getting the feel of reading it like a first time, haha.


message 27: by Steve (new)

Steve I'm still working through the backlog of friends' reviews, but sure am glad I took the time with this one. It's very insightful. I like the picture, too -- it's easy to see why they're simpatico from what you described of this.


Garima And now this review is complete because you finally read it and thanks a lot for that. Simpatico - my vocabulary just got better ;)


message 29: by Steve (new)

Steve Garima wrote: "And now this review is complete because you finally read it and thanks a lot for that. Simpatico - my vocabulary just got better ;)"

Haha, and what a relief that is -- to complete your review. I suspect we're simpatico ourselves, Garima, in our tastes for cool words.


message 30: by Garima (last edited Jun 22, 2013 12:23AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Garima Steve wrote: "Garima wrote: "And now this review is complete because you finally read it and thanks a lot for that. Simpatico - my vocabulary just got better ;)"

Haha, and what a relief that is -- to complete y..."


Great minds and all :P


message 31: by Ian (new) - added it

Ian "Marvin" Graye Garima wrote: "Now, you see Calvino can’t do anything wrong in my eyes."

I love everything that this implies (impleyes?). I see. You see. Calvino sees through or "in" your eyes. You see through Calvino's eyes. This review is full of insight for sore eyes.


Garima Haha! Thanks or your ins(eye)gtful comment, Ian. I'm not sure if I see through Calvino's eyes but oh! how much I wish to.


message 33: by Paul (new) - rated it 5 stars

Paul Agree with you wholeheartedly, Garima. And what a photo that is! Calvino and Borges - what a meeting of minds!


Garima Paul wrote: "Agree with you wholeheartedly, Garima. And what a photo that is! Calvino and Borges - what a meeting of minds!"

Thank you, Paul. I love that photo too.


message 35: by Paul (new) - rated it 5 stars

Paul It's my desktop background now!


message 36: by [deleted user] (new)

Indeed, "how could I live?" I have copied Calvino's quotation into a document I keep with favorite quotations. Thanks for this great review, Garima.


Junta Great review Garima. I agree that not everyone might enjoy it, but it indeed is a little book with a big heart.


R. D. "Bob" Mathison Brilliant review. Bravo!


back to top