Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Garima's Reviews > Hard Rain Falling

Hard Rain Falling by Don Carpenter
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
7915003
's review

liked it
bookshelves: my-2-cents


When a book starts with a line which is immediately reminiscent of Infinite Jest, then it’s alright to have some unrestrained expectations from it.
They can kill you, but they can’t eat you.
But with Hard Rain Falling I had to keep a lot many things in mind before letting my expectations go out of hand and to eventually give what I may immodestly pronounce as a fair reaction. The fact that this book was written in 1960’s was something I constantly reminded myself. It helped when I came across lines like: Nobody ever escaped from The Rock. Sean Connery? I digressed and I had to Focus. This went on for almost halfway through the novel because I was coming across one thing or the other I have either read or seen before. So what kept me going? Don Carpenter’s writing is one of the most honest narrative voices I have ever come across. There’s almost a childlike innocence in his account of some of the events that I even let out a corny awww on certain occasions.

This book is all Americana and a little more. It has orphanages, reform homes and Jack Levitt. It has pool-halls, runaway children and Billy Lancing. It has petty crimes, prisons, paroling and philosophy. And since it’s so huge in scope, the elements within are described in moderation. Nothing is over the top, nothing is under the bottom. Everything is there and that’s it. Except one or two instances, this novel failed to excite me as a reader. It takes a long straight road stretching over a period of three decades, hardly takes any interesting turns and the episodic stops at the road side joints a.k.a philosophizing usually serves the same old existential food. It’s like watching a documentary where the chronicles of a lonely person moves you in some inexplicable way but the same when written on a piece of paper doesn’t deliver the same kind of impact. But I better give this book its due where it deserves. The scenes dealing with homosexuality are handled beautifully and if nothing else this book can be read for that part only. The internal monologues are good, again thanks to the honesty of Don’s writing but at times most of the things read like the paraphrasing of the same ideas.

So what was his life? Look out there at all the ten million things life can be, and tell yourself which are yours, and which you will never do. And there was the agony of it; so much he wanted to do, and so little he could do.

The above sentence sums the whole book pretty well. Just replace few words with freedom, sex and money. Considering it was Don’s debut novel evoked some sensitivity in me but I’m afraid it doesn’t seem to have the power to leave an ever lasting impression.

3 Stars averaging out on I really liked it, I liked it and It was Ok because the rain must be falling hard but all I felt was a mild drizzle.
55 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Hard Rain Falling.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 8, 2013 – Started Reading
June 8, 2013 – Shelved
June 9, 2013 –
page 83
26.95% "He did not want to see the war movie. It would be full of shit. He walked on up to the drugstore on the Corner and drank a Coke and waited for something interesting to happen.

Hmmm..I'm also waiting for something interesting to happen."
June 12, 2013 –
page 260
84.42% "..he spent a month wading through Ulysses, which Sally told him was the greatest novel ever written. He threw it aside late one night and said to her, “Baby, I just can’t cut it. That book’s as full of shit as a Christmas goose.

“Maybe it is a little too advanced for you,� she said.

“Maybe it is,� he said. “Maybe I should go back to comic books.�"
June 13, 2013 – Finished Reading
October 11, 2013 – Shelved as: my-2-cents

Comments Showing 1-27 of 27 (27 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Samadrita (new)

Samadrita Your ending sentence is beautifully done Garima.
A great review of a book you did not like much.


message 2: by s.penkevich (new)

s.penkevich I was half hoping this was going to be somehow related to that . Sounds pretty decent, but, as you say, a bit generic. Too many good books spoils the rest haha (I mean, after Marias, other philosophical musings in books don't quite stand up for me either). Grand review though!


Garima Samadrita wrote: "Your ending sentence is beautifully done Garima.
A great review of a book you did not like much."


Thanks Samadrita. I wanted to really like this book but alas.


Garima s.penkevich wrote: "I was half hoping this was going to be somehow related to that Dylan song. Sounds pretty decent, but, as you say, a bit generic. Too many good books spoils the rest haha (I mean, after Marias, othe..."

It's decent, yes! And agree with whatever you said and funny that you mentioned Marias. I was thinking about him throughout while reading the long monologues but the magic was not the same. I'm spoilt. Damn pomo, damn meta but oh well, what can be done and THANK YOU!


message 5: by Dolors (new)

Dolors Never seen a more balanced 3 stars rating than this piece of writing. You give your reasons in a sound and elegant way. And one gets the perfect idea.
Once again, you nail it Garima. Fantastic review.


Garima Dolors wrote: "Never seen a more balanced 3 stars rating than this piece of writing. You give your reasons in a sound and elegant way. And one gets the perfect idea.
Once again, you nail it Garima. Fantastic review."


Thank you, Dolors. Yeah! the idea was not to discourage others to read it. It could be it's me not you case, so possibly others might like it a lot more than me.


message 7: by Tej (new)

Tej Nicely reviewed Garima, as Dolors said, u balanced it out well... That is never easy! Especially when the book fails to meet expectations :)


message 8: by Praveen (new)

Praveen Really liked the review .....particularly on your statement on Don Carpenter’s writing

"...is one of the most honest narrative voices I have ever come across. There’s almost a childlike innocence in his account..."


Garima Tej wrote: "Nicely reviewed Garima, as Dolors said, u balanced it out well... That is never easy! Especially when the book fails to meet expectations :)"

Thanks Tej! I tried and glad you liked it.


Garima Praveen wrote: "Really liked the review .....particularly on your statement on Don Carpenter’s writing

"...is one of the most honest narrative voices I have ever come across. There’s almost a childlike innocence ..."


Thank you Praveen. His writing is definitely refreshing, as if you're talking with a friend who calls spade a spade, so yeah! I liked it a lot.


message 11: by Nandakishore (new)

Nandakishore Mridula ...because the rain must be falling hard but all I felt was a mild drizzle.

Terrific. I understand perfectly how you felt.


Garima Nandakishore wrote: "...because the rain must be falling hard but all I felt was a mild drizzle.

Terrific. I understand perfectly how you felt."


Thanks a lot, Nandakishore :)


message 13: by Mala (new)

Mala He is a Buried writer� You shd add him.


Garima Mala wrote: "He is a Buried writer� You shd add him."

I was thinking about it but I doubt if he qualifies. At least this book has decent number of ratings.


message 15: by Kalliope (new)

Kalliope I have not read Infinite Jest, so I could not use your reference point.

Your sentence below, with one word changed, could apply to this site...!!

And there was the agony of it; so much he wanted to READ, and so little he could do.


Garima Kalliope wrote: "I have not read Infinite Jest, so I could not use your reference point.

Your sentence below, with one word changed, could apply to this site...!!

And there was the agony of it; so much he wanted ..."


No problem! It was not that important but it certainly raised some hopes and yeah! You replaced the perfect word there.


message 17: by Steve (new)

Steve This was an excellent, honest review, Garima. You've demonstrated that, contrary to your conclusions about the book, honesty can be interesting! Sorry to hear that your hopes of an IJ-like experience were dashed.


Garima Steve wrote: "This was an excellent, honest review, Garima. You've demonstrated that, contrary to your conclusions about the book, honesty can be interesting! Sorry to hear that your hopes of an IJ-like experi..."

Thank you as always, Steve. Going by the reviews of this book, I had high expectations from it (that I got to read this book before I die) but I was left a little disappointed. Having said that, my review shouldn't discourage you or anyone to read it. I think you'd probably like it a lot more than me.


message 19: by Steve (new)

Steve Garima wrote: "I think you'd probably like it a lot more than me."

Oh right, because I can relate to the uninteresting and have a penchant for childlike innocence. ;-)


Garima Steve wrote: "Garima wrote: "I think you'd probably like it a lot more than me."

Oh right, because I can relate to the uninteresting and have a penchant for childlike innocence. ;-)"


tee-hee! Naah. It would be interesting for you to read about America of that period, I reckon. Advantage of proximity, charm of nostalgia and stuff.


message 21: by Steve (new)

Steve OK, well that's different then. Thanks, Garima. :-)


message 22: by Ian (new)

Ian "Marvin" Graye In which Garima proves that an OK book can inspire a great review.


Garima You're too kind, Ian and today seems to be my lucky day, haha. Thanks again n again.


message 24: by Tony (new) - rated it 3 stars

Tony I just re-read your review, having now posted mine. Re-like! Also, I note, with some amusement, that we graded it the same, but with some uncertainty.(Amusement, because such things are so arbitrary.)


Garima Tony wrote: "I just re-read your review, having now posted mine. Re-like! Also, I note, with some amusement, that we graded it the same, but with some uncertainty.(Amusement, because such things are so arbitra..."

And I'm happy that you gave it the same rating. Guess I didn't miss much after all.


message 26: by Tony (new) - rated it 3 stars

Tony I was starting to question my 3-star rating but now I feel better.


Garima Tony wrote: "I was starting to question my 3-star rating but now I feel better."

haha! Good to know.


back to top