Alan's Reviews > The Complete Poems of Emily Dickinson
The Complete Poems of Emily Dickinson
by
by

See the Dickinson documentary A Loaded Gun for my take on this writer, arguably the best poet in English. (I play the villain in that film directed by James Wolpaw.) I have given reading-whistlings of ED's bird poems, from memory of course, in the garden of the Dickinson Manse in Amherst, and I have recited an hour of Dickinson on several occasions (from memory). In fact, Dickinson is fairly easy to memorize--a hallmark of fine verse. Perhaps only Yeats' tetrametric "Under Ben Bulben" is easier to recall, and maybe a couple Seventeenth Century lyrics, and maybe a ballad or two. (I may add, as a Shakespearean for 35 years, I have memorized a couple dozen of his sonnets and maybe twenty major speeches. Some of his sonnets are easy to memorize: one I learned in ten minutes one morning walking; others I have to re-memorize every year.*)
I recommend reading this poet three poems a day for a year and a half. They resonate so much that time between them rewards the reader. If you read them straight through, you may withdraw your participation in the text. A very famous critic I know well read all the poems and her critics in a couple months; he came away less appreciative. I say, he would not have read all Shakespeare like that, and Dickinson has the heft of Shakespeare. In many cases, one must know--say, what Robins eat--to enjoy:
"A Bird came down the Walk -
He did not know I saw -
He bit an Angle Worm in halves
And ate the fellow, raw..."
Or on a much less common bird now, which I only saw after decades, though I heard when young:
"I"ll tell you how the sun rose--
A Ribbon at a time.
The Steeple swam in Amethyst,
The News--like Squirrels--ran.
The hills untied their bonnets,
The bobolinks begun.
Then I said softly to myself,
“That must have been the sun!�
Some other Dickinson critiques I have published in my Birdtalk (Random House/ Frog, 2003).
In winters I always recite her Blue Jay, "No Brigadier throughout the year/ So Civic as the Jay..." and always her Oriole, "One of the ones that Midas touched/ Who failed to touch us all.." as well as a couple of her short Robin poems, "The Robin is the One/ That interrupts the Morn/ With Hurried, few, express Reports/When March is scarecely on." E.D. here lays down the best description of a Robin's song,a burbling, impure, emphatic series. This poem is also what Yeats calls "passionate syntax," poetic thwarting of English grammar: here, the poetic singer uses "one" as a collective pronoun. Neat trick. As a collective pronoun, it takes a plural verb, "the One/ That interrupt ...." It's grammatically impossible, but it works. (my book BirdTalk, p.93).
* The former, learned in ten minutes walking, "Why is my verse so barren of new pride"(#76); the one I re-memorize, "Some glory in their birth, some in their skill"(91).
I recommend reading this poet three poems a day for a year and a half. They resonate so much that time between them rewards the reader. If you read them straight through, you may withdraw your participation in the text. A very famous critic I know well read all the poems and her critics in a couple months; he came away less appreciative. I say, he would not have read all Shakespeare like that, and Dickinson has the heft of Shakespeare. In many cases, one must know--say, what Robins eat--to enjoy:
"A Bird came down the Walk -
He did not know I saw -
He bit an Angle Worm in halves
And ate the fellow, raw..."
Or on a much less common bird now, which I only saw after decades, though I heard when young:
"I"ll tell you how the sun rose--
A Ribbon at a time.
The Steeple swam in Amethyst,
The News--like Squirrels--ran.
The hills untied their bonnets,
The bobolinks begun.
Then I said softly to myself,
“That must have been the sun!�
Some other Dickinson critiques I have published in my Birdtalk (Random House/ Frog, 2003).
In winters I always recite her Blue Jay, "No Brigadier throughout the year/ So Civic as the Jay..." and always her Oriole, "One of the ones that Midas touched/ Who failed to touch us all.." as well as a couple of her short Robin poems, "The Robin is the One/ That interrupts the Morn/ With Hurried, few, express Reports/When March is scarecely on." E.D. here lays down the best description of a Robin's song,a burbling, impure, emphatic series. This poem is also what Yeats calls "passionate syntax," poetic thwarting of English grammar: here, the poetic singer uses "one" as a collective pronoun. Neat trick. As a collective pronoun, it takes a plural verb, "the One/ That interrupt ...." It's grammatically impossible, but it works. (my book BirdTalk, p.93).
* The former, learned in ten minutes walking, "Why is my verse so barren of new pride"(#76); the one I re-memorize, "Some glory in their birth, some in their skill"(91).
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
The Complete Poems of Emily Dickinson.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Started Reading
January 1, 1967
–
Finished Reading
June 12, 2013
– Shelved
June 30, 2018
– Shelved as:
american-lit
Comments Showing 1-29 of 29 (29 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Alan
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Oct 30, 2021 08:09AM

reply
|
flag

I once had a friend serving a life sentence in a high-security prison and we used to entertain ourselves by memorising poems. A good way to beat the tedium of solitary confinement. You never know when you may need this solace.

Yes, I recited an hour of Dickinson from heart, but then, she's among the most easily memorized of poets-- along with Yeats (also did an hour of his) and some of Shakespeare, as well as some of the 17C lyricists, like Herrick and Herbert. On the basis of memorization alone, she's as good as Shakespeare.

Thanks, Fergus, for your generous reaction.



Remember that Dickinson writes in the most basic form, Ballad Form, like "Bonny Barbara Allan" but also Coleridge's Ancient Mariner. With Dickinson, there's a wider variation in tone and irony than either of those. She even changes tone in the middle of a line sometimes. And her half-rhymes ar American Yankee pronunciation.
Ballad form: abcb, 4-beat, 3 beat, 4 beat, 3 beat. ED does some variants, of course.. The most famous critic in the U.S. at the time, Higginson (also a Civil War hero) said E.D. tired him with all her references and imaginative connections when talking.


Not in her garden, but I cover most of the six poems I did in my Conversations with Birds, to be published in Feb. '23, with an audiobook. There should be already fifteen of my bird-versions in ads for the book. I sent recordings to the Bear and Company (Inner Traditions, VT) publicist over a month ago. Dunno where or if she posted them. I should ask, but right now I'm doing the final review of the copyedit, one third through it. Hope I remember to ask once I've shippe the MS back. Hoever, it's a big enough publisher that my editor will not be in VT, but on Long Island. And I've dealt with two or three others, by email. I can look up where I sent those recordings.


If it's hard to memorize, it's worse verse. Sunday outside in the sun I gave a reading from memory of a few parts of my Parodies Lost, best audience I've ever had, enthused applause after every poem (a local players group I've been part of for fifteen years). I know sections of that book are worse because they're harder to memeorize.




You said it, Bill. Her house is a block away from my Amherst College, a great school when I went there, co-founded by her dad. Don't think its so much now, beaten in polls by our arch-rival Williams Coll, a much richer place--I lucked out buying my house from a Williams grad, now his two daughters live across the street, on the Westport River half a mile down their lane. One married a surgeon who had a silver cup with his name on it--from the 18thC! That surgeon studied with my AmColl freshman roomate Sid Schwab, who terrified him at San Francisco General hospital--Sid a 6'4" gerneral surgeon; the Wms guy very wisely focused on bones and joints. I do feel a bit guilty that his 18C silver cup was robbed, bec they asked if there was a robbery problem. I said NO, but then, I didnt have boxes of silver in my basement before moving in. Taken, not recovered, though I i.d.'d some thieves next door (dif house) a month later. Our house is up 75 yards from the road, so only robbed once, by teens down the street. 35 years ago. They left our T.V. in the hallway, wondering why they were stealing that piece of junk. Since then we've inherited some valuable furniture, but that's a specialty thief. So far, so good. One tf the pieces has no laquer, but 19C painting on it, stained by a Florida woman who kept a plantpont on it, expecting it was laquered.

But you've inspired me to reread some. Thx!

Thank YOU. I taught poetry starting with Bob Dylan and Paul McCartney. All songs are poems. Almost all we know from memory, poems. They're written to be memorized--Homer, delivered from memory!, Chaucer, Shakespeare, Moliere. Easiest to memorize, Dickinson (who writs in simple ballad form) and Yeats.



The libraries are average. We have a lot of smaller local libraries unless I care to drive in a stressful mess to get to the main one downtown. I can get most of what I want over holds at my local, but since they stopped overdue fines it has become too frustrating to wait for the books to arrive. Usually months. So I don’t know how book banning is- my daughter has graduated.
I just keep a list of books and search for them on each visit to used book store unless it’s a book or an author I need NOW- then I’ll buy it new.
I never thought I’d say it- but please reinstate fines. My muscle memory would not allow me to turn them in late anyway. I hope they work out something before summer reading program- that is a must participate!🤫

Thanks for the informative note. Yes, for me, my library can borrow from most otehr libraries, though not private ones like Brown University. I'm pleased to see my new book, Conversations with Birds: the Metaphysics of Bird and Human Communication, is shipping to early buyers, though officially out on Feb 21. I have a couple of radings scheduled alrady, first on Washington's Birthday, 22 Feb, evening at a local library a couple towns away.

Congratulations! Sounds very fun, though I’m sure you have to deal with a variety of questions. Good practice!