Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Allison Hurd's Reviews > Empire of Silence

Empire of Silence by Christopher Ruocchio
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
14495279
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: fantasy, man-author, sff-bookshelf

Empire of too many words in the Glacial Torrent series, more like. A bit grounchy by the end. It definitely needed some editing in the last like 20%, min.

CONTENT WARNING: (view spoiler)

Things that kept me reading:

-Foreshadowing. Curious about how we got to where this hints things go from where we started. Lots of cool hints and shiny red herrings.
-So very broody. So broken, so many travails.
-Everyone else liked it. What can I say, apparently if all my friends jumped off a cliff, I'd put it on my TBR.
-Audionarrator. He did a good job, I'd look up his other works.

Things that make it doubtful I'll continue:

-Overly long. While this book is very fluent to read, a lot of it is fluff. Pretty fluff and or perhaps meant to be thought provoking, but in the way that a hoard is a collection. Sure there's good stuff in there, but when there's this much of it, the focus is not on how cool your stuff is anymore.

-It's not like *that*. He's a good fighter who gets his ass beat. But he's REALLY good, like professionally, until the story is more fun for him to fail for some reason. We watch so many failed and useless plans from their inception to their execution to their eventual failure. While this might be true to life, the cool thing about writing about it afterward is you get to pick your scenes. He's a softy who would never abuse his power or cause harm for knowledge until the first opportunity to do so? Things like that all over the place. Whatever you think, nerds, this isn't like that, ha ha, gotcha.

-The torture scenes. For a book that starts with a desire not to torture anyone, it sure has a lot of it. I mean, a lot. I think at least 2 chapters are full of it. I skipped several pages of it because it gets graphic and there are who pages of *bad thing is done in exquisite detail to this person* between "Tell me what you know!" and "I don't know anything!" type dialogue. And this is also seen in the beginning where it's just chapters of people being mean to this (admittedly very whiny and stuck up) teen.

-Nobody until he's somebody. While stewing about the torture scenes, I had mental space to muse on how the whole set up of this book and how we're meant to think of Hadrian as a nobody with nothing going for him and no one on his side until the story needs him to use his power. It's, like, every single major plot point (and even some minor ones) is solved by people suddenly giving him authority.

It wasn't necessarily bad. I see the fun things. I liked a lot of what the author was going for. I stuck it out. But I think I just require much tighter writing and this, while cogent, was still very much too "seat-of-the-pants" plotting for me to engage fully with it.
22 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Empire of Silence.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
May 30, 2024 – Shelved as: to-read
May 30, 2024 – Shelved
June 4, 2024 – Shelved as: fantasy
June 4, 2024 – Shelved as: man-author
November 2, 2024 – Shelved as: sff-bookshelf

Comments Showing 1-7 of 7 (7 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Gyan K I felt the same way about Hadrian being a Mary Sue. As I kept reading, things fell into place and there is a reason for this device/trope. Him being a Mary Sue did make sense as I read the next installments. This trope did seem like an easy cop-out to get him out of sticky situations. That said, this truly is a great sci fi tale, probably one of the best I have seen/read.


Allison Hurd I've heard they get better, but it'll definitely be awhile until I can being myself to read the next one!


message 3: by Feliciana (new) - added it

Feliciana I liked this one, even though I agree with a lot of what you shared. I was hoping that the pace would pick up further in the series, but the Sun Eater ate up my joy and left me only bored for dessert. I ended up DNF with second book.


Sarah Had to laugh at the seat of the pants comment. I thought to myself on multiple occasions, this book was almost fully pantsed. Which seems impossible for a 7 book series. The ending bothered me too. Hadrians transition from who he is on page 1 to who he is on page 578 doesn’t feel remotely “earned� or justified. I can buy “because principles� in the beginning but if that’s the principles they shouldn’t just randomly change later when it suits the story.


Allison Hurd Agreed!


message 6: by Beth (new)

Beth I was curious about this one, because some number of my GR friends were reading it in close-ish proximity to each other. Thought-provoke-y hoard I could get into, though too much meandering in similar grooves and even I might get anxious for the plot to get a move on.

...explicit torture sequences, though? Okay, pass.


Allison Hurd Yeah, I tried to remember if they delve into you Hard No trigger, and I don't recall that, but soooo much torture.


back to top