ŷ

Rachel Hanes's Reviews > Land of Milk and Honey

Land of Milk and Honey by C Pam Zhang
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
75009563
's review

bookshelves: book-club, library

This book was chosen by my book club. So this was my June, 2024 book club read. Would I have chosen this book on my own? No. Was I happy to give it a chance? Yes I was, as I am open to “expanding my horizons�. However� this book did not work out for me or any of the other members of my book club unfortunately.

All I have to say is this book is bizarre. An unnamed narrator tells the story of how a smog has taken over. The smog destroyed America and Southeast Asia first, and then a year and a half later it reached Europe. The smog has destroyed all the crops, sheep, and cattle. Food is made with a processed flour/meal that is highly addictive. Our unnamed narrator is a chef who gets a job in Italy - she was able to land this job by lying on her resume.

In Italy, our unnamed chef/narrator meets her rich boss and his daughter Aida. Here she also gets acquainted with foods, such as strawberries, that she hasn’t seen in years. She becomes friends with Aida and is taken to a lab where animals are reproduced. She is also taken to a place where grass is planted, called “the land of milk and honey�.

None of us were really sure what the point of this boring, depressing book was. We have several thoughts and theories (way too many to get into in this review). I mean, our food sources could certainly be destroyed one day. We already have Bill Gates manufacturing genetically engineered foods, and they’re already selling Impossible Meat at the stores- so maybe this book was a glimpse into our future. And it seemed that only the rich will be able to eat the real foods that are left, and live in proper housing to protect them from the smog�

Regardless, this was a weird book. This wasn’t my cup of tea, and I honestly couldn’t even bring myself to finish this book. Since I only read about half of this book, I have decided not to rate this book as it wouldn’t be a fair rating.
59 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Land of Milk and Honey.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 16, 2024 – Started Reading
June 16, 2024 – Shelved
June 16, 2024 –
page 47
19.58% "I’m reading this for my Book Club this month. Not sure how I’m going to feel about this, as this has a very dystopian theme/feel to it."
June 18, 2024 –
page 125
52.08% "I think I’m going to put this book on hold, and just listen to the discussion at my book club next week. Not my cup of tea. Long, drawn out and boring�"
June 26, 2024 – Shelved as: book-club
June 26, 2024 – Shelved as: library
June 26, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-32 of 32 (32 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Cindy (new)

Cindy Sheppard Gidge hats off for your honesty..... sounds like a punishment to endure too. You nailed it with how it's going to be with food plants being burned down++, farmers everywhere being drove into bankruptcy , food shortages big time( people dropping like flies since the shots) and with shortages it makes it easier to control how much we are allowed to purchase / social credit coming/engineered food ;yuck/ insect plants......... Oh "goodie", this is probably very well a glimpse ahead sadly; unfortunately.

How in the world do such strange books win awards anyway I wonder??


message 2: by Jayme (new)

Jayme Sounds depressing too! Hope you love your next! ❤️


message 3: by Rosh (new)

Rosh If everyone at your book club didn't get the book, something surely went wrong in its execution. Book club discussions are most fun when opinions are divided, not when everyone loves or hates the book almost unanimously.
That said, I truly appreciate not just your honesty in this review, but also your decision of not rating this one as you didn't complete it. I don't get reviewers who read barely a quarter of a book and then give it 1 star as it "was horrible." Sorry this was just a dud for you, Rachel. I hope your book club pick for next month works out far better! ❤️


message 4: by Holly (new)

Holly  B (slower pace!) Sorry it didn't work Rachel!


message 5: by Rachel (new) - added it

Rachel Hanes Cindy wrote: "hats off for your honesty..... sounds like a punishment to endure too. You nailed it with how it's going to be with food plants being burned down++, farmers everywhere being drove into bankruptcy ,..."

Cindy, that point was brought up that this book would probably be turned into a movie and win an Oscar and a bunch of other awards- and we’d all be there just shaking our heads. However, I do feel this is a glimpse into our future with the food plants being burned down, our loss of farmers, engineered foods, and food shortages. It’s actually quite scary if you really think about it.
I do wish that this book was written in a more interesting way/format, because I think that it could have opened a lot of people’s eyes to what’s going on�


message 6: by Rachel (new) - added it

Rachel Hanes Jayme wrote: "Sounds depressing too! Hope you love your next! ❤️"

It was very depressing. Thank you so much, Jayme! 💗


message 7: by Rachel (new) - added it

Rachel Hanes Rosh wrote: "If everyone at your book club didn't get the book, something surely went wrong in its execution. Book club discussions are most fun when opinions are divided, not when everyone loves or hates the b..."

Thank you so much, Rosh! 💗 Even though we unanimously did not like this book at book club, it did give us a lot to talk about. Lol! The execution of the book was horrible (in my opinion), because it was like the author was trying to write in poetry- when this wasn’t a poetic story� There were no italics used, and we never knew when she was jumping from past to present. So very weird.
I’ve also learned not to rate books I don’t finish anymore- it’s not a fair judgement on my end (although I think this one would have been on the lower end 😬).


message 8: by Rachel (new) - added it

Rachel Hanes Holly wrote: "Sorry it didn't work Rachel!"

Thanks, Holly! We all tried to give it a shot! 🤗


message 9: by Srivalli (new) - added it

Srivalli Rekha I know right away this book is not for me! Sorry it didn't work, Rachel. The execution seems to have gone really wrong!


message 10: by Terrie (new)

Terrie  Robinson It sounds horrible, Rachel, and like one I would struggle to finish, too. Your review is amazing!🩷


message 11: by Michelle (new)

Michelle Terrific review, Rachel! 💙 This book doesn't sound like one I would enjoy either.


message 12: by Rachel (new) - added it

Rachel Hanes Srivalli wrote: "I know right away this book is not for me! Sorry it didn't work, Rachel. The execution seems to have gone really wrong!"

Thanks, Srivalli! The execution went totally wrong in this book. I wasn’t the only person who could not finish this book in the group, and with it being a short book- it took the others weeks to finish it�


message 13: by Rachel (new) - added it

Rachel Hanes Terrie wrote: "It sounds horrible, Rachel, and like one I would struggle to finish, too. Your review is amazing!🩷"

Thank you, Terrie! 💗 This is definitely a book that everyone struggled with in my book club. Half of us couldn’t finish it, and the other half took weeks to read it.


message 14: by Rachel (new) - added it

Rachel Hanes Michelle wrote: "Terrific review, Rachel! 💙 This book doesn't sound like one I would enjoy either."

Thank you, Michelle! 💗 Yeah, I tried, but it just wasn’t for me unfortunately.


Taste_in_Books You are definitely not alone in your thoughts. As much as I loved her debut novel, I just did not get along with this one. Too bizarre and very disappointing..


message 16: by Rachel (new) - added it

Rachel Hanes Taste_in_Books wrote: "You are definitely not alone in your thoughts. As much as I loved her debut novel, I just did not get along with this one. Too bizarre and very disappointing.."

Thank you, Taste-in- Books! This book was very bizarre. I never read her debut novel, but I’m not so sure if I will after this book�


message 17: by Cara (new)

Cara Fabulous review, Rachel💖!!!!!!!! I'm so sorry this book didn't work out for you or any of your book club members, I hope you love your next read much better😘!!!!!!!!!


message 18: by NZLisaM (new)

NZLisaM Well I definitely won’t be reading it. Thanks for the heads up, Rachel.


message 19: by Susan (new)

Susan This doesn’t sound too appealing but I enjoyed your review! Gosh usually one or two in my book club group may dislike something but when everyone thinks it’s a dud? No thanks! Better luck on your July book!


message 20: by Rachel (new) - added it

Rachel Hanes Cara wrote: "Fabulous review, Rachel💖!!!!!!!! I'm so sorry this book didn't work out for you or any of your book club members, I hope you love your next read much better😘!!!!!!!!!"

Thank you, Cara!! 💗 We all tried with this book, but it just didn’t work for us. Very bizarre and depressing� I hope you love your next read too! 🤗


message 21: by Rachel (new) - added it

Rachel Hanes NZLisaM wrote: "Well I definitely won’t be reading it. Thanks for the heads up, Rachel."

You’re welcome, Lisa! You really won’t be missing much if you skip this one�


message 22: by Rachel (new) - added it

Rachel Hanes Susan wrote: "This doesn’t sound too appealing but I enjoyed your review! Gosh usually one or two in my book club group may dislike something but when everyone thinks it’s a dud? No thanks! Better luck on your J..."

Thank you, Susan! We were all shocked and a little disappointed with this one at book club. I’m hoping July goes much better as well! 🤗


message 23: by Barbara (new)

Barbara Good for you that you gave it a chance, It's what book club is all about. Excellent review Rachel!


message 24: by Rachel (new) - added it

Rachel Hanes Barbara wrote: "Good for you that you gave it a chance, It's what book club is all about. Excellent review Rachel!"

Thank you so much, Barbara!! :)


message 25: by Yun (new)

Yun Great and fair review, Rachel! Glad you gave this book a chance, but too bad it wasn't for you. Hope you love your next read.


message 26: by Rachel (new) - added it

Rachel Hanes Yun wrote: "Great and fair review, Rachel! Glad you gave this book a chance, but too bad it wasn't for you. Hope you love your next read."

Thank you so much, Yun! I hope you love your next/current read as well! :)


message 27: by A (new)

A Mac This sounds like a tough one, especially since most of y'all didn't find anything much to like about it. It's certainly frustrating to not find anything engaging or meaningful, and I'm glad you decided not to lose any more time to it. Helpful review, Rachel!


message 28: by Rachel (new) - added it

Rachel Hanes A wrote: "This sounds like a tough one, especially since most of y'all didn't find anything much to like about it. It's certainly frustrating to not find anything engaging or meaningful, and I'm glad you dec..."

You’re welcome, A! This was a tough book to read. Although we didn’t like this book, it did bring up many topics for discussion- so I guess that is one plus to this book. :)


Shelley's Book Nook It's not you, it's the book. If your book club all agree that it's not a great book then I'd say something is wrong with the book. I love your review, Rachel. Very clear in your critiques. I hope you're enjoying The Lion Women of Tehran. 🤗💕


message 30: by Rachel (new) - added it

Rachel Hanes Shelley's Book Nook wrote: "It's not you, it's the book. If your book club all agree that it's not a great book then I'd say something is wrong with the book. I love your review, Rachel. Very clear in your critiques. I hope y..."

Thank you so much, Shelley! 💗 I’m so glad everyone in my book club agreed (or maybe not, because we do want someone to like this book), that this wasn’t a very good book. It was a very good book for discussion though. However, I am loving The Lion Women of Tehran!! I wish I had more time to finish it up this week! 🤗


message 31: by Reader (new)

Reader Thank you!


message 32: by Rachel (new) - added it

Rachel Hanes Reader wrote: "Thank you!"

You’re welcome, Reader!


back to top