ŷ

Roman Clodia's Reviews > Creation Lake

Creation Lake by Rachel Kushner
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
56111743
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: netgalley

Now Longlisted for the Booker 2024
We've ceased to locate ourselves in a larger system, a grand design. We've cut the rope, my children.

Rachel Kushner is that cool girl novelist who's also deeply smart and thoughtful. This book is closer to The Flamethrowers than The Mars Room but what they all share is an anarchic energy and a wayward trajectory epitomised by an unruly, unbound female protagonist-narrator (I'm discounting here Kushner's finding-her-feet-as-a-writer book Telex from Cuba).

Kushner's women have a kind of androgyny about them: they're sexy - here self-consciously and manipulatively so - but they also operate in environments that are more often gendered masculine: here as an ex-FBI-style agent now independent and possibly a bit rogue; in other books as part of a motorbike speed-racing group, and in prison.

The mood of this novel is unmoored: 'Sadie Smith', our protagonist, is operating under a pseudonym as she infiltrates a kind of eco-commune in France who may or may not be planning acts of violence. But Sadie's clients are shadowy and morally questionable - is she working for a government agency or for big corporate business interests who want to paint protesters as criminals and terrorists?

This sense of disorientation permeates the text and is complicated by the presence of Bruno's voice: a man with a troubling twentieth century past whose theories of Neanderthal man and whose retreat into the caves of France paint him initially as something between a crank and a cult guru but whose thoughts on how to live under late-stage capitalism form a parallel narrative to the main storyline - and seem to become increasingly judicious and perceptive.

This is not, I'd say, a book for readers who want a clear pull-through and who are uncomfortable with ambiguities at all levels. But for me, this is a fascinating exploration of where we are today, where we have come from and how we might be at a form of crossroads in terms of where our future lies. All that wrapped up (but never neatly or tidily) in a questing, searching, probing narrative that asks serious questions without making itself earnest.

Yep, Kushner is right up there on my list of exciting writers working today.

Many thanks to Random House, Vintage for an ARC via NetGalley
204 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Creation Lake.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

July 16, 2024 – Shelved
July 22, 2024 – Started Reading
July 23, 2024 –
page 0
0.0% "'Neanderthals were prone to depression, he said.'"
July 23, 2024 –
7.0% "'Truck ruts and panties snagged on a bush: that's "Europe".'"
July 23, 2024 –
7.0% "'Truck ruts and panties snagged on a bush: that's "Europe".'"
July 26, 2024 –
page 71
17.4% "'But none of these eruptions had resulted in the overthrow of capitalism in any of the advanced industrial nations of the entire European continent - not a single one.'"
July 27, 2024 –
page 128
31.37% "'Some kind of lunatic, a man who lived in a cave and ranted about cave frequencies, but his descriptions of the region were being confirmed one after the other.'"
July 27, 2024 –
page 247
60.54% ""The Hotel Maurice is like a theatre stage," Vito says, "where we watch the important men of France order a very expensive hamburger.""
July 27, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-16 of 16 (16 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

endrju I admit I had a bit of a guard when I saw it's forthcoming, but you made it sound very exciting. Looking forward to picking it up when it comes out.


Roman Clodia It's especially exciting watching Kushner grow as a novelist and I'd say this is her most ambitious book yet. Looking forward to your thoughts when you get to it.


Gumble's Yard - Golden Reviewer Sounds intriguing - hoping to get an ARC of this soon.


Roman Clodia It's one of those books where we'll all see different things, I think.


Kartik I was so confused by why I wasn't finding this book... Until I realized I was confusing Rachel Kushner with Rachel Cusk 💀


Roman Clodia Haha, well, they're both brilliant and cool!


Isabel Would you say I should read telex from Cuba? Or is it not great?


Roman Clodia Isabel wrote: "Would you say I should read telex from Cuba? Or is it not great?"

It didn't work for me and doesn't feel like Kushner had found her voice yet.


message 9: by S (new) - rated it 4 stars

S Gouldman I loved your use of the word “unmoored� when describing the mood of this book because it crystallized exactly my feelings of how I felt reading this book and when discussing the book with a friend my thoughts were somewhat “unmoored� when trying to describe what exactly I thought was the message of the book. Excellent review


Roman Clodia Glad to hear that resonated with you, S!


Michael Jennings I found the book badly wriitten and deeply depressing rather like the USA today


Roman Clodia Michael wrote: "I found the book badly wriitten and deeply depressing rather like the USA today"

I found it the opposite - but you know that from my review!


message 13: by Bev (new) - rated it 4 stars

Bev Sharpe I'm trying to review my read books so i remember them properly. I was a bit at a loss of what to say about this book as i got quite bored by it mid way through especially when i read it in short bursts as the "Bruno" bits seemed to distract from the story. Your review clarified my thinking on the novel as a whole. Really well written thought provoking and a great female protagonist but i am not sure that i really enjoyed it. Thanks.


Roman Clodia Glad to help! Kushner 's books can seem straightforward on the surface but repay thinking about - not always possible when we're reading in short bursts amidst life. Writing reviews helps me clarify my own thoughts in a slightly more cohesive way.


Lindsay Van Niekerk There's a strong streak of subversiveness in this novel. She tosses so much into the mix and its feels intentionally unsettling. Kushner is a great observer, I imagine she keeps a notebook with her because many of the characters seemed drawn from observation with their weirdly specific quirks and oddities. And definitely no cliches about the charming French countryside


Roman Clodia Lindsay wrote: "There's a strong streak of subversiveness in this novel."

Definitely - and in her other books.


back to top