ŷ

Taufiq Yves's Reviews > Hear the Wind Sing

Hear the Wind Sing by Haruki Murakami
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
167492150
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: japanese-lit, fav-haruki-murakami, chinese-translation

When I first read Haruki Murakami’s debut novel, Hear the Wind Sing I was baffled by why he wrote so much about Derek Hartfield. I knew Hartfield was a writer he admired, but it seemed over the top to include such large portions of his work in a debut novel.

In this novel, he writes:

”Hٴھ has a short story called Martian Wells, which is one of his most unconventional works, almost suggesting the upcoming emergence of Bradbury. I read the book a long time ago and have forgotten the details, but here is the gist: It's a story about a young man who descends into countless bottomless wells on Mars. The wells were likely dug by Martians thousands of years ago. Strangely, these wells all cleverly avoid water veins. No one knows why they dug these wells.

In fact, aside from these wells, the Martians left nothing else. No writings, no houses, no utensils, no iron, no graves, no rockets, no towns, no vending machines, not even shells, no nothing. Only wells. Whether this can be called civilization is hard for Earth scholars to determine. Indeed, these wells are impeccably constructed; despite thousands of years passing, not a single brick has collapsed.

It goes without saying that several explorers and investigators have descended into the wells. Those with ropes had to return due to the wells being too deep and the horizontal passages being too long. Those without ropes never returned.

One day, a young man wandering the cosmos descended into a well. He was tired of the vastness of the universe and longed for a quiet death. As he descended, he felt the well becoming increasingly comfortable, and a strange force began to gently envelop his body. After descending about a kilometer, he found a suitable horizontal passage, entered it, and aimlessly walked along its winding paths. He had no idea how long he walked—his watch had stopped long ago. It could have been two hours, maybe two days. He felt no hunger or fatigue; the mysterious force still surrounded his body.

At some point, he suddenly saw daylight. The horizontal passage had connected to another well. He climbed along the well wall and returned to the surface. He sat by the well, gazing at the vast, unobstructed wilderness and then at the sun. Something had gone wrong! The breath of the wind, the sun... The sun, though at its zenith, had turned into a huge orange mass, like the setting sun."


Besides this passage, he mentions Hartfield several times in the novel. It's rare for any author to extensively quote another writer's work, even for Murakami. This might be the only instance.

Now, I finally understand his intent. First, we need to understand what this thin novel - is really about. What themes are hidden behind the seemingly chaotic reviews, descriptions, dialogues, memories, broadcasts, and music?

I believe it's about loneliness and the fragile connections between people. Of course, you might think differently. The novel is Murakami’s, and apart from me, there are millions of readers, including you, each with their interpretations.

On my third read of this novel, I felt a profound sense of loneliness - perhaps an unprecedented loneliness. The evidence is as follows:

1. The record store girl with only 9 fingers: the detached finger from her body;
2. The wandering girl "I" once took in: after a few days of passionate lovemaking, she silently left without even a note;
3. "My" college girlfriend, who died alone in a corner of the woods by the sports field that summer. The cause of death is unknown;
4. Rat (“my� friend) talking about a story he wants to write: a shipwreck, survival, he and she drifting in the ocean, swimming in opposite directions (one toward an island, the other toward land), meeting years later in a bar;
5. After that summer, “I� went to Tokyo for school and never saw the record store girl again (Why was she drunk in the bar initially? Why was she traveling alone (or having an abortion)? Why did she leave the city? Why did Murakami say she had a twin sister?);
6. On the radio, a girl dedicates a song for "me," asking for an old record she lent “me”years ago. After “I”bought the same new record, “I� couldn't find her.

So, I say this is a novel about loneliness. What makes it beautiful is the pervasive subtle sadness (you can call it "loneliness") throughout the story.

Returning to the initial question - why does Hear the Wind Sing extensively quote Hartfield, especially his short story Martian Wells?

On January 15, 2003, Murakami’s long-time Chinese translator, Lin Shaohua, met Murakami for the first time. In the preface to the Chinese edition of Kafka on the Shore, Lin wrote, ”During our chat, he was in high spirits. An hour later, I asked him several questions in an interview format. One of the questions was about loneliness.

”Life is essentially lonely, but at the same time, you can communicate with others through the channel of loneliness," Murakami continued. ”People always enter their world alone, and at the deepest point, a sense of connection arises. Or, people dig deep into their own holes; if they keep digging, they'll connect with others somewhere."

This immediately reminded me of Hartfield’s Martian Wells. ”No one knows why they dug these wells. In fact, aside from these wells, the Martians left nothing else... Whether this can be called civilization is hard for Earth scholars to determine... Those with ropes had to return due to the wells being too deep and the horizontal passages being too long. Those without ropes never returned." And ”At some point, he suddenly saw daylight. The horizontal passage had connected to another well. He climbed along the well wall and returned to the surface."

People, in their deep loneliness, connect with others somewhere. Only then can they return to the surface. Murakami'’s Sputnik Sweetheart note: Sputnik means "travel companion" in Russian; Sputnik 1 was the first artificial Earth satellite launched by the Soviet Union, and Sputnik 2 carried the dog Laika and was not recovered) wrote two strange stories, like dreams - no, like fantasies - unbelievable stories. Hartfield, too, wrote Martian Wells with wild imagination.

Murakami always says his intention in writing novels is to communicate with others through loneliness. He chose an unusual way, through seemingly far-fetched imagination. He says, ”Everyone has an imagination; the difficult part is approaching that place, finding the door, opening it, entering, and then returning. If readers resonate with my books, they have the same world as mine."

Murakami found Harrfield’s well on Mars, and I found his Sputnik satellite. So, we are connected somewhere deep in the well, sharing the same world.

4.6 / 5 stars

My other reviews of Murakami's Work:
The City and Its Uncertain Walls
Norwegian Wood
1Q84
Hear the Wind Sing
Kafka on the Shore
Sputnik Sweetheart
The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle
South of the Border, West of the Sun
After Dark
135 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Hear the Wind Sing.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

October 6, 2020 – Started Reading
October 15, 2020 – Finished Reading
July 24, 2024 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-43 of 43 (43 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Jonas (new)

Jonas Powerful and poignant review. I’m blown away. I have read almost all of Murakami’s novels and read some twice. Your review has convinced me I need to reread all of his work a second time. I love what you’ve brought to light. I missed so much in my first read of this one.


Taufiq Yves Jonas wrote: "Powerful and poignant review. I’m blown away. I have read almost all of Murakami’s novels and read some twice. Your review has convinced me I need to reread all of his work a second time. I love wh..."

Murakami is one of my favorite authors, Jonas. I can't quite explain why, but only as I've gotten older have I truly grasped his writing. I find myself rereading his works all the time, and each time I do, I discover something new.


message 3: by Gillian (new)

Gillian Excellent review Taufiq!


message 4: by Tina (new)

Tina So glad this was an excellent start to a new series. Great review!


message 5: by Maddy � (new)

Maddy ✨   ~The Verse Vixen Such a stunning review , I am up for this author's work 🤍


Taufiq Yves Gillian wrote: "Excellent review Taufiq!"

Thanks, Gillian.


Taufiq Yves Tina wrote: "So glad this was an excellent start to a new series. Great review!"

Thanks, Tina.


Taufiq Yves Maddy wrote: "Such a stunning review , I am up for this author's work 🤍"

Thanks, Maddy.


message 9: by Akankshya (new)

Akankshya Wonderful review, Taufiq! It's so nice that you took the time to delve into the intricacies of this novel and interconnected references. It's cool that you've read this one so many times already :D


message 10: by Baba (last edited Jan 15, 2025 03:45AM) (new)

Baba A sublime review, thank you for sharing Taufiq :)


message 11: by Fran (new)

Fran Magnificent, well crafted review Taufiq!


Jennifer (Jaye) (catching up slowly) WoW, this is a fascinating review Taufiq, truly mind blowing 🥰🥰🥰


message 13: by Keri (new)

Keri Stone Wonderful insightful review Taufiq. The beauty of books is the meaning we each come away with. And then are able to share in this community on GR!


message 14: by Jayme (new)

Jayme Incredible review! 💖


message 15: by Christina (new)

Christina Fabulous review, Taufiq!


message 16: by Karen (new)

Karen Stunning review Taufiq. Are you a teacher? You definitely have what it takes to teach. Thank you. ☺️


Brenda ~The Sisters~Book Witch Excellent review, Taufiq!!


message 18: by Maureen (new)

Maureen Another stellar review Taufiq 👏


message 19: by Rosh (new)

Rosh Murakami isn't for me, but glad you enjoy his works, Taufiq. Your review speaks of your love for his writing. :)


Brittany (Brit.tea.reads) Wonderful review my friend ☺️


message 21: by Terrie (new)

Terrie  Robinson As I read your lovely review, Taufiq, it became clear to me how much you admire Murakami's writing skill. I'm not sure he is an author for me though...


Taufiq Yves Akankshya wrote: "Wonderful review, Taufiq! It's so nice that you took the time to delve into the intricacies of this novel and interconnected references. It's cool that you've read this one so many times already :D"

Thanks, Akankshya.


Taufiq Yves Baba wrote: "A sublime review, thank you for sharing Taufiq :)"

Thanks, Baba.


Taufiq Yves Fran (Not Receiving Notifications) wrote: "Magnificent, well crafted review Taufiq!"

Thanks, Fran.


Taufiq Yves Jennifer (Jaye) (catching up slowly) wrote: "WoW, this is a fascinating review Taufiq, truly mind blowing 🥰🥰🥰"

Thanks, Jaye.


Taufiq Yves Keri wrote: "Wonderful insightful review Taufiq. The beauty of books is the meaning we each come away with. And then are able to share in this community on GR!"

Thanks, Keri.


Taufiq Yves Jayme wrote: "Incredible review! 💖"

Thanks, Jayme.


Taufiq Yves Christina ( Waaaaay behind) wrote: "Fabulous review, Taufiq!"

Thanks, Christina.


Taufiq Yves Karen wrote: "Stunning review Taufiq. Are you a teacher? You definitely have what it takes to teach. Thank you. ☺️"

Thanks, Karen.


Taufiq Yves Brenda ~The Sisters~Book Witch wrote: "Excellent review, Taufiq!!"

Thanks, Brenda.


Taufiq Yves Maureen wrote: "Another stellar review Taufiq 👏"

Thanks, Maureen.


Taufiq Yves Rosh wrote: "Murakami isn't for me, but glad you enjoy his works, Taufiq. Your review speaks of your love for his writing. :)"

Thanks, Rosh.


Taufiq Yves Brittany (Brit.tea.reads) wrote: "Wonderful review my friend ☺️"

Thanks, Brit.


Taufiq Yves Terrie wrote: "As I read your lovely review, Taufiq, it became clear to me how much you admire Murakami's writing skill. I'm not sure he is an author for me though..."

Thanks, Terrie.


message 35: by Christy (new)

Christy fictional_traits Lovely review Taufiq. I must admit, I’ve not read anything of Murakami’s yet!


message 36: by Rain (new)

Rain Sounds like Murakami has a beautiful way with words. Lovely review.


Taufiq Yves Christy wrote: "Lovely review Taufiq. I must admit, I’ve not read anything of Murakami’s yet!"

Thanks, Christy.


Taufiq Yves Rain wrote: "Sounds like Murakami has a beautiful way with words. Lovely review."

Thanks, Rain.


Persephone's Pomegranate This was your third time reading the novel? Wow. Such a profound review.


message 40: by Darla (new)

Darla You have really taken time to understand this author. An awesome review, Taufiq.


Taufiq Yves Persephone's Pomegranate wrote: "This was your third time reading the novel? Wow. Such a profound review."

Thanks Pomegranate.


Taufiq Yves Darla wrote: "You have really taken time to understand this author. An awesome review, Taufiq."

Thanks, Darla.


Khalida Thank you for this amazing review!


back to top