ŷ

Gaurav Sagar's Reviews > Ways of Going Home

Ways of Going Home by Alejandro Zambra
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
8148922
's review

really liked it
Read 2 times. Last read August 19, 2024.

Instead of howling I write books.


We often contemplate upon various possibilities in literature and more so when we come across any metafictional narrative, and every such encounter leave us in awe of what we have achieved till now and what more could be done with literature, for we could only answer that question when our future traverses the realm of time to get buried under the depths of past. Such questions keep knocking at our consciousness, time and again, to examine the limits of literature and also to expand them.


The question one needs to really ask is that is it possible to write a genuine story at all, if one wants to; does any author of requisite skill and caliber capable of producing such a story which stands on its own? For the process of writing demands a particular rhythm, precision which one needs to overcome the creative inertia, moreover, the characters chosen by the author, at times, may behave on their own so it may so happen that those may choose the author to behave as per them.


The quintessential characteristics of metafiction involve the self-reflectiveness, the story reflects upon itself as if it is self-sufficient, the device of self-reflection is abundantly used in postmodernism and metafiction. Alejandro Zambra weaves in a unique narrative style wherein multiples stories are nested inside a larger story or perhaps the larger story reflects unto the smaller one. The narrator of book is an author himself who writes about the narrator of a book he is writing; the narrator of that book is also an author who writes about the narrator of a book he himself is writing; or perhaps it is other way around- from interior to exterior. Moreover, the narrator of book which the narrator of Zambra is writing about has a being of its own and expresses himself through creation of other story and the other narrator, and the process goes on to ad infinitum. It reminds me of Maurice Bhanchot whose all novels are self- reflective.


The book raises the basic questions about the process of writing itself in a way that the narrator of the book poses the question about the very premise of writing that is it really possible to attempt a genuine story about someone, something or even oneself, something which is sacred in itself and doesn’t need anything to refer to. An author works like a spy who peeps into others� lives to look for various possibilities but doesn’t know what exactly he wants. The author takes this metafictional examination to deep into core of the very process of writing i.e. is an author capable of being unaffected by his past, could an author write with a Zen like attitude so that his pasts or memories won’t come to haunt him through his words?


The fundamental question is that could we write by keeping our past aside? Moreover, the stories which we tell through our writing, do they have existence of their own, in sense that they do not resemble the stories of people we come across in life. Or do we tell stories of other people who we encounter in our lives? Is it right to use stories of other people in our stories? And most importantly, are we capable of telling other people’s stories? Isn’t it so that however we try to reveal others� stories, but we always end up sharing our own stories?


And we need to further deep delve into the core that what are our stories comprised of? Do words protects us or expose us? The narrator of the story perhaps writes to come back to his childhood; to relive the moments he lost there in the graveyard of time. Whatever way he tries, he always ends up with looking for childhood memories, to relive them, or perhaps to make peace with them and to get away from the ghost those memories. We long for time when we are lost, and everything is new so that we may start afresh with no baggage of the haunting past. The narrator or the author says that when we write something, we wash our hands of everything as if by that we may advance towards something and perhaps that’s why we lie so much that it becomes very difficult to write an honest and genuine story. It reminds me of autofiction genre, which has become quite popular in the recent times, so as to see it in the light of honesty to tell a story.


The author contemplates upon the problem of our past reincarnating itself through our stories and proposes that perhaps what we need are those odd little fragments of memory that have no beginning and no end, when we think about our past, we remember the sounds of the images, and we should simply describe these sounds, which the author calls “stains on memory� and nothing more. However, we fall to the curse and habit of creating a ‘passable� prose and end up producing ingenuine and obscure story. Though it is said that words are better than silence as proposed by the narrator that though his parents maintain silence to authoritarianism, he and his friends use words as to show their resistance; but we can’t save ourself from the cruel and stingy wounds of the words as they expose us in the process of writing our own stories, ‘echoes and hollows of the language� define our life through their pattern, and that’s the risk an author has to take while writing stories.


Ways of Going Home alludes to the various possible (and perhaps impossible too) ways to writing a story, it is like a laboratory of an author wherein he not only actually shows by writing the story in multiple ways, putting into practice the very process of creation but it may also refer to multiple ways of remembering, understanding and accepting by making peace with our past. Writing may be a tricky vocation in which there may be melodrama for initially having wasted many nights on this useless passion, but gradually we start feeling comfortable with it, without looking for or feeling the need of any grandeur purpose or goal in it. However, it is a vocation which requires a perseverance of plenitude as it is also an expression of our solitude wherein, we seek validation from others, and it may not come easy at times.


Though the novel may be slim in size, a small story or series of attempt to write one based in the times of Pinochet, the structure of the novel consists of unique vastness like sea wherein the dynamic narrative is created using the alternating chapters of the narrator’s life and the book he is writing, wherein we find that the life of the narrator is repeated through endless revisions through the story of the book he is writing, the process goes on and on until it eventually dawn on you that perhaps it is not just about the narrative of the story in general but it also showcases the way a story is being written under political repression. At this juncture, it reminds me of Ismail Kadare, who we lost this year, who used parables, fables, allegories and folk stories to write under the rule of totalitarianism.


So, what could be said about the book which is so unique in structure and nature, is it a memoir or a love story? Well, it could be mentioned with authority that Ways of Going Home is about the survivors of the lost world, those who did not give in to the tortures of the dictatorship as they are main characters of the book, and it is also about those who grew up in the fallout of dictatorship and try to recreate the history of a generation which has no class, no rituals and no roots. The narrator of the book and the narrator of the book he is writing take writing as their divine tool to make peace with their haunting pasts, while the narrator longs for validation of his manuscript through the eyes of Eme, the narrator of the book he writes, helps his lover, Claudia to reclaim her past through their journey into the place of their childhood or as a character to reclaim her own existence which in a way depends on their past or our own past for that matter. It may be said that it isn’t love that unites the narrator and Claudia, rather it’s the love of memory.

We discover coincidences that inevitably bring us back to real life, to our youth, to childhood. Because we can’t, we don’t know how to talk about a movie or a book anymore; the moment has come when movies and novels don’t matter, only the time when we saw them, read them: where we were, what we were doing, who we were then.
266 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Ways of Going Home.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 5, 2024 – Started Reading
August 6, 2024 – Shelved
August 6, 2024 – Finished Reading
August 19, 2024 – Started Reading
August 19, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 70 (70 new)


message 1: by Jaidee (new)

Jaidee Very interesting thoughts here Gaurav. I am glad that I got a taste of this book through your review.


message 2: by Sh (new) - added it

Sh Kishan Oustanding review, Gaurav. I really enjoyed your essay on the writing, fiction and storytelling, great job. Thank you !!!


Taufiq Yves "Instead of howling, I write books". Great choice and great review, Gaurav.


message 4: by Kevin (new)

Kevin Ansbro Another astute, well written review, Guarav.


message 5: by Emma.catherine (new)

Emma.catherine Absolutely amazing review!


message 6: by Laysee (new)

Laysee This sounds like an interesting take on the metafictional aspects of writing. Great review, Gaurav.


message 7: by Jennifer (new) - added it

Jennifer Welsh This is such a full review, Gaurav, I was shocked when I came to the paragraph mentioning it was slim, lol. I LOVE books about writing that ask all these deep questions which are really about what we are made of in the first place and how does creation from us unfold. I’m adding—thanks for putting this on my radar. Have you read Spark’s, Loitering with Intent? That brought up many of these questions for me in a very fun way, and is also slim.


message 8: by Greta (new) - added it

Greta Samuelson This is such a great review- I must read this now
Thank you for sharing!


message 9: by Mwanamali (new) - added it

Mwanamali Great review Gaurav


message 10: by Joe (new)

Joe Krakovsky That was quite an analysis and you asked a lot of thought provoking questions. Maybe you should be a teacher.


message 11: by Vesna (new)

Vesna This early Zambra must be fascinating that it inspired such a captivating writeup from you, Gaurav. A stunning presentation of its structure, style and, not the least, its poignant story about the life under dictatorship.


message 12: by Kimber (new)

Kimber Silver Another wonderfully written and intriguing review, Gaurav!


message 13: by Violeta (new)

Violeta Thank you for a superb presentation of a work and a writer I had never heard of, Gaurav.


message 14: by Esta (new)

Esta I enjoy reading your thorough and insightful reviews Gaurav, and this one provided some interesting food for thought :)


message 15: by David (new)

David Gaurav, such fine words. I must look for this book as I do like Zambra a lot!


message 16: by s.penkevich (new)

s.penkevich Marvelous marvelous review! Okay, I've owned this for over a decade and have somehow not read it, now I really need to


message 17: by Mirnes (new) - added it

Mirnes Alispahić I've enjoyed this review, Gaurav. Thank you for it and this recommendation. I'll certainly look for this novel.


message 18: by Simon (new)

Simon The review interestingly enough reminds me of Art Spiegelman's "Maus" where as much of the narrative revolves around the author's experience writing and creating the comic book as about his father's experiences during WW2. As well as with the problems of reconstructing past events on the basis of one person's subjective memories, that in turn get filtered through another person's interpretation. Right down to the events recalled taking place in one of the 20th century's most infamous dictatorships.


message 19: by Nilguen (new)

Nilguen Terrific review, Gaurav!


message 20: by Liam (new) - rated it 5 stars

Liam Ostermann Wonderful review, much more insightful than anything I could say. I do remember one scene were the boy, now grown up, remembers making his parents to an event at the National Stadium and how as a child he didn't understand their reluctance. Now as an adult he knows that for his parents the Stadium was a sight of horror because of what was done there following the coup. But should he be haunted, was he wrong as a child? A very subtle and beautiful novel


message 21: by Nelson (last edited Aug 24, 2024 12:05PM) (new) - added it

Nelson Zagalo Great review Gaurav. Zambra is known for playing with form and representation, but I didn’t knew this one. Thanks ☺️


message 22: by Sonny (new)

Sonny I lack the creative mind to be a storyteller, but I have often marveled at the ability of writers to create a fascinating, nuanced story. You have captured that process well.


message 23: by AiK (new)

AiK Thanks for the interesting review, I wanted to get acquainted with the work of Alejandro Zambra.


message 24: by Kathleen (new) - added it

Kathleen Wow, Gaurav. You make this sound interesting on so many levels! I love your contemplations around this one, particularly the idea that we always end up telling our own stories--lots of truth there. Thanks for steering me to this one.


message 25: by Nika (new)

Nika Great review, Gaurav! You asked some big questions and offered us an interesting unique analysis of this story. The love of memory sounds powerful.
The idea that we may always end up telling our own stories seems particularly thought-provoking to me. I'm not sure about 'always', but I think it's quite common for people to talk more about themselves when they're trying to tell other people's stories.


message 26: by Axl Oswaldo (new)

Axl Oswaldo Superb review, Gaurav. Always wanted to read this author, for some reason I believe his works will be for me. I hope so. :)


Gaurav Sagar Jaidee wrote: "Very interesting thoughts here Gaurav. I am glad that I got a taste of this book through your review."

Thanks a lot, Jaidee for your kind words. Hoping that you enjoy it as much as I did :)


message 28: by Ken (new) - added it

Ken Lindholm I very much enjoyed Zambra’s Chilean Poet. I will check this out as well! Thank you for your review!


Gaurav Sagar Taufiq wrote: ""Instead of howling, I write books". Great choice and great review, Gaurav."

Thanks a lot, Taufiq for your kind words :)


Gaurav Sagar Kevin wrote: "Another astute, well written review, Guarav."

Thanks a lot, Kevin for your kind words :)


Gaurav Sagar Emma.catherine wrote: "Absolutely amazing review!"

Thanks a lot, Emma for your kind words. Hope you also enjoy it when you get to it :)


Gaurav Sagar Laysee wrote: "This sounds like an interesting take on the metafictional aspects of writing. Great review, Gaurav."

Thanks a lot, Laysee for your kind words. Yeah, it is a nice metafictional book. I came across the author last year and read a few books by him. Are you planning to read him ?


Gaurav Sagar Jennifer wrote: "This is such a full review, Gaurav, I was shocked when I came to the paragraph mentioning it was slim, lol. I LOVE books about writing that ask all these deep questions which are really about what ..."

Thanks a lot, Jennifer for your kind words. Hope you enjoy it as much as I did, would be looking to read your opinion on it.

I haven't read Loitering with Intent but I do remember reading your erudite review on it. I read just two books by Spark however those were enough to realize her gifts as an author, thanks for reminding me of it, would be trying to eturn to Spark soon. Btw, which all books by Spark have you read ?


Gaurav Sagar Greta wrote: "This is such a great review- I must read this now
Thank you for sharing!"


Thanks a lot, Greta for your kind words. Glad that you are planning to read it, hope you too like it as much I did. Would be looking to read your opinion on it when you get to it :)


Gaurav Sagar mwana wrote: "Great review Gaurav"

Thanks a lot, Mwana :)


Gaurav Sagar Joe (NOT RECEIVING NOTIFICATIONS) wrote: "That was quite an analysis and you asked a lot of thought provoking questions. Maybe you should be a teacher."

Thanks a lot, you've been kind :)


message 37: by Kevin (new)

Kevin Ansbro Great leading line and a fab review, Gaurav!


Gaurav Sagar Vesna wrote: "This early Zambra must be fascinating that it inspired such a captivating writeup from you, Gaurav. A stunning presentation of its structure, style and, not the least, its poignant story about the ..."

Thanks a lot, Vesna fot your kind words. Yes, it was grest read, I really enjoyed it, Zambra is like a breath of fresh air in the contemporary literary space. Are you planning to read him anytime soon ?


Gaurav Sagar Kimber wrote: "Another wonderfully written and intriguing review, Gaurav!"

Thanks a lot, Kimber for your kind words :)


Gaurav Sagar Violeta wrote: "Thank you for a superb presentation of a work and a writer I had never heard of, Gaurav."

Thanks a lot, Violeta for your kind words. Hope you enjoy it as much as I did when you get to it :)


Gaurav Sagar Esta wrote: "I enjoy reading your thorough and insightful reviews Gaurav, and this one provided some interesting food for thought :)"

Thanks a lot, Esta for your kind words :)


message 42: by Ken (new) - added it

Ken Lindholm I enjoyed Zambra’s Chilean Poet. This book is not available at my library, but it’s a Kindle deal for $2.99 today so I have a copy!


message 43: by Daniel (new)

Daniel Shindler I do not know how I missed your review, Gaurav. You have unraveled a complex novel very well.


Gaurav Sagar David wrote: "Gaurav, such fine words. I must look for this book as I do like Zambra a lot!"

Thank for your kind words. Glad to know that you too like Zambra. I've started reading him just a few months ago, which books by him have you read ?


Gaurav Sagar s.penkevich wrote: "Marvelous marvelous review! Okay, I've owned this for over a decade and have somehow not read it, now I really need to"

Thanks a lot, Steve for your kind words. Glad that you are planning to read it :)


Gaurav Sagar Mirnes wrote: "I've enjoyed this review, Gaurav. Thank you for it and this recommendation. I'll certainly look for this novel."

Thanks a lot, Mirnes for your kind word :)


Gaurav Sagar Nilguen wrote: "Terrific review, Gaurav!"

Thanks a lot, Nilguen :)


Gaurav Sagar Nelson wrote: "Great review Gaurav. Zambra is known for playing with form and representation, but I didn’t knew this one. Thanks ☺️"

Thank you Nelson. Hope you enjoy it as much as I did :)


message 49: by Bogdan (new)

Bogdan A great analytical and contemplative review, Gaurav! One of my favorite contemporary authors. As you so remarkably show, he questions sincerity through storytelling. That’s already walking on thin ice if we remember Wilde’s witty remark about sincerity producing only bad poetry...

And Zambra’s prose, of course, has a very poetic texture. He shines through brilliantly, I believe, rendering in the most subtle way the filia type of love � for a son, for example, and from very unexplored perspectives, such as that of a stepfather.


message 50: by Julie (new)

Julie G I am moved by the excerpts you have selected here, Gaurav, and, as always, you have given us something to contemplate. Thank you.


« previous 1
back to top