Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Andrew Reece's Reviews > On Sparta

On Sparta by Plutarch
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
103028353
's review

it was amazing
Read 2 times

Ploútarchos Chronicles The Deeds Of Lycugus The Lawgiver, & The Reigns Of The Spartan Kings Agis & Cleomenes.

Plutarch's 'On Sparta' was originally published in 1988 for the Penguin Classics with the translation work for the 'Lives' of Lycurgus, Agis, & Cleomenes done by Richard Talbert & the 'Life Of Agesilaus' by Ian Scott-Kilvert, whom also did the work for the 1960 edition of 'The Rise & Fall Of Athens'. This updated 2005 edition features Richard Talbert's revisions of the 4 aforementioned Spartan 'Lives' as well as a list of Sayings of Spartans & Spartan Women which are most often associated with Plutarch's series of moral essays, the 'Moralia', & finally, an appendix containing a translation of the 5th Century BC Greek historian Xenophon's political treatise, 'Politeia Of The Spartans', which Talbert prefers to render as 'Spartan Society'. All of the 'Lives' & the additional material feature exceptional introductions providing historical background, sources used, & further reading suggestions.

As he waits for his nephew Charilaus to attain his majority, Lycurgus travels abroad & begins laying the groundwork for a solid Spartan constitution by learning from the great civilizations of the Mediterranean. While at Crete he becomes acquainted with the lyric poet Thales, whose didactic verse possesses undertones that Lycurgus associated with the most powerful lawgivers, & as he stayed in luxurious Ionia, in Asia, he was introduced to the written works of the epic poet, Homer, & had them transcribed to share with his fellow Spartiates, & from the Egyptians he observed their practice of separating the warrior class from those of the laborers & craftsmen. Later in chapter 21 Plutarch describes the profound effect the travels of Lycurgus would have on Spartan culture : 'They were no less enthusiastic about training in lyric poetry & singing than they were about good style & purity in speech. Moreover their songs offered stimulus to rouse the spirit & encouragement for energetic, effective action, in style they were plain & unpretentious, while their subject matter was serious & calculated to mould character.'

In chapter 9 of his 'Life' Lycurgus the Lawgiver declares all gold & silver coinage null & void in a controversial edict, further decreeing that iron would be the only metal which could be used as legal currency. This has a catastrophic effect on the Spartan economy, aptly illustrated by Plutarch's vivid description : 'The iron money, after all, could not be exported elsewhere in Greece, & was considered a joke there, not an object of value. Consequently it was impossible to buy any shoddy foreign goods, & no cargo of merchandise would enter the harbours, no teacher of rhetoric trod Laconian soil, no begging seer, no maker of gold or silver ornaments -- because there was no coined money. Thus gradually cut off from the things that animate & feed it, luxury atrophied of its own accord.' Plutarch's 'Life Of Lycurgus' is paired with the 'Life' of the 2nd Roman lawmaker & king, Numa Pompilius, who is also credited as being the founder of the Roman religion.

After the death of the reigning Spartan King Agis II between 400/398 BC The Spartan Agesilaus gains the throne by manipulating an oracle's words & contesting the claim of Agis' heir Leotychidas, who was already thought to be an illegitimate son of the Athenian statesman Alcibiades. Throughout the course of his 40-year reign King Agesilaus II's pride, ambition, & unsuccessful panhellenic foreign policies prove to be the slow doom of the Spartan state Agesilaus later violates one of the Lycurgan 'rhetra' prohibiting frequent campaigns against the same enemy to prevent them from becoming effective in battle, when, possibly in 377 BC, after fighting in numerous expeditions against the Thebans he is seen wounded by Antalcidas, a prominent Spartan, who sardonically remarks to him : 'What splendid tuition you are receiving from the Thebans for having taught them to fight when they had neither the wish nor the knowledge to do so.'

At the beginning of his reign Agesilaus signs a treaty with the Persian Satrap of Lydia, Tissaphernes, the details of which include a release of Persian-controlled Greek cities, yet Tissaphernes nonetheless breaks the treaty & begins mobilizing his forces for war against the Spartans, prompting Agesilaus to employ a clever ruse where he first declares his intention to march on Caria & waits for the Persian force to amass their troops before proceeding to attack Phrygia instead. According to Plutarch, 'Here he captured many cities & seized a huge quantity of loot. In this way he demonstrated to his friends that to break a solemn agreement shows contempt for the gods, whereas to outwit one's enemy at once satisfies justice, earns great glory, & combines pleasure with profit.' King Agesilaus' 'Life' is paired with the famous Roman 1st-century BC general, Gnaeus Pompeius, who achieved great renown on the battlefield & was a member of the First Triumvirate with Gaius Iulius Caesar & Marcus Lucius Crassus.

Overall the Penguin Classics edition of Plutarch's 'On Sparta' is an exceptional piece of classical scholarship on a Greek city that is often overlooked in favor of more culturally well-known cities such as Athens & Rome, but the 'Lives' in this collection possess a unique atmosphere & high-energy tempo all their own, which sets them apart from Plutarch's other short biographies. At 211 pages this selection of 'Lives' is brief & also very easy to follow along with, making it a perfect choice for any reader unfamiliar with Plutarch's writing style. 'On Sparta' makes a wonderful companion piece to the 9 Athenian 'Lives' in 'The Rise & Fall Of Athens' set, also published by the Penguin Classics.
9 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read On Sparta.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
Finished Reading
August 7, 2024 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-4 of 4 (4 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Quo (new)

Quo Andrew: In a relatively short lifespan & with so very many other compelling books to read, it isn't likely that many of us will find the time to devour a book like Plutarch's On Sparta but I quite enjoyed reading your well-crafted review of the book. Bill


Andrew Reece Quo wrote: "Andrew: In a relatively short lifespan & with so very many other compelling books to read, it isn't likely that many of us will find the time to devour a book like Plutarch's On Sparta but I quite ..."

Thanks so much for the compliment! I really enjoyed learning about Sparta, I think they have an exciting history & after finishing 'On Sparta', I would like to eventually tackle Thucydides' 'History Of The Peloponnesian War' & Herodotus' 'Histories'. I am just beginning to become acclimated with Greek history, & before reading these 2 Plutarch compilations on Athens & Sparta the only experience I previously had with it were the Hellenistic Greek 'Lives' found in Plutarch's 'The Rise Of Rome'. Have a great night! Andrew


message 3: by Quo (new)

Quo Andrew: I think at one time or another, many of us contemplate reading Thucydides & Herodotus but eventually settle on books more approximate to our own age. As an example, I very much enjoyed Richard Cohen's book on how historians craft their historical tomes, Making History: The Storytellers Who Shaped the Past.

However, and in reference to Herodotus, the image of Ralph Fiennes in the "English Patient" carefully husbanding his copy of Herodotus in the film of the same name is rather unforgettable. Bill


Andrew Reece Quo wrote: "Andrew: I think at one time or another, many of us contemplate reading Thucydides & Herodotus but eventually settle on books more approximate to our own age. As an example, I very much enjoyed Rich..."

Hi Bill, I remember you mentioning 'Making History: The Storytellers Who Shaped The Past' in another comment & I thought that the book looked intriguing as I am also interested in learning about how historians craft their impressive chronicles.

I know that there are a couple of books devoted to Ammianus Marcellinus, & I'm not sure if you are familiar with a British historian, Sir Ronald Syme, who has written a number of essays on the 'Historia Augusta', which is basically what 'Lives Of The Later Caesars' is, as well as a 2-volume set on the Roman historian Cornelius Tacitus & a biography on Gaius Sallustius Crispus, another Roman historian from the late Republican era. I've not yet read any of those works quite yet but I have read Syme's 'The Roman Revolution', which is excellent.

I haven't yet seen 'The English Patient' but I am a fan of Ralph Fiennes & it looks like Herodotus' 'The Histories' has a fairly prominent role in the film because it's Fiennes' only possession when he wakes up, so I would probably enjoy the movie. Have a great day! Andrew


back to top