Candi's Reviews > You Are Here
You Are Here
by
by

“There is who we want to be and there is who we are. As we get older the former gives way to the latter, and maybe this is who I am now, someone better off by themselves. Not happier, but better off. Not an introvert, just an extrovert who had lost the knack.�
Marnie, divorced, and Michael, estranged from his wife, are middle-aged, lonely, and thrown together on a walking holiday. There are a few others along for the hike, but they quickly drop off leaving Marnie and Michael alone. Some entertaining and thoughtful banter ensues between the two. There are reflections on relationships and the ideas and expectations surrounding having children versus not having them.
“No one wants to be defined by the thing you don’t have, whether it’s a kid or a partner, and people are obsessed, especially people in a relationship.�
It’s an old, worn-out question, but I can’t help but ask why people need to get their noses in the business and choices of others? Perhaps it’s preferable to a long, hard look at oneself. Don’t we have bigger issues on the table to deal with these days? Sigh. I guess we’re all experts at something these days. Or judges. Lately, I’ve been thinking a lot about a quote from one of my favorite books, Fair and Tender Ladies: "I have made my bed and I wish everybody would let me lie in it."
I enjoyed this, my first David Nicholls novel. I’d love to find a sturdy, reliable pair of walking shoes and hit the trails. In fact, doing something like this is on my bucket list. I haven’t formulated exactly where or when, but it’s on the horizon. I like what Michael has to offer the reader about solitude and the outdoors. I’d have to agree. Still, it would be nice to make such a walk with a like-minded individual. I don’t want to be too much inside my own head, after all.
“At home he was merely lonely. Stepping outside transformed loneliness to solitude, a far more dignified state because it was his choice.�
I’m going to look at what else Nicholls has to offer. This was not so light and fluffy that I didn’t have to think at all, but it also didn’t require deep concentration � something I seem to be lacking these days. I’d recommend it!
Marnie, divorced, and Michael, estranged from his wife, are middle-aged, lonely, and thrown together on a walking holiday. There are a few others along for the hike, but they quickly drop off leaving Marnie and Michael alone. Some entertaining and thoughtful banter ensues between the two. There are reflections on relationships and the ideas and expectations surrounding having children versus not having them.
“No one wants to be defined by the thing you don’t have, whether it’s a kid or a partner, and people are obsessed, especially people in a relationship.�
It’s an old, worn-out question, but I can’t help but ask why people need to get their noses in the business and choices of others? Perhaps it’s preferable to a long, hard look at oneself. Don’t we have bigger issues on the table to deal with these days? Sigh. I guess we’re all experts at something these days. Or judges. Lately, I’ve been thinking a lot about a quote from one of my favorite books, Fair and Tender Ladies: "I have made my bed and I wish everybody would let me lie in it."
I enjoyed this, my first David Nicholls novel. I’d love to find a sturdy, reliable pair of walking shoes and hit the trails. In fact, doing something like this is on my bucket list. I haven’t formulated exactly where or when, but it’s on the horizon. I like what Michael has to offer the reader about solitude and the outdoors. I’d have to agree. Still, it would be nice to make such a walk with a like-minded individual. I don’t want to be too much inside my own head, after all.
“At home he was merely lonely. Stepping outside transformed loneliness to solitude, a far more dignified state because it was his choice.�
I’m going to look at what else Nicholls has to offer. This was not so light and fluffy that I didn’t have to think at all, but it also didn’t require deep concentration � something I seem to be lacking these days. I’d recommend it!
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
You Are Here.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
August 21, 2024
– Shelved
August 21, 2024
– Shelved as:
to-read
August 21, 2024
– Shelved as:
contemporary-literary
August 21, 2024
– Shelved as:
romance
December 2, 2024
–
Started Reading
December 10, 2024
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 56 (56 new)
message 1:
by
Diane
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Dec 15, 2024 05:18PM

reply
|
flag



I love that last quote about loneliness vs. solitude. They are very different in my opinion--one is due to circumstance and one is due to choice.
And if you come down my way, I'll happily walk with you.

Diane, this is one of those contemporary stories I can buy into. You're right - it was funny and witty! It was the right choice at the time for me :)

I love being outside too, Laysee. It's a bit brisk outside today, but I just returned from a nice walk. Fresh air does wonders! It would be such a pleasure to walk with you!! Thanks, friend :)

"Fortunate firsts" - I like that, Charles! Yes, it seems this title has satisfied a few of our mutual friends of late. I trusted those impressions enough to go for it, and I was not disappointed :)

I love to be in my own head, and have found that I actually need some nice long walks if I want to keep my sanity.
I didn’t love the only novel by Nichols that I read (ages ago), but I’m very tempted to try this one. Especially after your excellent review, friend. ☺️

I think this would work well for you at the moment, Lisa. There's enough here to feel fulfilled without being overwhelmed. I'll be interested to hear what you think of it! I'll get my walking shoes ready, my friend :)

It's a great quote from an incredible book, Fionnuala! I'm glad it appeals :)

Most people seem happy to consider themselves - it's the "hard" part that's tricky.

Re: your commentary, just like Barbara referenced one comment above � "It’s an old, worn-out question, but I can’t help but ask why people need to get their noses in the business and choices of others? Perhaps it’s preferable to a long, hard look at oneself. Don’t we have bigger issues on the table to deal with these days?" � well said. It's always easier to judge (i.e., look down at) others rather than face one's own shortcomings. Sad, but undeniably true.



This is a great pick when you're in the mood from some banter along with some meaningful observations on life, Judith :)

Thanks so much, Carmel! Self-discovery is something we should strive for more often, I think! :)

Thank you, Jen! I'm glad I decided to grab this one when I did :)

Thank you, Bianca! I realize I had mistakenly given this novel 5 stars, when in fact I meant to give it 4. It was easy to digest - good way to describe it! :)

I love to be in my own head, and have f..."
I'm sure you're quite right about the busybodies, Pedro! :D
Long walks are nice for clearing the head - as long as I don't get stuck inside it for too long :D I've been trying to walk outside when the temperatures are above freezing - even if it means walking in the snow a bit.
And friend, as I pointed out to Bianca, this was actually a 4 star book that I mistakenly rated a 5. I'm not sure that it would really dazzle you, to be honest. But it's your call! :)

Thanks so much, Barbara! I agree. Many people think about themselves constantly, sometimes above all else. They don't want to scrutinize or consider their actions or words though!

Re: your commentary, just like..."
Thank you very much, Fabian! If we spend enough time judging others, then we leave no time to take a look at ourselves. And that's exactly what many people would prefer, unfortunately!


Thanks a bunch, Sara! Of course, that quote was for you, my friend :) Such wise words from Lee Smith! If I'm ever in your neck of the woods, we'll hit whatever trail your legs are up for :) :)

Walking outdoors is one of my favorite pastimes, Antoinette. This time of year is difficult for concentration generally, but this year is even worse for me. I hope to get back into it with the new year. Time will tell! I added "Us" to my list. Thanks so much!

Many thanks, Linda. I'm pleased you like those quotes too :)

Why thanks a ton, Markus! I wish I could take a couple of weeks this spring and go on an adventurous hike. Not something too challenging - I need to work my way up to that :D Motor bikes can get the job done too - and much more quickly! Yes, the world is there for us to discover! :) Thanks for your thoughtful comment, friend :)

Thank you, Jeannie! Wouldn't it though?! And who can't use a great escape - especially these days?! :)

Thanks so much, S! Yes, I enjoyed my time spent "walking" in the company of these two characters :)


Do you mean after I've done all the legwork, Justin?! :D :D I guess if you agree to carry the snacks and water, it's a deal :)

Also, sadly, in the same boat re: waning concentration. Sigh.

Thanks a bunch, Melissa! Doesn't it get on your last nerve when people get involved in things that don't concern them?! I'm going to make a recommendation to you right now - if you have any time or inclination to read Fair and Tender Ladies, please do! The book I reviewed here is quite good, but that book is one of my all-time favorites :)

Sorry to hear your concentration hasn't been up to par either!


I'm always happy to help, K! Yes, sometimes just the right kind of book is called for at any given time! It would be my pleasure to walk with you if we could, K! :) :)


Thanks so much, Fran! And no apology necessary! We are all having issues with notifications - in addition to this, my time on GR has decreased significantly due to work and life circumstances, so I miss quite a lot, unfortunately! But I try to log in when I can because I don't want to lose touch :)
![Terence M - [Quot libros, quam breve tempus!]](https://images.gr-assets.com/users/1712357414p1/6658001.jpg)
"It’s an old, worn-out question, but I can’t help but ask why people need to get their noses in the business and choices of others? Perhaps it’s preferable to a long, hard look at oneself."