ŷ

Melissa (Semi-hiatus for Work)'s Reviews > The Strange Case of Jane O.

The Strange Case of Jane O. by Karen Thompson Walker
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
721595
's review

it was ok

2.5 stars, rounded down. Outlier alert!
Warning: if you dislike reading about the pandemic, this is not the book for you. There's a major section dealing with a pandemic.

I was really looking forward to this read, as I adored everything about The Dreamers. Unfortunately, this book just did not live up to my expectations.

I overall liked the premise, and even though it is a very slow burn, I initially had buy in because I wanted to see where things were going. In the end though, it just didn't deliver a cohesive enough story for me to get behind it. And then the ultimate ending made me round down, because of the weird ick factor it gave me.

The book is told from two perspectives. That of Dr. Henry Byrd, a psychiatrist, and the journal entries of Jane O., his patient who comes to him after experiencing some fugue state episodes.

We don't get to experience much in real time. It's a book full of telling us what happened and I felt like an outsider most of the time. I didn't connect with either of the main characters at all, and felt like they were both performing for each other rather than really trying to get to the heart of what was going on with Jane. I had zero buy in about Henry's "feelings" which came out of absolutely nowhere.

This was just not a book for me. There wasn't enough sci-fi to make it compelling (Like there was with The Dreamers) but there also wasn't enough of anything else to make it interesting without the sci-fi elements. I'll still give this author another chance because I do like her writing overall.

I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book, all opinions are my own.
48 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Strange Case of Jane O..
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 26, 2024 – Shelved
August 26, 2024 – Shelved as: to-read
February 23, 2025 – Started Reading
February 24, 2025 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-30 of 30 (30 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

JaymeO Sorry it didn’t work for you! I really enjoyed this one despite the quick ending. Terrific review!


Melissa (Semi-hiatus for Work) JaymeO wrote: "Sorry it didn’t work for you! I really enjoyed this one despite the quick ending. Terrific review!"

Just wasn't the book for me, glad you liked it though!


message 3: by NZLisaM (new) - added it

NZLisaM Sorry it wasn’t anywhere near as good as ‘The Dreamers� for you, Melissa. Fair and balanced review!


Melissa (Semi-hiatus for Work) NZLisaM wrote: "Sorry it wasn’t anywhere near as good as ‘The Dreamers� for you, Melissa. Fair and balanced review!"

Thanks Lisa!


message 5: by Suzy (new)

Suzy Terrific review Melissa! Books about the pandemic? No thank you! 🧡


Melissa (Semi-hiatus for Work) Suzy wrote: "Terrific review Melissa! Books about the pandemic? No thank you! 🧡"

It's a different pandemic but it has all the same elements. Yuck


message 7: by Amina (new)

Amina Great review, Melissa, with valid reasons for why it didn't work for you. I hope you enjoy your next read much more! 💞


message 8: by Holly (new)

Holly  B (slower pace!) Thanks so much for the warning!! Def skip for me 🩷


message 9: by Jayme (new)

Jayme I struggled with “The Age of Miracles� so I definitely won’t be picking this up! Terrific review! 💞


message 10: by Taufiq (new)

Taufiq Yves Haha, 'outlier alert' and pandemic warning—got it! Thanks for the candid review.


Srivalli Rekha I understand what you mean. While I liked the book, I didn't think of it much as a sci-fic read and the feelings part didn't work for me either. Fair review, Melissa.


message 12: by MarilynW (new)

MarilynW Ew, pandemics 🤮 Wonderful review, Melissa!


Melissa (Semi-hiatus for Work) Amina wrote: "Great review, Melissa, with valid reasons for why it didn't work for you. I hope you enjoy your next read much more! 💞"

Thanks Amina!


Melissa (Semi-hiatus for Work) Holly wrote: "Thanks so much for the warning!! Def skip for me 🩷"

You're welcome!


Melissa (Semi-hiatus for Work) Jayme wrote: "I struggled with “The Age of Miracles� so I definitely won’t be picking this up! Terrific review! 💞"

The Age of Miracles wasn't a huge favorite for me, but I adored the Dreamers.


Melissa (Semi-hiatus for Work) Taufiq wrote: "Haha, 'outlier alert' and pandemic warning—got it! Thanks for the candid review."

You're welcome!


Melissa (Semi-hiatus for Work) Srivalli wrote: "I understand what you mean. While I liked the book, I didn't think of it much as a sci-fic read and the feelings part didn't work for me either. Fair review, Melissa."
I'll look forward to your thoughts.


Melissa (Semi-hiatus for Work) MarilynW wrote: "Ew, pandemics 🤮 Wonderful review, Melissa!"
I know, I don't think authors get it that we don't really want to read about it.


message 19: by Rosh (new)

Rosh Fair review, Melissa! Sorry this wasn't the right book for you!


Melissa (Semi-hiatus for Work) Rosh wrote: "Fair review, Melissa! Sorry this wasn't the right book for you!"

Thanks Rosh!


message 21: by Cara (new)

Cara Fair and honest review, Melissa! I'm so sorry this one fell short for you!


Melissa (Semi-hiatus for Work) Cara wrote: "Fair and honest review, Melissa! I'm so sorry this one fell short for you!"

Thanks Cara!


message 23: by Jonathan (new)

Jonathan K (Max Outlier) As the baseball saying goes, "not every pitch is a strike"..looks like this one missed the plate..on to better stories!


Melissa (Semi-hiatus for Work) Jonathan wrote: "As the baseball saying goes, "not every pitch is a strike"..looks like this one missed the plate..on to better stories!"

Thanks Jonathan!


Shelley's Book Nook Sorry it didn't work for you, Melissa. I hope you are enjoying your current read. 🤗💕


Melissa (Semi-hiatus for Work) Shelley's Book Nook wrote: "Sorry it didn't work for you, Melissa. I hope you are enjoying your current read. 🤗💕"
Thanks Shelley!


NILTON TEIXEIRA Fair review, Melissa. Sorry you were so disappointed.


message 28: by Terrie (new) - added it

Terrie  Robinson I appreciate your honesty on this one, Melissa. I’m on the fence still but you mentioning it’s full of telling, feeling like an outsider, and not connecting are big issues and has me worried. I hope your current read is amazing!


Melissa (Semi-hiatus for Work) NILTON wrote: "Fair review, Melissa. Sorry you were so disappointed."

Thanks Nilton!


Melissa (Semi-hiatus for Work) Terrie wrote: "I appreciate your honesty on this one, Melissa. I’m on the fence still but you mentioning it’s full of telling, feeling like an outsider, and not connecting are big issues and has me worried. I hop..."
Thanks Terrie!


back to top