ŷ

Persephone's Pomegranate's Reviews > The Crow

The Crow by James O'Barr
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
123893338
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: anti-heroes, crime-thriller-horror, movies-tvshows

Death is eternal. My love for you is infinite.

The Crow (1994) ranks among my all-time favorite films. It's dark, gritty, beautiful, poetic, and deeply emotional. Recently, a remake was released, and everyone is upset about it, feeling that it was a bold move to touch a classic. So, what better opportunity to dive into the iconic comic that inspired the movie?

The Crow is enveloped in sorrow, both in its fictional narrative and in reality. James O'Barr, the book's author, penned the tale as a means to process the tragic death of his fiancée, Beverly. Brandon Lee, the son of Bruce Lee and the film's lead actor, lost his life on set due to a prop gun (a real revolver) that was mistakenly loaded with faulty dummy rounds while filming a scene. Brandon's life came to an abrupt end just a few weeks before he was set to marry his fiancée, Eliza Hutton. His unforgettable portrayal of Eric Draven continues to captivate audiences and remains a timeless classic for movie lovers.



The Crow tells the tale of a broken man on a quest for vengeance after the murder of his beloved fiancée, Shelly. Both Eric and Shelly are killed by a violent gang, with Shelly enduring horrific abuse before her death. Brought back to life by a crow, Eric embarks on a relentless mission to punish those responsible for his beloved's demise. As he exacts his revenge, he is perpetually tormented by memories of Shelly, and in the moments he isn't confronting his enemies, he grapples with the pain of his profound loss.

“People once believed that when someone dies, a crow carries their soul to the land of the dead. But sometimes, something so bad happens that a terrible sadness is carried with it and the soul can't rest. Then sometimes, just sometimes, the crow can bring that soul back to put the wrong things right.�

It's fitting that the author selected a crow as Eric's guide. Crows are remarkable creatures. When one of their own passes away, crows conduct their own unique “funerals.� They engage in rituals and are known to present gifts and small tokens to those who assist them. Numerous tales and videos showcase crows gifting items to people they regard as friends.



Many people are afraid of them, viewing them as harbingers of death. There might be some validity to that perception. When Eric returns, he certainly instills fear; he’s a transformed man driven solely by a desire for revenge. In the film, Eric expressed sentiments such as, "They're all dead. They just don't know it yet." However, he also exhibited a profound sensitivity and genuine concern for Sarah, the young girl whom he and Shelly looked after due to her mother's battle with addiction, as well as for Albrecht, one of the rare virtuous police officers in the city. Book Eric did not display the same level of emotional attachment as his cinematic version.

The book and the movie differ in numerous ways, and I lean towards the film's portrayal of Eric. Brandon Lee infused the character with such depth and emotion that it’s hard not to be captivated by him. In contrast, Eric from the book is much darker and more unstable, likely reflecting the author's own frustrations. I truly hope he has found some peace and has been able to heal from his grief.

The love between Eric and Shelly is both heartbreaking and enduring, transcending even death itself. We all yearn for a connection so deep that someone would go to any lengths for us, even seeking revenge on our behalf. This narrative captures that essence. While it contains elements of violence and graphic imagery, it also weaves a darkly romantic tale. Brandon's greatest desire was to marry Eliza, while Eric's deepest wish was to marry Shelly. Unfortunately, neither couple, whether real or imagined, achieved their dreams. Yet, the strength of their connections remains unshakable, even in the face of death. True love never dies.

It's not the years that matter, it's the moments.

237 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Crow.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
August 29, 2024 – Shelved
August 29, 2024 – Shelved as: to-read
August 29, 2024 – Shelved as: anti-heroes
August 29, 2024 – Shelved as: crime-thriller-horror
August 29, 2024 – Shelved as: movies-tvshows

Comments Showing 1-50 of 68 (68 new)


preoccupiedbybooks Great review! I loved the film too when I was younger. I personally think they should leave the cult classics alone, they rarely improve them!


message 2: by Pang (new)

Pang Life is Hectic again, Wait for me!! Wow! OoO I don't know about 'The Crow' movie before, dear. I gotta check! Your review did made me interested in the movie ( the classic one ) Anyway, wonderful review as uasual, Persephone. ;) <3


message 3: by Fran (new)

Fran PP...amazing review! I loved it! Why remake a cult classic......


message 4: by Esta (last edited Aug 30, 2024 02:56AM) (new)

Esta Dear PP I've missed you! I hope you've been doing well 🤍 I loved this movie, what a classic, such a poignant story behind it and adore the way you describe it. Did you know that I love crows and the corvid family? (I might have told you this already, I can't remember). I'm very much a bird lady, so you can understand why I appreciate your review so much. I have a family of magpies that visit me most days, they're so intelligent and full of personality, and they introduce their new babies to me each year and bring me gifts. Sometimes the gifts are dead insects. But I appreciate the gesture! Beautiful review as always my friend! ❤️


message 5: by Constantine (new)

Constantine Excellent review, PP. Your review made me very interested in this book!


Alan (the Consulting Librarian) Teder I don't think I ever knew there was a book version. Thanks as always for an entertaining review PP and for the visual inserts 🐦‍⬛!


message 7: by Vaishali � [V.L. Book Reviews] (last edited Aug 30, 2024 06:09AM) (new)

Vaishali • [V.L. Book Reviews] Your review for The Crow was so very immersive and compelling my friend, I couldn't not be pulled into the tragedy, the sadness and the human affliction. Your passion for the film is so very knowing, intelligent and informed, while you gather the fullness of the inspiration, the performance and real-life tragedy of something that informed the entire process. I also love your passage that details the significance and the symbolism of the crow, I had no idea that they practiced some form of funereal ritual, that's so interesting. A brilliant review, P! ❤️

P.S. I hope you're doing ok P, and it's so nice to hear from you, lovely 🌹


message 8: by Yun (new)

Yun Great review, PP! I didn't realize the movie was inspired by a book? I haven't seen the movie, so now I'm totally curious. Glad you enjoyed the book even if it wasn't as good as the movie. :)


message 9: by Alexandra (new)

Alexandra It's great to see a review by you again! It was amazing.


message 10: by Beata (new)

Beata Beautifully written PP ..


message 11: by Baba (new)

Baba Exquisite writing PP, and you have got me immediately interested in reading this seemingly fascinating work.


message 12: by Emma.catherine (new)

Emma.catherine Absolutely beautiful review


message 13: by Marquise (new)

Marquise Lovely review, Persy! I only know this through cultural osmosis, as I've never watched it or read anything about it, but it's popular enough that I know the plot by exposition. :)

I hear they're going to film another with Bill Skarsgard. Will you watch that one or you prefer to stick with the classic film?


message 14: by Nika (last edited Aug 30, 2024 02:26PM) (new)

Nika What a heartbreaking and emotional story! I've never watched
The Crow, but now I think I should. The film's portrayal of Eric sounds impressive. A desire for revenge can transform people.
I can understand Eric's feelings, but all this is so sad. Poor Shelly!

"It's not the years that matter, it's the moments."
Beautiful and wise words... and quite sad as well.

Thanks for this finely crafted review, my friend! Your words captured my attention and will probably stay with me for some time.


message 15: by Zainab (new)

Zainab Qadeer - Hiatus till May Loveee this review my gorgeous loveee 4 stars is what we want to see 💕💕💕💕


Shelley's Book Nook Such a well-written review, PP. Glad you enjoyed the read. 🤗💕


Rosh (Off GR duty for a fortnight!) I love your insightful review, Perse!! I know of 'The Crow' only as a movie where Brandon Lee lost his life. I haven't watched it, nor did I know that it was based on a comic. The parallels between the story and Brandon's life are uncanny.
I share your appreciation for the humble crow. They work so well in a group and as a species. I wish people would look beyond their appearance and caws. Then again, human beings are really shallow.. :/
I'll see if this graphic novel is available in my library.


Persephone's Pomegranate preoccupiedbybooks wrote: "Great review! I loved the film too when I was younger. I personally think they should leave the cult classics alone, they rarely improve them!"

Hollywood seems to be on a mission to remake every classic film out there. Seriously, who convinced them that people are actually into remakes? Because it doesn't seem like anyone is. Thank you!


Persephone's Pomegranate Pang wrote: "Wow! OoO I don't know about 'The Crow' movie before, dear. I gotta check! Your review did made me interested in the movie ( the classic one ) Anyway, wonderful review as uasual, Persephone. ;) <3"

The original is fantastic, and I strongly suggest you give it a watch. Thank you, Pang!


Persephone's Pomegranate Fran wrote: "PP...amazing review! I loved it! Why remake a cult classic......"

This film really didn't need a remake. Thank you, Fran!


Persephone's Pomegranate Esta wrote: "Dear PP I've missed you! I hope you've been doing well 🤍 I loved this movie, what a classic, such a poignant story behind it and adore the way you describe it. Did you know that I love crows and th..."

I’ve missed you as well, dear Esta! I’ve been dealing with some things recently, which has made me less inclined to read and check out ŷ. I’m a bit envious that you get to see magpies up close; I’ve heard they’re quite smart. Did you know their brain-to-body-mass ratio is second only to humans and is similar to that of aquatic mammals and great apes? Many people underestimate birds, thinking they’re not very bright, but that’s not accurate. I have a little hedgehog who comes to see me at night, and he loves munching on my cat's food. I once found him almost completely inside the bowl, and it was the most adorable sight.


Persephone's Pomegranate Constantine wrote: "Excellent review, PP. Your review made me very interested in this book!"

The comic is really good. I hope you check it out. Thank you, Constantine!


Persephone's Pomegranate Alan wrote: "I don't think I ever knew there was a book version. Thanks as always for an entertaining review PP and for the visual inserts 🐦‍⬛!"

While there are several comics that take place in this universe, the first one stands out as the most acclaimed and beloved. Thank you, Alan!


message 24: by len ❀ (new)

len ❀ wonderful review, perse! i haven’t seen the film and haven’t read this but now i’m curious about both! it’s sad how bad of a reputation crows have. they’re protective and loyal. will definitely need to add this, so thanks for the rec! 🖤


Persephone's Pomegranate Vaishali � [V.L. Book Reviews] wrote: "Your review for The Crow was so very immersive and compelling my friend, I couldn't not be pulled into the tragedy, the sadness and the human affliction. Your passion for the film is so very knowin..."

The recent remake has motivated me to dive back into the hauntingly dark universe of The Crow. I had nearly overlooked how incredible the original film is. Its backstory is just as heartbreaking and powerful. I've been dealing with some personal challenges lately, which is why I haven't been active on ŷ. Thank you, my friend. I love reading your comments. xoxo


Persephone's Pomegranate Yun wrote: "Great review, PP! I didn't realize the movie was inspired by a book? I haven't seen the movie, so now I'm totally curious. Glad you enjoyed the book even if it wasn't as good as the movie. :)"

The original film is a classic. You should check it out. Thank you, Yun!


Persephone's Pomegranate Alexandra wrote: "It's great to see a review by you again! It was amazing."

Thank you, Alexandra, I appreciate it!


Persephone's Pomegranate Beata wrote: "Beautifully written PP .."

Thank you, Beata!


Persephone's Pomegranate Baba wrote: "Exquisite writing PP, and you have got me immediately interested in reading this seemingly fascinating work."

The comic was expertly crafted, beautifully conveying the sense of tragedy and darkness throughout. Thank you, Baba!


Persephone's Pomegranate Emma.catherine wrote: "Absolutely beautiful review"

Thank you, Emma!


Persephone's Pomegranate Marquise wrote: "Lovely review, Persy! I only know this through cultural osmosis, as I've never watched it or read anything about it, but it's popular enough that I know the plot by exposition. :)

I hear they're ..."


I watched the remake and, to my surprise, I didn't hate it like many others did. Sure, it has its fair share of issues, particularly with the direction, dialogue, acting, character development, and pacing, but overall, it's a decent film. It had a lot of promise, but unfortunately, the script and direction held it back from reaching its full potential. I’m not optimistic about a sequel, though, since it wasn't well received. Thanks, M!


Persephone's Pomegranate Nika wrote: "What a heartbreaking and emotional story! I've never watched
The Crow, but now I think I should. The film's portrayal of Eric sounds impressive. A desire for revenge can transform people.
I can u..."


The original movie is iconic. I adore it not just for its captivating storyline and Brandon Lee's stunning performance as Eric, but also for its distinct 90s aesthetic. The soundtrack is simply incredible. While the remake is decent, it just doesn't manage to capture the essence of the original. The colors in the remake are overly bright, the city feels too generic, and the crow doesn't play as significant a role in the plot as it did before. Plus, the acting and pacing left much to be desired. I didn't dislike it as much as some people did, but the original is such a classic with its strong gothic atmosphere that recreating it today seems nearly impossible. Thank you, my lovely friend!


Persephone's Pomegranate Zainab wrote: "Loveee this review my gorgeous loveee 4 stars is what we want to see 💕💕💕💕"

Thank you, dear Zainab!


Persephone's Pomegranate Shelley's Book Nook wrote: "Such a well-written review, PP. Glad you enjoyed the read. 🤗💕"

Thank you, Shelley!


Persephone's Pomegranate Rosh wrote: "I love your insightful review, Perse!! I know of 'The Crow' only as a movie where Brandon Lee lost his life. I haven't watched it, nor did I know that it was based on a comic. The parallels between..."

What I adore about both the comic and the movie is their vibrant 90s aesthetic. They exude a gothic atmosphere that truly transports you to another realm—one that is dark, moody, and intense. This is precisely why the remake didn't resonate; it was overly bright and contemporary, missing the beloved dark gothic charm that fans cherished in the original comic and film. Thank you, dear Rosh!


Persephone's Pomegranate len ❀ wrote: "wonderful review, perse! i haven’t seen the film and haven’t read this but now i’m curious about both! it’s sad how bad of a reputation crows have. they’re protective and loyal. will definitely nee..."

Crows are truly fascinating animals. I have to confess that I used to find them a bit intimidating at first, but over time, I've grown to admire them. Their intelligence is really impressive. Thank you, Elena!


message 37: by Esta (last edited Aug 31, 2024 02:51AM) (new)

Esta Persephone's Pomegranate wrote: "Esta wrote: "Dear PP I've missed you! I hope you've been doing well 🤍 I loved this movie, what a classic, such a poignant story behind it and adore the way you describe it. Did you know that I love..."

It sounds like you’ve had a lot on your plate lately. Sending you some hugs and if you ever need a friend to chat to, feel free to DM me anytime! Hedgehogs are such little charmers—I can totally picture yours diving into the cat food bowl, adorable. I love hedgehogs! Oh yes, corvid intelligence in general gets underestimated big time! They really are intelligent and cheeky and can be befriended quite easily (very social). They also recognise themselves in mirrors unlike another little wild peewee lark friend I have, who keeps trying to attack his own reflection, some days repeatedly. 😁


message 38: by Rain (new)

Rain Brandon did such a good job in that role. Heartbreaking what happened to him. Lovely review!


message 39: by Joe (new)

Joe Krakovsky FYI what folks don't realize is that when a blank is fired the hot gas that normally propels the bullet still shoots out the barrel. Instead of having a bullet mounted in the brass case some blanks are just crimped shut or maybe have a wad of cardboard or plastic material plugging it that still shoots out the barrel. Firing a blank at close range to someone's head can still be lethal.


message 40: by Nika (new)

Nika Persephone's Pomegranate wrote: "Nika wrote: "What a heartbreaking and emotional story! I've never watched
The Crow, but now I think I should. The film's portrayal of Eric sounds impressive. A desire for revenge can transform peo..."


The strong gothic atmosphere and distinct 90s aesthetic is something that appeals to me. I'll need to watch the original.

P.S. I've been missing your reviews. So happy to read you again :)


Persephone's Pomegranate Esta wrote: "Persephone's Pomegranate wrote: "Esta wrote: "Dear PP I've missed you! I hope you've been doing well 🤍 I loved this movie, what a classic, such a poignant story behind it and adore the way you desc..."

Thank you, Esta, you're a lovely person.❤️ It's truly fascinating that magpies are among the select few animals that can identify themselves in a mirror, alongside elephants, great apes, bottlenose dolphins, and orcas. It's disheartening to meet individuals who still insist that animals lack intelligence and emotions. Believing that humans are the sole possessors of complex thoughts and feelings is a form of arrogance. This is especially poignant when we reflect on how we treat our planet and one another. We tend to think we're more advanced than we really are.


Persephone's Pomegranate Rain wrote: "Brandon did such a good job in that role. Heartbreaking what happened to him. Lovely review!"

Thank you, Rain!


Persephone's Pomegranate Joe wrote: "FYI what folks don't realize is that when a blank is fired the hot gas that normally propels the bullet still shoots out the barrel. Instead of having a bullet mounted in the brass case some blanks..."

I don't know anything about guns. It's upsetting what happened to Brandon, but on the bright side, it has significantly enhanced gun safety on film sets. Nevertheless, as evidenced by events from a few years prior, there remains room for further advancements. Complacency kills.


Persephone's Pomegranate Nika wrote: "Persephone's Pomegranate wrote: "Nika wrote: "What a heartbreaking and emotional story! I've never watched
The Crow, but now I think I should. The film's portrayal of Eric sounds impressive. A des..."


I have a deep appreciation for films from the 80s and 90s. They possess a unique and enjoyable atmosphere that seems to be absent in contemporary cinema. I would be interested to hear your opinions if you decide to watch the film. Thank you, my friend. ❤️


message 45: by Baba (new)

Baba Persephone's Pomegranate wrote: "... Complacency kills.."

It sure does!


message 46: by Esta (new)

Esta Persephone's Pomegranate wrote: "Esta wrote: "Persephone's Pomegranate wrote: "Esta wrote: "Dear PP I've missed you! I hope you've been doing well 🤍 I loved this movie, what a classic, such a poignant story behind it and adore the..."

Yes, exactly this! Intelligence and empathy aren’t exclusive to humans and it's very disheartening that some people still believe that. Humans are great at overestimating ourselves—but perhaps we're just the most elaborate species of cluelessness. 🌍🦄 Maybe one day, we’ll catch up to the animals ❤️


message 47: by A (new)

A Mac I've been meaning to watch this one for ages, and it's good to see that the source material is quite good as well! Wonderful review, PP!


Persephone's Pomegranate Baba wrote: "Persephone's Pomegranate wrote: "... Complacency kills.."

It sure does!"


:)


Persephone's Pomegranate Esta wrote: "Persephone's Pomegranate wrote: "Esta wrote: "Persephone's Pomegranate wrote: "Esta wrote: "Dear PP I've missed you! I hope you've been doing well 🤍 I loved this movie, what a classic, such a poign..."

It's quite alarming how many people intentionally choose ignorance. Unfortunately, a lot of people take pleasure in feeling superior, not just to animals, but also to their fellow humans.


Persephone's Pomegranate A wrote: "I've been meaning to watch this one for ages, and it's good to see that the source material is quite good as well! Wonderful review, PP!"

I hope you watch it, it's an iconic movie. Thanks, A!


« previous 1
back to top