ŷ

Brooke's Reviews > The Blue Hour

The Blue Hour by Paula Hawkins
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
156242339
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: thriller, physical-read, one-star-and-dnr

⭐️ 2 stars ⭐️

« How very odd it must be, living at the mercy of the tide. »


[ Another pretty cover that will sit on my shelf just for me to glare at it every time I see it. *intense hate stare* ]

The Blue Hour was excruciatingly boring and predictable. It was a painful slow burn, a mess of annoying characters, boring art fluff and an absolutely unsatisfying ending.
I’m pretty sure I hated every moment of this.
Possible spoilers.

When the tide comes, Eris is unreachable.


The Eris Island setting was evocative and had a very chilling yet beautiful vibe to it. I loved the imagery of the endless sea, the not-quite-an-island getting cut off from the mainland for hours or even days. It was a perfect mix of artistically stunning but also eerie and daunting at the same time.
The setting is where my praise for this book ends.

It is strangely thrilling, the idea of her as forbidden object of desire rather than wife.


The fuck, my dude??
Let’s leave the “mystery� to the side for a sec and take a look at these awful characters, ‘cause this quote is just the tip of the fuckery iceberg. From the late reclusive artist, center point of the mystery, to the curator of her pieces aka the lovely man whom this quote belongs to, the wife the exes the missing husband the friends � they all sucked. The relationships are messy and borderline toxic, everyone cheating on everyone, manipulative and scheming.
Not having a relatable or even simply an enjoyable character made this read 10 times more unbearable and a chore to finish.

He sees the light again, from the lighthouse, it is strobing, flashing faster now, faster, it is no longer white, now it’s blue.
Now it’s blue.


We all know the ending is what makes or breaks a thriller. Not that I thought this was salvageable by then, but the ending definitely made it worse than I thought possible.
The plot is really slow and the mystery completely predictable. You know when you think Nah, that’s too obvious it can’t be that?
Yeah, it was the super duper obvious thing.
Not only was it predictable, but it felt rushed and incomplete, unfinished plot points left unraveled, more questions than there were answers.

I could rant for ages but would rather spare myself the migraine, so TL;DR slow burn mystery with too little action and an unsatisfying ending.

An act of violence can be an act of devotion, too.
85 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Blue Hour.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

October 15, 2024 – Started Reading
October 15, 2024 – Shelved
October 15, 2024 – Shelved as: thriller
October 17, 2024 –
page 20
5.95% "I answer to no one, only the tide. "
October 20, 2024 – Finished Reading
October 21, 2024 – Shelved as: physical-read
January 28, 2025 – Shelved as: one-star-and-dnr

Comments Showing 1-29 of 29 (29 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Drache.... (Angelika) I'm sorry Brooke.. :(


Brooke Drache.... (Angelika) wrote: "I'm sorry Brooke.. :("

Thank you love ❤️ so disappointed cuz I loved the girl on a train from PH, but this was just bad ☹️


kendyl ʚ♡⃛ɞ oh no! i hope your next read is much better angel! xx


Brooke kendyl ʚ♡⃛ɞ (review slump) wrote: "oh no! i hope your next read is much better angel! xx"

Thank you beautiful 💖�


message 5: by Charles (new)

Charles I've had very mixed result with this author, and this sounds pretty bad, sorry you had to experience this mess ( but thanks for saving me from it 💙)


Brooke Charles wrote: "I've had very mixed result with this author, and this sounds pretty bad, sorry you had to experience this mess ( but thanks for saving me from it 💙)"

Thank you Charles!! 💕 and you are so welcome, this was painfully bad 😅


Jquick99 Seems like it should be 1 star instead of 2.


Brooke Jquick99 wrote: "Seems like it should be 1 star instead of 2."

Yeah maybe, but I still liked the setting so in my mind felt more like a two. Sorry this one didn’t work out for you either!!


message 9: by S (new) - rated it 2 stars

S McConnell Totally agree! Major disappointment


Brooke S wrote: "Totally agree! Major disappointment"

Such a shame, really!! I expected so much more.


message 11: by S (new) - rated it 2 stars

S Totally agree. How anyone could rate this mess over 3 stars is beyond me. And what was that ending??!


Brooke S wrote: "Totally agree. How anyone could rate this mess over 3 stars is beyond me. And what was that ending??! "

The ending was atrocious, def the worst part!!


message 13: by Jay (new)

Jay H (Hiatus) This review is such a MOOD!! Especially the ‘intense hate stare� at the pretty cover. 😂 Love how detailed and honest you were!!! Definitely sounds like one to skip. 😬


Brooke Jay wrote: "This review is such a MOOD!! Especially the ‘intense hate stare� at the pretty cover. 😂 Love how detailed and honest you were!!! Definitely sounds like one to skip. 😬"

Thanks love 💘 unfortunately I have quite a few pretty covers on my shelf that I glare at everyday lol 🥲


message 15: by Abby (new) - added it

Abby Agreed. I thought those 3 artsy characters, Becker, Sebastian and Helena, plus “Seb’s� mom were pretentious a-holes.


Brooke Abby wrote: "Agreed. I thought those 3 artsy characters, Becker, Sebastian and Helena, plus “Seb’s� mom were pretentious a-holes."

Every character in this book was pretentious and egocentric. And reading about shitty people isn’t really my fave yk? Sorry this one didn’t work out for you either Abby!


Rangeley I’m not keeping it on my bookshelf, I never want to see it again. I can put it in the little free library…but is that fair to the next reader?


Brooke Rangeley wrote: "I’m not keeping it on my bookshelf, I never want to see it again. I can put it in the little free library…but is that fair to the next reader?"

Right? I might have to glare at it everyday, but it’s one less copy going around lol. Ooh, I have an idea - let’s gift them to someone we don’t like 🤭😈


message 19: by Joyce (new) - rated it 1 star

Joyce Exactly! I could not have said it better!


Brooke Joyce wrote: "Exactly! I could not have said it better!"

Aww sucks you didn’t enjoy this either, but glad we can all share a common hatred for this book. 😌


Ashley Wands Yes, my thoughts exactly!


Brooke Ashley wrote: "Yes, my thoughts exactly!"

So disappointing!!


Vicky 100% feel exactly the same...what the heck kind of ending is that??? After all those boring details you have to end it like that??? I was so mad!


Brooke Vicky wrote: "100% feel exactly the same...what the heck kind of ending is that??? After all those boring details you have to end it like that??? I was so mad!"

That ending was so maddening! I still glare at this book every time I look at my library. Sorry this was bad for you too, Vicky!


Fiona Great review, I completely agree!


Tiffany Reynolds Give your copy away, lol. I'm glad I just checked it out of the library--to be returned immediately!


Brooke Fiona wrote: "Great review, I completely agree!"

Thank you, Fiona! � sorry this didn’t work out for you either!


Brooke Tiffany wrote: "Give your copy away, lol. I'm glad I just checked it out of the library--to be returned immediately!"

I definitely should lol! Sorry this was a disaster for you, too! 🫶🏼�


Megan 💯


back to top