ŷ

Caroline's Reviews > You're Not Listening: What You're Missing and Why It Matters

You're Not Listening by Kate   Murphy
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
6257531
's review

liked it
bookshelves: miscellaneous

This is going to be an odd ŷ review! I was reading this book - slowly as usual - but long before I had finished the book, I found that I had to return it to the library, and couldn't renew it again. It was also an inter-library loan, so it would have been a kerfuffle to get it out again.

So, and this is the odd bit, I have only read up to page 119.... What I did read was interesting, a bit predictable in places, but interesting, and a good wake-up call for listening more carefully, which is always helpful.

What I do have from reading the books so far though is a pile of notes I wish to keep - which is why I basically did the review.... (view spoiler)
35 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read You're Not Listening.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

October 20, 2024 – Started Reading
October 20, 2024 – Shelved
January 24, 2025 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-18 of 18 (18 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Jan-Maat (new)

Jan-Maat Well, good luck in getting the book back so you can discover what is on page 120 and beyond!


message 2: by CanadianReader (new)

CanadianReader I loved your “odd� review. You gathered a lot of information, which I was fascinated to read. I was particularly interested in the idea of being open to quite different perspectives and the possibility that you might be enlightened in some way, even set right!

I wonder what you found most illuminating and useful.
It strikes me that good listening requires a high degree of self awareness and, yes, restraint.

On a related note:
I recall a relative of mine always asking me about school (when I was a kid) and then quickly looking away, not the least bit interested. I couldn’t understand why she bothered asking. I suppose it was like the routine How are you? of adults, which generally has nothing to do with the questioner wanting to know how you actually are!

I was very young, but I remember how unsettling it was. It was my earliest introduction to the sort of distracted non listening that is the norm in the digital age. Phones and computers in general have affected people’s attention spans, yes, but also the ability to be present mentally and emotionally. I know it’s cliché, but it’s such a bad thing. A mother pushing a stroller along in which a baby or toddler is facing her, but she is looking down at her phone (not at the child) as she walks. Talk about attachment issues, eh?

There’s a good essay by American journalist Brenda Ueland called “Tell Me More�. (Years ago—before the internet was big and wide—I used it in an English course I was teaching to adult students who were training as child care workers. I believe it is likely available online.). It’s ages since I read it, but I seem to recall that Ueland mentioned that people don’t get to the good stuff until they’ve expelled the surface flotsam and jetsam thoughts.

Listening takes energy!


Caroline Jan-Maat wrote: "Well, good luck in getting the book back so you can discover what is on page 120 and beyond!"

Hi Jan-Maat, and good to hear from you! Sadly I don't think I will ever be finishing this book. It was an inter library loan, and I see that my own library as about four books on listening - so should I return to the subject I will probably get one of those.

No regrets though, I found what I read very interesting.


message 4: by Caroline (last edited Jan 24, 2025 11:17AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Caroline Jan-Maat wrote: "Well, good luck in getting the book back so you can discover what is on page 120 and beyond!"

Oh thank you CR - it seemed a cheek to post this review, but I really wanted to keep the notes.

It's interesting that it was the idea of being open to different perspectives that interested you. I thought that was helpful too. It's so easy to listen to someone with very different ideas and just put up one's defences.

I found the fact that in the last trimester foetuses can hear people talking and pick up the tone of voice, and respond to it, very interesting. Also how we can become over confident that we know what those closest to us will say, and therefore often don't listen properly to them. Finally I thought what was said about prying was also very interesting.

Your description of the relative who asked you about school in an absent-minded fashion and then didn't listen to your reply was very unpleasant. It's hugely rejecting to treat people like that.

Finally, you're absolutely right - being a good listener does involve a lot of restraint. I recognise in myself an urge to be understood, and therefore an urge to speak about ME - and that really doesn't make for good listening.

I found and read Brenda Ueland's article “Tell Me More�. It was very interesting. She talked about listening to a lecturing relative for days, until eventually he realised that she was listening to him, (rather than just enduring his lecturing), and he began to respond by listening to her too. Not sure I would have had the endurance to get to that point, but it was highly admirable. It also struck me that there are probably a quite a few people around who are used to not being listened to.


message 5: by CanadianReader (new)

CanadianReader Caroline wrote: "Jan-Maat wrote: "Well, good luck in getting the book back so you can discover what is on page 120 and beyond!"

Oh thank you CR - it seemed a cheek to post this review, but I really wanted to keep ..."


Yes, I fully agree that we often do not listen well to those close to us or people we see on a very regular basis. Sometimes I think the “listener� can become a bit like Charlie Brown when he hears his teacher droning on in the background. The teacher is just background noise. No words actually penetrate his consciousness!

I wonder if the author writes about the experience of people not being listened to. You mentioned attachment styles. It occurs to me that if parents weren’t listened to, they can’t offer true listening to their children. It also strikes me that there are many people who so badly need to be listened to.

Glad you found the Ueland essay. I reread it and was impressed by her observation that being listened to can be stimulating and regenerating.

I really liked what you included about questions to ask yourself after a conversation.

So much of what you noted above seems to be about self-awareness and deep attention. Listening is effortful. One must be well rested to do it well!


message 6: by Emily (new)

Emily I love your thorough reviews, as always! I am very familiar with the Closeness Communication Bias, unfortunately. 😏


Caroline CanadianReader wrote: "Caroline wrote: "Jan-Maat wrote: "Well, good luck in getting the book back so you can discover what is on page 120 and beyond!"

Oh thank you CR - it seemed a cheek to post this review, but I reall..."


I didn't see the author specifically addressing the issue of people who aren't listened to, unlike Ueland who was so interesting on that subject. (But of course I read less than half the book....)

I completely agree with you that attachment styles carry on between generations - that's why it's so good there are books like this which can hopefully make us stop and think about what we might be doing wrong. (Not as well as a proper family therapist would, but at least it's a start...)

"Listening is effortful" That is so very true....


Caroline Emily wrote: "I love your thorough reviews, as always! I am very familiar with the Closeness Communication Bias, unfortunately. 😏"

Oh me too! 😟


message 9: by Cecily (last edited Jan 26, 2025 11:43PM) (new)

Cecily Thank you for sharing what you did read, which was very interesting. Closeness Communication bias was the most notable point for me, and one that rings true.

In some ways, it's apt that it's incomplete.


message 10: by Mark (new)

Mark  Porton I love this semi-review Caroline, thanks for sharing your story and also using the word 'kerfuffle' - we need more of it 😉


message 11: by Caroline (last edited Jan 28, 2025 11:40AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Caroline Cecily wrote: "Thank you for sharing what you did read, which was very interesting. Closeness Communication bias was the most notable point for me, and one that rings true.

In some ways, it's apt that it's incom..."


Yes, Closeness Communication bias made sense for me too.

I liked what you said about it being appropriate that my review was incomplete! (And how generous too.....)


Caroline Mark wrote: "I love this semi-review Caroline, thanks for sharing your story and also using the word 'kerfuffle' - we need more of it 😉"

Hi Mark, and thank you! I have a lot of kerfuffle in my life, so it creeps into my vocab now and then....


message 13: by Emmkay (new) - added it

Emmkay Very interesting, Caroline - I see I already have this book on my want-to-read list, and the notes you've made suggest I should bring it forward. One thing I often find interesting in public places like transit and the like is to listen to other people in conversation with each other - so often it's the equivalent of toddlers engaged in parallel play, one person says something about themselves, then the other, after perhaps a perfunctory acknowledgement (or not) launches into their own anecdote and back-and-forth it goes. I try to be mindful not to do the same thing, but I'd be appreciative of authorial tips!


Caroline Emmkay wrote: "Very interesting, Caroline - I see I already have this book on my want-to-read list, and the notes you've made suggest I should bring it forward. One thing I often find interesting in public places..."

Gosh, your conversations overheard in public places were pretty damning! Lets hope when those people get jolted into listening better when it really matters. I thought what you said about parallel play was brilliant. Yes, it's exactly that.


message 15: by Am (new)

Am Y Wow you literally made a whole series of lecture notes on this book! 😆👍🏻


Caroline Am wrote: "Wow you literally made a whole series of lecture notes on this book! 😆👍🏻"
I have such a bad memory - so do find my notes helpful - I often come back to them. 😊


message 17: by Am (new)

Am Y That is a great idea and so useful for everyone else too! 😄


Caroline Am wrote: "That is a great idea and so useful for everyone else too! 😄"

Aw, thank you!


back to top