Pollopicu's Reviews > Push
Push
by
by

** spoiler alert **
The story is a typical ghetto tragedy of a young uneducated girl who's raped by her father and severely abused (also raped) by her mother. She ends up having two children by her dad, one of which who has Downs Syndrome. She also sadly ends up contacting the HIV virus from him as well.
I feel the author took the easy way out in making the book too shockingly vulgar, which is the only thing I felt held this novel together. The writer definitely tried too hard in that aspect of the story, and I wasn't really impressed by it. It's a shame the Philadelphia Inquire proclaimed this book may find a place in the African-American literary canon. If that's true, What does this say about African-American literature? not very much.
This story-line has been done so many times in literature and especially in film.
I think people are more like 'oooh this book is so good because her father rapes her and she says she likes it'. I myself am not so easily convinced.
Also Precious Jones' ignorant talk sounded more like bad ghetto Yorkshire than a girl who is simply ignorant and uneducated. Just because she couldn't read or write doesn't mean she shouldn't be able to speak. I knew people who grew up in bad situations who couldn't read or write, they spoke fine. The writer makes her talk like she's been living in a basement for 16 years.
One thing I did like about the story is how the teacher had each of girls create a private journal as a way for them to communicate back and forth and express themselves about difficult issues they weren't comfortable talking about face to face with their teacher or counselors/social workers. The journals provided the girls with a sense of anonymity they needed in order to talk about the horrendous things they had to endure in their day to day home life.
I would love to enjoy a good piece of urban literature, but this was so far from it.
I feel the author took the easy way out in making the book too shockingly vulgar, which is the only thing I felt held this novel together. The writer definitely tried too hard in that aspect of the story, and I wasn't really impressed by it. It's a shame the Philadelphia Inquire proclaimed this book may find a place in the African-American literary canon. If that's true, What does this say about African-American literature? not very much.
This story-line has been done so many times in literature and especially in film.
I think people are more like 'oooh this book is so good because her father rapes her and she says she likes it'. I myself am not so easily convinced.
Also Precious Jones' ignorant talk sounded more like bad ghetto Yorkshire than a girl who is simply ignorant and uneducated. Just because she couldn't read or write doesn't mean she shouldn't be able to speak. I knew people who grew up in bad situations who couldn't read or write, they spoke fine. The writer makes her talk like she's been living in a basement for 16 years.
One thing I did like about the story is how the teacher had each of girls create a private journal as a way for them to communicate back and forth and express themselves about difficult issues they weren't comfortable talking about face to face with their teacher or counselors/social workers. The journals provided the girls with a sense of anonymity they needed in order to talk about the horrendous things they had to endure in their day to day home life.
I would love to enjoy a good piece of urban literature, but this was so far from it.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Push.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Comments Showing 1-14 of 14 (14 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Tim
(new)
Dec 09, 2009 04:58PM

reply
|
flag



I like Urban literature, but this story-line seems like it has been done over and over again.

Hehe...well Tree is old school ghetto! :D Yeah okay...maybe not. Oh..I know...what about Blackboard Jungle...wasn't that one of the first urban gritty books? ( I am going from a vague memory...I know nothing about Urban ghetto lit. :) )

I almost picked up A tree grows in Brooklyn the other day! that's going to be one of my reads for January!

I almost picked up A tree grows in Brooklyn the other day! that's going to be one of my reads for January! "
awesome! I look forward to it. That was my favourite surprise of last year.
I don't know what I would think of real ghetto. Up here all we see are sped mannerisms in white kids with too much money and aboriginal kids with too little.

Dee, I'm going to do les Mis as the first book of the new year. After that, do you want to do A tree grows in Brooklyn together? late Jan. Very early Feb?
