ŷ

Allison E's Reviews > Firebird

Firebird by Juliette Cross
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
139256742
's review

did not like it
bookshelves: 2024-reads, so-bad-i-wanna-give-it-a-0

I know 2 things:

1. This Romantasy is going to blow up when it comes out
2. I did not like it one bit

Now that we both know these two things, let’s proceed with caution shall we? This is a story about a witch blessed with emphatic magic to feel and control the emotions of others. She is captured by an infamous Roman general who is immediately captivated by her and makes her his body slave. In this world the Roman Empire is obviously corrupt and lots of people are actually dragons. The general (love interest) is keeping secrets and is probably not as evil as his reputation would have you believe.

Before I unleash my inner rath let me say 2 nice things. Firstly I appreciated that the Malina wasn’t just a snarky stabby rinse and repeat FMC. She’s definitely snippy but I wouldn’t quite put her into the 100% insufferable category. Secondly I liked that the author picked Ancient Rome as her setting inspiration because finallyyyy the girlies get to have their romance empire moment. Nice!

Now for� everything else.

At the end of the day I don’t think I was ever going to jive with a colonizer/slave master x slave romance. For this story to even remotely work it would have to be handled with such nuance. Firebird doesn’t have that. The power imbalance between them was so icky that I found myself closing my eyes in dread at scenes leading up to intimacy because I was like “no pleaseee don’t do anything until you both are actual equals.� That’s just not a pleasant way to experience romantic progression.

This issue was also exacerbated by the fact that the love interest Julianus is a dragon. The dragon within him (and also just straight up the man) often says things like “you are mine� “tell me you’re giving yourself to me� “my treasure� “say you are mine� etc. I understand these are romantasy cash lines and while I’m not even a big fan of them in the base case, given the context, they were so uncomfortable to read. I’ll also say that since this is a romance you know the love interest is going to be redeemed and has his reasons etc etc. but I just didn’t buy it? I don’t care why he conquered and murdered all her people, I care that he did it in the first place.

Let’s move on from the romance. Let’s talk about world building/ setting. This is a Romantasy pitched as From Blood & Ash meets House of the Dragon. Unfortunately the only similarity between Cross’s Roman inspired setting to George R.R. Martin’s Westeros (besides the existence of dragons) was gratuitous violence towards woman. If you are hoping this story will have complex political maneuvering and characters with depth, look elsewhere. The politics is so surface level I couldn’t even submerge my pinky in it. Plus the presence of dragons just felt like an excuse for insta love, mating bonds, and “inexplicable connections� between two people to exist.

Humor me, let’s come back to the romance itself for a second. APART from the ickiness in the context between them, the actual interactions between Malina and Julianus made me feel nothing. Their dynamic was just canned romantasy lines, attraction without substance, and cringe spicy scenes. I know that’s pretty subjective but words like nub, quim, and cunny were present. No thank uuu

Alright wrapping up this rant. I’ll admit I read this book up until the 60-70% mark before I truly started skimming it. That is LATE in the game for a dnf and skim. I stuck with it for that long only because I was genuinely curious how the author was going to navigate the power imbalance between them romantically, not because I cared about the characters, the romance, or the world stakes.

I leave you with a quote from early on, when our guy Julianus turns into a dragon on site when he sees his girl being attacked:

“Treasure. Slicing into the world, I roar. The gray half-man shakes with fear. As he should. He is no dragon. Nor man. He is a vile creature who planned to defile my treasure. He must bleed. He must die.�

Literally: rawr XD
219 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Firebird.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 23, 2024 – Shelved
November 23, 2024 – Shelved as: to-read
December 21, 2024 – Started Reading
December 21, 2024 –
5.0% "I have an unbound manuscript of this which is fun. Whether or not this story will also be fun, I shall determine swiftly."
December 22, 2024 –
25.0% "I know he was a dragon at the time but what does it even mean for “pleasure to throb up your throat�. I’ll probably dnf and skim soon but for some reason I can’t stop reading"
December 24, 2024 – Shelved as: 2024-reads
December 24, 2024 – Shelved as: so-bad-i-wanna-give-it-a-0
December 24, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-19 of 19 (19 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by BoldKate (new)

BoldKate .. 🥺 i was looking forward to this one


Allison E BoldKate wrote: "🥺 i was looking forward to this one"

I do think the romantasy girlies are gonna love this one! Just wasnt for me hehe I do see your maybe more the Grace Draven flavor of romantasy which this book is not lololol


message 3: by Gaby (new)

Gaby Roan the quote made me ill


Booksblabbering || Cait❣️ Oh no�. But also I am living for this review! Thank you


message 5: by Donna (new)

Donna The quote . . . I am cackling.


message 6: by Arina (new)

Arina I removed it from my tbr when I saw cunny was used


Maddie Reads Thrills & Chills Bless you for reading this book so I don't have to.


message 8: by Karen (new) - added it

Karen Chappell Thank you for you ability to see thru the facade of romantasy that some authors are using to pass on books they for some reason rushed their writing of. I feel more authors are giving in to the pressure of cranking book after book out and not truly taking time for better research for world-building, character evolvement , and finding a vocabulary of sexual words that don’t make us readers cringe or just plain laugh out loud! I wanted to read this after a few positive reviews but your honesty probably has saved me a days with of time I can devote to something more engaging, thanks again!


message 9: by Andye.Reads (new)

Andye.Reads Omg 🤦‍♀�


message 10: by Kayla (new) - added it

Kayla Brooke I feel gross about the grape scene at the beginning


message 11: by Nix (new) - added it

Nix Kharon Thanks for this review. I love romantasy, but I also love George R.R. Martin and I hate it when books are compared to his work when there is nothing alike. It's then just a cheap marketing lie and ends in disappointment. I also don't like possession when the characters are in different positions of power over each other. It's not hot when MC is possessive for his unequal slave with ownership. It's just yack.


message 12: by Queen KB (new)

Queen KB I made it 28%. The “cunny� made me gag


message 13: by mostlyslumped (new)

mostlyslumped Can you recommend books with fantasy, plot twists and complex politics, even betrayal🤣


message 14: by Sarah (new)

Sarah Vinson Thank you for the review! I almost fell for the beautiful darkly box special edition cover. Thanks for reading so I didn’t have to!


message 15: by elle anaïs (new)

elle anaïs the book desc ist bad as it is but this review made sure i never read it hahah


message 16: by Luana (new)

Luana I just cancelled my preorder for this book, thank you fo your review!🙏🏻


message 17: by Rowan (new) - rated it 1 star

Rowan YOU ARE SOOO RIGHY


message 18: by Katie (new)

Katie  katiek-is-booked This is spot on. I couldn’t make it past 20%. The master/slave romance?!?! Just no. I don’t care if he “saved her� from a worse fate. She is still enslaved. He is still the one with all the power to make demands. I DNF’d and rarely recommend against reading a book (to each their own) but I will recommend against this one.


message 19: by Stephen (new)

Stephen Wallace fun review! High praise when you can say 'wouldn’t quite put her into the 100% insufferable category.'


back to top