ŷ

Jayme's Reviews > The Perfect Plan

The Perfect Plan by Caitlin Weaver
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
11345366
When I saw that Caitlin Weaver (Things we Never Say, Such A Good Family) was releasing another book-I downloaded it without reading the synopsis-and I am glad I did. The very FIRST sentence hints at what is to come, and I am glad that I didn’t know!

I did figure (correctly) that she would offer us another story with a good moral dilemma (or two!) to ponder-and that she did!

Is Fabiola as altruistic as she appears?

When her “BEST� friend Liz, who cannot have children, needs a surrogate, Fabiola offers up the perfect plan-she will carry the baby. But is she doing this for Liz-or for Liz’s husband Peter, who was Fabiola’s childhood friend, and remains her unrequited love, despite her marriage to Aron, and their three children.

When things become “complicated� who will she put first?

I was NOT immediately drawn in by this story, which took awhile to become interesting, although eventually, I became engaged and wanted to find out how it would all end. While it is still a good book-I didn’t enjoy it as much as the first two.

The biggest issue for me was the denouement-which was MUCH TOO TIDY, and not one that I found to be very believable. Had the dilemma occurred sooner, and had we been able to explore in the second half, the dynamics which helped the characters to come to these resolutions- this story might have been more plausible, and worked better for me.

For that reason, I will award this one 3.5 ⭐️ rounded down.

Thank You to Storm Publishing for the gifted ARC provided by NetGalley. As always, these are my candid thoughts!
84 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Perfect Plan.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 9, 2024 – Shelved as: to-read
December 9, 2024 – Shelved
December 9, 2024 – Shelved as: contemporary-fiction
December 9, 2024 – Shelved as: influencer-program
December 9, 2024 – Shelved as: netgalley
December 9, 2024 – Shelved as: publisher-s-invitation
December 9, 2024 – Shelved as: widget-received
December 9, 2024 – Shelved as: women-s-fiction
December 11, 2024 – Started Reading
December 11, 2024 –
1.0% "PERFECT seems to be this weeks theme! After this book, I have “The Perfect Home�! Hopefully two good ones! 🤞🏻🤞🏻"
December 12, 2024 –
25.0%
December 12, 2024 –
75.0%
December 13, 2024 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 73 (73 new)


Darla So pumped for this one. Did you get an ARC on NetGalley?😎


Jayme Darla wrote: "So pumped for this one. Did you get an ARC on NetGalley?😎"

Storm sent me a widget! But it is now available to request on NG!
I am starting this one today!


Darla Jayme wrote: "Darla wrote: "So pumped for this one. Did you get an ARC on NetGalley?😎"

Storm sent me a widget! But it is now available to request on NG!
I am starting this one today!"


Same! Also on the Storm email list. Looking forward to your review, Jayme!


Jayme Darla wrote: "Jayme wrote: "Darla wrote: "So pumped for this one. Did you get an ARC on NetGalley?😎"

Storm sent me a widget! But it is now available to request on NG!
I am starting this one today!"

Same! Also..."


I am as well! ☺️


message 5: by Tina (new)

Tina I just got approved for this one! Happy reading Jayme! 📖😊


Jayme Thanks Tina! Enjoy!


message 7: by MarilynW (new)

MarilynW Wonderful review, Jayme, too bad it's not as good as the other two titles!


Jayme MarilynW wrote: "Wonderful review, Jayme, too bad it's not as good as the other two titles!"

I know! Ceecee was disappointed too! 💞


message 9: by JaymeO (new)

JaymeO Great review! Sorry it didn’t live up to your expectations!


Jayme JaymeO wrote: "Great review! Sorry it didn’t live up to your expectations!"

Thanks Jayme!


message 11: by Nina (new) - added it

Nina Prabhu That was a perfect review.


message 12: by Rowan (new)

Rowan MacDonald Such a great review, Jayme! ☺️


message 13: by Mary Beth (new)

Mary Beth Great review! 🧡


message 14: by Rosh (new)

Rosh Wonderful review, Jayme! Endings can make or break a thriller. Too bad this went the negative way. Wish you better luck with the other 'perfect' read! ❤️


message 15: by Kat (new) - added it

Kat Terrific review, Jayme! I'm glad you still enjoy the author, even if this one didn't dazzle you! 💗


Jayme Nina wrote: "That was a perfect review."

Thank You! 🥰


Jayme Rowan wrote: "Such a great review, Jayme! ☺️"

Thanks Rowan! 💞


Jayme Mary Beth wrote: "Great review! 🧡"

Thanks Mary Beth! ❤️


message 19: by Jayme (last edited Dec 13, 2024 07:14PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Jayme Rosh wrote: "Wonderful review, Jayme! Endings can make or break a thriller. Too bad this went the negative way. Wish you better luck with the other 'perfect' read! ❤️"

Thanks Rosh! 🤞🏻


Jayme Kat wrote: "Terrific review, Jayme! I'm glad you still enjoy the author, even if this one didn't dazzle you! 💗"

Thanks Kat! Will definitely read her next! 💞


Ceecee Yes pretty much what time thought too. Not sure how it gets so many five star reviews but there you go!! Great review as always and sorry I messed up the chance of a buddy 💙


Ceecee What time?? Eh?? What I thought �. 😂


message 23: by Holly (new)

Holly  B (slower pace!) Terrific review Jayme! 🩷


Jayme Ceecee wrote: "Yes pretty much what time thought too. Not sure how it gets so many five star reviews but there you go!! Great review as always and sorry I messed up the chance of a buddy 💙"

Next time! ☺️


Jayme Ceecee wrote: "What time?? Eh?? What I thought �. 😂"

If ever-but probably never! 🤣


Jayme Holly wrote: "Terrific review Jayme! 🩷"

Thanks, Holly! 💞


Darla A thoughtful and honest review. May not be Caitlin Weaver's best, but I still look forward to reading it. 🥰


Jayme Darla wrote: "A thoughtful and honest review. May not be Caitlin Weaver's best, but I still look forward to reading it. 🥰"

And, I look forward to your thoughts! 🥰


message 29: by Karen (new)

Karen A perfectly fair review Jayme. Happy Holidays! 🎄


message 30: by Jenny (new)

Jenny Great review Jayme! I dont know this author Ill check her out. 🤗


message 31: by Kaceey (new)

Kaceey Excellent review Jayme! I’ll pass!💗


message 32: by Yun (new)

Yun Great review, Jayme! Glad you still got some enjoyment out of it at least. :)


Jayme Karen wrote: "A perfectly fair review Jayme. Happy Holidays! 🎄"

Thank You! Happy Holidays!


Jayme Jenny wrote: "Great review Jayme! I dont know this author Ill check her out. 🤗"

Her other two books were fantastic!


Jayme Kaceey wrote: "Excellent review Jayme! I’ll pass!💗"

Thanks Kaceey! 💞


Jayme Yun wrote: "Great review, Jayme! Glad you still got some enjoyment out of it at least. :)"

Thanks Yun! 💞


NZLisaM What a shame it wasn’t as good as the first two for you, Jayme. This author sure does write fast. I’ve requested it and am keeping my fingers crossed I am approved. Superb review, Jayme. 💙


Jayme NZLisaM wrote: "What a shame it wasn’t as good as the first two for you, Jayme. This author sure does write fast. I’ve requested it and am keeping my fingers crossed I am approved. Superb review, Jayme. 💙"

Looking forward to your thoughts! I am sure you will be granted a copy! 💞


message 39: by L.A. (new)

L.A. Fabulous and a fair review! 🥰


Jayme Thanks L.A.!


message 41: by Rachel (new)

Rachel Hanes Terrific review, Jayme! 🤗 I’m glad you still enjoyed this one, even though it didn’t live up to the first two books from this author.


Jayme Thanks Rachel! ❤️


message 43: by Krystal (new)

Krystal Sorry to hear this one doesn’t live up to the earlier novels. A fair and fantastic review, Jayme!


Jayme Krystal wrote: "Sorry to hear this one doesn’t live up to the earlier novels. A fair and fantastic review, Jayme!"

Thanks Krystal! 💞


message 45: by Michelle (new)

Michelle Wonderful review, Jayme! 💜


Jayme Michelle wrote: "Wonderful review, Jayme! 💜"

Thank You, Michelle! 💞


message 47: by Srivalli (new)

Srivalli Rekha Sorry this wasn't a great read. Terrific review, Jayme.


Jayme Srivalli wrote: "Sorry this wasn't a great read. Terrific review, Jayme."

Thank You, Srivalli! 💞


message 49: by Melissa (new)

Melissa ~ Bantering Books A fantastic review, Jayme! :)


message 50: by Jayne (new)

Jayne Great honest review, Jayme. Sorry this "Perfect" book lacked the perfection you were seeking. It's always a disappointment when a trusted author fails to deliver. I hope your next book is a winner.


« previous 1
back to top