ŷ

Candi's Reviews > The Good Rain: Across Time and Terrain in the Pacific Northwest

The Good Rain by Timothy Egan
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3639005
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: history, non-fiction, travel, favorites

“As the summer dries out and the pink glow off the western glaciers of Mount Baker disappears earlier and earlier, I begin to feel like a spiritual delinquent, holding up a long-planned reunion of body and soul.�

This book is the perfect combination of travel writing, history and nature, all wrapped in adept and often lovely prose with a dose of humor as the bow set firmly on top. If The Good Rain was a novel rather than a work of non-fiction, I’d say author and journalist Timothy Egan deftly presented the reader with a powerful dose of man versus nature conflict. Egan has a wish to fulfill from the start. I’ll let him explain it to you himself, so you can get a feel for the tone of his writing:

“All summer long Grandpa remains in the basement, two pounds of cremated ash in a plain cardboard cylinder. I can’t get used to the idea of this odorless beige powder as the guy who taught me how to land brook trout with a hand-tied fly, the son of a Montana mineral chaser, the teller of campfire tales about hiding from the Jesuits with his schoolboy chum, a jug-eared kid named Bing Crosby.�

“I will take a year� from Oregon desert to green-smothered rain forest, from storm-battered ocean edge to the inland waters, from the new cities of the Northwest to the homesteads of the Columbia Plateau, to see what a century can produce from scratch, and maybe� come to some understanding of why Grandpa belonged in the wellspring of the White River, as do I.�

I traipsed with Egan across the Pacific Northwest, more specifically through Oregon, Washington and parts of British Columbia. I spent time in the temperate rainforest, the volcanic mountain ranges, the Columbia River gorge, and the Pacific coast. He touches on a lot of the history from the indigenous peoples to the first white settlers to the timber and salmon fishing industries. He caused me to add a trip to the San Juan Islands to my list when I finally make it to this region of the world. I learned a bit about the plight of the sea otter and the orca, the pleasures of wine and apples, and the harnessing of the powers of the mighty rivers. As per usual, when man plants himself in the natural world, we begin to see the demise of some of our most abundant resources.

I wish I had more time to dive into the particulars of Timothy Egan’s knowledgeable discourse, but I find that commodity lacking these days. Suffice to say that I highly recommend this book to anyone looking to learn more about the Pacific Northwest. With that said, keep in mind that this was published in 1990. I’m hoping a lot of advances in the protection of those endangered resources will have been put in place since that time. I’ll be on the lookout for more recent works concerning the region in the future. Any suggestions are welcome! I’ll leave you with some of the highlights of my reading with the goal of enticement.

“But he (John Muir) would most likely disapprove of the odd distinction the camp named after him has gained: it is the site of the world’s most expensive outhouse, a $50,000 solar shitter which uses high-altitude ultraviolet rays to cook and compost climbers� waste.�

“Before the dams, some chinook would swim as far inland as the Continental Divide, deep in Idaho, Montana and British Columbia, before committing the final act of fornication, a very proper squirt before death. Like British sex, it is dignified and oddly ritualistic, following a strict set of biological rules, most of which seem to make sense at first glance.�

“Most of my life, I’ve stared out at The Brothers from Seattle � a two-breasted beauty that seems to sweep up from the very surface of Puget Sound. From the city, the tips turn pastel in sunset and then dark in silhouette, a very theatrical mountain, almost a custom fit of Winthrop’s description of a peak that, viewed from a seat in civilization, stirs the soul.�

“It was the British, the apostles of rose gardens and high tea, who nicknamed this place “England of the Pacific,� and sent boatloads of pipe-smoking, tweed-wearing, Queen-loving, tea-drinking gentlemen here to settle it. Unlike the American settlers, who brought bibles and guns to their new land, the British immigrants were urged to arrive with cricket bats, carriage harnesses and a library of the classics.�

“Full moon over Puget Sound, the last one of summer. Look at the sky, all full of doubt. The light is gone from the back side of Mount Rainier, leaving a coned cutout on the horizon.�

“Any doubts that the land is alive and in command of all that lives atop its surface are removed by the view to the south. Still smoking and stuffed with debris, Mount St. Helens, the youngest of all Cascade volcanoes, looks like an ashtray after an all-night party. Denuded, it nonetheless pulses with new life as the dome inside the crater rebuilds.�

“My past is imprinted on me, a tattoo of sensory dimensions, released by a breath of fog-dampened air or the sight of a leaf of faded color. So it is with the Pacific salmon, who are guided home by the smells from their juvenile days.�
80 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Good Rain.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 16, 2024 – Shelved
December 16, 2024 – Shelved as: to-read
December 16, 2024 – Shelved as: history
December 16, 2024 – Shelved as: non-fiction
December 16, 2024 – Shelved as: travel
January 12, 2025 – Started Reading
February 22, 2025 – Finished Reading
March 8, 2025 – Shelved as: favorites

Comments Showing 1-50 of 54 (54 new)


Left Coast Justin I almost bought this a while back....interested to hear what you thought of it.


Candi Left Coast Justin wrote: "I almost bought this a while back....interested to hear what you thought of it."

I’m slowly making my way through this and absolutely loving it! Learning a lot and admiring his writing style too!


Left Coast Justin Oh, cool! I guess I'll be having a look then.


Candi Left Coast Justin wrote: "Oh, cool! I guess I'll be having a look then."

Awesome! :)


Left Coast Justin Oh, this sounds great! I could use a gray rainy PNW break.


message 6: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala Here I am thinking of those pacific salmon blocked from carrying out their biological drive by those damn dams! Only joking;-)
What I'm really thinking about is the restful feeling after reading your review, Candi—I'd been catching up on news reels just before. Now I'm feeling refreshed.


message 7: by Diane (new) - added it

Diane Barnes We could all use a dose of this kind of writing. Just added.


message 8: by Saphirra (new) - added it

Saphirra I’ve lived in Oregon my whole life- backpacking and hiking many trails here and in Washington- we have such a vast variant of landscapes that I would find it difficult to move elsewhere! It’s hard to imagine running out of things to explore! Also dams along the Klamath River have been removed recently and it will be interesting to see how that ends up playing out with the salmon. Also a fun fact- the Smith River in Northern California and Oregon is one of the cleanest rivers in the world! It is beautiful!


message 9: by Kerry (new)

Kerry Pickens I have read most of his books except this one. He is a very talented writer.


message 10: by Judith (new)

Judith E Sounds wonderful. I read his amazing “The Worst Hard Time�.


Cathrine ☯️ I sure loved the other 2 books if his I read. Will definitely check this one out. Great review Candi.


message 12: by Bianca (new)

Bianca Great review, Candi, those quotes are delish. I hope I come across it.


message 13: by Chris (new)

Chris Wonderful review!


message 14: by Holly R W (new)

Holly R W Candi, I have just finished two books set in the Pacific Northwest and was very interested in your review. Thanks!


message 15: by Antoinette (new)

Antoinette Excellent review, Candi! Sounds like a perfect interlude. Love the passages you included.


message 16: by Barbara K (new)

Barbara K Lovely review, Candi. It’s easy to see why you would be swept up by this book, given the quotes you’ve shared.


Candi Left Coast Justin wrote: "Oh, this sounds great! I could use a gray rainy PNW break."

I suspect you would really appreciate this one, Justin. Likely you already know this, but a fact I learned was that Sequim, Washington, though surrounded by temperate rainforest, receives very little rainfall :)


Candi Fionnuala wrote: "Here I am thinking of those pacific salmon blocked from carrying out their biological drive by those damn dams! Only joking;-)
What I'm really thinking about is the restful feeling after reading yo..."


Those dams sure did cause a lot of trouble for the salmon, Fionnuala! I don't know why, but I've always had a bit of a fascination for them. I'm pleased my review provided a bit of respite from the chaos and nonsense that has seeped into pretty much all news events these days!


Candi Diane wrote: "We could all use a dose of this kind of writing. Just added."

We most certainly can use a tonic like this, Diane. I imagine this one being one of your bedtime books. It was one of mine, and that's why it took a bit longer to get through than it should have - especially considering how much I loved it!


message 20: by Laura (last edited Mar 09, 2025 09:22AM) (new)

Laura Hi Candi - fabulous review. It stirs up all my longings to travel in that part of the world. I did Geography as my first degree and I remember going to a professor's house - and his living room wall was covered in art work - primarily native art from British Columbia. But after watching all the great Eastwood films I need to travel to Idaho and Washington State and Oregon and, and and . . . I have a couple of books for you - you might already have read them: I Heard the Owl Call My Name by Margaret Craven - I think a fairly sensitive version of an outsider, a priest trying to connect with a native community in B.C.
Gretel Ehrlich The Solace of Open Spaces


Left Coast Justin Actually, Candi, I've never heard of Sequim, Washington, nor it's anomalous weather. Thanks!


Candi Saphirra wrote: "I’ve lived in Oregon my whole life- backpacking and hiking many trails here and in Washington- we have such a vast variant of landscapes that I would find it difficult to move elsewhere! It’s hard ..."

It does sound like you live in a beautiful part of the country, Saphirra! That's great news about the Klamath River dams. And, I'll add the Smith River to my list when I make it out that way :)


Candi Kerry wrote: "I have read most of his books except this one. He is a very talented writer."

This was my first, Kerry. But I have a few more added to my reading list now!


Candi Judith wrote: "Sounds wonderful. I read his amazing “The Worst Hard Time�."

It was wonderful, Judith. I'll be on the lookout for The Worst Hard Time now, too :)


Candi Cathrine ☯️ wrote: "I sure loved the other 2 books if his I read. Will definitely check this one out. Great review Candi."

I'm excited to hear from some of Egan's fans, Cathrine! I am definitely interested in reading more of his work. Thanks so much!


Candi Bianca wrote: "Great review, Candi, those quotes are delish. I hope I come across it."

Thanks a bunch, Bianca! This was a pleasure to read. I hope you can locate a copy!


message 27: by Lori (new) - added it

Lori  Keeton This sounds wonderful, Candi! I have never been any further north on the west coast than San Francisco. I imagine how beautiful the PNW is just from these snippets you shared.


message 28: by Maureen (new)

Maureen Lovely review Candi.


message 29: by Linda (new)

Linda Very well done.


message 30: by Debra (new)

Debra Fantastic review, Candi!


Candi Chris wrote: "Wonderful review!"

Thank you, Chris :)


Candi Holly R W wrote: "Candi, I have just finished two books set in the Pacific Northwest and was very interested in your review. Thanks!"

Ooh, which books were they, Holly?! I'd love to read more set in this region. This would be a good companion piece to yours :)


Candi Antoinette wrote: "Excellent review, Candi! Sounds like a perfect interlude. Love the passages you included."

Thanks very much, Antoinette! I love to "travel" like this from time to time. When it's accompanied by some excellent writing - even better!


Candi Barbara K wrote: "Lovely review, Candi. It’s easy to see why you would be swept up by this book, given the quotes you’ve shared."

Thanks a bunch, Barbara. It was the perfect sort of book for me right now :)


message 35: by Mark (new)

Mark  Porton Oh man, this is such a heartfelt review Canders, it sounds like just the tonic. Wonderful. I love the sound of being stuffed in a cardboard box in a basement when expired - that'll do me!! Also nice to see the word 'shitter' - I haven't used that one in a while, my mission is to find a use for it today - which should be very easy my friend. Great review :))


message 36: by Laysee (new)

Laysee Beautifully reviewed, Candi. I enjoyed the excerpts you picked as enticement.


message 37: by Lorna (new)

Lorna Beautiful review, Candi. I love how you find these wonderful books that traverse our unique world with beautiful prose. The Pacific Northwest is another place that I’m hoping to explore.


message 38: by Terrie (new)

Terrie  Robinson Lovely review, Candace! I can tell how much you loved this one.


message 39: by Vanessa (new)

Vanessa I enjoyed your review so much today, Candi! When I'm in the mood to read more about the PNW I will keep Egan's book in mind. Thank you!


message 40: by Wyndy (new) - added it

Wyndy A part of the U.S. I’ve yet to visit in person, but I see some PNW armchair travel in my future. Thanks for the enticement, Candi ;-)


Candi Laura wrote: "Hi Candi - fabulous review. It stirs up all my longings to travel in that part of the world. I did Geography as my first degree and I remember going to a professor's house - and his living room wal..."

Thanks very much, Laura. Oh, that would be very cool to see that native art! I'd be sure to visit an art gallery or two in the PNW when I make it there :) I appreciate those recommendations! I have the Craven book on my list already but haven't read it. The other one is new to me so I'm going to go take a look at its GR page now - thanks :)


Candi Left Coast Justin wrote: "Actually, Candi, I've never heard of Sequim, Washington, nor it's anomalous weather. Thanks!"

Oh! Well then, you are quite welcome!


Candi Lori wrote: "This sounds wonderful, Candi! I have never been any further north on the west coast than San Francisco. I imagine how beautiful the PNW is just from these snippets you shared."

It was a delightful reading experience, Lori. I've not been to the west coast at all - but San Francisco is a must someday too!


Candi Maureen wrote: "Lovely review Candi."

Many thanks, Maureen :)


Candi Linda wrote: "Very well done."

Thank you, Linda!


Candi Debra wrote: "Fantastic review, Candi!"

Thank you, Debra!


Candi Mark wrote: "Oh man, this is such a heartfelt review Canders, it sounds like just the tonic. Wonderful. I love the sound of being stuffed in a cardboard box in a basement when expired - that'll do me!! Also nic..."

Thanks so much, Markus! Ha! I'd not mind the cardboard box, but I hope to maybe be placed somewhere in the sun rather than the damp basement :D I so hope you were able to use "shitter" in conversation by now! I'd say just turning on the news would inspire use of the word ;D


Candi Laysee wrote: "Beautifully reviewed, Candi. I enjoyed the excerpts you picked as enticement."

Thanks a bunch, Laysee. It's not often I enjoy the prose of a non-fiction piece this much, but am thankful when I do! :)


Candi Lorna wrote: "Beautiful review, Candi. I love how you find these wonderful books that traverse our unique world with beautiful prose. The Pacific Northwest is another place that I’m hoping to explore."

These are fortuitous findings, Lorna! I actually had a difficult time finding a piece of travel writing about the Pacific Northwest. I'm hoping to find another one now. Wishing both of us luck with making it to that part of the world. Thanks very much :)


Candi Terrie wrote: "Lovely review, Candace! I can tell how much you loved this one."

Thank you, Terrie! I'm glad I conveyed my feelings for it properly! :)


« previous 1
back to top