Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Garima's Reviews > The Posthumous Memoirs of Brás Cubas

The Posthumous Memoirs of Brás Cubas by Machado de Assis
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
7915003

... this book is written with apathy, with the apathy of a man now freed of the brevity of the century, a supinely philosophical work, of an unequal philosophy, now austere, now playful, something that neither builds nor destroys, neither inflames nor cools, and, yet, it is more than a pastime and less than an apostolate.

My Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ morning started on an emotional note today. I logged in and found a book recommendation by Ali, friendly comments from Dolors and Dustin, the surprised mention of my name in Manny’s review and lovely messages in the inbox. What more could I have asked for? The update feed however, presented a different and grim story altogether. A chilling reminder about the unfavorable direction this site is heading towards. A site which is of, by and for the readers. Good readers, Great readers, readers without whose recommendations and reviews, I wouldn’t be the reader, I’m today. Emotions surged up when I started imagining the what ifs scenarios and when you dedicate a huge chunk of your time to a virtual world, the happenings in that world whether positive or negative, affects you in incommensurable proportions. It’s affecting me too and I would like to extend my heartiest thanks to each and everyone who are raising their voice in protest and hope that whatever happens the good reader in you will persevere and find blissful solace in wonderful books.

May I recommend The Posthumous Memoirs of Bras Cubas? Death is inevitable and melancholy is alright but what fun to have an everlasting smile pasted on your face while reading a book. Bras Cubas is dead but gifted us all these wonderful posthumous memoirs. Why Posthumous? Probably our narrator, a supposed alter-ego of our author was seeking a full-fledged creative freedom and wanted to break all the rules of writing that must be in practice during his time. The year was 1880 and Joaquim Maria Machado de Assis gave us this enchanting literary treat which surely holds the power to fascinate everyone of us in the present world of countless genres and sub-genres.
He had no other philosophy. Nor did I. I'm not saying that the university hadn't taught me some philosophical truths. But I'd only memorized the formulas, the vocabulary, the skeleton. I treated them as I had Latin: I put three lines from Virgil in my pocket, two from Horace, and a dozen moral and political locutions for the needs of conversation. I treated them the way I treated history and jurisprudence. I picked up the phraseology of all things, the shell, the decoration ...

The truth in his humor, the irony in his innocent expressions and the wisdom in his reckless way of living life (while he lived), will make you instantly fall in love with Cubas. He’s not perfect but he’s perfectly human. The writer in him finds a way of telling us his witty intentions without sticking to conventions as apparent in the following quotes:

What looks like a simple inventory here are notes I'd taken for a sad and banal chapter that I won't write.

I found in her a certain ethereal softness wedded to the polish of earthly forms—a vague expression and worthy of a chapter in which everything must be vague.

Few tears, lots of laughs and random sighs - the life viewed from the other side of the grave is not sieved through the judgmental eyes of the people around us but comes across in an unadulterated form consists of memories collected, mistakes committed and admissions of guilt in the confession box of our hearts and in retrospect, the life appears to be beautiful. Cubas tells us that and that’s what we should tell ourselves while we are living.

Believe me, remembering is the least evil. No one should trust present happiness, there's a drop of Cain's drivel in it. With the passing of time and the end of rapture, then, yes, then perhaps it's possible really to enjoy, because between these two illusions the better one is the one that's enjoyed without pain.
79 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read The Posthumous Memoirs of Brás Cubas.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

September 14, 2013 – Started Reading
September 14, 2013 – Shelved
September 16, 2013 – Shelved as: its-not-you-its-meta-or-gfhrytyt
September 16, 2013 –
page 73
30.42% "Virgilia gave me lots of news from the world outside, narrating it with humor, with a certain touch of a wicked tongue, which was the salt of her talk. I, ready to leave the world, felt a satanic pleasure in making fun of it all, in persuading myself that I wasn't leaving anything worthwhile.

FUN FUN FUNNY READ."
September 18, 2013 –
page 145
60.42% "Take a look now at the neutrality of this globe that carries us through space like a lifeboat heading for shore: today a virtuous couple sleeps on the same plot of ground that once held a sinning couple. Tomorrow a churchman may sleep there, then a murderer, then a blacksmith, then a poet, and they will all bless that corner of earth that gave them a few illusions."
September 19, 2013 – Shelved as: favorites
September 19, 2013 – Shelved as: sui-generis
September 19, 2013 – Shelved as: to-re-read
September 19, 2013 – Finished Reading
October 11, 2013 – Shelved as: my-2-cents
May 27, 2014 – Shelved as: remember-me-with-words

Comments Showing 1-37 of 37 (37 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Luke You're reading this! You're reading this! Yay yay yay!


Garima Haha! Yes Yes, I'm reading this and thoroughly enjoying it. All thanks to you lovely goodreads folks.


message 3: by Samadrita (new) - added it

Samadrita What a heartfelt piece of writing, Garima. Let's hope the note of optimism in your review rings truer than the Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ shenanigans over the last one week. May we stick it out together as a community here and not on Booklikes or elsewhere. Cheers!


message 4: by Lit Bug (new) - added it

Lit Bug What a beautiful reflection... I hope to write like this someday. The book, I'm adding it. And I worry about people leaving GR - it isn't a 'virtual' community for me anymore - it's as real as the neighbor next door.


message 5: by Tej (last edited Sep 26, 2013 12:29PM) (new) - added it

Tej I read your opening paragraph with a choke in my throat because that was exactly what I had been grappling with over the days. This virtual world seemed much more real than the world around and it had provided immunity against so much of ruckus in our 'real' lives that I had started to take it for granted. It still is there but seems that sort of sanctity has been blemished in all this mire... AND suddenly against wish I had to imagine the world without Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ!!!

And aside from all this conundrum, far away from the talk of business models and all, this is what this site means... the wonderful books reviewed so wonderfully well by wonderful people like Garima. There is some part of us in these small assemblages of words, each time, over and over. This is the real deal! I hope that this whole murky business will kill itself with time and we shall continue getting treated with such beautiful literary pieces...

Thank You Garima... wonderful as ever :)


message 6: by Dolors (new)

Dolors Gosh Garima, what am I going to do without GR? Your opening paragraph made my skin crawl at the simple idea of losing touch with all of you...I've just arrived here!
Disheartened and distressed, I continued reading, and as usual, your words worked its magic. Facing death and melancholy with a smile pasted on one's face? A timid movement is playing in my lips. "He is not perfect, but he is perfectly human" A half smile is transformed into a broad one, now plastered on my face.
Surely there's hope for us readers as long as there are writers who inspire us, and reviewers like you who keep their voices alive and spread their puffs of fresh air around, right? At least, that's what I choose to believe, at least for now. Thanks for posting such a heartening review in times like these, Garima.


message 7: by Dolors (last edited Sep 26, 2013 12:30PM) (new)

Dolors Samadrita, Tej and Lit Bug...a toast for you all, may we stick together, come what may! Thanks for posting those moving comments, this is not a "virtual" world, it feels like "real" family to me, a family I am not ready to lose. Bring the guns guys, we're not done yet, we are going to fight! :)


message 8: by Tej (new) - added it

Tej Samadrita wrote: "What a heartfelt piece of writing, Garima. Let's hope the note of optimism in your review rings truer than the Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ shenanigans over the last one week. May we stick it out together as a commun..."

Second that....!!!


message 9: by Tej (new) - added it

Tej Dolors wrote: "Samadrita, Tej and Lit Bug...a toast for you all, may we stick together, come what may! Thanks for posting those moving comments, this is not a "virtual" world, it feels like "real" family to me, a..."

Absolutely........


Mariel What's happening? I haven't been on this week (work, work, work)? I'm really nervous now.

Great review, Garima! I liked this book too.


Garima @Samadrita, Tej, Dolors, Lit: You all have echoed the same thoughts I have in my heart, so thank you so much for that and thank you for being my friends here. I want to say more but I'm pretty overwhelmed by your words right now.

@Mariel: I've been away all day so I'm sure you must have got to know by now what all is happening. Another definition added to 'bullshit'. Anyway, thanks a lot, Mariel. Glad to know you liked the book too. :)

@Mike: Certainly ahead of his time and extremely witty. Although I have added a lot of quotes in my review, there were many more I was itching to include. And thanks a lot, Mike. You read all the good stuff so no wonder you liked this book too.


message 12: by Traveller (new) - added it

Traveller Bravo, Garima! This review is my ray of light for today. :)) Thank you.


Garima Traveller wrote: "Bravo, Garima! This review is my ray of light for today. :)) Thank you."

That really means a lot for me, Trav. Thank you!


message 14: by s.penkevich (new) - added it

s.penkevich Lovely review, Garima! I agree, the what if's are frightening. This place is my happy place and escape from grimness and stress, so it's a real shame when things start getting grim here. At least there are wonderful people such as yourself that still keep this site the shining beacon of hope and joy that it is!


Garima s.penkevich wrote: "Lovely review, Garima! I agree, the what if's are frightening. This place is my happy place and escape from grimness and stress, so it's a real shame when things start getting grim here. At least t..."

Thank you as always, Sven. The same goes out for you too. It's an honor to be in the company of brilliant readers like you and this thought is more than enough to make me happy in these dark times. AND do read the book. I'd love to read your thoughts on this one.


message 16: by Rakhi (new)

Rakhi Dalal Great review,Garima! [Well, it goes without saying for any of your reviews :)]

I echo the feelings of our dear friends here on GR! Life seems so real with GR and friends here than what we actually are living in reality. I will never think of leaving the place cos I have learnt so much here and gained so much in terms of knowledge and good friends. Let's fight for what we believe in!


Garima Rakhi wrote: "Great review,Garima! [Well, it goes without saying for any of your reviews :)]

I echo the feelings of our dear friends here on GR! Life seems so real with GR and friends here than what we actually..."


That's really kind of you to say, Rakhi. And I won't go anywhere too. I'll stalk goodreads forevahhhh... :P


message 18: by Deepthi (last edited Sep 27, 2013 11:22AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Deepthi Wonderful review, Garima! Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ definitely feels less virtual with your presence. :)
This review made my morning emotional. I better go and get some chocolate ice-cream now.


Garima Deepthi wrote: "Wonderful review, Garima! Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ definitely feels less virtual with your presence. :)
This review made my morning emotional. I better go and get some chocolate ice-cream now."


Haha! Please have a lil extra as a treat from my side. And thank you very much. Glad you liked it and sad that it made you emotional.


Deepthi Haha.. Sure. *Scooping some more*
And don't be sad because it made me emotional. I am glad it did so. They were happy-sad emotions.


message 21: by Dustin (new) - added it

Dustin Garima, my lovely GR friend, you've done it again. You've totally blown my mind with your beautiful, honest, and enduring words! (((Hugs)))

I've just added Bras Cubas to my TBS this morning, so imagine my surprise when I saw that you'd wriiten a review, and gave it 5 solid stars! Like I told you before, I'm very interested in experiencing various authors from around the world, and this clearly qualifies.


Also, it truly warms my heart to see my name mentioned here, and to know that my comments are appreciated by you. It's always a pleasure to see comments from you, as well!!


Garima Thank you so much for such a warm and endearing comment, Dustin. You're always so kind, thank you. I'm sure you'll enjoy reading this book.


message 23: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala I really enjoyed this review, Garima.


Garima Fionnuala wrote: "I really enjoyed this review, Garima."

Glad to know that, Fionnuala. Thank you!


message 25: by Ema (new) - added it

Ema I'm glad to see another praising review for this, as the book is sitting on my shelves, patiently waiting for me. Well written thoughts for what seems to be a must read novel, especially if it is also endorsed by Mike Puma!
I've known you for a short time, Garima, but I'm beginning to trust your tastes (the same goes for Samadrita, whom I befriended at the same time). So I really hope that this enchanting virtual world will not fall apart. It's good to catch up with reviews, but not so good to learn of the turmoil in GR...


Garima Ema wrote: "I'm glad to see another praising review for this, as the book is sitting on my shelves, patiently waiting for me. Well written thoughts for what seems to be a must read novel, especially if it is a..."

You'll love this novel, Ema. And thank you so much for being such a lovely friend here. The same goes out for you too. Your comments and reviews have become a source of great recommendations and invaluable happiness for me and I would love to let it continue like this only.


message 27: by Harry (last edited Oct 01, 2013 08:09PM) (new)

Harry Garima, another lovely review and strangely reflective of that first paragraph but transformed with a bit more wisdom than I've seen elsewhere here on GR - to which I will say: reviewers like you are the reason GR exists. You, and reviewers like you are the value that make this site work. You are GR, Great Reviewers. And everyone knows it.

Emotions are a bit like thermometers where the mercury rises when it gets hot and drops when things cool off. Sometimes it's just a good idea to hang the thermometer outside your kitchen window and when the mercury rises, retire into your home's cool interior. Heat stroke makes for unpredictable behavior. Cool heads always prevail. So, look out your kitchen window, Garima... That mercury will drop...it always does.


Garima Harry wrote: "Garima, another lovely review and strangely reflective of that first paragraph but transformed with a bit more wisdom than I've seen elsewhere here on GR - to which I will say: reviewers like you a..."

Thank you once again for such an endearing comment, Harry. You're too kind. I hope that the mercury drops soon and things get back to, if not normal, then at least at an acceptable level which makes our survival comforting rather than suffocating.


message 29: by Moira (new) - added it

Moira Aww, fantastic review. First paragraph made me tear up a little bit.


Garima Moira wrote: "Aww, fantastic review. First paragraph made me tear up a little bit."

Thank you so much, Moira. I was under the influence of emotions that day and poured them in this review.


message 31: by Kalliope (new) - added it

Kalliope Garima,

What a wonderful review, and how appropriate to recommend this book (already in my list) in the context of the changes that GR is establishing in its new legal standing.

Your comments and reviews in my feed are also great contributors to my great enjoyment of GR.


Garima Kalliope wrote: "Garima,

What a wonderful review, and how appropriate to recommend this book (already in my list) in the context of the changes that GR is establishing in its new legal standing.

Your comments and..."


I appreciate and always look forward to your reviews and comments too, Kalliope. And thank you for your encouraging words. Do read this book or any book by De Assis soon. I'm sure you'll love his writing.


message 33: by Tony (new) - rated it 3 stars

Tony Wonderful review, Garima. Added.


Garima Thanks, Tony :)


Garima Killer Rabbit wrote: "Garima wrote:"...hope that whatever happens the good reader in you will persevere and find blissful solace in wonderful books..."

A worthy and timeless sentiment. And I do believe, even after all ..."


Thank you, Kat. I agree but I feel sad thinking about the ones who left this site. Hope they'll make a return some time soon.


message 36: by Renato (new) - added it

Renato I'm glad you've read Machado de Assis, Garima. I need to re-read this as it's been already quite some time since high school where I read it.


Garima Renato wrote: "I'm glad you've read Machado de Assis, Garima. I need to re-read this as it's been already quite some time since high school where I read it."

I'm equally glad too and need to read his other books soon. Reading those quotes made me realise what an awesome writer he was.


back to top