ŷ

Rachel Hamilton's Reviews > Fortunately, the Milk

Fortunately, the Milk by Neil Gaiman
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
20086072
's review

it was amazing

A review by my 9 y-o son, described by the utterly lovely Neil Gaiman as the 'best review ever':


Today I was sick. My mum doesn’t always believe me when I say I’m sick, but my sister was sick yesterday so Mum said I could stay off school. ‘BUT,� she said, ‘Don’t think you’re going to be lazing around watching TV and playing on the computer all day.�

That was bad news. That is, indeed, what I was planning on doing. :(

I was bored, so Mum let me borrow her Kindle to read a book that was making her laugh, called, ‘Fortunately, the Milk…� by Neil Gaiman with illustrations by Chris Riddell. I noticed that it had brilliant pictures in it � even on the Kindle! � and Mum said I could go on the iPad if I wanted to draw a front cover for the book. I did. Look�

(you can see the images at: )

There was something very good about this book. It was an ‘enhanced edition� which means that the writer reads the book out loud to you while you read it! This writer is a good reader and he didn’t sound at all like the dalek voice that normally comes out of the Kindle. Mum said I could stay on the iPad if I wanted to draw a picture of the writer reading the book. But I can’t draw good faces so I drew a picture of the Kindle talking. Then I labeled it ‘Kindle� because Mum asked what it was.

(you can see the images at: )

I started to read. This is me reading. And no. My face is NOT the book.

(you can see the images at: )


Everyone should read this book. It will make everybody laugh. It is good and very clever. The best thing is that it goes backwards and forwards in time with the Dad meeting himself all over the place in the past and in the future and in crazy wormholes.

(you can see the images at: )

It has good characters. The dad is a funny dad. I also like the brother and sister because they are not stupid. They ask the dad clever questions to try and trap him, but he is good at wiggling out of trouble.

I think this is a very good book and it deserves 5 stars, which I have drawn here (because it meant I could stay on the iPad for longer. :) )

(you can see the images at:

One day I would like to write books as good as ‘Fortunately, The Milk…� and draw pictures as good as this too.
513 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Fortunately, the Milk.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
September 19, 2013 – Finished Reading
September 20, 2013 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-25 of 25 (25 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Kelly (new)

Kelly Murphy This is an awesome review! I especially like the line about the "dalek voice". We just had this book recommended to us, so when my kiddo is a little older, we will definitely check it out!


Rachel Hamilton I'll tell my son. He'll be really pleased. As he says, it's a fantastic book.


Lindsey Awesome review - almost as good as the book myself. I've started reading bits at a time to my 6 & 8 year old sons and so far we love it!


Olga I love this review. I think your son just might grow up to write books as good as this. And I do agree with him, it is a fantastic book with great characters.


message 5: by Melissa (new)

Melissa Love this review!!! Your son is awesome!


Rachel Hamilton Melissa wrote: "Love this review!!! Your son is awesome!"

Aw, thank you. He has his moments :)


Jannah Great review!


Maria My favorite thing about the children was that they were clever too. They had really good questions. This is a wonderful review. Thank you!


message 9: by Nanette (new) - added it

Nanette This review helped my 7 year old change her mind about reading this book. Thanks


message 10: by Jess (new) - added it

Jess I love this review! I'm adding it to my 6 year olds collection :)


message 11: by Anna (new) - added it

Anna I am sold out on the book.


LAKISHA I give this review


Cheryl Great review!


Preda One day I would like to write reviews as good as this one!!


message 15: by Hilary (new)

Hilary What a fabulous review and amazing illustrations!! 😊


message 16: by Monica (new)

Monica Fantastic review AND drawings! Good job, Mum and Son!💕


éԱٳٱ Loots Love it!!!!!!


message 18: by Shannon (new)

Shannon Great review. In fact, best review that I have read in a long time. 4.5 star review. Please keep writing...and drawing. We need more like you.


Demi R-W i also read the book and i loved it at my age. it's amazing. And Funny


message 20: by Layne (new) - added it

Layne Thank you for sharing this review. If only all reviews were this well done. And I mean that sincerely. 😊


Eileen What a wonderful review! We could all learn from your son! I did happen to love this short story!


Heather This is such a fun story.


joewtmn The best review. Also, i’d like to be just as great as a writer too. ❤️


message 24: by íٳ (new) - rated it 5 stars

íٳ A kid with culture. Love the "dalek voice" thing. Accurate 😂


message 25: by J (new) - rated it 5 stars

J Excellent review, kid!


back to top