ŷ

Paul Bryant's Reviews > In Cold Blood

In Cold Blood by Truman Capote
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
416390
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: true-crime, novels

Question : IS THERE SUCH A THING AS FATE?

Answer : no, but there are things that happen that could convince a person that there was.

Like this�

In 1959 two guys doing short stretches in Lansing (aka Kansas State Penitentiary) are sharing a cell and like all cons they talk about their lives and maybe cook up a plan or two for some future malfeasance. This one guy, Floyd, is telling Dick, the cellmate, about maybe the best job he ever had, which was working on a big old wheat farm in Kansas for a real rich farmer. He particularly remembers this farmer because he was such a kindly employer. Farm was way out in the middle of nowhere. Oh says Dick, rich? Oh yeah, maybe every week they did ten thousand dollars of business. Hey, says Dick, did you happen to see a safe in that farm house ever? Well, says Floyd, I kind of sort of remember there was something. All right, says Dick, I will rob this farmer, and I will shoot all the witnesses. Well, in jail, everybody brags on the great deeds they will do, what else is there to yap about. Floyd discounted this big talk.

In fact there was no safe at all, there was no cash kept in the farmhouse. Floyd got that part wrong, what a shame. So when Dick and his good friend Perry crept into the said farmhouse a few months later, all they found was thirty bucks. But they’d already agreed there would be no witnesses left, whatever happened, so they shot all four members of the Clutter family that night and left. And they were careful and there were no clues.

Imagine Floyd’s surprise when a couple of days later, him being still in the jail, he hears on the radio about this terrible crime. He about jumped out of his skin. Dick and his pal actually did it! At this point he realised that aside from the criminals he was the only person in the world who knew who’d done it. What to do? As every con knows, snitches get stiches. But on the other hand, there was a thousand dollar reward for information. Hmmm.



WAITING IMPATIENTLY FOR THE HANGMAN

Truman Capote did more than interview the two killers once they were caught. He visited them dozens of times, spent many hours with them, particularly liked Perry Smith, sent them the maximum allowed letters and gifts of books and candy. The book was finished by 1963 � all except for the last chapter, when the death penalty would be finally applied.

He could not finish his book until he had an ending, but neither could he put it aside and go on with something else. …His frustration was made worse by his knowledge that, lying in front of him, missing only thirty or forty pages, was the best-seller that would alter his life irrevocably, that would make him rich� the success of In Cold Blood was as predictable as the future movements of the planets.

Imagine the bizarre mixture of hopeful anticipation and agonised disappointment as Perry and Hickock went through appeal after appeal, their damned busy lawyers petitioned for a new trial � this nearly gave TC a heart attack � he liked these miserable malformed murderers but why didn’t they just go ahead and hang them so he could get his book done and become rich and famous as was his destiny? Why are they torturing me like this with their endless appeals and delays? I’m only human!

A MASTERPIECE

This is a great but strange book, a non fiction novel, I can see where that odd phrase came from, it veers between reportage and entirely novelistic recreations of some scenes with dialogue and characters and all, in this way it’s the exact literary version of the “re-enactments� they do on some true crime shows � I hate those, but in Truman’s hands it never comes across as tacky.

Not everyone was attentive; one juror, as though poisoned by the numerous spring-fever yawns weighting the air, sat with drugged eyes and jaws so utterly ajar bees could have buzzed in and out.

So good is TC in this book that it becomes a real shame that this book made him and destroyed him at the same time. He spent the next 20 years dithering, writing bits and pieces, but there was never another novel or much of anything after this one. Then he died.



IN COLDER BLOOD

Three movies :

In Cold Blood (1966) � the film of the book, really excellent

Capote (2005)
Infamous (2006)

Both these biopics concentrate on TC’s weird relationship with Perry Smith, both are worth it

And Gerald Clarke’s biography of TC is really excellent.
118 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read In Cold Blood.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 4, 2025 – Started Reading
February 4, 2025 – Shelved
February 8, 2025 – Shelved as: true-crime
February 8, 2025 – Shelved as: novels
February 8, 2025 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-12 of 12 (12 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Brad Lyerla I read IN COLD BLOOD a very long time ago. Your review brought it all back again very ably. Nice work.


Paul Bryant thanks Brad!


message 3: by Rikard (new)

Rikard Bergquist Great review, great novel.


Paul Bryant thanks Rikard !


message 5: by Amanda (new) - added it

Amanda Whitehouse Woo five stars ..On my list. I really liked the film infamous.


message 6: by Marta (new) - added it

Marta I started reading it a few years ago but I left it after a while. I think it was partly because I got a sense of intense dread from the beginning and I thought it would be a traumatic reading. Also, I was reading it on my Kindle, which only worsens those feelings because you have no real sense on where you are in the book. Your review makes me really want to pick it up again. Thank you!


Alison S ☯️ This was a 5 star read for me, and and all time favourite. It's the book that got me into reading non fiction, particularly "narrative non fiction". The only book that's come close is Helen Garner's This House of Grief, if you've read that?


Paul Bryant I did and gave it 4 stars, very powerful book

/review/show...

And thank you Marta!


Alison S ☯️ That one was also 5 stars for me. It was very powerful, but also pretty heartbreaking and harrowing.


Mark  Porton Great review, Paul. It's a very good book too!


message 11: by Randy (new)

Randy Rhody In Cold Blood and Helter Skelter are the scariest books I ever read. Couldn’t leave my apartment for days, fifty years ago.


message 12: by Paul (new) - rated it 5 stars

Paul Bryant thanks mark !

and yes, Helter Skelter is another true crime classic. There aren't too many true classics in this often dubious genre. Truman Capote was not followed by many others - Norman Mailer being an exception (The Executioner's Song - another great read).


back to top