ŷ

Trish's Reviews > Secret River

Secret River by Kate Grenville
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1826682
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: audio, australia, british, fiction, historical-novel

For years I’d wanted to have a go at this, and when Grenville was again nominated for an Australian Prime Minister’s Award for the third book in the trilogy (Sarah Thornhill) of which this novel is the first, I finally decided to begin at the beginning. This novel was a finalist for the Man Booker Prize in 2006, and won numerous other awards when it came out, for good reason. It is old-time storytelling, whose characters who begin life poor and grubby on the streets of London early in the nineteenth century, get “sent down� to Australia in a convict ship, earn their freedom, and scratch out an existence in that unholy land.

Grenville’s descriptions of early nineteenth century London evoke a world crammed with humanity living cheek-by-jowl on crooked cobbled streets, cold and grimy with coal dust. Grenville contrasts this with the dry heat of Australia, blazing with sun, and the wide open, unsettled (and unsettling) bigness of it. The Australian Aborigine is caught to perfection in her words…the thinness, the looseness of limbs, the blackness, the brows, the teeth, the joy, the dignity and fierceness. Her language is Dickensian, her story that of Australia.

Parts of this book are difficult to read, they seem so cruel. That man is a fearful and fearsome creature, we know. It is just painful to see ourselves through that glass so darkly reflected. I can hardly recommend this title enough. I have loved the writing of Kate Grenville forever, it seems. She has the potential for greatness, and while some of her books may not quite reach that level, this one does. I listened to this book on Blackstone Audio, narrated by the excellent Simon Vance.

For those who come away from this book with that breathless sense of needing to know how she did that, she has written a memoir about writing the novel called Searching For The Secret River: A Writing Memoir. I believe it took her as long to come down from writing it as it will take us to absorb it. I look forward to enjoying her skills again.
39 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Secret River.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

October 1, 2009 – Shelved
August 6, 2012 – Started Reading
August 6, 2012 – Shelved as: audio
August 6, 2012 – Shelved as: australia
August 6, 2012 – Shelved as: british
August 6, 2012 – Shelved as: fiction
August 6, 2012 – Shelved as: historical-novel
August 6, 2012 –
page 55
0% "Riveting. A modern classic."
August 7, 2012 –
page 155
0% "American readers, listen up! If you've never heard of Australian author Kate Grenville, know that she has created whole cloth with this first in a trilogy. This is fiction done the old way, full of gorgeous language and big characters with larger lives."
August 9, 2012 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-26 of 26 (26 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Kim (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kim I've loved reading a review written by someone who loves this novel as much as I do!


Trish Kim wrote: "I've loved reading a review written by someone who loves this novel as much as I do!"

She's a wonder, and deserves to be more widely read. It is strange, in this time of instant everything and ease of communication, that writers in English in Australia are still not as widely known in the USA as English speakers in countries as far-flung as India and Pakistan.


message 3: by Kim (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kim Trish wrote: "It is strange, in this time of instant everything and ease of communication, that writers in English in Australia are still not as widely known in the USA as English speakers in countries as far-flung as India and Pakistan. ..."

I agree, Trish. Mind you, I don't read as many Aussie novelists as I should. Are there others you like reading?


message 4: by Trish (last edited Apr 30, 2015 06:07AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Trish Kim wrote: " Are there others you like reading?..."

I really loved a debut novel by Rohan Wilson called The Roving Party and Foal's Bread by Gillian Mears. I've tried Patrick White so many times and just couldn't do it. Have another here, waiting: Journey to the Stone Country by Alex Miller. I see from the reviews that it is not for everyone. I look forward to a moment for it.

It is not always easy to get Australian books here--mostly they come to us via Canada. My brother, who lives in Sydney, BTW, is coming over this fall. What should I tell him to bring, do you think? Your favorites?


message 5: by Kim (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kim I'm with you on Patrick White, Trish. I read a couple of his novels many years ago when I was at university and I found them a slog.

I haven't read the novels you mention, although I've heard of "The Roving Party" and "Foals Bread". My favourite contemporary Australian novelists are probably Tim Winton and Thomas Keneally. I also like Christopher Koch and Richard Flanagan (athough he's pretty depressing!). Other writers I've read a bit of in the past are Janette Turner Hospital and Janette Turner Hospital. And I love Geraldine Brooks.

Of course, if you haven't read the two other books in "The Silent River" trilogy, The Lieutenant and Sarah Thornhill, they're both worth reading.


Trish Kim wrote: "And I love Geraldine Brooks. ..."

Geraldine Brooks is a national treasure. Have read much Tim Winton, Peter Carey, J.M.Coetzee and lots of others, but no Koch or Hospital, nor much Keneally. Flanagan I admire so, Look forward to trying his latest again soon. Every year I have a look at the Prime Minister's awards to see what's on offer.


Emma You might like Anna Funder's book All That I Am (sorry, I can't link on my phone). The Miles Franklin prize is another big one - it won it. I prefer Grenville though, and her memoir about writing The Secret River is really wonderful. Funder's book is set in Europe. I love Peter Carey but I can't get into Winton or Flanagan - though I will read the Narrow Road to the Deep North.


Emma I have heard good things about Joan London too. Not read her yet.


message 9: by Kim (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kim Oh yes, "All that I am" is excellent.

I think the reason I love Winton so much is that in some ways he reminds me of Steinbeck, whose writing I adore.


Trish Kim wrote: "I think the reason I love Winton so much is that in some ways he reminds me of Steinbeck, whose writing I adore."

Hmmm. Have to think about that. Interesting.


message 11: by Kim (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kim Trish wrote: "Hmmm. Have to think about that. Interesting."

They both have compassion for their characters, combine poetic imagery with vernacular speech and have a strong connection to the environment. I think that's sums up why Winton reminds me of Steinbeck. Both writers are fresh in my mind because over the last couple of years I've read all but one of Steinbeck's novels and all of Winton's adult novels, except for those I'd read previously.


message 12: by Kim (new) - rated it 5 stars

Kim Kim wrote: "I've read a bit of in the past are Janette Turner Hospital and Janette Turner Hospital...."

Duh! The second Janette Turner Hospital was supposed to be Thea Astley.


Trish Kim wrote: "Kim wrote: "I've read a bit of in the past are Janette Turner Hospital and Janette Turner Hospital...."

Duh! The second Janette Turner Hospital was supposed to be Thea Astley."


Ah. Okay.


Trish Kim wrote: "Kim wrote: "I've read a bit of in the past are Janette Turner Hospital and Janette Turner Hospital...."

Duh! The second Janette Turner Hospital was supposed to be Thea Astley."


Wow! Astely's list looks terrific! So strange I'd never heard of her. Look forward to finding a few.


message 15: by Karen (new) - added it

Karen Loved your review Trish! I too have had this book on my TBR list for a very long time. I didn't realize it was part of a trilogy. I will have to move this one up my TBR stack :)


Trish Karen wrote: "Loved your review Trish! I too have had this book on my TBR list for a very long time. I didn't realize it was part of a trilogy. I will have to move this one up my TBR stack :)"

You won't be disappointed. It's marvelous. I corrected something in the body of the review so it came up again in my list. I read it awhile ago, but it is always nice to revisit the Australians.


message 17: by Starlight (new)

Starlight  gold Great review


message 18: by Betsy (new) - added it

Betsy Robinson Wonderful review. I'm trying NOT to add to my "to read" list because I'm actually trying to read the books on the list, but you've seduced me.


Trish Betsy wrote: "Wonderful review. I'm trying NOT to add to my "to read" list because I'm actually trying to read the books on the list, but you've seduced me."

I know about 'to read' lists, Betsy, believe me, but you know, some books you won't be interested in reading in a couple of months. This one is not one of the those.


message 20: by L (new) - rated it 3 stars

L F A poetic review. Enjoyed your prospective.


Trish L wrote: "A poetic review. Enjoyed your prospective."

Thanks, L. You didn't appear to like it as well as I, but Grenville's writing inspired any poetry in mine.


message 22: by Krista (new)

Krista I read this pre-ŷ, and while I do remember having loved it, what sticks out in my mind is how tough kangaroo meat is, even after a slow roast over low coals. (That was this book, right?) I'd totally read that memoir.


Trish Krista wrote: "I read this pre-ŷ, and while I do remember having loved it, what sticks out in my mind is how tough kangaroo meat is, even after a slow roast over low coals. (That was this book, right?) I'..."

Are you saying she talks about eating kangaroo meat or you have tried it? All that jumping...and they basically eat grass...I guess if one kept them penned & unable to move they'd get fat...ugh. Don't remember that bit. Yes, the memoir would be great. You make me want to plan a trip with GR friends to Australia...


message 24: by Krista (new)

Krista I haven't tried it, no, don't eat mammals, but I remember something about that main couple nearly starving because they couldn't make a kangaroo tail tender enough to eat (pure muscle, all that jumping) until some Aborigines came out of the gumtrees and showed them how. Something like that?
Australia, Ho!


Trish Ha!


message 26: by Jonathan (new)

Jonathan Bennett An excellent book and although I read it some years ago, I will always remember this compelling story.


back to top