ŷ

Kelly (and the Book Boar)'s Reviews > More or Less Maddy

More or Less Maddy by Lisa Genova
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
11183856
's review

it was ok
bookshelves: tragiporn, super-meh, read-in-2025, liburrrrrry-book

I always thought I would be a one and done with Lisa Genova because she clearly gets off on writing tragiporn novels centered around terminal or chronic illnesses. Like billions of others I read Still Alice, but then The O’Briens was once again about some sad debilitating disease with no hope so I was officially out. Never say never, though, because maybe a story about a young woman being diagnosed with bipolar disease might be up my alley and I thought I'd give it a go.

I thought I would quite possibly dig this one, but it pretty much lost me right away at the somehow weirdly recently overused "main character who wants to be a comedian." Dear Authors: Stop making unfunny characters have comedic aspirations. How did that even become such an overused career goal in books recently? If you’re going to make these characters be aspiring comics, they have to be FUNNY. Comedy isn’t just writing jokes and memorizing them - it’s people who are naturally hilarious. No one would want to sit through this chick’s ranty Ted Talk comedy special. And if the bizarre zero dollar an hour career choice wasn't odd enough, then the additional manic episodes featuring Taylor Swift related imaginings just put it over the edge. Then there’s the problem of Maddy having little to no developed personality outside of her illness and what glimpses we did get being so unlikeable and first world with a great support system (and great insurance to boot). So unrelatable.

This was as easy read, but I didn't think it was very good.
20 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read More or Less Maddy.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 15, 2025 – Started Reading
February 15, 2025 – Shelved
March 6, 2025 – Shelved as: tragiporn
March 6, 2025 – Shelved as: super-meh
March 6, 2025 – Shelved as: read-in-2025
March 6, 2025 – Shelved as: liburrrrrry-book
March 6, 2025 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-5 of 5 (5 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Marialyce Sad that your compassion level is so low


Kelly (and the Book Boar) Seriously? Because I choose not to read bleak novels in my free time or found this particular FICTIONAL character unlikeable? Good grief.


JanB I’m often on outlier island so I get not enjoying a book. We like what we like, right?

But I do think the author’s motivations are honorable. I don’t think she gets off on “tragiporn�. As a neuroscientist she really wants to shed light on little understood diseases.

I personally know a young man who had access to the best of care but he still lost his life to this horrible illness. I had a front row seat to the devastation, so this story is special to me. But it’s not for everyone. I hope you love your next read!


message 4: by Kelly (and the Book Boar) (last edited Mar 12, 2025 06:01AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Kelly (and the Book Boar) I'll admit "gets off" was probably not the correct way of phrasing things - we all have days where the words just come out as they are. I still wish Maddy would have been more than her illness, but she wasn't so my rating reflects that - and 2 Stars means "it was okay" so users like the the one above who want to make judgment calls on my compassion levels will simply be blocked from ever having to interact with me again. That's the one thing I can do for MY mental health.

(And I 100% stand by not understanding the flush of main characters being comedians that is happening lately. Was it because Romantic Comedy was such a hit so everyone hopped that bandwagon???? I don't know.)


JanB Interesting. I did not read Romantic Comedy so I didn’t know this was a thing. It’s certainly an interesting career choice! Not my favorite part of the book but I thought the author chose it as a career as unconventional as Maddy was. Who knows?

We all have a right to our opinion, I’ve certainly been there where I was annoyed at a book/author!


back to top