Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Robin's Reviews > In Our Time

In Our Time by Ernest Hemingway
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
36555254
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: 2025, american, literary-fiction, short-stories, literature, debut

The idea of my reviewing this collection of stories, which are classic and experimental and incalculably influential, is a bit silly.

Nothing I can possibly say will be new, or illuminating, so I won't even try, on that score. What I'll say is wow - some of these stories still hold up beautifully today, still hold an immense power.

This is the author's first collection, published in 1925, and came before his novels, and before his fame, so there is no overtly masculine posturing here. What I felt was a post war wounding, and the "iceberg theory" that is used to describe his writing. So much under the surface, much unsaid, and in a style that rejects the 19th century writers that came before him.

I read 'Indian Camp' through twice, and was brought to tears both times. I dare you to get through it dry-eyed. 'A Very Short Story' sounds like something that happened countless times to young people at the end of the war, with a decidedly unromantic return to reality. 'Big Two-Hearted River' - a vision of a soldier returned home, finding healing in nature (but none of that actually stated, buried deep under the almost plot-less images).

Certain stories feel wholly relevant, while others seem dated. This is something to see, though, it's a big part of what brought literature to where it is today.

(Besides the one about the soldier who begs Christ to help him survive, and who makes desperate promises, I could have done without the little vignettes between each story, I have to admit. Particularly the ones involving bulls and matadors. As soon as bullfighting is a thing on the page, I fall asleep. Why so much bullfighting, Ernest Hemingway? WHY?)
41 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read In Our Time.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 3, 2025 – Started Reading
March 3, 2025 – Shelved
March 9, 2025 –
page 45
25.57% "Just read "Indian Camp" for the 2nd time, both times brought me to tears."
March 10, 2025 –
page 117
66.48%
March 16, 2025 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-13 of 13 (13 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Diane (new) - added it

Diane Barnes I'm not a Hemingway fan, but anything written before the "masculine posturing" might be okay. Did you ever read about the challenge he gave a few people at a table with him? It was to write a complete short story in 6 words. His was: " Baby shoes for sale. Never used." He won.


Dave Was reading this book on an unairconditionsd el train to its stop on Howard Street. i was so transported to a cool river upper Michigan that a conductor had to nudge me to get off the train.


message 3: by Bonnie G. (new)

Bonnie G. I love this review, and mostly love Hemingway despite the macho. These early stories are my favorites. I think in part because I recognize my fellow Michigander who sees the beauty but longs to get out of the mitten, but more because it is like nothing that came before and he was a just a moment past being a child and he still got so much right.


Robin Diane wrote: "I'm not a Hemingway fan, but anything written before the "masculine posturing" might be okay. Did you ever read about the challenge he gave a few people at a table with him? It was to write a complete short story in 6 words. His was: " Baby shoes for sale. Never used." He won."

Diane, thanks so much for sharing this story with me - I don't think I'd heard it before! He's definitely the person I'd expect to win such a contest. Thinking on it, I think it's actually brave to write (or under-write) the way he did. There's this pressure a writer can feel, to make sure the reader understands everything, and I think it can be a mistake to explain it. Hemingway definitely doesn't make that mistake.

I think this might be a collection you could appreciate. My macho-radar didn't go off, not once, although, as I said, the bullfighting vignettes were tiresome -- but easily skipped over. :)


Robin Dave wrote: "Was reading this book on an unairconditionsd el train to its stop on Howard Street. i was so transported to a cool river upper Michigan that a conductor had to nudge me to get off the train."

Your reading experience really speaks to the powerful nature of these stories, Dave! I love hearing that.


Robin Bonnie G. wrote: "I love this review, and mostly love Hemingway despite the macho. These early stories are my favorites. I think in part because I recognize my fellow Michigander who sees the beauty but longs to get out of the mitten, but more because it is like nothing that came before and he was a just a moment past being a child and he still got so much right."

Thanks so much, Bonnie. It's been many years since I'd read Hemingway (I should mark The Old Man and the Sea for a re-read), so it was great to re-visit his work. It's at once of a time, and also timeless - or even modern - in style, if not subject matter.

You put it so well when you point out that he was so young and yet got so much right. I'm smitten anew by what he was able to capture. Sort of like Philip Roth, who was a baby adult when he penned the brilliant Goodbye Columbus. I am amazed by what these young authors accomplished... I was such a dimwit at the same age!


message 7: by Lorna (new) - added it

Lorna Lovely review, Robin. I’m happy that this is on my list as I am a big fan of Ernest Hemingway’s writing.


Laysee This is a helpful review, Robin. I like knowing that these stories written long ago are still relevant today. Like you, I will fall asleep when I read about bull-fighting. :-)


message 9: by Javier (new)

Javier Fernandez After watching my St. Louis Cardinals get spanked 11-5 in their game against the Miami Marlins yesterday, I could use a good cry. "Indian Camp" sounds like just the spark I need to release all my pent up sadness. I own a copy of Hemingway's Complete Short Stories, but unfortunately I'm on the road. I should probably also take a double dose as soon as I get back to home camp, Robin. It might be just what the medicine man ordered.


Robin Lorna wrote: "Lovely review, Robin. I’m happy that this is on my list as I am a big fan of Ernest Hemingway’s writing."

Thank you Lorna! Hope you enjoy and appreciate it as I did!


Robin Laysee wrote: "This is a helpful review, Robin. I like knowing that these stories written long ago are still relevant today. Like you, I will fall asleep when I read about bull-fighting. :-)"

I see you weren't a big fan of this collection Laysee! Maybe the bull-fighting tipped the scales? :) Thanks so much for your comment, it's always so nice to see you here.


Robin Javier wrote: "After watching my St. Louis Cardinals get spanked 11-5 in their game against the Miami Marlins yesterday, I could use a good cry. "Indian Camp" sounds like just the spark I need to release all my pent up sadness. I own a copy of Hemingway's Complete Short Stories, but unfortunately I'm on the road. I should probably also take a double dose as soon as I get back to home camp, Robin. It might be just what the medicine man ordered."

Sorry to hear about the Cardinals, Javier! Yes, let it out, read 'Indian Camp'. If you end up reading him, let me know what you think!


message 13: by Javier (new)

Javier Fernandez Will do, Robin! It's obvious I need to get to this sooner rather than later!


back to top