Giedre's Reviews > The Moor's Last Sigh
The Moor's Last Sigh
by
by

Giedre's review
bookshelves: indian, magic-realism, historical-fiction, british, liked-but-couldn-t-love, booker-shortlist, 20th-century, 1990s
Oct 11, 2013
bookshelves: indian, magic-realism, historical-fiction, british, liked-but-couldn-t-love, booker-shortlist, 20th-century, 1990s
I admit that I had already given The Moor‘s Last Sigh by Salman Rushdie a couple of unsuccessful tries before I finally challenged myself to reading it in one go a couple of weeks ago. It seemed just the right time to plunge into something by Rushdie after I unexpectedly met him at a conference he was giving in Madrid as part of the World Book Day celebration.
And yes, it was a big challenge. If one can love and hate a book at the same time, admire and despise it, crave for more and wish to finish it immediately, then I experienced it as well while turning the pages of The Moor‘s Last Sigh. I couldn‘t but admire Rushdie‘s genius, his boundless imagination and his capacity to interweave the lives of the characters of the book and the historical facts into one single fabric full of new colors. And at the same time I hated the slowness of the plot, which became even slower mixed with my incapacity to read Rusdhie‘s ornate language faster.
I loved how the author‘s experienced hand mixed classes, religions, ethnic groups, politics, business, crime and art. And I pitied my lack of knowledge of the historical and political context, which made me miss a lot of allusions and connotations that would have made more sense for somebody living in India.
I was tired of long sentences. And I relished the poetry of the language.
I chose to quote one single sentence, which resumes everything I tried to say in this review, and everything I was not able to express:
“And if the flies buzzed in through the opened netting-windows, and the naughty gusts through the parted panes of leaded glass, then opening of the shutters let in everything else: the dust and the tumult of boats in Cochin harbour, the horns of freighters and tugboat chugs, the fishermen’s dirty jokes and the throb of their jellyfish stings, the sunlight as sharp as a knife, the heat that could choke you like a damp cloth pulled tightly around your head, the calls of floating hawkers, the wafting sadness of the unmarried Jews across the water in Mattancherri, the menace of emerald smugglers, the machinations of business rivals, the growing nervousness of the British colony in Fort Cochin, the cash demands of the staff and of the plantation workers in the Spice Mountains, the tales of Communist troublemaking and Congresswallah politics, the names Gandhi and Nehru, the rumours of famine in the east and hunger strikes in the north, the songs and drum-beats of the oral storytellers, and the heavy rolling sound (as they broke against Cabral Island’s rickety jetty) of the incoming tides of history.�
Give it a try. Or a few. You’ll love it or you’ll hate it. Or both.
Oh, and if you are not sure what a palimpsest is, this book will teach you everything you need to know about it, I promise.
And yes, it was a big challenge. If one can love and hate a book at the same time, admire and despise it, crave for more and wish to finish it immediately, then I experienced it as well while turning the pages of The Moor‘s Last Sigh. I couldn‘t but admire Rushdie‘s genius, his boundless imagination and his capacity to interweave the lives of the characters of the book and the historical facts into one single fabric full of new colors. And at the same time I hated the slowness of the plot, which became even slower mixed with my incapacity to read Rusdhie‘s ornate language faster.
I loved how the author‘s experienced hand mixed classes, religions, ethnic groups, politics, business, crime and art. And I pitied my lack of knowledge of the historical and political context, which made me miss a lot of allusions and connotations that would have made more sense for somebody living in India.
I was tired of long sentences. And I relished the poetry of the language.
I chose to quote one single sentence, which resumes everything I tried to say in this review, and everything I was not able to express:
“And if the flies buzzed in through the opened netting-windows, and the naughty gusts through the parted panes of leaded glass, then opening of the shutters let in everything else: the dust and the tumult of boats in Cochin harbour, the horns of freighters and tugboat chugs, the fishermen’s dirty jokes and the throb of their jellyfish stings, the sunlight as sharp as a knife, the heat that could choke you like a damp cloth pulled tightly around your head, the calls of floating hawkers, the wafting sadness of the unmarried Jews across the water in Mattancherri, the menace of emerald smugglers, the machinations of business rivals, the growing nervousness of the British colony in Fort Cochin, the cash demands of the staff and of the plantation workers in the Spice Mountains, the tales of Communist troublemaking and Congresswallah politics, the names Gandhi and Nehru, the rumours of famine in the east and hunger strikes in the north, the songs and drum-beats of the oral storytellers, and the heavy rolling sound (as they broke against Cabral Island’s rickety jetty) of the incoming tides of history.�
Give it a try. Or a few. You’ll love it or you’ll hate it. Or both.
Oh, and if you are not sure what a palimpsest is, this book will teach you everything you need to know about it, I promise.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
The Moor's Last Sigh.
Sign In »
Quotes Giedre Liked

“Yes, I know there is a fashion nowadays for these Hitler's-valet type memoirs, and many people are against, they say we should not humanise the inhuman. But the point is they are not inhuman, these Mainduck-style little Hitlers, and it is in their humanity that we must locate our collective guilt, humanity's guilt for human beings' misdeeds; for if they are just monsters - if it is just a question of King Kong and Godzilla wreaking havoc until the aeroplanes bring them down - then the rest of us are excused.”
― The Moor's Last Sigh
― The Moor's Last Sigh
Reading Progress
October 11, 2013
– Shelved as:
to-read
October 11, 2013
– Shelved
November 16, 2013
–
Started Reading
November 24, 2013
– Shelved as:
indian
April 27, 2014
– Shelved as:
magic-realism
April 27, 2014
– Shelved as:
historical-fiction
April 27, 2014
– Shelved as:
british
April 28, 2014
–
12.21%
""Still, it is easier to breathe in than out. As it is easier to absorb what life offers than to give out the results of such absorption. As it is easier to take a blow than to hit back.""
page
53
May 4, 2014
–
31.34%
""When I was young <...> I used to dream of peeling of my skin plantain-fashion, of going forth naked into the world, like an anatomy illustration from Encyclopaedia Britannica, all ganglions, ligaments, nervous pathways and veins, set free from the otherwise inescapable jails of colour, race and clan.""
page
136
May 11, 2014
–
76.5%
""Corruption was the only force we had that could defeat fanaticism.""
page
332
May 11, 2014
–
98.62%
""There is in us, in all of us, some measure of brightness, of possibility. We start with that, but also with its dar counter-force, and the two of them spend our lives slugging it out , and if we're lucky the fight comes out even.""
page
428
May 11, 2014
–
Finished Reading
July 5, 2014
– Shelved as:
liked-but-couldn-t-love
January 10, 2015
– Shelved as:
booker-shortlist
September 27, 2015
– Shelved as:
20th-century
September 27, 2015
– Shelved as:
1990s
Comments Showing 1-9 of 9 (9 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Dolors
(last edited May 13, 2014 02:29AM)
(new)
May 13, 2014 02:28AM

reply
|
flag


Thank you so much for visiting and reading this review, Cheryl! I am very glad to hear that you are interested in reading the book and would love to hear your thoughts about it! Your constand support is very encouraging, thank you for that!

That's an incredibly generous comment, Bill! Thank you so much for such an encouragement!


Jareed, I am very honoured to read that you are willing to give this book a try! Thank you for such a generous compliment as well! Will be really looking forward to your own thoughts when you get to reading it.

Perfect. And what a fantastic review. You should definitely write more.

Thank you so much, Garima! I feel really flattered to receive such an encouraging comment from you.