ŷ

✨Jܱ�'s Reviews > The Rose Bargain

The Rose Bargain by Sasha Peyton Smith
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
15367905
's review

liked it

� 3 stars �

What to Expect:
� Faerie Bargains
� Forbidden Love
� Marriage Competition
� Dangerous Trials
� Kissing for Practice
� Love Triangle
� Only One Bed
� Alternate History (1848 England)
� Immortal Fae Queen ruling England
� Unexpected Twists
� First Person Multi POV

This is a stunning book (I own the Fairyloot edition) that had a very intriguing premise that unfortunately I won’t be recommending.

The author had me hooked at the beginning but from there my interest started to wane. I struggled to connect with the FMC (Ivy) and I couldn’t muster up much interest for either MMC. (Also hate a love triangle. 🙄) The trials the girls faced should have been the main focus, but most of them felt very rushed and lacked originality. The book was written in First Person Multi POV which did set the book apart a bit, but I think there were some missed opportunities to add more subterfuge between the girls. In a way it was kind of nice that the girls were mostly kind and supportive of each other, but it seemed unrealistic to me since they were in competition and the consequences of failure were steep.

With so much hanging in the balance, it was disappointing that so much of Ivy’s focus seemed to repeatedly return to the past love interests of one of the Princes. My biggest issue however was that the author included an explicit scene in a book that is marketed as YA - a genre that is marketed to children as young as 12. I really don’t understand why this scene wasn’t removed or at least rewritten to be more fade to black when the book was edited.

I am on the fence on whether or not I will read book two. There was a pretty major twist at the end that could take the series in an interesting direction, but at this point I feel pretty indifferent about continuing. I’m bummed that I didn’t love this more, especially considering how gorgeous my Fairyloot SE is! Oh well, it will still look pretty on my shelf. 🌸

✼  ҉  ✼  ҉  ✼  ҉  ✼  ҉  ✼  ҉  ✼  ҉  �

Pre-read: A society where all citizens are expected to make a Fae bargain? What could go wrong? 🙃

� � � � �

Connect with me on
124 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Rose Bargain.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 12, 2025 – Started Reading
March 12, 2025 – Shelved
March 25, 2025 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 51 (51 new)


ᖰhᖱeɭ Ooh, this sounds very interesting...hope you enjoyyyy!!


✨Jܱ✨ @Phidelia I think it’ll be a good one!


message 3: by naz (new)

naz i seen this everywhere!!! happy reading bestie 💗


message 4: by Jackie (new) - added it

Jackie Stone I'M SO EXCITED TO FINALLY START MINE. I NEED THIS TO BE AMAZING


message 5: by Anna jane (new) - added it

Anna jane Happy reading yes what could go wrong totally not getting tricked but this on my hold only because I borrowed to many books on libby so now it's on my hold because all of my loans are full so no I have to fight libby to keep it in the loan shelf until I finished some of my loans so I can grap I hate being a slow reader sometimes but the library did not take months to require it so that good atleast it but the cover is so gorgeous


message 6: by Madi (new)

Madi happy reading bb!! 🩷


Uswah HAPPIEST READING LOVELYYY� IT’S SOOO INTERESTING 🎀🎀🤭


message 8: by Anila (new) - added it

Anila Happy reading💜


message 9: by ଘRǰ (new)

ଘRǰ It sounds interesting !!


message 10: by cherie ^_-� (new)

cherie ^_-★ happy reading julie! 💖


message 11: by Hoda (new)

Hoda Happy reading love🤍


✨Jܱ✨ @naz me too! Just received the Fairyloot copy too! Enjoying it!


✨Jܱ✨ @Jackie RIGHT?!


✨Jܱ✨ @annajane totally get it! Libby always comes through when extra copies when you need it the least lol


✨Jܱ✨ @madi thanks girl!


✨Jܱ✨ @uswah I’m seeing that! 👀


✨Jܱ✨ @anila thank you beautiful! 💗


✨Jܱ✨ @rory you should check it out! I’m enjoying it!


✨Jܱ✨ @cherie thanks bestie! 🫶🏻


✨Jܱ✨ @hoda 💗💗💗


message 21: by kitkat (new)

kitkat happy reading bestie!! 💖


✨Jܱ✨ @kitkat thank you bb 🫶🏻


message 23: by Esta (new)

Esta I need to know if this is good bestie and I trust you! Happy reading 💛


✨Jܱ✨ @ Esta Probably won't be my favorite, but it's pretty good for the YA genre!


message 25: by sonia (new)

sonia excited to hear what you think!! enjoy ml <3


message 26: by nina ʚïɞ (new)

nina ʚïɞ enjoy bb!! 🌷


message 27: by anh (new)

anh Happy reading 💓


rei ‧₊˚✩彡 hope you enjoy pretty 🥰🫶🏼


message 29: by maria (new)

maria Happy reading love!!!💓


✨Jܱ✨ @sonia thank you lovely!


✨Jܱ✨ @nina thank you beautiful! 🫶🏻


✨Jܱ✨ @anh thank you ml 💗


✨Jܱ✨ @rei 💗💗💗


Fairuz ᥫ᭡. That sounds like a super intriguing premise! 💖 Hope you’re enjoying it so far! 📚�


✨Jܱ✨ @fairuz 💗💗


fadheela ♡ (catching up) happy reading loveee!!!😍💖


✨Jܱ✨ @fadheela thank you beautiful!


message 38: by Fiza (new)

Fiza Sorry it didn't hit fully, hope your next read is sm better!! 💗


✨Jܱ✨ @fiza thank you! Currently reading Quicksilver and it’s definitely hitting!


Uswah aww� stunning review sweetheart 💖💖💖 but hoping your next read is sm better 🫂


✨Jܱ✨ @uswah thank you ml 🫶🏻


message 42: by Emma.catherine (new)

Emma.catherine Great review lovely 😻 I hope your next read is better 💖


message 43: by Anna jane (new) - added it

Anna jane I hope your next read is better


✨Jܱ✨ @emma.catherine thanks you beautiful! 🫶🏻


✨Jܱ✨ @annajane thank you ml ❤️


April (catching up) Sorry it didn't work 😔 at least it's pretty! Hope you next read is better love 💗


•°Dahlia °•  ( semi-hiatus ) Happy u enjoyed babes ♥︎


kendyl ʚ♡⃛ɞ gorgeous review!!!


✨Jܱ✨ @April thanks love! 🫶🏻


✨Jܱ✨ @dahlia 💗💗


« previous 1
back to top