ŷ

Jen �'s Reviews > Matteo

Matteo by Eva Winners
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
21567815
** spoiler alert ** I'm sure this will be great for someone else, it's just not my thing and that's totally fine.

It was a little chaotic and kind of all over the place. There are just so many people to keep track of, and honestly, it took me a bit to figure out who's who.

Then, a lot of the choices and actions by the characters (not just the MCs) were pretty frustrating and just didn't make sense to me.

Lastly, this is definitely not the dual virgin I had in mind. I was looking forward to reading this book, and given my familiarity with this author, I know she has dual V in her stories. But this was not it. 🙅‍♀�

Matteo (25) was supposed to be obsessed with Arianna (25) since they were eight. Yet, at the 41% mark he dropped this freaking line:

“I’ve f*cked zero women...I would never hurt you by lying to you. I’m not saying I’m a saint and never experimented, but I’m saying I saved myself for you.�

This experimenting wasn't clearly explained, and it really left a bad taste. What do you mean you experimented but saved yourself for her??? 🥴 Before that annoying line, I was genuinely swooning over his possessiveness with Ari. I mean, who wouldn't want a man who's been so in love with you since childhood? But after that remark, his possessiveness made me want to throw my Kindle against the nearest wall. 😤

His audacity and hypocrisy in getting territorial over Ari was so annoying it's not even funny. After all the years they've known each other, he made every possible threat to all the guys who showed interest in her, and yet apparently he still found time to "experiment." Like, make it make sense. 🤦‍♀️�

“Baby, I’ve been chasing away every male for almost two decades. Do you really think I’d let any woman touch me now that you’re mine?�

I really wish this was explained clearly because leaving it open to interpretation is not going to work for me. I tend to jump to the worst conclusions (probably a me issue), so in my mind, this suggests he likely engaged in other activities with other girls, except for the actual penetration, which seems to be the only thing he's reserving for her. 🤷‍♀�

But then he also said this:

“Yeah, but did you protect what’s mine? Did you refrain yourself from being with other women?� He remained quiet, giving me my answer. “So typical of a man to be a hypocrite. How many women have you been with?� He watched me with a burning gaze. “Zero.�

So, idk anymore. 🥴 It's possible he experimented on his own, but who really knows? I can't help but think his lines were contradictory, but maybe it's just me and my need for a straightforward explanation. Anyway, do what you what with that info.


Book info:
- College romance
- Childhood friends to lovers
- Sister's fiance
- Forced marriage
- Stalking
- Gun pointing
- Kidnapping (past and present)
- Organ trafficking
- Substance abuse
- Violence, gore, death
- Dual V (but he experimented with OW) 🤮😡
- No cheating, OM/OW
- With separation (weeks)
- HEA (18 mos later, married w/ newborn son)


Notes:
- OW. But not really. Ari's sister, Hannah, has always claimed she wanted to marry Matteo since they were kids, but he never really felt the same way about her and has always been more interested in Ari instead. When Matteo said he wanted to marry one of Nico's daughters, everyone just figured he meant Hannah. So, their parents set up the engagement announcement and decided to do it at a party. And he was totally taken aback when they announced the wrong twin but he vowed to make things right. Also, Hannah was interested in someone else and only using Matteo to make the guy jealous.
- When Matteo eventually caught up with Ari's whereabouts, he cornered her in her hotel room to knock some sense into her and get her to go with him. But when she didn't agree, he got pissed and pulled a gun on her. It was blank, but still. This might be triggering for some readers. When she still wouldn't budge, he injected her with a tranquilizer and then kidnapped her. 🫣
48 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Matteo.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 30, 2025 – Started Reading
March 30, 2025 – Shelved
March 30, 2025 –
41.0% "This is how you ruin a dual V. Wanted her since she was eight, my ass. 🙄😒

“It’s the honest-to-God truth. I’ve fucked zero women. I’ve only ever fantasized about you. I’ve only ever wanted you. So I’ve waited until you were ready for me.� I scoffed, and he continued, “I would never hurt you by lying to you. I’m not saying I’m a saint and never experimented, but I’m saying I saved myself for you.�"
March 30, 2025 – Finished Reading
March 31, 2025 – Shelved as: dual-virgin
March 31, 2025 – Shelved as: 2025-reads
March 31, 2025 – Shelved as: part-of-series
March 31, 2025 – Shelved as: no-op-drama
March 31, 2025 – Shelved as: no-cheating
March 31, 2025 – Shelved as: friends-to-lovers
March 31, 2025 – Shelved as: standalone
March 31, 2025 – Shelved as: spicy-book
March 31, 2025 – Shelved as: smutfest
March 31, 2025 – Shelved as: tw-included

Comments Showing 1-30 of 30 (30 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Eunoia (new)

Eunoia ugh come on. hate these stuff on stories with dual v or v mmc. we almost never have this freaking complication when it is in the case of FEMALE charas, it would almost always she is a never been kissed virgin meanwhile, this is how lots of authors write so called v mmc, confusing, indirect statement like they want us to guess, or they will write experienced virgins. can't they just make up their damn mind if they will write a v mmc or not, if this is how upsetting it is, it would be better if author will write this as a non v mmc, in that case, we won't be that frustrated lol Sad, the double standards won't go away anytime soon.

As always, awesome review, Jen! hope our next read with a v mmc would be better. ༎ຶ⁠‿⁠༎ຶ


cajareads It’s always the double standard that is killing the mood in the story 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀� He’s likely done everything else with other women except for actual penetration sex which is so icky and so annoying because I actually do like him a lot


Jen ♥ Eunoia wrote: "ugh come on. hate these stuff on stories with dual v or v mmc. we almost never have this freaking complication when it is in the case of FEMALE charas, it would almost always she is a never been ki..."

I totally get that, and that's my beef with V MMCs, too. When it comes to women, everyone knows she’s never been touched, kissed, or messed around with. But when it comes to men, the situation is often unclear and confusing. Sometimes they’ve done just about everything except the actual penetration. 🤧 I sooo agree that it was really frustrating, because that's how I felt with this one. And I'm not joking when I say that my interest went from 100 to 0 in no time.

Thanks, Eunoia! 💗 I seriously hope our next read with this kind of MMC turns out to be better. 🤞


Jen ♥ cajareads wrote: "It’s always the double standard that is killing the mood in the story 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀� He’s likely done everything else with other women except for actual penetration sex which is so icky and so annoying..."

The ambiguity is driving me crazy; did he or didn't he get involved with other women? Why does he have to say that ridiculous line? Ugh. If he truly loved her, why can't he just wait and figure things out together with her?🤦‍♀�

I liked him too in the beginning, but after reading that part, my appreciation vanished instantly. 🫠


dee🧚🏽 My same issue honestly like he kept saying he was obsessed with her and whatever but I just didn’t buy it 😭 and there were too many characters I felt lost omg .
Anyways great review hon💗💗


message 6: by Aleksandra (new)

Aleksandra Ugh and we can’t even be sure if he done sth with ow or not because what he says in the quotes is kind of contradictory?? I’d assume he did some things with ow but then he says zero women, and it’s getting confusing 🫤 anyway, great review Jen!!


Jen ♥ dee🧚🏽 wrote: "My same issue honestly like he kept saying he was obsessed with her and whatever but I just didn’t buy it 😭 and there were too many characters I felt lost omg .
Anyways great review hon💗💗"


I agree with the characters. I need a freaking family tree to know who's who. As for his obsession, I fell and bought it at the start, but after his stupid line, I couldn't believe it anymore. And the "experimenting" annoyed TF out of me and gave me the ick. 😤


Jen ♥ Aleksandra wrote: "Ugh and we can’t even be sure if he done sth with ow or not because what he says in the quotes is kind of contradictory?? I’d assume he did some things with ow but then he says zero women, and it’s..."

Exactly. Now, Idk what to believe anymore. But imo, I think he did mess with OW, but maybe it doesn't count for him because there's no actual penetration. But then again, who knows? I guess it's up to the readers to interpret that line and convo. 😑


message 9: by Alina (new) - added it

Alina Hi Gross


Jen ♥ Alina wrote: "Gross"

he kinda is 🫠


message 11: by Alina (new) - added it

Alina Hi So i asked the author and this is what she said
" He saved himself for Arianna however he did experiment in other areas with other women "


message 12: by Jen � (last edited Apr 01, 2025 04:12AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Jen ♥ Alina wrote: "So i asked the author and this is what she said
" He saved himself for Arianna however he did experiment in other areas with other women ""


Welp, that's disgusting. I think he got all of her firsts while she got the crumbs from other women. That's not how it was supposed to work. Obsessed, my ass. Now it's even more icky and gross. 🤮🤮🤮


message 13: by LaBlue (new)

LaBlue Zero women implies, solo, toys or men. lol.


message 14: by LaBlue (new)

LaBlue Other women went to zero women. Pick a lane author. lol.


Jen ♥ LaBlue wrote: "Zero women implies, solo, toys or men. lol."

LaBlue wrote: "Other women went to zero women. Pick a lane author. lol."

Experimenting probably doesn't count. Which is ridiculous, btw! He still got involved with others, when he was supposed to be in love with the FMC. 🤮


Nancy (Exam Hiatus) Zelman okay but the 'he remained quiet' is damning


Jen ♥ Nancy (Exam Hiatus) wrote: "okay but the 'he remained quiet' is damning"

I think this is the confirmation that he didn't refrain himself. 🤮🤮


cajareads Like seriously and a damn genuine question as well; why is it so hard for them to write a true virgin hero????? Are they afraid readers would think of him of less of a man because he’s inexperienced?! This ended up reeks of double standard since from the start he knew he was going to marry her and chased away all her boyfriends. So annoying. The more I learned about his fake ass virginity the more I am upset. He was so damn perfect in other areas, so obsessed and possessive but I guess not obsessed enough then 🥱🥱 not sure if I want to change my rating or not because I genuinely enjoyed reading about the other characters and the mafia stuffs in this book 😪


Jen ♥ cajareads wrote: "Like seriously and a damn genuine question as well; why is it so hard for them to write a true virgin hero????? Are they afraid readers would think of him of less of a man because he’s inexperience..."

I knooow, this kind of setup ruins the whole idea of dual virgins. We don't need a non-virgin virgin MMC. 😤 I loved his possessiveness and obsession too in the beginning, but after dropping that bomb? There's no way I'm believing anything he says. This guy isn't freaking faithful. Because, wdym you know she's the one and still got involved with others? Wtf is wrong with you? Isn't that cheating? I promised I wouldn't give a rating, but the author's confirmation pissed me off. So I changed my mind. 🤷‍♀�


message 20: by Eunoia (new)

Eunoia and him being obsessed with the fmc is not convincing anymore bc wdym, he is so obsessed with her but then was able to do things with other women like it doesn't make any sense. also he double standards here is fr disgusting, he is mad, and jealous when the fmc gets involved with other men but he cannot keep his d in his pants. gross. Tbh, an experienced and celibate mmc would be better than this experienced virgin ones. At least, in a lot of instances, those mmcs from the moment they saw their fmcs, they only had eyes for their women and remained faithful all throughout the book


message 21: by Eunoia (new)

Eunoia I would never consider these experienced v, virgin in my book/ reading list hahaha. It is sooooo difficult to find a quality dual v book in these times of day. Sometimes, there are good ass never been kissed dual v but storyline and writing sucks and the other times, good writing, quality plot and storyline but these stuff happens. UGH


message 22: by Alina (new) - added it

Alina Hi Eunoia wrote: "and him being obsessed with the fmc is not convincing anymore bc wdym, he is so obsessed with her but then was able to do things with other women like it doesn't make any sense. also he double stan..."

Exactly after knowing he touched and was touched by other women and did stuff with them, nothing can convince me of his true obsession and feelings for the fmc anymore, he just wants her as a possession period.


message 23: by Koryne (new)

Koryne lololol “saving himself for her HOWEVER…� yeah no thank you on that 😂


Jen ♥ Eunoia wrote: "and him being obsessed with the fmc is not convincing anymore bc wdym, he is so obsessed with her but then was able to do things with other women like it doesn't make any sense. also he double stan..."

Alina wrote: "Eunoia wrote: "and him being obsessed with the fmc is not convincing anymore bc wdym, he is so obsessed with her but then was able to do things with other women like it doesn't make any sense. also..."

@Eunoia. So true, it's not only the double standards but also the blatant hypocrisy that infuriates me. What makes him think he can interfere with her and keep her all to himself while he clearly can't do the same for her? And it's even more frustrating that she's okay with being the one who gets the leftovers from OW. As if he's some kind of treasure just because he didn't dip his junk into someone else's hooha. Yuck. 🤮

@Alina. I can't agree more that he sees her merely as an object to own. If he really loves her and is obsessed with her, then he wouldn't act in ways that clearly indicate otherwise. 😒


Jen ♥ Koryne wrote: "lololol “saving himself for her HOWEVER…� yeah no thank you on that 😂"

Yeah, you better avoid this book. 🥲


message 26: by Jen � (last edited Apr 01, 2025 07:02PM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Jen ♥ Eunoia wrote: "I would never consider these experienced v, virgin in my book/ reading list hahaha. It is sooooo difficult to find a quality dual v book in these times of day. Sometimes, there are good ass never b..."

Right??? It's honestly a struggle to find a good story with dual V. 😩


message 27: by Lara (new) - added it

Lara I love this thread! I want to cry because I HATE this kind of ambiguity. If you're not going to give me a 100% virgin hero, don't give me a shit. You know what? I'm going to ask the author. She must be sick of me because I'm always writing to her, but I need to know.


Jen ♥ Lara wrote: "I love this thread! I want to cry because I HATE this kind of ambiguity. If you're not going to give me a 100% virgin hero, don't give me a shit. You know what? I'm going to ask the author. She mus..."

Alina said she asked the author and here's her answer: "He saved himself for Arianna however he did experiment in other areas with other women."


Miki’s⚠️ Safety, Rants & Lazy Reviews⚠️ This author messed this up. This is my most HATED BS ever! I loved her kept men away from her but fucked around w OW? How is the at a man obsessed or even a Virgin. He ain’t no Virgin. And how is it possible to love her and fuck around? Like do author really like the smell of their own shit? Cause they are trying to shove their double standard shit down our throats 💩


message 30: by Jen � (last edited Apr 04, 2025 03:02PM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Jen ♥ Miki’s⚠️ Safety, Rants & Lazy Reviews⚠️ wrote: "This author messed this up. This is my most HATED BS ever! I loved her kept men away from her but fucked around w OW? How is the at a man obsessed or even a Virgin. He ain’t no Virgin. And how is i..."

I had a few days to calm down about this. I was so excited for this book cuz it's childhood friends to lovers, but yeah, you're right, this was ruined by hypocrisy and double standards. 🥴


back to top