Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Glenn Russell's Reviews > The Aleph and Other Stories

The Aleph and Other Stories by Jorge Luis Borges
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
23385697
's review

it was amazing



THE IMMORTAL
We have all experienced different dimensions in our life, to name just three: waking, deep sleep and dreaming. Yet when it comes to describing or imagining the afterlife, I’ve read very few accounts postulating how awareness could shift between various levels; rather, life (or lack of life) after death tends to be portrayed as an uninterrupted hum all at one frequency, the three major frequencies: 1) awareness within a specific form, like a light body 2) formless awareness, that is, our consciousness merging with undifferentiated oneness, an ocean of universal conscious 3) complete obliteration without a trace of conscious awareness.

Why is this? Why can’t we think in terms of an alternating between various frequencies or modes of awareness, perhaps even with an occasional shift into oblivion? And these questions are compounded if we also think of our bodily existence on planet earth continuing forever, if we became part of the race of the immortals. Questions such as these pop up, at least for me, after reading this Jorge Luis Borges tale.

Vintage Borges: The Borges-like narrator discloses a verbatim transcription of a document a French princess purchased in an old London bookshop after a conversation she had with the grubby old bookdealer in various languages: French, English, Spanish, Portuguese; she subsequently walked out of the shop with Alexander Pope's rendering of Homer’s Iliad in six volumes and later found this document in the last volume. You have to love how our Borges-like narrator isn’t claiming to invent the story; quite the contrary, he is simply reporting on someone else’s factual account of their extraordinary experience.

The Manuscript: The document’s narrator provides us with his back-story in brief: he is an officer in the Roman army in Egypt, the Roman legions that have recently defeated Egyptian forces; however, since he himself didn’t participate in any of the bloody combat, he was propelled to embark on an adventure through the deserts in quest of the secret City of the Immortals. You also have to love how the narrator, an adventurous soldier, hale, hearty, bold leader of men and lover of the god Mars, functions as an alter-ego to the frail, bookish, solitary Borges.

The Spark: One day a stranger, exhausted, covered in blood, rides into camp and, prior to dropping dead that very evening, informs the tribune how he is searching for the river that purifies men of death; and, he goes on to say, on the other side of that river lies the City of the Immortals, a city filled with bulwarks, amphitheaters and temples. With the inclusion of amphitheaters as part of his description of the immortal city, we are given a direct signal that what is contained within its walls shares a common culture with the Greco-Roman world. Anyway, the stranger’s words fire his spirit and imagination, thus primed for an astonishing discovery, off they go, the tribune and two hundred soldiers under his command provided complements of a high-ranking military commander.

Going Solo: As the tribune informs us, the first part of the journey proved harrowing, grueling and strenuous beyond endurance - most of his men were either driven mad or died, while others, attempting desertion, faced torture or crucifixion. Also in this initial phase, the seekers crossed lands and deserts of fantastic tribes, including the Troglodytes who “devour serpents and lack all verbal commerce.� Events reach such a pitch he is told by a soldier loyal to his cause that the remaining men desire to avenge a crucifixion of one of their comrades and plan to kill him. He subsequently flees camp with several soldiers but disaster hits: in the fury of blinding desert whirlwinds he quickly gets separated - from now on, he is on his own.

Turning Point: Our tribune wanders for days in the desert, forever scorched by the sun and parched by thirst until his living nightmare shifts and somehow he finds himself bound hands behind his back and lying in a stone niche the size of a grave on the slope of a mountain. There’s a stream running at the foot of this mountain and beyond the stream he beholds the dazzling structures of the City of the Immortals. Marcus Flaminius Rufus (at this point the tribune lets us know his name) can also see numerous holes riddling the mountain and valley and from those holes emerge grey skinned naked men with scraggly beards, men he recognizes as belonging to the race of Troglodytes. My sense is these Troglodytes represent a mode of being at the extreme opposite end of the spectrum from that of a refined aesthete and man of letters like Borges. I suspect Borges perceived (and perhaps dreamed) many of his fellow humans inhabiting a Troglodyte-like existence.

Exploration, One: After many days and having finally freed himself from his bonds, Marcus enters the City of the Immortals. Soon after he explores the periphery, we read, “The force of the day drove me to seek refuge in a cavern; toward the rear there was a pit, and out of the pit, out of the gloom below, rose a ladder. I descended the ladder and made my way through a chaos of squalid galleries to a vast, indistinct circular chamber. Nine doors opened into that cellar-like place; eight led to a maze that returned deceitfully, to the same chamber; the ninth led through another maze to a second circular chamber identical to the first.� Anybody familiar with Jorge Luis Borges will recognized a number of recurrent themes: mazes, caverns, ladders, doors, chaos, circular chambers.

Exploration, Two: Having spent what appears an eternity underground, Marcus spots a series of metal rungs on a wall leading to a circle of sky. He climbs the ladder, sobbing with tears of joy, until he emerges into a type of small plaza within the brilliant City. Marcus senses the city's antiquity and wanders along staircases and inlaid floors of a labyrinthine palace thinking how all what he sees is the work of the gods or, more accurately, gods who have died or, even, perhaps, since much of the architecture appears to lack any trace of practical purpose, gods who were mad. Then, we read, “I had made my way through a dark maze, but it was the bright City of the Immortals that terrified and repelled me.� And this is only the beginning: as Marcus further discovers, there are revelations even more astonishing, including the shocking true identity of one of those Troglodytes.

Universal Questions: The second half of the tale takes a decidedly philosophical turn and, in the spirit of this Borges classic, I will conclude with a series of question posed either directly or indirectly by the narrator:

� How does memory relate to immortality? Is the erasure of our memory the first step in achieving immortality?

� Likewise, how does time relate to immortality and is the erasure of time a critical step in experiencing immortality?

� If we were to experience a state free of memory and time in this life, through powerful hallucinogens, deep meditation or otherwise, have we achieved a kind of immortality, at least for a time?

� What part does ecstasy and bliss play in the state or experience of immortality?

� How far does the consequences of our action extend? To a subsequent rebirth or afterlife in another state?

� How much weight should we give to history or a specific epoch of history? To our own personal history? How much of history is so much smoke and mirrors?

� What role does transformation on any level, physical, mental, artistic, spiritual, play in our life?





When I read the work of Jorge Luis Borges I feel like my universe is expanding a thousand-fold. And for good reason - my universe is, in fact, expanding a thousand-fold! This is especially true as I read The Aleph and Other Stories. Such sheer imaginative power. Fantastic! There are nearly fifty stories and brief tales collected here and every tale worth reading multiple times.

For the purposes of continuing this review, I will focus on 4 stories, the first 3 being no longer than 2 pages. (4,3,2 . . . moving down to the infinity of the Borges 0, which happens to be the shape of the Aleph). Sorry, I am getting too carried away.

THE TWO KINGS AND THE TWO LABYRINTHS
The king of Babylonia builds a labyrinth ". . . so confused and so subtle that the most prudent men would not venture to enter it, and those who did would lose their way." Although the king of Babylonia tricked the king of the Arabs into entering his diabolical labyrinth, the king, with the help of God, manages to find the secret exit. After claiming victory in a bloody war, the king of the Arabs leads the king of Babylonia, in turn, into a different kind of labyrinth, and says, " . . . the Powerful One has seen fit to allow me to show thee mine, which has no stairways to climb, nor doors to force, not wearying galleries to wander through, nor walls to impede thy passage." Then, the king of the Arabs abandoned the king of Babylonia in the middle of the desert. These two images of a labyrinth, one intricate, convoluted, infinitely confusing and the other an endless desert, have remained with me since I first read this tale some thirty years ago and will remain with me as long as there is a `me' with a memory.

THE CAPTIVE
A tale of identity where a young boy with sky-blue eyes is kidnapped in an Indian raid. The parents recover their son who is now a man and bring him back to their home. The man remembers exactly where he hid a knife. Not long thereafter, the man, now an Indian in spirit, returns to the wilderness. The story ends with a question, "I would like to know what he felt in that moment of vertigo when past and present intermingled; I would like to know whether the lost son was reborn and died in that ecstatic moment, and he ever managed to recognize, even as a baby or a dog might, his parents and the house." For Borges, memory and identity are ongoing themes. After reading Borges, I can assure you, memory and identity have become ongoing themes for me also.

THE PLOT
How many volumes have been written pondering and philosophizing over fate and free will? In two short paragraphs Borges gives us a tale where we are told, "Fate is partial to repetitions, variations, symmetries." How exactly? Let's just say life is always bigger than human-made notions of life.

THE ALEPH
Around the universe in fifteen pages. There is a little something here for anybody who cherishes literature - a dearly departed lover named Beatriz, a madman and poet named Carlos Argentino Daneri, who tells the first person narrator, a man by the name of Borges, about seeing the Aleph, and, of course, the Aleph. What will this Borges undergo to see the Aleph himself? We read, "I followed his ridiculous instructions; he finally left. He carefully let down the trap door; in spite of a chink of light that I began to make out later, the darkness seemed total. Suddenly I realized the danger I was in; I had allowed myself to be locked underground by a madman, after first drinking down a snifter of poison." Rather than saying anything further about the Aleph, let me simply note that through the magic of literature we as readers are also given a chance to see what Borges sees. I dare anybody who has an aesthetic or metaphysical bone in their body to read this story and not make the Aleph a permanent part of their imagination.

Go ahead. Take the risk. Be fascinated and enlarged. Have the universe and all its details spinning in your head. Read this book.

333 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read The Aleph and Other Stories.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
November 25, 2013 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-39 of 39 (39 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Donna (new)

Donna Another amazing review Glenn. Even I'm intrigued now :)


Glenn Russell Donna wrote: "Another amazing review Glenn. Even I'm intrigued now :)"

Thanks, Donna! Glad you are intrigued by Borges.


message 3: by Lawyer (new)

Lawyer Along with all your evident skills, Glenn, I believe you are a consummate fisherman, outwitting the wiliest trout in the stream. For you certainly have the skill as a reviewer to draw the reader to pick up a book and discover its treasures. You're a fine example of why I gain so much from this community and the reason I value our friendship. Carry on!


Glenn Russell Mike wrote: "Along with all your evident skills, Glenn, I believe you are a consummate fisherman, outwitting the wiliest trout in the stream. For you certainly have the skill as a reviewer to draw the reader t..."

Thanks so much for your comment here, Mike. And, yes, we all have a great thing going here on Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ.


Jibran Brilliant. All these stories you have referenced are also my favourite in the collection. Glad that you referred to this review in the other thread.


Glenn Russell Jibran wrote: "Brilliant. All these stories you have referenced are also my favourite in the collection. Glad that you referred to this review in the other thread."

Thanks! Again, so glad we are both Borges fans!!


Negri You write the reviews that books deserve.


Glenn Russell Negri wrote: "You write the reviews that books deserve."

Thanks,T! Very kind of you to say so.


message 9: by Ned (new)

Ned I'm carefully reading my first Borges now, but only in the morning when I am fresh and alert. It's a delight, but taking his stories slowly, one by one.


Glenn Russell Ned wrote: "I'm carefully reading my first Borges now, but only in the morning when I am fresh and alert. It's a delight, but taking his stories slowly, one by one."

Your approach contains keen wisdom, Ned. No need to rush -- they will really live with you if you take your time.


Silvia I'm so glad I read your review, Glenn. I actually think I am overwhelmed after reading The Aleph and other stories!


message 12: by Richard (new)

Richard Hannay I wonder how Borges translates into English. Sentences like " Era, nos dice, un hombre consumido y terroso, de ojos grises y barba gris, de rasgos singularmente vagos. Se manejaba con fluidez e ignorancia en diversas lenguas; en muy pocos minutos pasó del francés al inglés y de inglés a una conjunción enigmática de español de Salónica y de portugués de Macao. " or this small jewel. "En Bikanir he profesado la astrología y también en Bohemia.", seem to me almost impossible to render into any other languaje. Then again Borges famously said " I have never believed that Don Quixote were untranslatable, and what's more it grows in the translation".


Glenn Russell Richard wrote: "I wonder how Borges translates into English. Sentences like " Era, nos dice, un hombre consumido y terroso, de ojos grises y barba gris, de rasgos singularmente vagos. Se manejaba con fluidez e ign..."

Great question, Richard. Sorry, I am not the best person to ask since I can only read English (typical monolingual American). I would think something is definitely lost when translating a classic from another language, especially poetry.

I just did post my full, final review of this tale, you might want to check out.


message 14: by Sal (new)

Sal It really depends on the translator. I studied translation a bit, and I worked on translating poetry for a semester while I was finishing up my degree. I worked on it from a few different perspectives. You can take the spirit and write it anew, translate it literally, or somewhere in the middle. Typical, I aimed for the middle ground. Translation is immensely difficult, even more difficult to do well. Very fascinating process.


message 15: by [deleted user] (new)

I must say, I am drawn to the Exploration, One story...I love that about Borges...the endless mazes, caves...while reading Borges I would often not know where his story might lead, but when I would finish one story it would be later, thinking about it when I realize how it has expanded my thinking, my mind...


Glenn Russell while reading Borges I would often not know where his story might lead, but when I would finish one story it would be later, thinking about it when I realize how it has expanded my thinking, my mind... ------- JLB can do that to a reader open to transformation!


message 17: by Dolors (new)

Dolors Alright, this is the guide I need to follow next time I try to expand my universe when reading Borges! Thanks for the enlightening review, Glenn.


message 18: by Arah-Lynda (new) - added it

Arah-Lynda The opening picture alone was enough to draw me in but then you followed it up with an amazing and intriguing review. I am not sure why I feel a little intimidated by the thought of reading Borges but this review has made me want to try.


message 19: by Zoeytron (new)

Zoeytron Fate versus free will has always been an intriguing subject to me. Fascinating review, Glenn.


Glenn Russell Dolors wrote: "Alright, this is the guide I need to follow next time I try to expand my universe when reading Borges! Thanks for the enlightening review, Glenn."

My pleasure, Dolors. If you tried Borges and he was too abstract and baroque for your taste at the time, then many stories in this collection, short and straightforward, will be just the thing. The other two collections where he uses less baroque, abstruse language: Book of Sand and Brodie's Report.


Glenn Russell Arah-Lynda wrote: "The opening picture alone was enough to draw me in but then you followed it up with an amazing and intriguing review. I am not sure why I feel a little intimidated by the thought of reading Borges ..."

Thanks! No need to be intimidated, as I noted above, this collection along with Book of Sand and Brodie's Report make for accessible reading.


Glenn Russell Zoeytron wrote: "Fate versus free will has always been an intriguing subject to me. Fascinating review, Glenn."

Yes, very intriguing subject - has keep philosophers going for thousands of years. Thanks so much for reading my review!

I myself put more emphasis on free will and freedom since I view creativity and imagination supremely unique expressions of our humanness.


message 23: by Ned (new)

Ned Loved this story, so interesting and well told.


Glenn Russell Ned wrote: "Loved this story, so interesting and well told."

Yes, so amazing. I enjoy when Borges is locked in the madman's cellar and thinks he was mad for permitting himself to get in such a fix. And he thinks this might just be the end of his life. ... Then he sees the Aleph.


message 25: by Gaurav (new) - added it

Gaurav Sagar An engrossing review, Glenn!


Cecily Another impassioned, insightful and tempting Borges review. You're on a roll, Glenn. As you say, "Be fascinated and enlarged."


Glenn Russell Gaurav wrote: "An engrossing review, Glenn!"

Thank you, Gaurav!


Glenn Russell Cecily wrote: "Another impassioned, insightful and tempting Borges review. You're on a roll, Glenn. As you say, "Be fascinated and enlarged.""

Thanks, Cecily. No doubt about it - if we as readers need a bit of expanded universe to liven up our lives, Borges is the ideal author.


message 29: by flo (new) - rated it 5 stars

flo Reading your Borges reviews is always such a treat. Amazing write-up, beautiful concluding paragraph.


Glenn Russell Florencia wrote: "Reading your Borges reviews is always such a treat. Amazing write-up, beautiful concluding paragraph."

Thanks so much for reading and your kind words here, Florencia. Borges is such an inspiration.


Glenn Russell Marita wrote: "Your review is a treat to read and the first image is a delight."

Thanks! Glad you enjoyed. Borges is really a treat for the imagination.


message 32: by posthuman (last edited Jun 09, 2020 06:42PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

posthuman Thanks for this lovely review, Glenn! These are some of my favorite stories ever written


Glenn Russell posthuman wrote: "Thanks for this lovely review, Glenn! These are some of my favorite stories ever written"

Wonderful, P. I especially appreciate your kind words since, as you note, these Borges tales are counted as among your favorites.


message 34: by Nick (new) - added it

Nick Sometimes I am afraid I will love your reviews more than the actual books, Glenn. But you have the skill of getting other people excited to read a work. Thanks for doing this. Keep up the good work. :-)


Philip of Macedon Outstanding review, as always. Borges has so much good and interesting work. I have his Collected Fictions and have only scratched the surface with Ficciones and A Universal History of Iniquity. Maybe these stories you've reviewed are the next I'll read.


message 36: by Glenn (last edited Jun 10, 2020 07:31AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Glenn Russell Nick wrote: "Sometimes I am afraid I will love your reviews more than the actual books, Glenn. But you have the skill of getting other people excited to read a work. Thanks for doing this. Keep up the good work..."

Thanks much, in turn, Nick. I've so much enjoyed the past 8 years here on Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ. For me it has been something of a dream come true: I can write a review at 8AM, readers from around the globe can read at 9AM and I can receive multiple comments from friends from the West Coast USA, Netherlands, India, Peru by 10AM. Remarkable.


Glenn Russell Bukk wrote: "Outstanding review, as always. Borges has so much good and interesting work. I have his Collected Fictions and have only scratched the surface with Ficciones and A Universal History of Iniquity. Ma..."

Thanks, Bukk. Borges is so worth it. I would encourage you to read the tales I highlighted here - they are among the great Argentine author's finest.


message 38: by Rita (new) - rated it 5 stars

Rita Bellizia Glenn
Brilhantes suas observações a respeito dessa complexa obra.
Notei o seu conhecimento e sensibilidade em seus comentários a respeito do livro " Nostalgia" de Mircea Cartarescu.
Passei a te companhar e admirar
Por favor você poderia analisar com mais detalhes o polêmico conto deutsches requiem de JLB?
Desculpe escrever em português.


message 39: by Rita (new) - rated it 5 stars

Rita Bellizia Desculpe foi outra pessoa que comentou Nostalgia mas mesmo assim aguardo seus comentários a respeito de deutsches requiem


back to top