Michael's Reviews > Blood Meridian, or, the Evening Redness in the West
Blood Meridian, or, the Evening Redness in the West
by
by

Michael's review
bookshelves: literature, goodest-reads-2009, cormac-mccarthy, most-popular-reviews
Nov 17, 2009
bookshelves: literature, goodest-reads-2009, cormac-mccarthy, most-popular-reviews
*Updated, now with an additional McCarthyized section of the Bible, moved up from the comment section.*
Here's what I'm thinkin.
THE CORMAC MCCARTHY PROJECT
Ever since reading Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, I've been considering the possibilities of revisiting the classics and, um, reinterpreting them. Butchering? Yes, you're probably right. Butchering them. That's the right word.
Anyway, since Cormac McCarthy has the most distinctive and powerful voice of any modern writer (that I've read recently)(in my opinion), I pose the question: what if Cormac McCarthy were to revisit the classics of the English canon? What if McCarthy had been the author of The Great Gatsby? How would it have ended up? I think this is an important enough question to begin a new writing project, or, at the least, write a Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ review pretending I'm going to.
First, we have to establish these new versions of the classics will be stylized after McCarthy's Western Novels, starting with Blood Meridian and ending with Cities of the Plain. Characteristics include:
1) No punctuation other than periods and question marks.
2) No indication of who is talking during dialogue, although you can always tell.
3) Poetic descriptions of barren landscapes which often reflect the callous indifference of nature to the plights of humanity.
4) Untranslated Spanish dialogue.
5) No hint of the characters' internal dialogue; all characters are revealed only through action and conversation.
6) Gratuitous and unexpected acts of horrendous violence.
7) During casual conversation, characters frequently say incredibly profound shit.
Although there's more to his style than this, we can take this as the most bare-essential aspects of what is necessary to properly "translate" a novel into its McCarthy version.
As an example, let's take a certain scene from Pride and Prejudice. How about the one where Lady Catherine is quizzing Elisabeth about whether D'arcy has indeed proposed to her? They're alone, walking in the garden (although in the McCarthy version, they would be walking upon a windswept moor). Here we go:
+++++++
Dust clung to their boots and the tall grass shuddered on the frigid wind. A raven perched upon the fallen branch of an elm and watched them with one jet eye. Lady Catherines hands grasped nervously at nothing as she looked across the moor.
Young women of unfortunate birth shouldnt attempt to reach beyond their station.
What?
Don't pretend you don't know of what I speak.
Eliza spat and turned away. She walked into the doorway of a church. Inside dozens of bodies lay heaped upon the floor. Blood hard and dried like clay caked upon the stone of the floor. Flies traversed upon the eyelids of a child that stared blankly at Eliza who turned away.
Los Muchachos estan muerto.
Muerto?
Muerto.
Si.
Eliza brushed her hair back. All of the constrictions you place upon mans actions are nothing to the ineffable stretch of the world which knows that all is war. No system of morality is anything but pretense which the least of gods vile beasts can shatter simply through the act of killing for its survival. Morality holds no water when it stands eye to eye with stark reality.
Lady Catherine spat and wiped her mouth on her sleeve.
Its damn cold.
Wait which of us said that?
I did.
Oh. Alright.
I wont promise I would never accept a proposal if I dont think its ever to be given. Nor can I swear as to what I would do in a situation that Ive never known myself to be in.
Well arent you a contrary little whore. Lady Catherine spat. Ill not forget how youve treated me this day. Her finger moved closer to the knife that hung at her hip.
++++++
And here's one of the Bible's more memorable passages, McCarthyized:
19:1 From out the dark sky over all Gods reckoning the two drifted like fallenleaves downward as Lot tipped back the widebrimmed hat, rubbing his thumb over stubble and spat on the grounddirt. Raising heavy to his feet and stretching he ambled forward dust raising an etherial plume in the nightair like ghosts of sinners dwelling on the threshold of the dark. the untamed past hovered there in the darkness by Sodom.
19:2 Come in ifn you want.
We don't mind sleepin outside.
No really I got plenty room. Cmon in.
The angels came in bare feet on the packed dirt covered with indescribable years of footprints crisscrossed into an impossible to fathom reckoning of feet stretching back through indescribable years. So many feet and such a dirty floor.
19:3 He cooked bread. They warshed up and ate.
19:4 Out the window shadows encroached from the jet locustridden expanse of Sodom. Figures in stillness, nooses dangling from withered hands and that dust rising like the dead pounding from the other side of eternity trying to return trying to be unforsaken from the temporal purgatory the men dwelt in. Who them men we saw with them white robes.
19:5 Gone home, Jenkins, he said.
Not til we know who them fugitives is you harborin. They aint niggers is they.
Didn't you see they white robes. They aint no niggers.
Lot walked out the house into that humidity the wind like the word of God drifting with threats of retribution and reckoning. Tell you what, men, you better get back on home and mind ya damn business. This aint no affair of yourn.
The Willis boy had a strapon fixed to his forehead pointing up accusingly at the heavens an erection of defiance. He wore that collar that said Slave as always. He was danglin handcuffs from his hand like like a hypnotist without a pocketwatch. We just wanna see um. We just wanna meet um. Maybe have a little fun with um.
19:7 Lot spat a wad of nasal discharge loudly upon the earth and glanced back at the house. Tell you what boys. I invited them men into my house and I wont have them mistreated but I got them two good fer nothin daughters. You leave my visitors alone Ill bring them on out.
19:8 Willis nodded, that plastic tusk swaying in the nightair. What fer.
Whatever yall find fittin. It aint fer me to say. Just leave my visitors alone.
Okay, apparently it's not easy to write in Cormac McCarthy's style without sucking. I suppose the only way THE CORMAC MCCARTHY PROJECT can be effectively carried out is if McCarthy himself were to actually write these translations. So, if anyone runs into Cormac, let him know about this project, and how important it is for him to get to work right away. After all, there are lots of classics. I believe he lives in New Mexico. So, if you're wandering through a dark, dank cave and hear the sounds of typewriter keys pounding away, you've probably found his lair. Approach slowly, and don't make eye contact.
I suppose, while I'm at it, I could say something about Blood Meridian. FUCKING AMAZING! I hate giving five star ratings, probably because I'm so curmudgeonly. But, for the third time, McCarthy is making me give him one. I just can't find anything to fault here, and the story is different from any I've ever read before. The writing is amazing, the characters are good (although the Judge fits a certain fiction stereotype, he's a very memorable version of it), and I was startled by the horror of it all . . . until I became numb to it. Which was the intention, or I think it was at any rate.
This is the horrifying story of a group who are being paid to hunt down injuns and scalp them. Over time, the bloodlust of the group grows and they begin scalping those they're intended to be saving, and basically everyone they come across. When it comes time to be paid for the scalps, the scalps all look the same anyway. Sothey make tons of money from the indiscriminant slaughter of soldiers, villagers, travelers and everyone else. And, from there, things get uglier.
This is all based on historical events, or so I've heard. I haven't researched it enough to know how closely. But, this is a very dark vision of the "wild west," and the blood that was spilled while the land was still wild. If you have the stomach for it, this is an amazing book.
Here's what I'm thinkin.
THE CORMAC MCCARTHY PROJECT
Ever since reading Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, I've been considering the possibilities of revisiting the classics and, um, reinterpreting them. Butchering? Yes, you're probably right. Butchering them. That's the right word.
Anyway, since Cormac McCarthy has the most distinctive and powerful voice of any modern writer (that I've read recently)(in my opinion), I pose the question: what if Cormac McCarthy were to revisit the classics of the English canon? What if McCarthy had been the author of The Great Gatsby? How would it have ended up? I think this is an important enough question to begin a new writing project, or, at the least, write a Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ review pretending I'm going to.
First, we have to establish these new versions of the classics will be stylized after McCarthy's Western Novels, starting with Blood Meridian and ending with Cities of the Plain. Characteristics include:
1) No punctuation other than periods and question marks.
2) No indication of who is talking during dialogue, although you can always tell.
3) Poetic descriptions of barren landscapes which often reflect the callous indifference of nature to the plights of humanity.
4) Untranslated Spanish dialogue.
5) No hint of the characters' internal dialogue; all characters are revealed only through action and conversation.
6) Gratuitous and unexpected acts of horrendous violence.
7) During casual conversation, characters frequently say incredibly profound shit.
Although there's more to his style than this, we can take this as the most bare-essential aspects of what is necessary to properly "translate" a novel into its McCarthy version.
As an example, let's take a certain scene from Pride and Prejudice. How about the one where Lady Catherine is quizzing Elisabeth about whether D'arcy has indeed proposed to her? They're alone, walking in the garden (although in the McCarthy version, they would be walking upon a windswept moor). Here we go:
+++++++
Dust clung to their boots and the tall grass shuddered on the frigid wind. A raven perched upon the fallen branch of an elm and watched them with one jet eye. Lady Catherines hands grasped nervously at nothing as she looked across the moor.
Young women of unfortunate birth shouldnt attempt to reach beyond their station.
What?
Don't pretend you don't know of what I speak.
Eliza spat and turned away. She walked into the doorway of a church. Inside dozens of bodies lay heaped upon the floor. Blood hard and dried like clay caked upon the stone of the floor. Flies traversed upon the eyelids of a child that stared blankly at Eliza who turned away.
Los Muchachos estan muerto.
Muerto?
Muerto.
Si.
Eliza brushed her hair back. All of the constrictions you place upon mans actions are nothing to the ineffable stretch of the world which knows that all is war. No system of morality is anything but pretense which the least of gods vile beasts can shatter simply through the act of killing for its survival. Morality holds no water when it stands eye to eye with stark reality.
Lady Catherine spat and wiped her mouth on her sleeve.
Its damn cold.
Wait which of us said that?
I did.
Oh. Alright.
I wont promise I would never accept a proposal if I dont think its ever to be given. Nor can I swear as to what I would do in a situation that Ive never known myself to be in.
Well arent you a contrary little whore. Lady Catherine spat. Ill not forget how youve treated me this day. Her finger moved closer to the knife that hung at her hip.
++++++
And here's one of the Bible's more memorable passages, McCarthyized:
19:1 From out the dark sky over all Gods reckoning the two drifted like fallenleaves downward as Lot tipped back the widebrimmed hat, rubbing his thumb over stubble and spat on the grounddirt. Raising heavy to his feet and stretching he ambled forward dust raising an etherial plume in the nightair like ghosts of sinners dwelling on the threshold of the dark. the untamed past hovered there in the darkness by Sodom.
19:2 Come in ifn you want.
We don't mind sleepin outside.
No really I got plenty room. Cmon in.
The angels came in bare feet on the packed dirt covered with indescribable years of footprints crisscrossed into an impossible to fathom reckoning of feet stretching back through indescribable years. So many feet and such a dirty floor.
19:3 He cooked bread. They warshed up and ate.
19:4 Out the window shadows encroached from the jet locustridden expanse of Sodom. Figures in stillness, nooses dangling from withered hands and that dust rising like the dead pounding from the other side of eternity trying to return trying to be unforsaken from the temporal purgatory the men dwelt in. Who them men we saw with them white robes.
19:5 Gone home, Jenkins, he said.
Not til we know who them fugitives is you harborin. They aint niggers is they.
Didn't you see they white robes. They aint no niggers.
Lot walked out the house into that humidity the wind like the word of God drifting with threats of retribution and reckoning. Tell you what, men, you better get back on home and mind ya damn business. This aint no affair of yourn.
The Willis boy had a strapon fixed to his forehead pointing up accusingly at the heavens an erection of defiance. He wore that collar that said Slave as always. He was danglin handcuffs from his hand like like a hypnotist without a pocketwatch. We just wanna see um. We just wanna meet um. Maybe have a little fun with um.
19:7 Lot spat a wad of nasal discharge loudly upon the earth and glanced back at the house. Tell you what boys. I invited them men into my house and I wont have them mistreated but I got them two good fer nothin daughters. You leave my visitors alone Ill bring them on out.
19:8 Willis nodded, that plastic tusk swaying in the nightair. What fer.
Whatever yall find fittin. It aint fer me to say. Just leave my visitors alone.
Okay, apparently it's not easy to write in Cormac McCarthy's style without sucking. I suppose the only way THE CORMAC MCCARTHY PROJECT can be effectively carried out is if McCarthy himself were to actually write these translations. So, if anyone runs into Cormac, let him know about this project, and how important it is for him to get to work right away. After all, there are lots of classics. I believe he lives in New Mexico. So, if you're wandering through a dark, dank cave and hear the sounds of typewriter keys pounding away, you've probably found his lair. Approach slowly, and don't make eye contact.
I suppose, while I'm at it, I could say something about Blood Meridian. FUCKING AMAZING! I hate giving five star ratings, probably because I'm so curmudgeonly. But, for the third time, McCarthy is making me give him one. I just can't find anything to fault here, and the story is different from any I've ever read before. The writing is amazing, the characters are good (although the Judge fits a certain fiction stereotype, he's a very memorable version of it), and I was startled by the horror of it all . . . until I became numb to it. Which was the intention, or I think it was at any rate.
This is the horrifying story of a group who are being paid to hunt down injuns and scalp them. Over time, the bloodlust of the group grows and they begin scalping those they're intended to be saving, and basically everyone they come across. When it comes time to be paid for the scalps, the scalps all look the same anyway. Sothey make tons of money from the indiscriminant slaughter of soldiers, villagers, travelers and everyone else. And, from there, things get uglier.
This is all based on historical events, or so I've heard. I haven't researched it enough to know how closely. But, this is a very dark vision of the "wild west," and the blood that was spilled while the land was still wild. If you have the stomach for it, this is an amazing book.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Blood Meridian, or, the Evening Redness in the West.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Finished Reading
November 17, 2009
– Shelved
November 20, 2009
– Shelved as:
literature
February 21, 2010
– Shelved as:
goodest-reads-2009
January 30, 2013
– Shelved as:
cormac-mccarthy
June 30, 2014
– Shelved as:
most-popular-reviews
Comments Showing 1-44 of 44 (44 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Jacob
(new)
Nov 20, 2009 03:57PM

reply
|
flag

Holy crikey. If Tolstoy rewrote all the classics, I'd probably read a lot less of them. He'd turn Heart of Darkness into an eight-hundred page epic. And I'd hate to see what he'd do to The Stranger!

Was this in the original P&P? I read it several times over and I'm still not sure I untwisted all the negatives.

Since I can't even remember what I had for dinner the night before last, my guess is only slightly better than yours.

Was this in the original P&P? I read it several times over and I'm still not sure I untwisted all the negatives."
Gutenberg says no? (<3 Gutenberg) but there was this -
At one time she had almost resolved on applying to him, but the idea was checked by the awkwardness of the application, and at length wholly banished by the conviction that Mr. Darcy would never have hazarded such a proposal, if he had not been well assured of his cousin's corroboration.
Also I just reread the Mr Collins scenes online. //shudders


I remember the first time I read the book I pretty young and didn't realize Mr Bennett was teasing and kept expecting Lizzie to ACTUALLY GET MARRIED TO MR COLLINS OHNO. It was suddenly like a horror film.
(hey it ain't the size of the ship it's the motion of the cruise liner in the ocean with David Foster Wallace aboard, &c &c)



I'd also be interested in seeing Oscar Wilde McCarthy-ized. And, of course, Twilight.

======================
A frozen moor. Shiftless, sepulchral. Fraught with a haze beyond his reckoning, he wanted to say. Yet whereupon bloodlines once Nordic and thick and drunk with a conquerous mania slew their fellows and trampled upon their viscera and watched their blood freeze over the epithelium of their gaze did now lie empty to the pusillanimity of their heirs.
The boy spat.
A walk, he said.
The possibility even now interdicted. As though evading the natural violence beyond would render the pathetic fallacy of his existence irreproachable before man or God or too the very circumstances of his inalterable frigidity. And Eliza and John and Georgiana looked upon him and found him wanting and turned and did not speak.
The matriarch lay beached upon a sofa, sweating and quivering under the weight of her own adipose. She pronounced the child wanting.
Aint a crime in no Bible I ever read.
The crime of questioning.
The same.
The matriarch unfurled one quivering finger from her endless folds of tissue and pointed it northward like some fallen angel of bode and christening and said that the child had since time immemorial been fettered to silence and that if his folly would fain usurp the laws of habit she would see his throat loosed open like the yaw of sin itself and the flesh of his daughters spread like so much offal upon the plains where wolves prowl and the bison jerk and haw.
And my accuser?
You would have him known.
I would.
God alone, she said, and his hands were bound and his face kicked until he spit teeth like so many pesetas in the beggar's cup and she wrapped him in velvet and staked him with his face exposed to sun and bade him think upon birds in flight and they left him there. And the night fell and he slept and the coyotes howled and he dreamed of the place of his birth, cold beyond memory. And when the sun rose on the third day the ravens arrived and pecked him blind and cawed like madmen and finally the boy wept and when the coyotes arrived to tear out his stomach he was still alive but made no sound and stared vacant into the maw of the sun as his blood whet the sand and he passed into the land of vacance and memory.


*Runs away chuckling*


19:2 Come in ifn you want.
We don't mind sleepin outside.
No really I got plenty room. Cmon in.
The angels came in bare feet on the packed dirt covered with indescribable years of footprints crisscrossed into an impossible to fathom reckoning of feet stretching back through indescribable years. So many feet and such a dirty floor.
19:3 He cooked bread. They warshed up and ate.
19:4 Out the window shadows encroached from the jet locustridden expanse of Sodom. Figures in stillness, nooses dangling from withered hands and that dust rising like the dead pounding from the other side of eternity trying to return trying to be unforsaken from the temporal purgatory the men dwelt in. Who them men we saw with them white robes.
19:5 Gone home, Jenkins, he said.
Not til we know who them fugitives is you harborin. They aint niggers is they.
Didn't you see they white robes. They aint no niggers.
Lot walked out the house into that humidity the wind like the word of God drifting with threats of retribution and reckoning. Tell you what, men, you better get back on home and mind ya damn business. This aint no affair of yourn.
The Willis boy had a strapon fixed to his forehead pointing up accusingly at the heavens an erection of defiance. He wore that collar that said Slave as always. He was danglin handcuffs from his hand like like a hypnotist without a pocketwatch. We just wanna see um. We just wanna meet um. Maybe have a little fun with um.
19:7 Lot spat a wad of nasal discharge loudly upon the earth and glanced back at the house. Tell you what boys. I invited them men into my house and I wont have them mistreated but I got them two good fer nothin daughters. You leave my visitors alone Ill bring them on out.
19:8 Willis nodded, that plastic tusk swaying in the nightair. What fer.
Whatever yall find fittin. It aint fer me to say. Just leave my visitors alone.



If you wanna give him a shot, you might like The Road. That one is very readable...alas, it still doesn't have punctuation.

yours are just as good. thanks for linking to this in the favorite reviews thread. now i don't want to link to any of my half-assed amusements.

You must link! You have some excellent reviews!

i'll have to look through them, thanks for the encouragement.


Read your original review of Blood Meridian and couldn't stop laughin. I tip my hat to you.





I also remember how your wife would tell you things were up your ass when she was annoyed at you (did you ever get that stool out?, bwahaha!). I use her phrasing with my partner regularly. I'm sure he loves it.

With your testimonial, perhaps we could convince Cormac (or Corm-Dog if you're a close friend like me) that it's time to get started on this project. We may need more than one testimonial, but I suppose my review counts as a second, and I AM up to 40 total comments here.
You know what? The whole ass storage method recently came in super helpful when we moved to London, England. Our strategy was "two suitcases and Michael's ass," and we fit everything we absolutely had to have. Including one nice stool from the early oughts, and a steamer we forgot was in there!

With your testimonial, perhaps we could convince Cormac (or Corm-Dog if you're a close friend like m..."
Haha I think we all got crochety with the times a-changin' and life. I'm glad to have caught the idealistic early flush of book readers and read some memorable takes. I'm easing back into reading actual books after a pause.
We should contact Cormie-baby soon! At 89, after 3 wives, and a wikipedia entry that makes him sound extremely cranky it might take coaxing to get him to come outside and play. I'm positive you'll connect with him on the topic of giant crabs. He loves science!
Hahahaha! I happy the moving experience was so successful with your magical ass that's bigger inside than it appears from the outside. Are you sure London can handle it? I hear they're very stuffy over there. Perhaps not as stuffed as your ass was.

Did I ever tell you I saw Corm-Dog in real life one time? He went to an ASU event where he talked (sort of) about science with people like Neal Stephenson, Neil DeGrasse Tyson, Bill Nye, and.... very strangely..... Cameron Diaz. Cameron and Cormac had the fewest scientific insights. Before he was on the stage, I spotted him in the audience and told Joy, "That's fucking Cormac McCarthy!" and she said, "It's probably just some crotchety old white guy." It was one of several (SEVERAL!) times I was right and Joy was wrong.
So far, London is lovely. I mean, it's overcast, rainy, windy, and everyone has weird accents but us, but it's lovely nonetheless. Basically it's like Portland with a lot less craft beer and probably fewer homeless encampments. We have the cutest dog in the world now, by the way, who we adopted while we were briefly living in Seattle.
London is so far handling my ass quite well, and I'm much more comfortable now that we've fully unpacked. Wincing less when I walk, too.

Did I ever tell you I saw Corm-Dog in real life one time? He went to an ASU event where he talked (sort of) about science with pe..."
I consider the many books I think about reading as having a psychic weight that's nearly, but not quite, physical. Plus, all the articles, headlines, captions, and tv show subtitles are non-book readings!
Haha what a mixed group of famous people! Even if that was fucking Cormac McCarthy, Joy was still right.
I'm glad all is well in London, although it is impossible that you have the cutest dog because that title belongs to the dog that lives in my house. I don't know that the homeless encampments are any worse here than elsewhere, just way more attention from polarized people who don't realize their opinions have been co-opted by persistent and immersive manipulation...don't get me started! I know I sound like a conspiracy chaser. The shoe is starting to fit!
Don't be ashamed to get an inflatable donut pillow. We're all getting older and your ass should be comfortable after all that work.