Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

mark monday's Reviews > Goliath

Goliath by Scott Westerfeld
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
131922
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: fog-and-gears, rain-man-reviews, inbetweenworld

darwinists take the strands  ClankerS TakE ThE FormS
of life and weave them into  OF MachineS, RemakE TheM.
new forms � a new kind of  NeW ShapeS - A NeW WaY
life, a new way of living.� � TO SeE, A NeW WaY TO BE!
cute talking animals!  HugE WalkinG MachineS.
living dirigibles!  A TeslA CannoN.
all sorts of strange beasties  AlL SortS OF ContraptionS
now at our beck and call.  NoW AvailableE FoR AlL.
but are these darwinists� BuT ArE ThesE ClankerS
unholy manipulators of  WarlikE BrutalizerS OF
nature? they control � � TechnologY? TheY RulE
england, france, russia...  GermanY, AustriA-HungarY...
they wage a sort of war  TheY WagE A KinD OF WaR
in america... will they  IN AmericA... WilL TheY
control the world itself?  ControL ThE WorlD ItselF?
fortunately, if darwinist  FortunatelY, IF ClankeR
ranks include the likes of  RankS IncludE Folks LikE
� DERYN SHARP �  � PRINCE ALEK �
a brave young lady whose  A BravE YounG GenT WhosE
sharp mind and sharp eye  LoyaltY & WitS
frequently save the day  FrequentlY SavE ThE DaY
and whose need to hide her  AnD WhosE NeeD TO BE A
gender is its own sort of  ParT OF A GreateR WholE
darwinist transformation...  IS SO VerY ClankeR...
then maybe these  TheN MaybE ThesE
brilliant scientists  UbeR-CraftsmeN
aren’t so bad at all. maybe  Aren't AlL SO BaD. MaybE
they are only one side  TheY ArE OnlY OnE SidE
of the same coin.  OF ThE SamE CoiN.
  of ThE SamE CoiN!

This is a wonderful conclusion to a charming steampunk trilogy for children. I enjoyed the preceding novels but this third volume impressed me even more. It seamlessly threads together classic Young Adult tropes, various steampunk motifs, actual history and historical characters from World War I and beyond, and a breathlessly paced series of fun adventures into one rather grand story. It is more than just a joy to read � it’s also often surprising and genuinely moving. There were moments that shocked me and there were moments that struck me right in my so-called heart. Appealing characters, superb illustrations, and even a thoughtful and touching afterward. A great achievement by Westerfeld.

The cleverness of these novels also inspired my own attempts to be clever, here and in the prior two novels' reviews:

Leviathan
Behemoth
34 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Goliath.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
December 9, 2013 – Shelved
December 29, 2013 – Shelved as: fog-and-gears
January 8, 2014 – Shelved as: rain-man-reviews
January 12, 2019 – Shelved as: inbetweenworld

Comments Showing 1-10 of 10 (10 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Julio (new)

Julio Genao well done, mate. as usual.


mark monday thank you kindly!


message 3: by AH (new) - rated it 5 stars

AH I loved this series. The illustrations were pure genius and really helped visualize all the cool contraptions.


message 4: by Tom (new)

Tom My bank account just asked me to stop reading your reviews. I've been looking for a reason to check out this series. Now I have to. Thanks a lot.
:)


mark monday if you like kid's lit or YA (although it veers a bit younger than most YA), then I definitely recommend it. it's a lot of fun!


message 6: by AH (new) - rated it 5 stars

AH Tom wrote: "My bank account just asked me to stop reading your reviews. I've been looking for a reason to check out this series. Now I have to. Thanks a lot.
:)"
It's worth it just for the illustrations.


mark monday so it has been brought to my attention by a couple folks that because of the creative (or I suppose self-indulgent) formatting in this review, on older computers the review is impossible to read. so here is an image of the review, as it is intended to look:




Jeffery Moulton I loved this whole trilogy and got my wife and kids to read it as well. It really is a great series and I really wish Westerfeld could keep it going!

Oh, and great review. :)


mark monday thanks Jeffery. nice that the whole fam got to enjoy it. I want to check out more Westerfeld but his other major YA series just doesn't look appealing to me. I want more of this!


Jeffery Moulton I too want more Leviathan, it is awesome! The Uglies series is interesting, but not nearly as good as the Leviathan stuff. Unfortunately, it feels a bit too much like a Twilight/Hunger Games knock-off and doesn't have the same level of originality to it (at least the first book doesn't, which is all I've read so far). But still...


back to top