Sign in with Facebook
Shelby *trains flying monkeys*'s Reviews > Cut
Cut
by
by
I read that the author researched for 3 years before writing this book. Now is that violating GR's terms since I mentioned the author? Heck it's to the point where I don't know how to review a book anymore. I guess since I'm giving it 2 stars (which is not horrible) it's ok? If she did I just don't get it. The characters completely felt lifeless to me.
Maybe if the book was longer? I've read shorter books though that got their point across better. It's a sensitive subject that's handled here and I have a very close friend who experienced the same problem. It just seems that cutting isn't really delved into in this book.
Ok, so I'm going to run hide now because I cringe now every time I review a book.
Maybe if the book was longer? I've read shorter books though that got their point across better. It's a sensitive subject that's handled here and I have a very close friend who experienced the same problem. It just seems that cutting isn't really delved into in this book.
Ok, so I'm going to run hide now because I cringe now every time I review a book.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Cut.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
December 21, 2013
– Shelved
January 10, 2014
–
Started Reading
January 11, 2014
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-23 of 23 (23 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
karen
(new)
Jan 11, 2014 03:01PM
you mean mean person! how dare you!!
reply
|
flag
Lol Karen! I can't help it
Oh I'm flagged and I like it!
the character is lifeless bc she is depressed and has serious issues? This book isn't supposed to be some entertaining, exciting, happy book.
Emma wrote: "the character is lifeless bc she is depressed and has serious issues? This book isn't supposed to be some entertaining, exciting, happy book."Oh for fuck's sake. Did I say that? No I didn't. Go trolls somewhere else.
um you said the characters seemed lifeless? so I'm not trolling, or never was actually.
Emma wrote: "um you said the characters seemed lifeless? so I'm not trolling, or never was actually."I'm blocking your ass..Just cuz I'm in a pissy mood and not up to dealing with your shit.
Facedesk. Is it oddly hilarious to anyone else that she didn't think she was trolling?
R.S. wrote: "Facedesk. Is it oddly hilarious to anyone else that she didn't think she was trolling?"Well..You know she just had to tell me how I was so wrong about the book.
Nick wrote: "Great review, Shelby!":)
Personally, I thank you for the honest review, Shelby! Please keep them up!
Kimberly wrote: "Personally, I thank you for the honest review, Shelby! Please keep them up!"LOL I will :)
So sad that you cringe every time you review a book now. I, for one, love reading your reviews. I find them funny and insightful. Please don't let the trolls get you down.
Jen wrote: "So sad that you cringe every time you review a book now. I, for one, love reading your reviews. I find them funny and insightful. Please don't let the trolls get you down."Sometimes it gets to me more than others. I'm hanging in.
Shelby *wants some flying monkeys* wrote: "Well..You know she just had to tell me how I was so wrong about the book."Your opinions are wonderfully perfect - because they're your own. I hold you in the highest regard!
I salute and give praise to the almighty Shelby - because she retains the courage to say what she really, really thinks.
You guys/girls are the bestest. :)
Well the book truly wasn't meant to be focused on her issue of cutting but rather the development of Callie and her beginning to open up in my opinion.
Sydney wrote: "Well the book truly wasn't meant to be focused on her issue of cutting but rather the development of Callie and her beginning to open up in my opinion."Since you seem to be fairly new at GR I'm not going to blow my top at you. If you like a book feel free to post your own glowing review. Going on negative reviews and letting people know how wrong they are is not going to win you any friends or make people want the book.
They aren't trying to dictate completely how you feel. They're starting a conversation with you. They are just trying to shoe you how they saw what was being done.
